International Human Rights And Humanitarian Law

1077 words - 5 pages

While there exist distinct points of difference, principles of international human rights laws and international humanitarian law overlap on multiple occasions. It is both interesting and informative to understand the differences and similarities in these principles between the two. Differences include underlying intention behind formulation, range of application and effect on different parties while similari underlying enactment ties include general principles The researcher attempts to analyse these aspects by first delving into the points of distinction and then move on to the coinciding issues in both. Finally, a conclusion encompassing the law as it stands today with ...view middle of the document...

These rights also stem from conventional and customary international law. International human rights law envisages the preservation of a number of core principles which find codification in the form of treaties like the International Covenants on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), and on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights of 1996, as well as Conventions on Genocide (1948), Racial Discrimination (1965), and Torture (1984). The onus of protecting these rights such as right to life and dignity and right against racial discrimination and torture is on the state. The states not only have the burden of protecting the rights of their own citizens but can also call upon other nations to adhere to these basic standards of human rights.
In terms of intention, international human rights law primarily targets the inclusion of certain basic human rights into the governance of states as routine practice and has a much broader area of application. In other words, the idea is to infuse organic change on a global level. Humanitarian law on the other hand has a much more limited area of influence. It tries to ensure some basic standard of humanity during times of war so that human rights aren’t completely neglected in such times of armed conflict.
It must be kept in mind however, that international human rights law applies during peacetime as well as conflict. Only in times of emergency or immitigable circumstances that countries may not act according to the provisions of international humanitarian law. However, even in such times, human rights like the right to life cannot be derogated. This clearly illustrates the overarching
Points of Similarity
Having established that certain human rights are to be guaranteed to citizens in all situations, it would not be incorrect to state that IHL and IHRL can have a symbiotic relationship and can act simultaneously. This proposition has gained currency over the years despite apprehensions that the two branches of law suffer from fundamental differences and cannot coexist. However, despite such apprehension, a more functional approach to the problem can be found in the form of ‘lex sepcialis’. According to this principle, the similarities between the two laws can be used to enforce each other and therefore create room of peaceful coexistence.
Even a cursory glance at Article 31 (3) (c) of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, 1969 provides much clarity...

Find Another Essay On International Human Rights and Humanitarian Law

Relevance of Public International Law in Human Rights

1317 words - 5 pages Human rights seem to be one of the most current issues worldwide. Uncountable efforts have being made to assure the avoidance of violations and abuse of them during human history. However, it is not just until the end of World War II that joined efforts by most of the countries in the world were visible, being public international law one of the ways to . It could be said that public international law is one of those important efforts that

International Adoption and Human Rights Violations

1157 words - 5 pages is when human rights are violated. Some people voice concern that international adoption in some cases “rips” the children out of the hands of their parents, leaves American children without families, violates one of the most basic rights of all humans, and is in some case similar to human trafficking. Adoption alone is a wonderful opportunity to provide a home and family for a child that would otherwise go without, and international adoption is

Law and Society: Human Rights Violation

1263 words - 5 pages UN report, “Gross human rights violations remain a serious threat to continuing efforts to transform Afghan society,” The number of human right violations has increased from the past according to the UN report and immediate steps have to be taken place so that the people of afghan can enjoy their freedom and to the country’s long-term prospects for peace, stability, democracy, development and the rule of law. “Coupled with a weak, corrupt and

Islamic Law and Universal Human Rights

3191 words - 13 pages interest and have brought further awareness on the subject. The problem that many of these authors and citizens around the world see with this subject is that there are areas in which the practice and Islamic law itself are in clear violation of human rights. However, complications within this issue can be found due to varying cultural lenses, portions of the law that coincide with human rights, and international understanding of the law itself

The Role of the Red Cross in International Humanitarian Law

1591 words - 6 pages International Humanitarian Law. Henry Dunant on his way to Italy to meet Napoleon III to discuss the difficulty of doing business in Algeria then under French control witnessed the Battle of Solferino in the small town of Solferino where in one battle night, up to 40000 men died and many more were left wounded with no medical attendance or any kind of relief. Abandoning his original plan, Dunant started to organize medical attendance and more relief to

Investigate the increasing importance of human rights after World War II in both international and Australian law

1153 words - 5 pages Atrocities of 2nd War led to greater emphasis on role of international law in achieving peace and established United Nations, an international organisation for maintenance of security and promotion of human rights. In 1948, Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) was proclaimed asserting rights to life, liberty and security of all. This led to a foundation for the fundamentality of human rights worldwide as states ratified and were liable

Amnesty International: Concealed Human Rights

1180 words - 5 pages “Don’t mourn. Organize”- Joe Hill, a labor activist. Amnesty International (AI) is the largest organization of ordinary citizens uniting to end human rights abuse. AI is independent from any government, economic interest and political ideology. Originally they created global pressure by writing letters to prisoners of consciences. The reactions to the letters has exceeded the organization’s expectations and impressed the public by promoting

International Human Rights: Police Brutality

2247 words - 9 pages , Section 6(iii). (Amnesty International 1) The measures taken by the police and Mugabe’s government violate a substantial number of the human rights cited earlier. Violations include, but were not limited to, protection against torture, all persons being equal before the law, access to legal remedies, protection against arbitrary arrest and detention, freedom of assembly and association, political participation, and life, liberty, and security of

International Human Rights in Action

1038 words - 4 pages International Human Rights in Action The United Nations has been adapting its human rights machinery in order to better respond to the changing demands of the international community. During the cold war, the United Nations created the normative and institutional structures for international human rights protection, steadily broadening its competence in this area. At the same time, it supported the vast process of decolonization, which led to

Human Rights in Latin America and International Factors

1058 words - 5 pages organizations. Additionally, the increasing authority of human rights organizations such as the Organization of American States or the UN, and developments in international human rights law, started to result in amendments to the constitutions of both countries that more closely aligned them with international human rights law. For instance, section 75 article 22 of the Argentine constitutional revisions “gave constitutional hierarchy to nine international

The History and Obstacles of Facing International Human Rights Proliferation

1860 words - 7 pages across the globe, and would lay many of the conceptual frameworks for future human rights law. Nearly twenty years after the Geneva Conference on January 6, 1941, Franklin D. Roosevelt would deliver his “Four Freedoms” speech that would breathe life into the international rights movement. The President declared that there are four essential human freedoms that should be able to be exercised no matter where in the world a person is: “the freedom of

Similar Essays

International Humanitarian Law Essay

1952 words - 8 pages International Humanitarian Law (IHL) is seen as the law in which provides basic human rights in time of armed conflict. The use of IHL in a modern scenario is needed now more then ever with the increase of entities that wish to disrupt the peace by ignoring basic human rights. Organisations and treaties have been created to help govern the IHL; which will need to be analysed to provide insight into IHLs. This essay aims to critically analyse IHL

Kenya: International Human Rights Law Essay

1362 words - 6 pages On the global scale, transnational actors have the capability to enforce international human rights laws. Such capability is currently in place in the global system through the intergovernmental organization known as the International Criminal Court (ICC). The ICC hears cases on genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity from around the world. This court is different from the World Court, as it has the ability to indict individuals from

Children Protected Under International Humanitarian Law

2575 words - 11 pages INTRODUCTION History of Human Rights and IHL CRC and its Approach to IHL 1. General Comments 2. Concluding Observations 3. State Reports Assessing the Role of the CRC. Introduction Child protection has been an unspecialized part of International Humanitarian Law (hereinafter “IHL”) when IHL was first established through the Geneva Conventions in 1949. However, as warfare grew to

Contemporary Challenges Facing International Humanitarian Law

2066 words - 9 pages conflict. • To examine the opportunities and challenges of International Humanitarian Law during armed conflicts. • To assess levels of civilian protection with regards of the intractability of conflicts. • To explore the ideas on the development of transparency and impartiality with regards to civilian protection during armed conflict. Hypotheses Hypothesis 1: Human rights considerations and civilian protection are being overridden in Afghanistan