Interpreting The Uninterpretable: Unreasoning Nature And Heroic Endurance In Crane's The Open Boat

1847 words - 7 pages

Ever since it was first published in 1897, ''The Open Boat'' has widely been considered a masterpiece of literary realism. All of the most recognizable elements of Realism are present within the story. In its graphic probing of events and in its objective description of the characters' psychological state, the story successfully presents a realistic sensation of the characters' experience without any of the false heroism or romantic plots that characterized other contemporary fiction. ''The Open Boat'' has no plot in the traditional sense; it is almost a mere description of thoughts and events. In fact, since author Stephen Crane actually experienced the events related in the story when he was ship-wrecked with the crew of the Commodore, one might suspect that the story is not fiction at all. Indeed, the story's subtitle, ''A Tale Intended to be After the Fact, Being the Experience of Four Men From the Sunk Steamer Commodore,'' presents the story as if it were a journalistic account. Yet, despite its appearance as an objective narrative, ''The Open Boat'' raises deeply philosophical issues and is rife with symbolism. When analyzed closely, it becomes clear that a simplistic categorization of the story as ''realistic'' fiction fails to do justice to the multi-dimensional qualities of ''The Open Boat.''A few days after Crane survived a shipwreck off the Florida coast, he published an account of his experience in a newspaper story entitled ''Stephen Crane's Own Story.'' It is interesting to compare this non-fictional account with the short story ''The Open Boat,'' which appeared six months later. In this first account, Crane relates only the events of the Commodore's sinking, without either the descriptive quality or the access to inner thoughts that characterize the later fictional story. In addition, Crane deliberately leaves out any description of his experience on the life raft, commenting that ''the history of life in an open boat for thirty hours would no doubt be very instructive for the young, but none is to be told here now. For my part I would prefer to tell the story at once, because from it would shine the splendid manhood of Captain Edward Murphy and of William Higgins, the oiler.'' In this statement, the theme and purpose of ''The Open Boat'' can be discerned. Despite the unsentimental realism of the story, Crane sought to portray his idea of the true meaning of heroism. His remark that such a story would be ''instructive for the young'' is particularly revealing because it links the purpose of ''The Open Boat'' with that of Crane's most famous novel, The Red Badge of Courage, in which a young man's romantic dreams about courage and heroism are shattered by his encounter with a real war. Henry Fleming, the young soldier, learns that battle is chaotic and meaningless and that heroism has nothing to do with extraordinary acts, but more with the mere luck of survival. Similarly, after Crane reflected upon the events of his shipwreck, he...

Find Another Essay On Interpreting the Uninterpretable: Unreasoning Nature and Heroic Endurance in Crane's The Open Boat

Stephen Crane's The Open Boat Essay

1420 words - 6 pages “The Open Boat” was written by Stephen Crane in 1897. This is an extremely powerful short story fictionalized by one of Crane’s own experiences out at sea. He is able to use what has happened to him, and spice it up to turn his story into a fictional account everyone can relate to. The reasons this story is so powerful is because of the literary devices Crane uses throughout the story, especially symbolism. In “The Open Boat,” Crane uses the

Symbolism and Devices in Stephen Crane's The Open Boat

1990 words - 8 pages is near and it is time for the final journey through the surf for the survivors.  Crane begins the section with the same gray setting as the beginning of the story and describes the scene to provide focus for his specific statement of the theme of “The Open Boat.”      This tower was a giant, standing with its back to the plight of the ants.  It represented in a  degree, to the correspondent, the serenity of nature amid the struggles of

The Open Boat: Crane's View of Naturalism

1134 words - 5 pages To define one's purpose is at the very least human nature and at the very most the meaning of life. Humans seek the significance of existence and try to define it in many ways. There are thousands of religions and countless seminars to help people discover the point of human existence. The idea that we may all be irrelevant in the grand scheme of life or to the universe is not a popular position. In his short story "The Open Boat

What are the themes found in Crane's Open Boat?

2413 words - 10 pages In "The Open Boat" Stephen Crane uses repeating themes of character experience, action and imagery to convey feelings of the overbearing vulnerability, and seeming futility, of the successful human race when placed in context and comparison to nature itself. Crane's depiction of four men in a dinghy that "many a man ought to have a bath-tub larger than" guides a reader through alternating themes of hopelessness and hope during a dilemma that

Analysis of Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat"

2114 words - 9 pages Stephen Crane’s short story “The Open Boat” is a story of conflict with nature and the human will and fight to survive. Four men find themselves clinging to life on a small boat amidst a raging sea after being shipwrecked. The four men, the oiler (Billie), the injured captain, the cook, and the correspondent are each in their own way battling the sea as each wave crest threatens to topple the dinghy. “The Open Boat” reflects human nature’s

Indifference to Anxiety in Crane's The Open Boat

2619 words - 10 pages experience in the open boat. In having his characters reach interpretation and not his readers, Crane here empowers direct experience of life over the act of reading. An example from the story manifests this privileging of experience over reading as the true generator of meaning. In the midst of his evening watch in Section V1, the correspondent reflects on his position in the universe. At first angered that "nature does not regard him as

Choices and Responsibility in London's To Build a Fire and Crane's The Open Boat

1642 words - 7 pages ' and Crane's 'The Open Boat' are ultimately responsible for their choices and consequences of their choices. In 'To Build a Fire,' the man's antagonist is nature: London displays the man's journey as restricted by external forces. First, the temperature of the tundra is seventy-five-below zero (978), which naturally exposes the man?s ?frailty as a creature of temperature? (977). Obviously the man is subject to the forces of winter, and can not

The Power of Nature Revealed in The Open Boat

935 words - 4 pages The Power of Nature Revealed in The Open Boat     In 1894, Stephen Crane said, "A man said to the universe: 'Sir, I exist!' 'However,' replied the universe, 'The fact has not created in me a sense of obligation.'" This short encounter of man and nature is representative of Crane’s view of nature. However, he did not always see nature as indifferent to man. In 1887, he survived a shipwreck with two other men. "The Open Boat" is his account

Man and the Vain Struggle Against Nature & Himself: Determinism in Stephen Crane’s The Open Boat

2238 words - 9 pages form of the sea and the weather, and he also presents nature in the form of the tired and hungry bodies of men. The four survivors on this small boat struggle against these forces acting upon them as they fight for survival. In “The Open Boat” Crane pits man against nature, but it is a fight in which at least one of the competitors, nature, is not actively participating, and by showing this, Crane is able to demonstrate shifting perceptions as

Themes of Nature, Brotherhood, and Knowledge in "The Open Boat" by Stephen Crane

2769 words - 11 pages boats" (361). However as the story progresses, it appears that Crane's conclusion is rather that nature (and thus God) is indifferent to men. In "The Open Boat," the correspondent sees a windmill on the shore. He saysThis tower was a giant, standing with its back to the plight of the ants. It represented in a degree, to the correspondent, the serenity of nature amid the struggles of the individual-nature in the vision of men. She did not seem

Autobiography in The Open Boat

973 words - 4 pages , “Among scholars, the consensus seems to be that, while "The Open Boat" is based in fact and served as an outlet for Crane's creative impulses, it is a work of fiction, one that has had great impact on the study of American literature and, in particular, the short story” (Eye). Debates are constantly roused over the fact or fiction aspect of the story. When analyzing “The Open Boat”, commentators come from the perspective of an autobiography in

Similar Essays

Man And Nature In Stephen Crane's The Blue Hotel And The Open Boat

2883 words - 12 pages essay I asserted that the characters' joyless acceptance of nature in "The Open Boat" leads the men to help and sympathize with one another. The opposite is true in "The Blue Hotel;" in that story, the characters' lies cause dissention and tragedy. Truthfulness in response to nature is everything. What Paul Johnson once wrote about Ernest Hemingway's characters is also true of Crane's: They "stand or fall by whether they are truthful or not

Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat" Essay

1096 words - 4 pages way.Stephen Crane's use of description and depiction of nature go hand in hand with one another in "The Open Boat." This is true because he used one to help create the other. The only depreciative factor in the story is the length. The men's state of affairs carried too long. For superfluous periods of time the story is reported without any change of events. The narrator continually describes the men's conditions without any great fluctuations. The

Stephen Crane's " The Open Boat"

1764 words - 7 pages than realism (Hart 525). Naturalism was boxed-in by a determinism established by Darwinian theory and Marxist economics. The compelling writings of Stephen Crane which celebrate a fierce self battling against the harsh elements of its environment offer a striking example of American naturalism. In Crane's often anthologized short story "The Open Boat", the careful reader can detect Crane's careful mixing of naturalist elements which results in one

Stephen Crane's The Open Boat Essay

776 words - 3 pages Stephen Crane's "The Open Boat"        “None of them knew the color of the sky.” This first sentence in Stephen Crane’s “The Open Boat” implies the overall relationship between the individual and nature. This sentence also implies the limitations of anyone’s perspective. The men in the boat concentrate so much on the danger they are in, that they are oblivious and unaware to everything else; in other words, maybe lacking experience. “The