Involuntary And Voluntary Essay

1377 words - 6 pages

"Aristotle's notion of voluntary and involuntary. If we excepted this in today's society, how will this change the way we look at morals." Aristotle notion and discussion of voluntary and involuntary is at its simplest form, the recognition of man's ability to make choice. Whether it is by force or by ignorance men are able to choose and must be held accountable for the decisions made.When Aristotle first speaks of involuntary and voluntary he says that if a man is forced to do something morally wrong then it is an involuntary action. He also says that if man is ignorant to the situation then that too is involuntary. But as he describes, there are varying degrees of force and ignorance.If we examine the nature of force to try to come to absolute about voluntary or involuntary action we see that there are many variables. Aristotle says that without qualification actions are called forced upon when the cause is in the external circumstance and the agent contributes nothing. However, Aristotle also says that each situation has particular circumstances that should taken into account. For example, if someone was on the border of financial ruin and was about to lose all his possessions, creditors could request that he sale his home to pay down debt. If the same man chooses not to sale his home but to rob a bank and in the process kills a clerk, we can not say that he was forced to do so and should not be punished. Furthermore, it is absurd to say that this force made him involuntarily kill. We as humans are able to reason and have the capacity to set moral limits.If we then look at Aristotle's notion of voluntary and involuntary in regards to ignorance we must again look at particular instances when seeking judgement. Aristotle says, "acting by reason of ignorance seems to be different from acting in ignorance; for the man who is drunk or in a rage is thought to act as a result not of ignorance but of one of the causes mentioned, yet not knowingly in ignorance". In this case a man may be said to be acting involuntarily because the cause was being drunk. The ignorance is focused on the cause and is said that people can not act irrational and may act involuntary when placed in the state of intoxication. However the state of intoxication should not be held accountable for the ignorance that occurred as a result. It should be recognized that before the man took his first drink, he had a choice and should be held accountable for the choice that was made.In today's society the legal system has been manipulated and legal tests have replaced and have hindered societies ability to make good moral choices. If Aristotle's notion of voluntary and involuntary was excepted in today's society and was unable to be twisted by the courts, it would definitely change the way courts and society looks at morals. In our judicial system there seems to be no room for morality. Everything is based on legal tests. With these tests lies opportunity for corruption and...

Find Another Essay On Involuntary And Voluntary

The Pros and Cons of Euthanasia

1640 words - 7 pages . a painful, disease or condition."# Euthanasia can be traced back as far back as the ancient Greek and Roman civilizations. It was sometimes allowed in these civilizations to help others die. There are many forms that Euthanasia can take. Euthanasia can active voluntary, passive voluntary, active involuntary or passive involuntary. Voluntary euthanasia was approved in some ancient societies. Today, the practice of euthanasia causes great

Euthanasia: ILLEGAL Stance Essay

581 words - 2 pages evolved from euthanasia for physical illness to euthanasia for psychological distress. Finally, it evolved from voluntary euthanasia to the practice and conditional acceptance of non-voluntary and involuntary euthanasia. Once the Dutch permitted assisted suicide, it was not possible medically, legally, or morally to deny more active medical help such as euthanasia to individuals who could not affect their own deaths.Once a patient has the means to

Voluntary Euthanasia: What's Right and Wrong?

2065 words - 8 pages patient's sanity at the time and argue the patient may not be fully competent and does not understand what choices they are making. Others stress, if voluntary euthanasia is legalized, involuntary euthanasia will soon to follow. Involuntary euthanasia ends a patients life without their consent. Despite the fear of involuntary euthanasia becoming

Do People Have the Right to Die?

2405 words - 10 pages Euthanasia defines euthanasia as "the intentional killing by act or omission of a dependent human being for his or her alleged benefit. (The key word here is ‘intentional'. If death is not intended, it is not an act of euthanasia)" (Hamlon). There are two distinct kinds of euthanasia: voluntary and non-voluntary (involuntary). Voluntary euthanasia is when the person who is killed has requested to be killed whereas non-voluntary or involuntary euthanasia

Actions and agents

925 words - 4 pages Aristotle believed there are four types of actions: voluntary, involuntary non-voluntary, and compulsory. Voluntary actions are actions that an individual does without outside influence and with absolute knowledge of the situation and the outcome. One example of a voluntary action is I go to college to get an education to better myself and receive the outcome of a degree. Another example of a voluntary action is noticing a red traffic light

Aristotle's Theories of Responsibility and Choice

757 words - 3 pages acting on causes external to themselves, and therefore cannot be held responsible. When control through knowledge is not plausible due to ignorance of the circumstances encompassed by the action, one also lacks the control necessary for voluntary action.This kind of ignorance itself must be divided in accordance to a voluntary and involuntary ignorance. These two types of ignorance are called general and particular ignorance. General ignorance is

The Slippery Slope of Euthanasia

1289 words - 5 pages The debate on whether voluntary euthanasia should be legalized has been a controversial topic. Euthanasia is defined as ‘a deliberate intervention undertaken with the express intention of ending a life, to relieve intractable suffering’ [1]. Voluntary euthanasia refers to the patients who understand the terms in the consent and sign up under consciousness, while involuntary euthanasia is performed against patient's wishes and some people may

Euthanasia, a controversial issue in the US

944 words - 4 pages allowed to die through a lack of care. The other category deals with consent, which can be voluntary, where the patient gives consent to be killed, and the other being involuntary, where the patient has not expressed his or her intention to die. Accordingly to Jeffko, an expert on contemporary ethical issues, these two pairs of distinctions generate four distinctive types of euthanasia: "active and voluntary, active and involuntary, passive and

muscular system

594 words - 2 pages The Muscular systemThe muscular system is responsible for the human body it is made up of over 700 named muscles. In the body they do everything from pumping blood to moving food through intestines, to helping lifting heavy objects. It is made up of voluntary and involuntary muscles, skeletal, visceral, and cardiac muscles, blood vessels, tendons and nerves.Http:// muscles are muscles that you have

Biography of Aristotle

1513 words - 6 pages voluntary and involuntary actions. Involuntary actions are those that are presented in ignorance or under pressure. An act is under pressure only when its purpose is not the human being performing it, but an outside power or individual. While somebody acts out of unreasonable emotion such as anger the act is not unintentional, as the sensation comes from his or her individual nature. An act is acted upon through lack of knowledge known as

Initial Incorporation

1661 words - 7 pages involvement to American mainstream and American institutions. Thus, labor market fails miserably in explaining the incorporation this ethnic groups in the American society. And labor market incorporation in this case leads no subsequent social economic success.Notwithstanding, Koreans and Japanese are mostly voluntary immigrants who do not share a strong feeling of oppression as involuntary immigrants did. These contemporary voluntary ethnic

Similar Essays

Against Both Voluntary And Involuntary Euthanasia.

789 words - 3 pages Physician Assisted SuicideBy: Ryan BirenPhysician assisted suicide is a death device for the diseased, that contributes to devaluing human life; and this will ultimately bring about a nations demise. "Where is my food? ... Nurse get me some water! ..." You may agree that senior citizens have it pretty comfortable here in Canada. For most of the year they live in their summer homes in the north and with the first spot of snow, they jump on a

Aristotle And The Book Of Nicomanchean Ethics

2543 words - 11 pages right person, but it is not for everyone, and he says it is not easy. He says goodness is altruistically hard to find. Thus, according to Aristotle, “It is difficult to live the virtuous life primarily because it is often difficult to find the proper mean between the extremes.” Voluntary and Involuntary actions. As I reference Book III of Nichomachean Ethics, the terms ‘voluntary’ and ‘involuntary’ are used with the indication to the moment of

Euthanasia Essay

1486 words - 6 pages euthanasia and its opposing views.Euthanasia comes form Greek, meaning a "good death". Euthanasia is divided into four types: active voluntary, passive voluntary, active involuntary, and passive involuntary. Voluntary means that a patient has decided to end his life. Involuntary means that a patient is not competent enough to make the decision and some else is to decide what is best. Active euthanasia is an actual lethal action is taken to end the

Euthanasia Essay

775 words - 3 pages euthanasia: voluntary and involuntary. There is an important to notice the difference between voluntary euthanasia where the decision to terminate life are that individuals wishes and involuntary euthanasia where the individual's decision nobody asks. I believe that voluntary and involuntary euthanasia is morally permissible and should be legalized.Lets take a look at the USA's and other countries' real situation of euthanasia. The Netherlands