This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Investigating Ethical Issues From A Philosophical And Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation

2115 words - 9 pages

Hernandez 3
parts of an animal’s body, sometimes the entire body, to conduct experiments about stress. Other of the many destructive procedures include electrocution, tail suspension and drowning. (Office of Animal Care and Use, 2005) Not all of these animals die due to the causes of only one experiment however, these animals are kept in captivity and are continually tested on until they unfortunately meet their untimely deaths. It is due evidences such as these, that animal experimentation for medical research can be seen as productive for human or harmful to the lives of innocent animals.
In a recent case study named, “Researchers Urged Not to Inject Virulent HIV Strain Into Chimps,” a group of primatologists, AIDS researchers and animal conservationists, strongly advise vaccine developers to immediately stop injecting chimpanzees with HIV. (J.Cohen) This study is an example of how animal experimentation is harmful for animals undeterred by the fact that research testing is being preformed to find a solution that will help fight against the deathly AIDS disease. John Cohen states the injections of HIV in the chimps cause “AID-like symptoms,” to which their bodies react in similar ways as humans do with the HIV virus or AIDS disease. As a result of the tests, it is noted that the chimps will die shortly after being injected (within four years). No progress was made during this experiment however, a new strain has infected the chimpanzees making causing death. It is in cases such as these where morality is questioned. Are these experiments, that infect and kill chimps, worth the risk and time when no new information is found? The lives of the chimps who have died could have been spared if the experiment was not conducted. It is as if they died for nothing since no progress was made. How do we know that with any experiments on animals that the answers we search for will be found? We do not, it is because of the desire for new medical information and change that the lives of these animals are not thought about because it is a situation where the lives of humans are not
Hernandez 4
being risked. It is because of the power that scientists have over animals that scientists see them as lesser to humans, somewhat not truly “alive.”
The pre-socratic philosopher Pythagoras founded the Pythagorean School of thought in 582 B.C. (Columbia Electronic Encyclopedia). Pythagoreanism was the system of esoteric and metaphysical beliefs influenced by mathematics, music and astronomy. As a student of the Pythagorean school of thought one sought to purify the soul by strict ways of life. One of the many beliefs was practicing vegetarianism. The “Pythagorean Diet” was otherwise known as vegetarianism. Vegetarianism, meaning not eating meat, fish or, in some cases, any food derived from animals (Merriam-Webster), was followed for religious, ethical and ascetic reasons. It was because of magico-religious values and beliefs, “of belonging to or...

Find Another Essay On Investigating Ethical Issues from a Philosophical and Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation

Animal and Human Cloning: Moral, Ethical, and Regulatory Issues

2478 words - 10 pages Animal and Human Cloning: Moral, Ethical, and Regulatory Issues Dolly, woolly, innocent, and sweet, strongly contrasts with the severity of the issues that she has raised. Ever since the news surfaced that Dr. Ian Wilmut had succeeded in cloning a sheep, people around the world have been participating in a frenzied debate over the morality of cloning animals, and more importantly human beings. The cloning of animals and humans could help

Animal Experimentation and Research Essay

2622 words - 10 pages and stops trying all together (99-100). This type of experiment seems rather cruel to the animal that is being tested, and is a good example of the experiments that should be prohibited. Indeed a vital question arises. When is it reasonable to perform research and experimentation? Consider the experiments done to help find a cure for cancer or AIDS. Does that not seem to be a worthwhile case? What if you were dying from a rare disease

A More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1628 words - 7 pages It’s Time for a More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation The debate about using animals for medical testing has been raging for years. The struggle always seems to be between extremist animal rights activists who believe that animals should never be used for research, and scientists who believe that any use of animals is acceptable. There are a growing number who argue that there must be a reasonable

Medical Schools and Animal Experimentation

2027 words - 8 pages eventually be put down. The animals are tortured just to live in fear and eventually be put down. All of the stress and boredom that they go through causes them to have neurotic behavior. When someone walks by the cages their blood pressure rises and they shake in fear. Animal research/experimentation is a form of animal abuse. There was a video I watched where the people were treating the animals terrible. They were ripping animals off of cages

animal experimentation: pros and cons

1945 words - 8 pages scientists test on. I'm not saying this is good, I'm saying that if we outlaw animal testing, what would happen to eating animals? Everyone where eating animals is outlawed and animal experimentation is outlawed, everyone would have to stop eating animals. This wont just be bad for human pleasure, but it would hit hard on the economy because many people would lose their jobs. A small factor to allow animal experimentation is for religious reasons. The

Animal Experimentation Pros and Cons

2364 words - 10 pages if there was no animal testing, because dogs helped us create insulin by taking out their pancreases. Concussions from sports would also be very hard to treat as animal experimentation has helped us understand it. Imagine your son or daughter having problems with their brain and you not knowing how to treat it. You would probably feel very bad and helpless. Also, there is no substitute for a whole body system in an animal or human. You could try

Investigating Crime and Relevant Issues

10646 words - 43 pages this experiment does not have any significance to humans, it means that the suffering an animal goes through is not justifiable, which is necessary to comply with ethical guidelines. Also animal results cannot necessarily be applied to humans. It is argued that animals do not have the same qualities as a person. Watson and Rayner’s Theory Little Albert was an orphan from a hospital. Watson and Rayner evaluated

A Religious Perspective on Motivation

2894 words - 12 pages in various forms which can be generally grouped into two categories negative and positive. While these two categories exist in both Western and Eastern religions, both take decidedly different approaches to motivation.Negative Motivations from a Western Religious PerspectiveSin from a religious perspectiveSin from a Western religious perspective is viewed as the breaking of God's law or of God's will. The Bible, John 3:4 states: "Whosoever

The Woman: A Religious Perspective

1105 words - 5 pages Christian Bible talks about keeping a women in her rightful place, that is, in the confines of domesticity and outside the frontiers of education and professions. Most churches have used these to prevent women from teaching theology and catechism, taking theology degrees, becoming ordained, preaching and playing a full role in the church. Women were not always just forced into these roles and left without appreciation. Chinese representations of

It's Time for a More Responsible Approach to Animal Research, Testing, and Experimentation

1442 words - 6 pages provides the greatest benefit from each animal, and thereby reducing the overall amount of pain, suffering, and use of these animals? Are the results we gain from these tests applicable to humans and therefore useful for a majority of humans? The answer to all of these questions, on the whole, may very well be no. Necessity, as defined by Webster is anything that is inevitable, unavoidable, something for which we have great need or something

From a homini's perspective

826 words - 4 pages I had just found a thick, juicy lizard under a rock when I heard a loud rustling nearby. I quickly climbed into the nearest tree and sat on a tall branch to observe the intruder. It resembled my kind, Australopithecus afarensis, but it was way too tall to be one of us. After examining it for a longer period of time whilst it tried to harvest fruit from a tall branch, clearly incapable of climbing as efficiently as us, I realized it was a Homo

Similar Essays

Investigating Ethical Issues From A Philosophical And Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation:

826 words - 4 pages Investigating Ethical Issues from a Philosophical and Religious Perspective: Animal Experimentation: “Ask the experimenters why they experiment on animals, and the answer is, “Because the animals are like us." Ask the experimenters why it is morally okay to experiment on animals, and the answer is, "Because the animals are not like us. Animal experimentation rests on a logical contradiction.” (Charles R. Magel) For abounding years the

Animal Experimentation Issues And Alternatives Essay

2527 words - 10 pages balance between animal rights and human needs. Works Cited AWI . 1951. Issues: Animals in Laboratories[online]. Washington. Available from: http//: www.awi on[Accessed 18 Jun 2010]. British orgnisation. 2008. Understanding Animal Research: About Research[online]. Available from: http:// www.Understanding animal /about_research/types of_animals. [Accessed 8 Jun 2010]. Fano, A. 1997

Animal Experimentation Is Ethical And Necessary

1168 words - 5 pages experimentation has been helpful in leading researchers to immense expanses in invaluable scientific discovery (Ericson para 9) Most medical breakthroughs of the twentieth century included animal testing in some manner (Saraf 6). Even though there are numerous guidelines and protocols that enforce the ethical treatment of laboratory animals, it is still a particularly controversial issue to animal rights activists and the general public

Animal Testing Regarding Ethical Issues Essay

1061 words - 4 pages strive to have the most accurate information possible to keep everybody safe. Animal testing does not assist in that. Today, there are so many technological advances that we could easily find a more ethical way to test medication. As a result, nobody will be harmed during the process of medicine testing. I realize that some people consider animal experimentation acceptable. There have been countless medical successes and colossal amounts of