Investigating The Extent To Which Historians Can Be Objective

1603 words - 6 pages

Investigating the Extent to Which Historians Can Be Objective

‘You have reckoned that history ought to judge the past and to
instruct the contemporary world as to the future. The present attempt
does not yield to that high office. It will merely tell you how it
really was’ - Leopold Von Ranke

‘There are no facts, only interpretations’ – Nietzsche

Here we encounter two diametrically opposed views concerning
objectivity. It can be argued that “true” objectivity cannot exist, as
history is more exposed to differing interpretations than any other
discipline and to be “factual”, dispassionate or truly objective would
be at best unrealistic and at worst impossible. Historians, in their
selective analysis of the past on the basis of surviving historical
records and evidence, draw conclusions, which must necessarily be
subject to their own individual interpretations – interpretations that
are in turn subject to the historians’ own individual ideologies. The
fact that history is constantly being rewritten is testimony to the
impossibility of attaining “true” objectivity.

On the other hand, “true” subjectivity would constitute a threat to
history itself as a discipline – the logical outcome of this would be
to grant every historian his or her own perspective, no matter how out
of synch with the “truth” it might be. The moral entanglement
resulting from such an approach is not difficult to imagine.

This essay will attempt to examine (some) historian’s views on
objectivity, within these two extremes, but the limited word count
necessitates the exclusion of others (White, Collingwood).

Can objective “facts” exist in history? Even when a historian only
presents the “facts”, would they not reflect their personal
consciousness? Even their personal writing style might mirror this.
Also, historians have been known to be deliberately selective about
which facts they present and which they don’t. It could be argued that
facts in history are never “pure” – they come to us distorted,
refracted by the writers’ own interpretation. This means that the
reader must in turn also be selective, critical and analytical about
the “facts” presented to them. The readers’ own understanding is
formed by their own political, ideological or moral consciousness.

Leopold Von Ranke advocated historical objectivity. His approach was
to avoid applying the spirit, modes of thought, wisdom and beliefs of
the present to the events of the past – this is known as historicism
and was pioneered by Giovanni Battista Vico – by only using
contemporary accounts and records. His tagline became Wei es
eigentlich gewesen (How it actually happened). Ranke distrusted
historical textbooks, and argued that primary rather than secondary
sources should be used. Arthur Marwick has slightly similar views
regarding the nature...

Find Another Essay On Investigating the Extent to Which Historians Can Be Objective

Assess the extent to which Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) can contribute towards mitigation and adaptation to climate change futures

1827 words - 7 pages adaptation objective/task should be assigned to each PPP. Vulnerability assessment of alternatives under changing and uncertain scenario should be carried out to judge the best suitable option (Byer et al. 2012). On the other hand base line environment can be significantly changed by variable climate upon which the impact of the proposal will be evaluated. SEA should define specifically the baseline environment; and should also portray specific

What does ‘oral history’ entail, and what use can it be to the agendas of anthropologists, or historians or archaeologists?

2143 words - 9 pages What does ‘oral history’ entail, and what use can it be to the agendas of anthropologists, or historians or archaeologists? Rowse states that ‘human society, its story and how it has come to be what it is, is due to the factors that operate in them’ (Rowse, 1963). This is especially true when looking at history from an oral historian’s perspective. Oral history has always been a topic open to much debate – whether or not it is a method worthy

To what extent can the UK be said to feature a "constitutional government"?

814 words - 3 pages , however there are ways in which it can act unconstitutionally, and no other body can stop them. Yet, the monarchy has the ultimate power so hence can generally stop parliament if need be. So, to a certain extent the UK has a constitutional government that adheres to, yet the unwritten constitution can still provide a framework for the government.

To what extent can Mikhail Gorbachev be held responsible for the collapse of the USSR?

1833 words - 7 pages factors in the collapse of the USSR and Gorbachev can hardly be blamed for it but he does come into criticism for the way he handled the situation. His use of force against dissenting republics such as Lithuania has been described as clumsy and ineffective and in the end his inability to solve the problem proved fatal for the Soviet Union. However I do not feel that this puts the responsibility at his feet, as it is commonly believed that the

To What Extent Can Adolfo Suárez Be Considered the George Washington of Spain?

2229 words - 9 pages shortcomings it does so in a tone so respectful that it fails to convince the reader that it is completely objective. The second most important source was “The Spaniards: A Portrait of the New Spain” by John Hooper which was published in 1987. This book can be considered a primary source since Hooper was a British journalist correspondent for The Guardian in Madrid throughout the early years of the Spanish transition to democracy after the death of

To What Extent Can the Problems of Urbanization be Met by a Policy of Sustainable Development

1815 words - 7 pages the advantage of underground space. In addition, according to Arturas Kersys (2011), people can reduce the serious traffic congestions by additional traffic lanes which can increase crossings throughput. Governments can build addition traffic lanes moderately, as a result, traffic jam would instantly be relieved. All in all, if people pay attention to research a more reasonable kind of road construction, the traffic problems can be solved to a

To What Extent Can the Problems of Urbanization Be Met by a Policy of Sustainable Development

1577 words - 6 pages first thought to enter the mind is energy saving. The phenomenon of wasting water and electrical energy can be seen everywhere in our lives and there are many energy saving tips which are easy to do. According to Energy Saving Trust (n.d.), it is a good idea to “try to be aware of unnecessary lights left on, and appliances left plugged-in or on standby. Nearly all electrical and electronic appliances can safely be turned off at the plug without

A view from the bridge: To what extent can the play be said to be about competing notions of justice?

1356 words - 5 pages causes the conflicting feelings inside Eddie to emerge. He is selfish, and goes against his own beliefs, pursuing an incestuous desire.Alfieri, the narrator of the play, and a family friend of the Carbones, is a wise attorney who dispenses legal advice to Eddie. He is the opposing argument to the Sicilian morals, and tries to warn Eddie of his hasty decisions. Each time a character sets foot inside his office, a conflict can be seen between the

To what extent can Stalin be held responsible for the Cold War?

1071 words - 4 pages above the USSR and therefore Stalin is also to blaim. He systematically took over Eastern Europe using the inaccuracy of terms to his advantage. He held elections as agreed but no ones said anything about elections where capitalist governments were allowed to be elected. Stalin made sure that there were only Communist candidates and any country which disobeyed had the leaders and senior members of the capitalist parties executed and murdered. Stalin

To what extent can Tybalt truely be blamed for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet.

763 words - 3 pages the peace." (1.1.97)In this Tybalt does receive a warning so although he can be blamed for exacerbating a fight in act 1 scene 1 he cannot be further punished.Some would believe that Tybalt does not really listen to the Princes warning which shows a lack of respect for authority which is all part of the reason that the Capulets and the Montagues are fighting anyway since, in Act 3 scene 1 Tybalt comes back to fight Romeo but in truth Tybalt is

To What Extent Can International Aid Be Really Effective?

690 words - 3 pages To what extent can international aid be really effective?One cannot help but be shocked to hear that often, medical and food supplies sent to flood victims have never reached the victims but have in fact fallen into the coffers of the officials who were to distribute the supplies to the victims. This is indeed an eye-opener and we wonder how long such activities have been going on undetected. It brings to realisation the truth that among so

Similar Essays

Discuss The Extent To Which Trade Theory Can Be Used To Explain The Competitiveness Of Locations.

3091 words - 12 pages environment which enables these firms to compete. The four include factor conditions, demand conditions, related and supporting industries and firm structure, strategy and rivalry. Chance and government intervention may also play a contributory role.There are many available theories which can be used to explain the competitiveness of locations. Four of the theories are reviewed and explained below.Theory of Absolute Advantage, labor productivities

Assess The Extent To Which Tsar Nicholas 2nd Can Be Held Personally Responsible For The Collapse Of The Russian Monarchy.

2051 words - 8 pages protests; most of which he was not even capable of administering. He was extremely ignorant and extended what influence he had to secluding his royal family from the world. Nicholas II cannot be held entirely responsible for the deterioration of Russia as there were a number of factors which lead to its revolution such as industrialism, revolutionary parties, peasantry and failed reforms. Ultimately, the Tsar was unable to maintain the autocracy of

The Extent To Which A Teacher Can Be Responsible For Their Own Professional Development And By What Means This Can Be Achieved.

734 words - 3 pages carried out in order to increase the teacher's understanding of classroom teaching and learning, and often to bring about a positive change. It is worth emphasising that not all dilemmas can be tackled satisfactory and not all problems will vanish. Yet, the benefit of dealing with such seemingly unmanageable situations may be developing a different attitude towards them which helps to limit personal strain.Action research consists of four main

Discuss The Extent To Which International Assistance Can And Should Be Effectively Used To Achieve Security Sector Reform As Part Of Post Conflict Peace Building.

3491 words - 14 pages this stage to begin to evaluate the role of the international community in achieving SSR in post-conflict societies. This paper provides an assessment of international assistance in SSR and how such assistance can be more productive in achieving SSR as part of post-conflict peace-building process. It argues for a comprehensive/holistic approach which recognizes institutional and procedural linkages between security agencies. The advocated