This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Internet Censorship Two Case Studies: Australia And The United States

2829 words - 11 pages

I. Introduction

Internet censorship laws started appearing around the world in 1995. These laws covered content already illegal in existing laws for non-internet content, as well as for content that is not suitable for minors. Worldwide, four different approaches were taken with internet censorship. 1) The government encouraged user self-regulation, and voluntary use of content filters by their citizens. 2) Laws were implemented that penalized content providers who made censored material available online. 3) Some governments instituted country wide blocking of censored material. 4) The most restrictive censorship implemented by some governments was complete blocking or restrictive access to the internet. 1

This paper will show whether the ethics of censoring internet content depends on the culture and laws of the country. I personally believe that internet censorship is not ethical and internet users should decide for themselves what they can and cannot see. This paper will prove the ethical implications of internet censorship through two case studies: the United States' Communications Decency Act, and Australia's Broadcasting Services Amendment (Online Services) Act 1999. The United States and Australia have both taken two different approaches to internet censorship. However, both countries started out with similar censorship laws. The United States in 1996 passed the Communications Decency Act. This law was later found to be unconstitutional and in violation of first amendment rights to freedom of speech. The US currently has no internet censorship laws. The Australian government uses the Broadcasting Services Amendment (Online Services) Act 1999 to censor internet traffic to this day.

II. US and the Communications Decency Act

In 1996 the United States passed the Communications Decency Act (CDA). "The CDA prohibits U.S. citizens from transmitting over any form of electronic network 'any comment, request, suggestion, proposal, image, or other communication which is obscene or indecent knowing that the recipient of the communication is under 18 years of age.' (Because Web pages and Usenet newsgroups are public, the law would apply to any material in these venues.) The CDA imposes fines of up to $200,000 and jail terms of up to two years for violators." 2

Opponents of the CDA argued that the Act was too vague, and would lead to subjective rulings. There were no definitions of what indecency meant legally. They also considered it unconstitutional, violating Americans first amendment rights. In 1997, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed with the opponents, and ruled that the CDA was unconstitutional. "Regulation, where required, of the Internet should promote freedom of expression, personal and technological innovation, and ubiquity of access to online services. Clearly, adults and children should not have access to obscene material. It is not protected by the First Amendment. However, governmental regulation of...

Find Another Essay On Internet Censorship Two Case Studies: Australia and the United States

Free Speech on the Internet v. United States Constitution

1681 words - 7 pages ” material? Is a website considered indecent if they use curse words and if it is indecent should they be fined $250,000 and serve up to 2 years in prison? This was answered on June 27, 1997 when the supreme court declared the CDA unconstitutional in the case Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union.(Greenhouse) Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens said that free speech on the internet is held to be a freedom protected by the highest of laws, the

The Early United States: A Two Sided Coin

1602 words - 6 pages standpoint to each law and federal policy. Since its start, the United States has been a two-sided coin of support and opposition. Issues such as Independence, Slavery, and Succession are three of the many that show the United States to be a country that does not always come to a consensus. From the beginning, the United States has been a country at least somewhat divided by political differences. Even in the late 1700s when the Colonists began

Of Fog and War: A Comparative Analysis of Two Japanese Bombing Attacks on the United States during WWII

1637 words - 7 pages Of Fog and War: A Comparative Analysis of Two Japanese Bombing Attacks on the United States during WWII Warfare, unfortunately, is an essential part of mankind. It has been witnessed since time immemorial. What is comforting to know, however, is that it does not always end with blood baths, or similar devastation. Sometimes warfare ends with two enemy forces forgiving one another. This happened years after the Lookout Air Raids, when the

What were the sources of the emerging Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union, and what key events in Germany brought the two sid

679 words - 3 pages Q8: What were the sources of the emerging Cold War between the United States and the Soviet Union, and what key events in Germany brought the two sides to the brink of confrontation? Despite having been allies during World War II, shortly afterwards in the late 1940s the United States and the Soviet Union found themselves in a new type of war. A war against one another. The period was known as The “Cold War”, which was a rivalry between the two

The Difficult Decision for the United States to Enter World War Two

1850 words - 8 pages February 1941. Within this editorial Luce had two main points about the war and America. The first point was not only one person or country will be enough to defeat Germany and Hitler. Henry Luce means that it has to be a joint effort. Everyone has to be in support in able to defeat Germany. Secondly, Henry Luce thought that the United States needs to replace Great Britain as the global leader and that America needs to make new of the systems of

Analyze how the American way of waging war during WW2 influenced the United States in the conduct of limited warfare in the post-World War Two era

976 words - 4 pages Question:Analyze the American way of waging war compared to the Japanese and German conduct of war in World War Two and how that experience influenced the United States in the conduct of limited warfare in the post-World War Two era. Address the societal aspects of the United States as they influenced its way of war. Be specific in your answer by discussing technology, tactics, formations, organizations, weaponry, training, doctrine and

Case study of two organizations; Pharmacy Board of Australia (AHPRA) and The Pharmacy Guild of Australia

601 words - 3 pages under control and asked to double her daily dose of coversly 5mg tablet to 10mg. Then few days later Mrs. Jenkins felt very unwell and called an ambulance and went to the hospital emergency. They did all necessary checks when the error was discovered. Case study of two organizations; Pharmacy Board of Australia (AHPRA) and The Pharmacy Guild of Australia Pharmacy Board of Australia: • Registration • Notifications • Compliance • Accreditation

Children and the Censorship of Internet Pornography

4232 words - 17 pages of hardcore pictures, movies, online-chat, and live sex chats that can be acquired by means via download and virtually viewed by the users of the Internet (upon pay sites). Sexually implicit materials can be found on web pages and news groups within the realm and hands reach of minors to view. c.)Obscenity (Three-Part Test) According to the1973 case of Miller v. California, material is obscene if all three of the following conditions are

Internet Censorship and Technology

1535 words - 6 pages to control the flow of ideas. Unfortunately for the Chinese officials internet usage did explode and with it came serious loss of credibility and control over the populace. As the government lost control it only strengthened its position towards censorship. The Human Rights Watch states that China Achieves this by, “requiring internet search firms and state media to censor issues deemed officially “sensitive” and blocks access to foreign websites

Internet Censorship and China

1371 words - 6 pages The Politics of Censorship – Bryan Thetford Such an enormous investment is, out of necessity, coupled with legislation and bureaucracy. In 2010 the People's Republic of China released a white-paper via their Information Office detailing its policies for implementing and regulating the Internet (Xu). Delegating control to over a dozen government organizations and detailing 18 specific laws or decisions regarding China's Internet, the document is

Censorship of the Internet

2802 words - 11 pages , Entertainment Weekly 10.My Phung Hinh, Global Look at Internet Censorship, 30 April 2004, 4 June 2004, <http://cseserv.engr.scu.edu/StudentWebPages/mhinh/mhinh_MidtermPaper.htm> 11. Diaz, Internet Censorship, Two Case Studies: Australia and the United States, 4 June 2004, <http://cseserv.engr.scu.edu/StudentWebPages/jdiaz/jdiaz_MidtermPaper.htm> 12.Ethics, Santa Clara University Markkula Center for Applied Ethics. 4 June 2004, <http://cseserv.engr.scu.edu/NQuinn/COEN288/EngrHandbook_Ethics.pdf>

Similar Essays

Comparing The Internet In China And The United States

2275 words - 9 pages Twitter users grew from 12 million to 35 million (Yang, 2012). Internet censorship in the United States is heavily protected by the freedom of speech and expression in the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. Due to this, there is very little government intervention on the Internet. Nonetheless, the American government ensures that the Internet is highly regulated and “supported by a complex set of legally binding and privately mediated

Internet Monitoring In The United States

1836 words - 7 pages to 37,616 in 2011. During that same time period, the number of people whose telephones were the subject of pen register and trap and trace surveillance more than tripled the number of authorized orders. That means that of the thirty-seven thousand people that were authorized to be spied on, over one million people were actually spied on that year. The Justice Department, and by proxy the entirety of the United States government, has been spying

Physical, Psychological, And Organizational Consequences Of Bullying Among Nurses In The United States And Australia

2571 words - 11 pages literature in Australia and the US appear to agree on the psychological and physical consequences to the victim however, there are more studies done in Australia to help dissect and illuminate the bullying issue in nursing. Australia seems to be taking a more proactive approach to the issue. Organizational Consequences It is projected that by the year 2020, the United States will be in need of 800,000 nurses (Weaver, 2013). The nursing shortage

A Review Of The Development Of Internet And Cyberlaw In United States

1322 words - 5 pages A Review of the development of Internet and Cyberlaw in United States The history of Internet can be traced back to the Arpanet 1968, a military research network sponsored by the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA). The ultimate purpose for the invention of the internet was to ensure the military communication during wartime. It was later developed to the private sectors and university researches in the 20th Century. This was the period