Interpretative Methods Essay

1060 words - 4 pages

Interpretative MethodologiesJane Dickins and Ronan O'Flaherty use different methodologies to learn about the past. Jane Dickins talks about ethnography which is the descriptive documentation and analysis of a contemporary culture. O'Flaherty discusses experimental archaeology which is a branch ofarchaeological investigation in which carefully controlled experiments are undertaken in order to provide data and insights that aid in the interpretation of the archaeological record. Dickins discusses what constitutes the ritual behaviour of Bronze Age axes and Central Australian tjurunga.O'Flaherty constructs a replica of the Early Bronze Age halberd and uses it on 20 sheep skulls.Jane Dickins talks about the use of ethnography which is the central interpretative methodology in this paper. The strength of this ethnographic method is that it "presents the possibility of varied and heterogeneous reasons or causes for a practice" (Dickins, 1996), for example the possibility that a Bronze Age person would deposit an axe in bog/wet land as part of an offering or to obtain a higher status. In this paper Dickins aims to analyze what constitutes the ritual behaviour of the Central Australian tjurunga and the Bronze Age axes. However, there are many flaws to this ethnographical analogy of the past. The weaknesses to this method is that the documentation about the contemporary culture is constructed on the basis of cross-cultural generalization without any note of the various different social backgrounds and beliefs that the people had that made them (Dickins, 1996). Although little records of the finds of axes have been kept as most were found by accident, the ethnographic documentation that has been recorded suits Dickins aim as the record of Irish axes and where they were found provides an answer to the aim of the paper. A hoard of 11 axes were found at Co.Kerry lying in a hollowed hole with their cutting edges facing outwards. This shows us that considerable care was enforced in placing these axes highlighting their significance in the ritual behaviour. Also, out of the 240 Bronze Age axes found, only 12 were found with something other than an axe. This again highlights their ritual significance. The ethnographical analogy used also suits the aim with regards to the Central Australian tjurunga. The term tjurunga describes sacred objects or boards which are kept hidden in isolated caves and rock shelters. They are passed down from spirit ancestors. We learn from records about the rituals involved in hiding a tjurunga. When a person becomes an o wner of a tjurunga, they are taken to a hidden store-house(caves/rock shelters) where their tjurunga are deposited in isoltaion from other sites and activities. The site of a tjurunga store-house is determined by the dreaming stories that it contains. The store-houses are usually marked by a feature in the landscape such as a cave, rock shelters or on hills. Although at Ilbalintja, in the eastern-central desert, there...

Find Another Essay On Interpretative methods

In sociological research, do the ends justify the means ?

962 words - 4 pages In Sociological Research, Do The Ends Justify The Means ? Discuss.This essay intends to define the purpose of ethics, ethical issues and considerations in research methods. It will look at the differences in research methods and various case studies to support them, but mainly focusing on participant observation.The definition of 'ethics' in the "Oxford Concise Dictionary" (1995) states a set of moral principles adj. 'ethical' - relating to

mission Essay

2319 words - 10 pages understand in greater depth the work currently done by Museum Educators for visitors to enjoy and make the most out of their experiences within museums, the following analysis aims to identify the central issue within the art education process, through description and reflection on the representative theories, methods and strategies applied in art educational programs of visual arts museums. The aim is to understand the nature of learning and how it is

DNA and DNA Profiling Made Simple

2243 words - 9 pages sampling the DNA sample. The figure below is an example of crime scene results (courtesy of How Stuff Works). The methods enlist the methodology used, which in this case if the STR loci amplification process. Finally, the report presents a table containing all the profiles generated and their matches with an interpretative statement. The interpretative statement shows whether the DNA profile generated matches the DNA samples from the suspect, victim

RMA and Demographic Variables

906 words - 4 pages Thesis The article discusses a study that was conducted to find out the public’s view on rape. Specifically, this study “investigates the relationship of RMA with demographic variables, intolerant belief systems, and ideological attitudes in a representative sample of German residents,” (Süssenbach and Bohner, 2011, p. 377). RMA stands for rape myths acceptance. According to Süssenbach and Bohner, RMA “serves as an interpretative schema for

Home exam

1582 words - 7 pages interpretivism. The aforementioned is the position which follows the principles and methods of natural science, while the latter is regarded as a contrasting alternative. Interpretivism is therefore typically related to studies of a qualitative more interpretative character such as semi-structured interviews as well as participatory observations. The interpretivistic position is a technique that recognizes the differences between "people and

Paratextual Features and Functions: Mapping Amorphis Tales from the Thousand Lakes

936 words - 4 pages The notion of paratexts as “thresholds”, as thought by literary theorist Gerard Genette, was initially intended for analysing books. However, researchers have recently applied that knowledge to a variety of mediums. Birke and Christ (2013) investigate how paratexts function in DVD cases and digital literature. They propose that paratexts serve three main functions: interpretative, commercial and navigational. In this chapter I will draw on Birke

Describe the main features of qualitative research and compare the advantages and disadvantages with experimental research

1575 words - 6 pages argue that social behaviour is an objective, independent reality, relying on theories which describe that reality (Megee, 2001). Theories depend on constructs and variables, and the relationship between these constructs/variables. Theories are formulated either deductively (based on logic) or inductively ( based on observation) or through a combination of these two approaches (Megee, 2001).Methods are quantitative and attempt to understand some


2458 words - 10 pages our responsibilities and actions within that world.” (Desai and Bailey, 2005, p. 39) Teacher be trained to use the educational material, and they will be encouraged to work the content addressed in their classroom prior to students visit Centex. The material develops conceptual-centered methods such as tools to explore not the content itself, but rather the aim is to develop skills such as how to look at art and express ideas and opinions

The Use of Improvisational Music Therapy

1286 words - 5 pages within a psychoanalytical approach. While this approach is valuable and should not be disregarded completely, it is not infallible. The work of the therapist within the case study is largely interpretative, which makes its validity questionable. For example, while Amir attributed ‘Lisy’s’ resistance to improvisation to her control issues that stemmed from her sexual abuse, another therapist may have interpreted this differently. Many classically

Computer Aided Language Learning (CALL)

1194 words - 5 pages technology assisted learning help these students gain literacy skills, language skills, and, simultaneously, self esteem and self worth? Once again, the concept would be challenging to research and the only format I can conceptualize is a mixed methods research incorporating qualitative and quantitative analysis. The following weeks and months will be very challenging since my topic has not been specifically designed, but the above thoughts should

The Digital and the Humanities

1087 words - 5 pages relationships between the digital and the humanities are rapidly demanding new modes of observation, exploration, and interpretation and in this perspective information visualization and interfaces are becoming essential tools to explore and make sense out of the increasing quantity of available data. Due to the fact that most of the methods and technologies adopted by the digital humanities come from other disciplines, today the biggest challenge in

Similar Essays

Phenomenology Essay

822 words - 4 pages Phenomenology used in Qualitative Research Many phenomenological methodologies have been developed and used by qualitative researchers to review individuals’ experiences. Phenomenology for organizational research, descriptive phenomenological method, hermeneutic phenomenology, interpretive phenomenology, and interpretative phenomenological analysis are the five popular phenomenological methodologies in qualitative inquiry. Phenomenology for

A Critical Review Of Qualitative Methodological Approaches

1546 words - 6 pages . This paper aims to review and compare three of the qualitative research methodologies: Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA), Discourse Analysis (DA) and Grounded Theory (GT), and identify how they can be applied in coaching research. Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA) Interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) is an experiential qualitative methodology developed by Jonathan Smith, for use in new psychology research

Management Research Methods Essay

1274 words - 6 pages from positivist epistemology and objectivist ontology (Hallebone & Priest, 2009). On the contrary, qualitative methods rely on concepts from subjectivity ontology and interpretative epistemology. The article outlines a research that was done to analyze the Spanish Hotel Industry with the view of determining the influence of training on organizational performance. The ontology of the research is directed towards finding the connection that exists

Qualitative Research: Idealist Ontology Essay

1072 words - 4 pages by both staff and patients in the locked psychiatric ward. Based on the previous theoretical foundations, methodology is chosen to guide the research process and justify methods (Giacomini, 2010; Carter & Little, 2007). Ethnography is a common methodology in qualitative research and was utilized by the researchers, with a participant observational approach, to become immersed in the culture of the locked psychiatric ward to seek an intimate