This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Ionian Revolt Essay

2194 words - 9 pages

The credibility of Herodotus' text is without doubt a source of much debate amongst classical scholars. For almost any given tale within the text, there are arguments from scholars both for and against the historical accuracy of that particular passage. The account of Aristagoras, the tyrant of Miletus, turned rebel leader, is yet another of such debated anecdotes.One of the few premises that are agreed upon by scholars is that 'the deficiencies of Herodotus, as a historian, if he is measured against modern standards, are notorious' (Chapman 1972, 546). This view is supported by Grundy, as referred to by Evans, who suggests that 'the imperfect character of the information which Herodotus furnishes with regard to the story of the great revolt is so evident that the historian himself must have been conscious of it' (Evans 1976, 25).There are however some elements of the life of Aristagoras that are generally agreed upon as being historically accurate. These include the fact that that there was a tyrant of Miletus named Aristagoras, that he was a key political figure in the Ionian Revolt, that he was involved in an unsuccessful military campaign against the island of Naxos prior to the outbreak of the revolt, and that when the Ionians were clearly losing impetus in the Revolt, Aristagoras left Miletus for Myrcinus.Just how significant a figure Aristagoras in the the leadership of the Ionian Revolt is also a matter of some conjecture. There is no doubt that Mabel Lang is of the opinion that Aristagoras was a selfless patriot dedicated to the liberation of Ionia. In a somewhat romantic explanation of the course of the Revolt, Lang purports that the Ionian Revolt was a revolutionary movement led jointly by Aristagoras and Histiaeus which was defeated less by the Persians and the ambition of its leaders than by a lack of cooperation on the part of the Ionians (Lang 1968, 24).The opinions of Lang however, are strongly refuted by Chapman, who considers that while Aristagoras may have a large amount of text dedicated to him by Herodotus, he in fact did not play a major role in the Revolt (Chapman 1972, 547). Blamire notes that the concept of a conspiracy between Histiaeus and Aristagoras with the purpose of instigating the Ionian Revolt is not very realistic (Blamire 1959, 146).Herodotus himself is of the opinion that Aristagoras was a self-interested tyrant who had nothing but personal gain on his mind, and that the Ionian Revolt was merely a way of protecting himself from the wrath of the Persians after his expensive failure at Naxos. This is evidenced in his statement: Aristagoras could not keep his promise to Artaphenes; he was also under a lot of pressure from the expenses required for the expedition, and he was afraid that the military failure and his quarrel with Megabates would result in the rulership of Miletus being taken away from him. Driven by all these fears, he began to contemplate rebellion. (Herodotus, Book 5.35) Fear, greed, and other...

Find Another Essay On Ionian Revolt

Assess Darius 1 as a Persian King

1320 words - 5 pages in India, as well as toward the west and Europe, starting with Thracia. In 499, some Ionian Greek cities of the satrapy of Lydia, under the leadership of Aristagoras of Miletus, rebelled against the Persians and set fire to Sardis. It was not until 494, with the naval victory of the Persian fleet at Lade, off the shores of Miletus, and the recapture of Miletus, that the rebellion was completely curbed. Having thus subdued the Ionian Greeks

good government Essay

1798 words - 8 pages their fellow Greeks for help. Among the cities that sent aid was Athens, who supplied ships to the ionian rebels. Despite this assistance the persians put down the revolt made Persian emperor Darius angry enough to seek revenge. He planned to punish the Ionians allies, especially Athens, by attacking the Greek mainland”,(The persian war, page 136) As a result the Athenian was won the war, This shows that their military system was organized and

The title of my Book Report is Called Greece its about the humanity and the wars they had back then

985 words - 4 pages little economic development during the period of almost 400 years under Turkish rule. Many Greeks fled the country, and there were periodic revolts. During the 18th century, however, the Greeks began to build their own economy and develop an organized resistance to the Turks. In 1770 the people of the Peloponnesus rose in revolt, but this was quickly stopped by the Turks. In 1821 the Greeks began a seven-year war of independence, which resulted in

The Heroism, Divine Support, and Greek Unity Displayed in the Persian Wars

2296 words - 9 pages threat of the Persian Empire's expansion into Greece and the imminent possibility that they would lose their freedom and become subservient to the Persians, so horrified the Greeks that they united together and risked their lives in order to preserve the one thing they all shared in common, their "Greekness". The Persian War stemmed from the Ionian Revolt which began in 499 BC. The Ionians became a part of the Persian Empire in 546 BC

Cyprus History Of Conflict

1778 words - 7 pages and the kings of Cyprus, while being allowed to retain their autonomy, were obliged to pay tribute to the Persian King and place their military forces at his disposal. Persia's domination, however, was not maintained easily and there were several attempts tooverthrow the Persian yoke, the most significant being the Ionian revolt and an attempt by King Evagoras I of Salamis to unite all of Cyprus' city-kingdoms under him. attempts failed.The

HSC Ancient History Assessment Task 1 Greek World 500 - 400BC

1044 words - 4 pages sent to Lydia after the revolt of the Ionian Greeks. As Ancient Historian Herodotus explains, he played his role in a very moderate way."Mardonius sailed along the coast of Asia and came to Ionia. I shall now relate a thing thatwill be a great Marvel to the Greeks: Mardonius deposed all the sole rulers of the Ioniansand established democracies in the cities".This was significant as a matter of politics as it enabled the people of these cities to

Athenian Imperialism and her Changing Relations with Allies

2219 words - 9 pages follow.Thucydides believes that it was the Ionian Greeks who instigated the transferal of leadership from Sparta to Athens, and Athens then said something which would have been a large cause for the Peloponnesian War which was to follow in 432BC; "We did not gain this empire by force. It came to us at a time when you [Sparta] were unwilling to fight on to the end against the Persians." This would obviously insult the Spartans greatly, as Sparta was a

The History of the Greeks: Hellenic and Hellenistic

6277 words - 25 pages mathematics, medicine and philosophy, the Ionians were revolting against the Persians.The Persian Wars began in 499 B.C. with a rebellion against the Persians. Realizing that they could not overcome the Persians alone, the Ionian leader went to Greece to request help. The Athenians responded by sending twenty of their ships to help the Ionian revolt. The Persians were aggravated by the Athenians' help and vowed revenge. In 490 B.C., the King of

Sparti in Modern Greece

1955 words - 8 pages experienced an emotion very strange to them: fear. To retaliate for advantage in numbers that the helots had over them, the Spartans turned to perfecting their war strategy should there ever be an uprising. Helots’ revolt is the chief believed reason behind the Spartan’s initial war craze, but not the only reason. Greece was constantly under war at this time. It was truly the best time to know how fight. The Ionian Revolt (believed to have

Greece

1662 words - 7 pages Greece Greece was founded in 3000 B.C. Greece is located in Southern Europe, bordering the Aegean Sea, Ionian Sea, and the Mediterranean Sea, between Turkey and Albania. Greece’s area can be compared to the size of the state of Alabama. Between 3500 and 3000 B.C., society was becoming more complex. Villages built during this time were becoming larger. However, the population increased at a slow rate. During the second millennium B.C. two

Investigating Athens' Treatment of Her Allies

6039 words - 24 pages the league was situated at Delos, an island mid-way between Athens and Asia Minor with a good harbour. It was also the centre of Ionian worship for the god Apollo. Originally, Sparta had been given the role of hegemonia (leadership), but due to the arrogant treatment of the allies by the king Pausanias, this role was handed over to Athens. Thucydides accounts that the allies saw this as a great advantage – ‘Because of

Similar Essays

Greece: The Greek World 500 400 Bc The Ionian Revolt

1236 words - 5 pages Ionian Revolt occurred in 499BCThe Ionian Revolt was the first round in the struggle between Greece and PersiaThe Greeks of Asia Minor revolted against Persian controlGreeks had been subject to Persia since 545BCHerodotus ViewsHerodotus believes the direct cause of the revolt as simply the ambitions and intrigues of the tyrant of Miletus (Aristagoras) and his father-in-law (Histiaeus)Herodotus does not take into account the widespread discontent

Crucial Battles Of The Persian Wars

2004 words - 8 pages ANCIENT HISTORY ASSESSMENT TASK - Ben PilgrimSalamis or PlataeaThe Ionian revolt provoked the Greeks and the Persians to start what is known as the Persian Wars. With the large pockets of Ionians living in Persia getting more and more discontent, a revolt was imminent. The first thing the revolting Ionians set out to do was to rid the Ionian cities of tyrants and set up democracies in their place. The Ionians were not alone, the Athenians sent

The Persian Wars And Their Effect On Western History

1053 words - 4 pages Persian army. During the battle the outnumbered Athenian hoplites roundly defeated the Persians. This victory meant a lot to the Athenians; it gave them confidence in their ability as a military and paved the way for further democratic developments. As a punishment for Athens part in the Ionian revolt, had Persia defeated them, Darius was going to install Hippias as a tyrant over them.1Mortimer Chambers and others, The Western Experience. 9 ed

Explain The Main Features Of Darius 1 Reign

1023 words - 4 pages with comparatively little success.Meanwhile, sometime after 513 BC Persian forces captured the Greek islands of Lemnos and Imbros. In approximately 499 the Ionian Greek cities on the west coast of Asia Minor revolted against Persian rule. At first the rebellion prospered even though it only received limited assistance from the Athenians. Military efforts continued for a few years until 494 BC when Persia was successful. After the revolt Persia