This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Investigating Students' Intuitive Knowledge About Patterns That Are Discussed In The Science Classroom

1754 words - 7 pages


Professional scientists construct explanations to explain how and why various phenomena in the world operate. Formulating an explanation can allow us to engage in the scientific process by providing a better understanding of new phenomena and the ability to reflect on observations. Both the content and the form of the explanation can influence our understanding of the phenomena to be explained and how we perceive the explanation. In this paper I will attempt to understand in detail the relationship between the content and form of students’ generated causal explanations.

The data presented in this paper was collected from an extra-curriculum summer course conducted in order to investigate students’ intuitive knowledge about patterns that are discussed in the science classroom and which occur in the everyday world (e.g. equilibration, oscillation, chaos, etc.). The two researcher/instructors had expected and scaffolded the students to construct force-based explanations about oscillation. Unexpectedly, the majority of the students’ explanations are based on energy.

Using two complementary analytical approaches I have investigate the relationship between causal form and knowledge pieces within these students’ force and energy explanations. To investigate the causal form of the explanations I will be applying a taxonomy of causal models developed by Grotzer and colleagues (Perkins & Grotzer, 2005; Perkins & Grotzer, 2000; Grotzer & Bell, 1999, etc.). One hypothesis put forth by Grotzer and colleagues is that students’ ability to access various level of complexity of causal form may influence their causal explanation. To analyze students’ knowledge within their causal explanations, I will be using the Knowledge-in-Pieces (KIP) theoretical framework (diSessa, 1993).

These two analyses will illuminate different aspects of the explanations. From the causal forms analysis, the results suggest that both students’ force and energy explanations are of a simple form; this is not completely unexpected given the context of Newtonian Mechanics. Additional results suggest that the causal forms analysis is unable to capture the sophistication of the energy-based explanations and other interesting explanatory characteristics. The results of the Knowledge-in-Pieces analysis suggest that the energy-based explanations contain multiple pieces of intuitive knowledge, including many p-prims and pieces of declarative knowledge; comparably the force-based explanations contain fewer pieces of either type of knowledge. Overall, these two analytical perspectives highlight different aspects of the force and energy explanations. This study has raised questions about Grotzer and colleagues’ taxonomy and questions about the relationship of causal form and knowledge pieces within students’ generated explanations.


Professional scientists construct explanations about various phenomena in the world. Similarly, a...

Find Another Essay On Investigating Students' Intuitive Knowledge About Patterns That Are Discussed in the Science Classroom

What should the government do about segregation in our public schools today? Does it matter to you, that students often attend public schools that are populated only by students of their own race?

665 words - 3 pages good ones.Local governments have the most responsibility out of all three of these. The local government's job is to make sure that the school system is up to date. If anybody is to blame for the segregation in public schools, it is the local government. They hold board meeting every month and if they are still segregating they need to realize that we are in the year 2004 not 1964. They have duty and a responsibility to the students and parents to

Critically Discuss Hakim's Argument That Women's Heterogeneous Preferences Regarding Work And Family Are The Main Determinants Of Female Employment Patterns (Full Time And Part Time) In The UK

4570 words - 19 pages Women’s heterogeneous preferences regarding work and family are the main determinants of female employment patterns in liberal, modern societies (Hakim, 1991; Hakim, 2000; Hakim, 2006). Catherine Hakim argues that the emergence of a ‘new scenario’ concurrent with other tenets of preference theory, has resulted in constraint free societies whereby choice becomes the dominant explanation for the changes in employment patterns. A

Wolfram|Alpha: Computational Knowledge Engine That Benefits Students and Teachers

896 words - 4 pages complete. Then, distribute these materials to students in the Astronomy building. This would be extremely effective for classes such as mathematics, economics and business, engineering and the sciences. This will help raise awareness and also make Wolfram|Alpha simpler to understand- because of its versatility, students without direction may not realize a function that is specifically useful to them exists. Continuing with the previous example, none

This is a detailed essay about the new emergence of SARS. The history, the physiology, the symptoms, and the treatment are discussed

936 words - 4 pages - known to cause the common cold and some intestinal ailments - that they believed was the real culprit. Canadian microbiologists also isolated the coronavirus in five of nine patients tested. There are 13 species of the virus known not all of them infecting humans; they also affect cattle, pigs, rodents, cats, dogs and birds - especially chickens.The disease is still in its early stages, and as often happens with a novel emerging pathogen which

IS the introduction of a Western-based education system in Kazakhstan producing students that are globally competitive?

1384 words - 6 pages social and political problems, there has been constructed Nazarbayev University and Nazarbayev Intellectual schools that is why they are in the center of view and in the press of citizenship and due to its purpose they are referred as area of experiments and yearly education systems, led by organization of “Nazarbayev Intellectual Schools” and Nazarbayev University and their partners, are involved in. The key issue is education system effect on

In the classroom that I observed I found it hard to pick just one academic expectation to talk about in this paper

782 words - 3 pages . Another thing that he had was a CD player which he used to play a CD of a radio report from beginning of the war. About fifteen minutes before class ended he used a VCR to show a video to review what they went over in class. This teacher was every good at displaying technology in the classroom.The second classroom that I observed it was a science class taught by Mrs. Kail is Wagner Traditional High School. In this classroom she show strong knowledge

What are Variables that Influence your Classroom Community?

1454 words - 6 pages and poverty issues in a classroom is having a consistent class schedule and routine. This would be able to provide a stable environment, which is important for those students who lack a stable home life. You could also try to be more creative with the ways you are trying to help your students. You could have students discuss homework in small groups before turning it in or discussing so that students who were unable to finish the homework have a

Study and Comparison the Knowledge of Medical Students and Public Health about Control and Treatment of TB with DOTS Strategy

695 words - 3 pages history of chronic respiratory diseases if their symptoms become exacerbated 12. Findings showed that the mean scores of knowledge, diagnosis, treatment of TB in medical students was 16.42±3.720 of total 40 and this scores in public health students was 16.91±3 which indicates students' poor knowledge about TB and DOTS Strategy. These findings are compatible with Fadaeezadeh's (1), Talaee's (2), Ayatollahi's (3), Jamshidi's (5), Ollé-Goig's (15) and

Study and Comparison the Knowledge of Medical and Public Health Students about Control and Treatment of TB with DOTS Strategy

1094 words - 5 pages (physician - health expert) about this disease. Experts believe that one of the most important and useful measures in the fight against diseases at different levels is health education and promotion of public medical and health science. Any plans for educational content in health depends on understanding and knowing educational needs of the audience. Considering the difficulties in treating resistant TB, identification of the medical students

Study and Comparison the Knowledge of Medical and Public Health Students about Control and Treatment of TB with DOTS Strategy

1102 words - 5 pages weakness of Physicians' knowledge about common infectious diseases. For example, in a study, which was conducted to investigate medical students' knowledge about TB, results has shown that only 30% of medical students were able to diagnose and treat TB patients. This issue led to a revision of TB education, so that after revision 90% of physicians had enough knowledge in the field of tuberculosis. 14 Another study was conducted by Ollé-Goig indicated

Science in the Renaissance: my essay talks about the discoveries that da Vinci and Galileo made. I compared and contrasted their discoveries to Aristotlean theory and each other

3319 words - 13 pages important scientists of the Renaissance. They differed from each other because Leonardo studied before the Scientific Revolution while Galileo studied while it was occurring. Their works varied in that Leonardo studied Aristotelian ideas and Galileo studied to disprove Aristotle's philosophies.In Florence, Leonardo da Vinci was studying something very similar to Aristotle's studies. He knew a lot about Aristotle's works, and had a great interest in

Similar Essays

Students In America Are Lagging In Science Scores Internationally

1178 words - 5 pages Students in America have been lacking on science scores compared to the international scores from other countries. It is well-known that science can help move civilization to the next level, but it all starts in school. “Science is a way of thinking much more than it is a body of knowledge.”-Carl Sagan. The imagination of the future revolves around the skills taught in a science class. The 21st century is predicted to produce aircraft such as

This Essay Debates About Euthanasia.The Pros And Cons Are Discussed In Simple And Clear Terms

690 words - 3 pages person to die in dignity" there are a few different situations involved. Often when the subject is discussed, the example given is about someone suffering from a painful or terminal illness. However the truth is that several situations are encountered. In this light, it seems that though for some cases the argument is straightforward, it is not so for others. Each case needs to be analysed separately.There are cases where a person is kept alive by

Explain The Models Of Oligopoly Behaviour That We Discussed. Discuss Whether The Respective Assumptions Are Realistic

1941 words - 8 pages different models for oligopoly behaviour such as the Cournot Solution, the Sweezy Kinked Demand Curve Solution, the Stackelberg Model and the Bertrand Model.The Cournot model focuses on the behaviour of quantities, prices and profits within a duopoly (if two firms are selling products in the same market). Within this model it is assumed that one firm will not react to all changes from the other firm's decision. Firm 1 can choose an output of p1

This Is An Essay About Madagascar. The Geography, Government, Culture, And Society Are Discussed

1340 words - 5 pages peoples over time. According to this theory, migrants from the Indonesian archipelago arrived first and eventually settled in the central highlands, followed by the arrival of African peoples as a result of normal migrational trends and the rise of the slave trade. Recent scholarship has suggested that perhaps the theories are complementary, with greater emphasis being placed on the first.Scholars traditionally have described Madagascar as being