Insanity And Consent Essay

6350 words - 25 pages

1CRIMES -1 ASSIGNMENTINSANITY AND CONSENT: A COMPARITIVE ANALYSISSUBMITTED TO,DR. BALAKRISHNANASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, NUALSSUBMITTED BY ,AKASH RADHAKRISHNAN831, IInd SEM, NUALSCONTENTSInsanity - an overview 4
Section 84 4
Situations were the section can be invoked 5
History of Insanity 6
Mcnaghten Rules 8
The irresisteible-impulse test 10
Durham Rule 11
ALI model Penal Code 12
Burden of Proof 13
Consent 15
Expressed or Implied consent 16
Burden of proof 17
Sections 88, 89 and 92 20
IntroductionThe project aims to study and draw a comparitive analysis between two defences against criminal liabilty. One being insanity, and the other consent. Both the topics will be dealt separately and will include the history , evolution, practicality in the Indian legal context, and the loopholes it faces today. It will also bring about how these are put into practicality and how one can use the existing remedies to get justice. The first half will focus on the 'defence of insanity' , the section that it is included in , its developments and some of its historical background. The second half will focus entirely on 'consent', sections in the Penal code that brings about it and also how they can be used practically.InsanityA general overviewInsanity can be defined as a mental illness of such a severe nature that a person cannot distinguish fantasy from reality, cannot conduct her/his affairs due to psychosis, or is subject to uncontrollable impulsive behavior. Insanity is different when it comes to legal terms. Insanity or mental abnormality is one of the exceptions to criminal liabilty recognized by law. When a person has committed a wrong or a crime in a state of mind where he falls under the essential ingredients of insanity he can use or avail the 'defence of insanity' .Section 84 of the Indian Penal Code which states ' Nothing is an offence which is done by a person who, at the time of doing it, by reason of unsoundness of mind, is incapable of knowing the nature of the act, or that he is doing what is either wrong or contrary to law' grants this provision. This is based on the principle of mens rea where a guilty mind alone in punishable and that an insane or mentally unsound person is incapable of having a will of his own , hence should be exempt from criminal responsibility. However, this provision has long been the subject of academic criticism for being unfair, unjust and out of date and failing to reflect the advances made in medicine, phsycology and psychiatry. The question of insanity is really not a question of law; it is essentially a question of fact. Moreover it is one of the topic in the criminal law that has led to a heated discussion on the question of the responsibilty of the insane for the crime between the medical and legal professions.Sec. 84Sec. 84 of the IPC is the sole section that brings the element of insanity. Sec.84 states ' Nothing is an offence which is done by a person who, at the time of doing it, by reason of unsoundness of mind, is...

Find Another Essay On Insanity and Consent

Canon Law Essay

4359 words - 17 pages far wider than insanity and covers many more conditions. Canon 1095 does not make this distinction; so I shall continue to use amentia where appropriate.Amentia has of course always been a ground of nullity, but there are degrees of insanity, and it has not always been easy to ascertain just how insane a person must be to be judged incapable of matrimonial consent. Ecclesiastical jurisprudence has come to realize better than before that there are

Escaping Insanity Essay

678 words - 3 pages Escaping Insanity Insanity is the state of being seriously mentally ill; madness. The woman in the short story suffers from post-partum depression, making her insane. According to a CDC survey, 8 to 19% of women reported having symptoms of post-partum depression. “The Yellow Wallpaper” by Charlotte Perkins Gilman expresses how creativity and madness go hand in hand because the protagonist in the short story is insane and her only escape is

Writing Assignment #1-Did Biegler and McCarthy Behave Ethically?

797 words - 4 pages After reviewing the two scenes from an Anatomy of a Murder and the Maryland Rules of Professional Conduct, it’s clear that Biegler and McCarthy behaved unethically; because he disclosed client information without consent and he indirectly imposed what defense Lieutenant Manion should plea. In the first scene, Biegler and McCarthy are discussing Biegler’s first visit with Mr. Manion and whether or not he was going to take the case; McCarthy also

Unethical Experiments

1589 words - 6 pages sentences it does so only conditionally, somewhat as follows: if such-and-such a sentence is true, then such-and-such another sentence is true. Logic itself does not decide whether the first sentence is true, but surrenders that question to one or the other of the empirical sciences. (Carnap 57) Unethical is the lacking of moral principles. Many laws were given to defend people who give consent to be experimented on. It is essential that the human

Euthanasia, a controversial issue in the US

944 words - 4 pages allowed to die through a lack of care. The other category deals with consent, which can be voluntary, where the patient gives consent to be killed, and the other being involuntary, where the patient has not expressed his or her intention to die. Accordingly to Jeffko, an expert on contemporary ethical issues, these two pairs of distinctions generate four distinctive types of euthanasia: "active and voluntary, active and involuntary, passive and

Insanity in The Yellow Wallpaper by Gillman and Fruit at the Bottom of the Bowl by Bradbury

1263 words - 5 pages ? until she is well again.? The woman has a feeling the house is haunted even though she is impressed that they are going to stay in such a place for their summer holiday. Once in the room, she notices the wallpaper, which is a horrible yellow colour. Day by day she becomes more obsessed about this wallpaper and begins to see women in the pattern. After asking her husband for consent to leave the room, he refuses and she becomes engulfed by the

American Revolution by Nathan Belisle did america have the right to revolt according to Thomas Paine's "Common Sense"

869 words - 3 pages appointing one man king and giving him the power to rule over an entire region of men is complete insanity itself despite that his descendents are automatically giving this same title. The fact that monarchy cuts a man off from outside information and then asks him to make decisions of the utmost importance requiring that information shows that it is ridiculous. As Tomas Paine writes "The state of a king shuts him from the world, yet the

Joseph Stalin, The Leader of USSR from 1922 to 1953

1294 words - 5 pages . For any type of group to be successful, it is required that there is one individual to consent or eliminate the ideas proposed. However, sometimes there are leaders who desire to obtain something with so much integrity that the best interests of the party are not met or are overruled. The leader will merely use its party to obtain the goals he or she wants, and abuse the rights and privileges of the party. Joseph

Procedures of American Criminal Trial

2653 words - 11 pages , and the defendant must refute this information. If the defendant issues notice of alibi but then withdraws the claim, this information cannot be held against him later in court. Another popular defense is the insanity defense. The court definition holds that “a person should not be guilty if they did not know what they were doing, did not know that what they were doing was wrong, or if their actions were the result of a mental disease or

The basic procedures of a standard American criminal trial...covers everything between indictment and sentencing

2633 words - 11 pages a lot of area, which is part of the reason for its popularity. If the defendant plans to claim insanity, he must notify, in writing, the state's attorney of his intentions, and also file a copy with the court clerk. Failure to follow these guidelines results in the disallowance of the insanity claim. A withdrawn claim of insanity is not admissible as evidence against the defendant.There are many other defenses, divided into three categories

United States Reform Movements

785 words - 3 pages institution, becoming known for excessively cruel punishments for criminal offenses. Extreme cases included imprisonment for insignificant amounts of debt, and asylums were common practices for what was believed to be insanity, following medieval practices. The Society for the Reformation of Juvenile Delinquents, in 1829, reported that they were "proud" to have "rescued" the youthful from temptation and turning them into "valuable members of

Similar Essays

The Insanity Defense Part I When Is The Insanity Plea A Reasonable And

866 words - 3 pages insanity defense pleadings--"far less than one percent"--were entered in Virginia during the same period. A 2001 study in Manhattan (Kirschner and Galperin) noted that over a ten year period, psychiatric defenses were offered by only 16 out of every 10,000 indicted defendants. More than 75% of the time that a psychiatric defense was successful, it was the result of the prosecutors' consent. Out of nearly 100,000 felony indictments during that

Civil Commitment And The Mentally Ill

1271 words - 6 pages ). In this paper we will talk about the insanity statutes being used in the state of Georgia and how often the insanity defense is being used, and the major criticisms of the insanity defense. For many years the public has fought with the idea that a mentally ill person should not be held accountable for criminal crimes (Allnutt, S., Samuels, A., & O'Driscoll, C. 2007). In states Montana, Idaho, and Utah, does not consent for the defendant to plea

Is The Current Law Defense Of Insanity Ineffective?

2143 words - 9 pages a particular offence. DIABETES Today, the insanity defence also includes psychiatric and neurological conditions, as well as disorders like diabetes. In the UK 3.2 million people suffer from diabetes, which is 6% of the UK average. In R v Hennessy (1989), the D was charged with taking a motor vehicle without consent. He was suffering from hyperglycaemia caused by high blood sugar level and he did not inject the insulin and he was in an

Affirmative Defences Essay

882 words - 4 pages most used justifications are self-defense, public duty, necessity, and consent.      The justification of self-defense is based on the defense that the defendant has the right to protect themselves as well as family from harm, such as robbery or rape. The self-defense justifications can be used when a person commits a crime such as assault or murder when the defendant believed they were about to be or already been physically