Insane, Or Not Insane? That Is The Question

958 words - 4 pages

Megan CollinsCordel BrowneENG 4U1October 19, 2007Insane, or not Insane? That is the QuestionThe definition of mad is as follows: a deranged state of the mind or lack of understanding. Throughout Shakespeare's play, Hamlet, the main character, young Hamlet, is brought on to find out who killed his father. He decides to put on a façade of madness as part of his plan to gain the opportunity to kill his Uncle, and new father, Claudius. Throughout the play, Hamlets "madness" becomes quite believable, causing most of the characters to think he actually is a mad man. However, through his inner thoughts and the apparent reasons for his actions, it is clear that he is not really mad and is simply an actor simulating insanity in order to fulfill his duty to his dead father. Hamlet only claims madness because it allows him to say and perform actions he otherwise would be prohibited from. Hamlet asks his friends Horatio and Marcellus not to mention anything about his "antic disposition" (1.5.173) and his erratic behaviour. Throughout the play, Hamlet speaks to many characters with disrespect, only being able to get away with it because he is believed as mad. He even goes as far as criticizing his love interest, Ophelia with sexual remarks "That's a fair thought to lie between maids' legs (3.2.115)." Had Hamlet not been seen as insane, this type of behaviour towards his girlfriend likely wouldn't have passed. Again, Hamlet uses his madness merely as an excuse for killing Laertes father, Polonius. Hamlet's madness redirects attention away from what he is thinking about his father's death, and puts it on why he has gone insane. This allows only himself to know what he is truly thinking, does not require him to answer any questions as to why he might be acting strange, and allows him to continue to plan his assault on Claudius. His plan to maintain an appearance of a madman is an ingenious one. The fact that he is able to fulfill the role of someone who is insane only makes Hamlet more ingenious, not more insane. Hamlet manages to act sane when the time is right for him. During the Hamlet's play to catch Claudius' guilt expression, Hamlet turns to Horatio and asks him to watch Claudius as well. Hamlet says it in a very sane, serious tone. But Horatio is one of the few people in the plane that knows that Hamlet is sane. Very soon Polonius catches on as well, stating "though this be madness, yet there is method in't?" (2.2.205) Because of Hamlet's logic thinking it is much more plausible to believe that he is a sane man playing an insane man, than an insane man playing a sane one. In the play, Hamlet gives a plethora of clever soliloquies seemingly having complete understanding of...

Find Another Essay On Insane, or not Insane? That is the Question

Hamlet's Oedipal complex with Gertrude and the question of whether or not he was really insane or just feigning it all along.

3022 words - 12 pages what the ghost told him was the truth; "The play's the thing/ Wherein I'll catch the conscience of the King(I, ii,580-581) (Lidz,150). These are not the actions of an insane person, they are those of an intelligent and cunning one, who is unsure and of his future and the further of his mother and the kingdom. On the issue of Hamlet's uncertainty, it is evident that he is extremely unsure, this is apparent in his "to be or not to be" Soliloquy

Sane or Insane? Essay

889 words - 4 pages ." This shows that even the character himself, knows that he is not insane so why should one say he is. Another example is when the narrator says, "but why will you say that I am mad?" This shows again that the character does not believe that he is a madman. The narrator is saying he is a sane person so therefore he should just be considered sane and be charged with murder and the question of insanity should not have to be brought up.Thirdly, the

To wear or not to Wear, That is The Question

920 words - 4 pages for the lack of wearing a seat belt.Next I asked if they would still wear seat belts even if it was not the law. Chris Riley said that he would wear it depending on the duration of the trip. If he was just going up the block, or to get some gas he probably would not. Phil Meckel replied that it depends on what kind of vehicle he is in. Being a semi truck driver he always wears his seat belt while at work. But when in regular vehicles he probably

To Live or Not to Live: That is the Question.

1803 words - 7 pages "In the absence of belief in some transcendent being or ultimate (for example, God), human life lacks meaning and is not worthwhile." This is The Meaning of Life Thesis. Early 20th century, Russian philosopher Leo Tolstoy is partial to the thesis. He believes that without a belief in a higher reality, there is no sense in living. On the other hand, E.D. Klemke, a late 20th century philosopher and professor, demonstrates that the ideal

To Do or Not to Do, That is the Question

553 words - 2 pages to wipe his mind clean of all trivial matters and memories; he would only focus on the revenge that the Ghost commanded. His “clean slate” quickly fills up and Hamlet becomes torn apart by the two conflicting forces of action and inaction. Hamlet’s conflict is caused by the Ghost’s request to kill Claudius. The Ghost resembles the late King Hamlet, but Hamlet is not sure if he should trust the Ghost or not. It could possibly be Satan in

To hear or not to hear that is the question

850 words - 4 pages an orthographically presented word. In the present paper the focus is on the perception of the test subjects in identifying the presence of a voiceless affricate, would they consider this phoneme as two sounds rather than one sound. And therefor give more incorrect answers to questions that had the presence of a voiceless affricate phoneme orthographically presented to them. Without any prior knowledge of phonetics or phonology how would the

To Homeschoolor not; that is the Question

822 words - 4 pages should be stopped. They say that homeschoolers do not get a good education. In some countries homeschooling is even illegal! Here are some advantages and disadvantages of homeschooling—decide for yourself! One advantage of homeschooling is a flexible timetable. You can decide to do school at any time you want. You can do school on Saturdays in the afternoon or on Monday in the early morning. I for example, sometimes do school in the morning and

To Lower or Not to Lower the Legal Drinking Age to 18, That Is the Question

1111 words - 4 pages ; however, the probability of damage or an accident increases in underage drinkers. Drinking while young, can impair learning and memory (State Legislator n.p.). The brain is not the only organ damaged by alcohol. Cirrhosis of liver would increase in population because of alcohol consumption at an early age ( Alcantara 468). “An average of 11 American teens die each day from Alcohol related crashes” (Vaos 464) 1.). “Since Congress passed the

Passion or Money? That is the Question

2645 words - 11 pages and destroyed for the greater good of their society. The real question is: why don’t people chase passions. Most people have a passion or dream, and then decide through one way or another not to follow that passion or dream. People don’t chase their dream career for a variety of reasons but people should chase it for a range of positive outcomes. A person should always be on the lookout for their dream job, and should try achieving every

"Hamlet" Monologue Analysis: "To Be or not To Be, That is the Question"

550 words - 2 pages decision. In that sense the poem transmits that the innate human quality of thinking is what makes us weak instead of being a useful tool to make right decisions. In other words, despite we can perceive a solution to our problems (death), we are incapable of taking action (committing suicide) because we have the eternal problem of thinking."To be or not to be, that is the question" this is the phrase that opens the poem, and in a sense, it is like

To Be Selfless or Not to Selfless, That Is the Question

1771 words - 7 pages country, despite their claims not to. Villanueva says that "Golez is attacking his own bill and raising the spectre of possible use by the administration of this special law to go after political opponents and foes in classifying any of their anti-government protest actions as terrorist acts." Clearly, the government is "caught" in a trap between apprehending this opposition through the proposed law, or letting them spread hysteria over the country to

Similar Essays

Insane Or Not Insane Essay

949 words - 4 pages Insane or Not Insane? Hamlet is a tragedy; which is a narrative epic tale that ends in death and irony, written by author/poet William Shakespeare. In the tragedy, Hamlet performed in ways that were concluded to be actions of insanity. In observing the actions of Hamlet, the question, "Is he insane or is he not insane," has been inquired.In the tragedy Hamlet, Prince Hamlet has been approached with many things that have caused him to be confused

To Be Or Not To Be Insane

733 words - 3 pages itself into stubborn resolution when the specter reminds him that “The serpent that did sting thy father's life / Now wears his crown.” As Hamlet's disbelief morphs into a cold, disturbed reasoning, he develops a plan to feign insanity. He tells his friends that from then on, he will maintain “an antic disposition” (1.5.28) so as to not seem suspicious in his quest for revenge. The prince is so convincing as a madman that the king requests

Hamlet Is Not Insane In Shakespeare's Halmet

2014 words - 8 pages . Claudius I believe does, have reluctance and sometimes portrays the characteristics of a mad man, when he finds out he has been tricked by Hamlet, after the Mousetrap he shows the manic tendencies. This could be equated to anyone in the same situation. Even Claudius and Polonius believe Hamlet is not insane,- ?Love? His affections do not that way. Nor what he spake, through it lacked a form a little. Was not like madness. There?s something

Hamlet Intelligent , Not Insane

1368 words - 5 pages mental state, and that he is far too intelligent to be mad. The relationship that Ophelia and Hamlet had in the play could be construed as insane behavior or the main character. Hamlet goes from treating Ophelia with great tenderness, to telling her she is a whore, and he does not love her. Hamlet's treatment of Ophelia can definitely be considered irrational, and without logic. In a letter to Ophelia, Hamlet declares his love by saying