This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Intrinsic Human Dignity And Equality In Relation To Liberal Democracy

1762 words - 7 pages

Liberal democracy is prevalent in the West. This political arrangement guarantees the rights of a people in relation to their government. Many Westerners, unfortunately, cannot give a philosophical explanation and/or justification for it. Ultimately, an examination of liberal democracy will demonstrate that it rests on notions of human dignity, equality and happiness, which are not recent developments in philosophy, but have their origins in classical and scholastic thought. It is in said examination that one can reasonably conclude that liberal democracy while not the best system of government is certainly better than the alternatives.
Democracy is not a contemporary phenomenon. It did not originate here in North America. Rather, its practice began---more than 2,000 years ago---in Athens, a city-state, in the Greek Mediterranean. The philosophers Aristotle and Plato attested to that fact in their writings. It is in Plato’s Republic that one finds the earliest definition of democracy, which is briefly, “the rule of the governed.” Plato compares democracy to monarchy, or rule of the one, oligarchy, or rule of the elite, and lastly, timocracy, or rule by property owners. Interestingly enough, the Republic’s author believed the rule of a philosopher-king was preferable to that of the masses. The Politics, written by Aristotle, provided a very robust explanation and justification of democracy, which will be detailed later in this paper. Nevertheless, democracy is synonymous with popular sovereignty or the notion that all within a human community have a say in the matters that affect them all.
If one accepts democracy as a practice, the question is then begged what kind of an institution sustains it? This discussion---though in different terms---is seen towards the end of Alasdair MacIntyre’s After Virtue, in which he argues that the practice of virtue is not advanced, refined and promote by an individual, but by individuals. MacIntyre wrote:
A practice involves standards of excellence and obedience to rules as well as the achievement of goods. To enter into a practice is to accept the authority of those standards and the inadequacy of my own performance as judged by them. It is to subject my own attitudes, choices, preferences and tastes to the standards which currently and partially define the practice (190)

It would be arbitrary and subjective for individuals to judge their own craft, may it be the arts or sciences, without referring to authoritative tradition or body to gauge the quality of their work. Thus, institutions are needed because “practices [require] a certain kind of relationship between those who participate in it” (191). This relationship is not only with contemporary practitioners, but with past practitioners “whose achievements extended the reach of the peace to its present point” (194). Thus, the dissemination of knowledge, the observance of religion and the practice of medicine require schools, churches and...

Find Another Essay On Intrinsic Human Dignity and Equality in Relation to Liberal Democracy

Human Dignity and Participation: A Right to Equal Education

3317 words - 13 pages somewhat improved. This is not up to par with human dignity and a right to participate in society. I believe equal education for all should be a basic right under the terms of social justice.Specifically, I would like to point out that Fourth Presbyterian Church is a well known church for its service to those in the city of Chicago. Their Chicago Lights program mission is:To provide children and adults with the opportunity to discover hope and

Relation Between Confucianism and Democracy Essay

2354 words - 9 pages democracy From the above discussion, first and foremost, definition of democracy matters. Due to the injection of liberal values into the democracy, it limits the scope and possibility of these two seemingly contrasting ideals being compatible with each other. Dworkin (2002) believed Confucianism blocked the nurture of universal human nature in which people are treated with equal concern and respect. However, it is advised to take a pause and look

Human Dignity and Universal Health Care

2296 words - 10 pages Human dignity in relation to healthcare is in this day a widely debated issue. With increasing focus on fair and just treatment for all human beings alike one finds that there is a great deal of attention paid to healthcare, one of the most basic requirements for humans (Buijsen, 2010). The case study,Human Dignity and Universal Health Care, looks into the debate underlying public healthcare in Australia and the terms of having citizens access

Human Dignity in Issac Singer's Autobiography

976 words - 4 pages The words Human Dignity can maintain a major aspect in ones life. Human Dignity generally refers to how one expresses him self and having self respect for yourself. As I read both of the Passages, I noticed how Human Dignity really comes into play in life. In Passage 1, a short story written by Anton Chekhov, clearly described and explained how Mashenka Pavletsky, the main character, has self-respect for her self. In the autobiography written by

Human Dignity and Universal Health Care

1782 words - 8 pages ability to fulfil their potential and god given free choices, not taking in the importance of looking after ones self-knowing that they will be looked after by the tax payers. It is described in relation to the quadrants in human dignity viewing a multidimensional aspect that in a 1A-B perspective the human race deserves health care because of inherent worth and free choices that we are able to undertake. However this can be overviewed by 2A-B

ESSAY: The theme of human dignity in the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee

1504 words - 6 pages Throughout history, people are often ranked and criticized by society. An individual's nationality, wealth and social status were closely looked over by society's eye. Thus, one's dignity would be decided based on society's opinion of them. In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the theme of human dignity is portrayed by Scout, Calpurnia, and Atticus. This essay will analyze the theme of human dignity and describe how this novel

appropriate relation between Confucianism and democracy

780 words - 4 pages -free political system. On the other hand, democracy has long been linked with liberal values, for example equality, individual liberty and freedom of expression that today is often known as substantive concept of democracy. Held by Dworkin (1997), protection of rights and liberties shall be the basis of democracy that intrinsically embraced people as equals in the society. Highlighting the divergence between the definitions of democracy reveals

Liberal Equality: America Living Up to the Ideal Over Time

2053 words - 8 pages to work towards. The American tradition was built and raised as the most liberal tradition in the world. It took a long time to truly become so. We can begin to look at the historical building of that equality, but first, from a liberal perspective, we have to understand equality. John Dewey, a more modern political thinker, described equality thus: “Belief in equality is an element of the democratic credo. It is not, however, belief in

Intrinsic Value in the Non-Human Natural World

1238 words - 5 pages Intrinsic Value in the Non-Human Natural World When it comes to the question of non-human rights and the value of nature, there are adamant advocates, those who completely disagree with particular values and rights for the ecosystem, and those could care less. For myself, I believe I have fallen somewhat in between these extremes and have honestly never really considered the idea of intrinsic value and certain rights

Death and Dying in Relation to Buddhism

2759 words - 12 pages Although people in general may have different views and/or ideas on death and dying, is it possible to come to some kind of consensus on its definition? In this essay paper titled, “What Is the Meaning of a Good Death?” I will focus on its definition; discuss where this idea came from and its relation to a traditional Buddhist death. Based on class lecture readings from RLCT 2066 (Death, Dying & Spirituality) and research completed on the

Analyse the complex relationship between Islam and liberal democracy

2410 words - 10 pages period of postwar history, but the end of history as such: that is, the end point of mankind's ideological evolution and the universalisation of Western liberal democracy as the final form of human government.` (Fukuyama, 1989: 50) However, after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, and indeed before that, the attention of many scholars and government officials has been directed towards the lack of democracy in the Islamic states and the

Similar Essays

The Role Of Religion As A Positive Or Negative Or Neutral Or Irrelevant Force, In Efforts To Further National Political Objectives Where Human Dignity, Equality, Justice And Peace Prevail

1923 words - 8 pages The role of the religion as a positive or negative or neutral or irrelevant force, in efforts to further national political objectives or to develop a world community where human dignity, equality, justice and peace prevail.The twentieth century that just gave way to a new millennium was the one of many great events. There were discoveries that defied ideas that were thought to be axioms and there were amazing inventions that radically changed

"Camus Defended The Dignity And Goodness Of The Individual" Discuss This Assertion In Relation To The Novel

1133 words - 5 pages thought that people lived for the truth as he did, that is why he would have a mild confusion after witnessing the reactions people would have with some of his answers. Albert Camus gave each human the dignity they deserved when they acted upon their own wishes and not those of (in Camus' view) a false deity.Meursault treats his acquaintances regarding them with an air of indifference, but this was one of the unique virtues that gave him the

Kiekegaard And Human Dignity Essay

1751 words - 8 pages on in despair. A decayed tooth would cause a person insurmountable pain and suffering for a very long time, and the idea of a secure home where one could raise a stable family --if such a concept could even be sustained amid all the chaos-- was a far-fetched dream. To put it, as Hobbes did, life was "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short" . In the face of all of this, human dignity was pitted against an all-powerful nature and the human

Liberal Democracy And Francis Fukuyama Essay

1161 words - 5 pages Francis Fukuyama argued that liberal democracy was deemed to be the final viable form for political institutions. This implies that liberal democracy will become the last form of regime for states. Fukuyama’s argument was reasonable at the time he created it because it was created after the cold war and the power state was The United States, and they implemented democracy to states surrounding them and states that were influenced by the U.S