Intelligent Design: Reasons It Shouldn't Be Taught

786 words - 3 pages

CONThe origin of life, its an unknown that has been discussed, researched, and pondered for an unknown length of time. But is the theory of Intelligent Design, or ID, a theory that should be taught in the science department of the United States educational system? Unfortunately no, its not. The theory should not be added to the science curriculum because it is not science. It better fits in another curriculum. Says Presidential Science Advisory John Marburger, "Intelligent Design is not a scientific concept." Because we agree with Mr. Margburger we must stand in negation of the resolution that in the United States, public high school science curriculum should include the study of the Theory of Intelligent Design.First a few Definitons:Intelligent Design, According to the Intelligent Design Network, is a belief that asserts that naturalistic explanations of some biological entities are not possible and such entities can only be explained by intelligent causes.Science, according to Merriam-Webster Dictionary, is the observation, identification, description, experimental investigation, and theoretical explanation of phenomena.First, Intelligent Design does not fit under the definition of science. If we look at the Merriam-Webster defintion, it has five criteria for science. 1. Observation, you cannot observe Intelligent Design taking place and no one has. 2. Identification, we cannot identify the intelligent agent associated with ID which leaves a big gap in the theory's validity. 3. Description, because we can't identify the intelligent agent it is impossible to describe it. 4. Experimental investigation, there is no way to experiment ID or test for its validity. And 5. Theoretical explanation of a phenomena, the only explanation is that we were designed but ID gives no means as to how.But this is not the only definition of science out there. According to Austin Cline, a Regional Director for the Council for Secular Humanism gives his definition of science, " Science is naturalistis and is founded upon the premise of repeatable events and testable predictions" he goes on to say that "neither of which are possible in a supernaturalistic context." He then argues, "ID is not naturalistic, it makes no testable predictions and explains no repeatable phenomena. It is not science by any stretch of the imagination and as such does not...

Find Another Essay On Intelligent Design: Reasons it shouldn't be taught

Evolution: It Should Be Taught In Schools

1470 words - 6 pages creationism which believes the Earth to be ~10,000 years old). Further evidence for Intelligent Design is the complexity of nature (e.g. Human Anatomy), something so complex that a foreign agent could have created it (Stafford) Astounding, only 15% of all Americans believe in the evolution of humans taught in schools, with 46% believing in traditional Creationism (Templeton). Such a staggering number means that the populaces will embrace a new

Music in schools and why it shouldn't be cut

2182 words - 9 pages associated with memory. So it is not simply that music can make you intelligent but simply that the practicing of it can increase your intelligence. The skills practiced in music can also be attributed to other aspects of life, which can be why music thought to make those who practice it more 'intelligent'. Data from the National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988 showed that music participants received more academic honors and awards than non-music

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1004 words - 5 pages intelligence. ”Normal language develops over a period and it is sequential or ordered” (Crystal,1992) To sum up, whether verbal intelligence is an innate or a taught attribute, is an arguable issue. According to the previous evidences mentioned above, it is very clear that any person can be intelligent by doing some activities as well as having good training. Another proof that verbal intelligence is not instinct is that educated people are

Creationism: Should It Be Taught Along Side Evolution?

1121 words - 5 pages benefit from having been taught a wide variety of “theories” in science classes. Creation Science, or Intelligent Design as some choose to use, do not require any religious faith in order to learn it. It simply claims to be a theory that critiques Evolution (Reiss 399-415). The concept of Intelligent Design is not based on religious texts and doesn’t refer to any of the supernatural. The designer that is referred to in these “Theories” may or

Birth control, Why It Should Be Taught in Schools

993 words - 4 pages n/a) That is because we teach too much abstinence only education. So you can see that although parents believe abstinence only education is appropriate, that schools should teach about birth control for two main reasons. First, students will have a better understanding how birth control works. But most importantly, it would decrease unwanted pregnancy in the future. So that is the many reasons why birth control should be taught in schools

Why Marijuana should be legalized and also why it shouldn't be

1200 words - 5 pages logically apply because marijuana has been proven to be far less harmful then some drugs I already talked about, such as alcohol and tobacco.In conclusion, I found many more reasons marijuana should be legalized than reasons why it shouldn't be. From a philosophical point of view it definitely should be legal. In my own opinion I believe that it should be legal. Our country could make a lot more money, less people would be going to jail, and many

The Controversy of Huck Finn: Reasons as to why Huck Finn should and should not be taught in schools

1276 words - 5 pages Since its publication, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, written by Mark Twain, has been challenged for a variety of reasons. Many schools have struggled in attempting to teach the book and several aspects of the novel seem inappropriate. For instance, some may agree that the use of the racial slur, nigger, Huck’s rebellion against religion, and the inaccurate portrayal of the South are all reasons why the book should not be taught. There

Huck Finn: Should It Be Taught In American Literature Mark Twain, The Adventures Of Huckleberry Finn

1331 words - 6 pages Huck Finn: Should it be taught in American Literature?Throughout the years, few books have been as highly debated and criticized as Mark Twain's 1885 novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. The book's controversies are still heavily debated today. Many schools have gone as far as to ban this book from high school reading lists, despite its strong display of realism. However, this novel is a historical piece of literature and should not be

Stillwater Mining: 3 Reasons It Might Be Time To Buy

915 words - 4 pages Over the last five year, Stillwater Mining (SWC) has returned 255.2%, outperforming its industry peers who have struggled to post positive returns. The Billings, Montana-based miner is engaged in developing, extracting, processing, smelting, refining, and marketing of platinum group metals (PGM). And despite it being up 24% year-to-date, there are a handful of reasons that should propel the stock price higher. Supply deficit South Africa and

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1310 words - 6 pages determines how important it is, and who should be responsible for the decision in case things got out of control. Being a conflict between different opposing sides, and having serious harmful consequences, citizens shouldn’t start a revolution unless there is a necessary demand for change and reform. According to Thomas Jefferson, the third president of the United States, the author of Declaration of Independence, and the

Young Offenders Act In Canada. Speaks of why it should be changed, and the the reasons and actions taken

1424 words - 6 pages of the material is not directed at one specific culture insociety, the facts remain that it is a problem that is growing inepidemic proportions. Many of the programs that exist in society todaydo not address the problems associated with young offenders ofspecific cultures. Although the trend is moving in a direction thataddresses programs for specific cultural groups much more emphasismust be put on these programs.For First Nations youth that are

Similar Essays

Intelligent Design Should Be Taught In School As A Science

1587 words - 7 pages ? Even if intelligent design was boring, that does not make any sense on why it does not qualify to be a science. The qualifications are clear; a science must be testable by experiment and observation. This was clearly proven at the presentation. “Just because you don’t agree with something being, does not mean it does not belong” (Greggory3). One of the biggest reasons Intelligent Design deserves to be taught in the classroom is that Intelligent

Should Intelligent Design Be Taught In Public Schools?

1629 words - 7 pages , for obvious reasons, can never pass as unaffiliated with religion, and thus can never be taught in government-funded public schools. As of now, its proponents’ claims for the earth’s age vary between 6000 and 4.5 billion years ago, as long as God did it (Branch). Rather than relying on scientific evidence, intelligent design thrives on the most miniscule of holes in evolutionary fossil records and the unfathomability of a living cell being created

Position Paper: Should Intelligent Design And/Or Creationism Be Taught Alongside Evolution In Public Schools?

901 words - 4 pages There are many controversies in courtrooms about whether or not should intelligent design should be taught alongside evolution in public schools, which has been going on for a great amount of years. Intelligent design is the idea of nature's changes cannot be a random process, but a type of guidance must have lead to why nature is the way it is in today’s era. In most cases, that specific guidance is God. God has created the world for a purpose

Can Intelligent Design Be Empirically Proven

3218 words - 13 pages question, how does intelligent design describe the origins of life? Does the concept of intelligent design correspond with the structure of what a scientific theory should be, or should society discard the study and see it as nothing more than a religious article of faith encased in a scientific cloak? Well, according to Stafford Betty, author of the article, Intelligent Design Theory Belongs in the Science Classroom, “Intelligent design theory