This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Irish Cases That Discuss The Meaning Of Intention

2319 words - 9 pages

Irish Cases that Discuss the Meaning of Intention There are only two reported Irish cases which discuss the meaning of
intention, one in the context of attempted murder,and the other in the
context of capital murder. These cases rely on the relevant English
authority pertaining to the definition of 'intention', and so it is
proposed to deal mainly with the latter cases here. Both the Irish and
English cases are set out below in chronological sequence.

Following DPP v Smith, the next major case in this area of the law to
reach the House of Lords was Hyam v DPP. In this case the accused, Mrs
Hyam, in order to frighten away her rival for the affections of a man,
poured petrol through the letterbox of the house where the woman and
her children were sleeping. She then ignited the petrol causing a fire
in which two of the children were killed.

The trial judge directed the jury that the necessary intent would be
established if the jury were satisfied that when the accused set fire
to the house she knew that it was highly probable that this would
cause death or serious bodily harm.

The question which came before the House of Lords was whether proof of
the fact that the accused knew that it was highly probable that the
act in question would result in death or serious bodily harm would
suffice to establish malice aforethought in the crime of murder. The
House of Lords, by a majority, upheld the conviction for murder. All
five judges were of the view that carrying out an act with the
knowledge that it was highly probable that death or grievous bodily
harm would result amounted to malice aforethought. Accordingly, as
this state of mind was held to be a species of malice aforethought, it
was not strictly necessary to decide whether the accused actually
intended to kill or cause grievous bodily harm. Nevertheless, various
views were expressed as to whether foresight of probable consequences
would amount to intention in the strict sense.

Lord Hailsham adopted the definition of intention laid down by Asquith
L.J. in the civil case of Cunliffe v Goodman:

"An 'intention', to my mind, connotes a state of affairs which the
party 'intending'...does more than merely contemplate. It connotes a
state of affairs which, on the contrary, he decides, so far as in him
lies, to bring about, and which, in point of possibility, he has a
reasonable prospect of being able to bring about by his own act of
volition."

Lord Hailsham also indicated that foresight of probable consequences
was not the same as intention. Although foresight of probable
consequences (or degrees of likelihood) was an essential factor that
should be...

Find Another Essay On Irish Cases that Discuss the Meaning of Intention

The True Intention of Affirmative Action

604 words - 2 pages "I have a dream that one day this nation will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: " We hold these truths to be self-evident: that all men are created equal." Dr. King stated this in his famous " I have a Dream" speech in Washington, D.C. in 1963. Since the civil rights movement of the 1960s the idea of diversity has become increasingly more desirable. Diversity in an organization is required instead of just praised. Affirmative

The Intention of Violent Video Games

970 words - 4 pages juggernaut of the game industry that contains violence is the infamous Grand Theft Auto, by Rockstar Games. It is often used as an example to portray violent games due to the violent nature of the game. The player is a criminal that is able to attack pedestrians, steal vehicles and, commit many other crimes. Overall only 15.5% of video games have a M rating and contain extreme violence, however they are there and 15.5% of a massive market is enough to

The True Meaning Behind that Layer of Blue Nail Polish

1050 words - 4 pages The True Meaning Behind that Layer of Blue Nail PolishWhen the red-based shades such as pink and orange were the onlytype of nail polish females dared to wear, I remember wondering if inthe near future they'd dare switch to completely new shades such asblue or green. Now that day and age has come when all differentshades of blue can be seen painted on teens' nails. Yet, this new choiceof blue isn't just another craze of the moment. Rather, it

Using Two Or Three Brands, Discuss The Influence Of Sponsorship On The Creation Of Brand Meaning

2763 words - 12 pages retained is more subtle than that from the more overtly paid-for advertisement. The meaning of a brand image basically expresses a way that a consumer thinks about the brand and the feelings the brand arouses when the consumer thinks about it. On the basis of these characteristics, which the consumer associates with the brand, the company can build a competitive advantage for its brand. When combining sponsorship and brand meaning the company can

Revival of the Irish Culture

1977 words - 8 pages immediately the people of Ireland took to this new sense of cultural nationalism. The Irish began to believe that their language was not merely a way to communicate, but a way of cultural values and a way of life (Hachey and Hernon Jr. and McCaffrey 140). People from the urban middle class, who previously knew nothing of the Gaelic history, began joining the league in massive amounts of numbers. Soon, many of the people who had previously lived

Buddhism vs Catholicism. Define two rituals within each religion and discuss the meaning of these rituals

1645 words - 7 pages , which lead to carelessness. The ceremony is finished after the monk gives the initiate a new name which has a meaning. This meaning is something that the initiate should try to fulfil during their lifetime. The meaning of a Christian Baptism is to become apart of the Christian community. In being baptised you will live your life the way that Jesus did in his life. Baptism is the first step taken as a child to become apart of the Christian

Criminal Justice/ DIscuss the Bill of rights and their court cases and how they are applied today

726 words - 3 pages ; "whether suspects had constitutional rights ...[and] ...how and when those rights could be exercised".The fourth amendment to the Bill of Rights states that people have the right to secure their homes, papers, themselves, and effects against unjustified searches. The amendment also required that a warrant be issued under probable cause, to search or arrest someone. In 1949 the court case of Wolf v. Colorado appeared in regards to this issue, the

"The explanation of a work is always sought in the man or woman who produced it." (Roland Barthes) Why should we not look to authorial intention for meaning in literature?

1868 words - 7 pages 'ultimate meaning'2 , the biography and psychology of the author should be cast aside by the reader and the focus should instead be on the text, 'It is language that speaks not the author.'3 In applying Barthes' theory to Virginia Woolf's 'Orlando' (1927-28) and Jeanette Winterson's 'Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit'' (1983-4) I hope to show that critics should not necessarily look to authorial intention for meaning in literature.In the reading of

The Intention of Staging Reunion Scenes in Drama and Literature

1430 words - 6 pages A reunion scene, or scene of recognition, is a common plot device used by authors and playwrights by crafting a series of coincidental and random events that lead up to the reuniting of estranged loved ones. Typically, these reunion scenes involve mistaken identity, newly discovered birthright or accidents at sea that result in the characters to believe their beloved are deceased. As a playwright, Shakespeare used missed chances and

Two cases of IT Initiatives that failed. - OSU - Assignment

538 words - 3 pages Two cases of IT Initiatives that failed. Both the cases stress on how not building and managing a system may be a huge risk in determining the success rate of an organization. On how project and following a lifecycle matter is really important, and if enough attention is not given to these fields, it could lead to a disaster. a. The problem the IT initiative addresses. · Informal methods to track of sales opportunities and forecast sales

The Meaning of Abortion

1462 words - 6 pages churches have different opinions on abortion, for example, The Roman Catholic Church says abortion is wrong and a sin In all cases. The Protestant Church says that abortion may be acceptable in some cases. Within the Christian church there is a diversity of belief and opinion on the subject. Christians believe all people should take full responsibilities for their bodies as they are 'the temple of the holy spirit

Similar Essays

Explain The Manner In Which Irish People Have Been Racialized In Britian And Discuss The Impact On People Of Irish Ethnicty Living In That Country

1685 words - 7 pages time. Historically the Irish were not considered, by the British, as being ‘white’, but were more akin to ‘negroes turned inside out’, ‘white negroes’, ‘apes’ and a beastly race in need of a superior guiding hand. Ultimately inferior to other ‘white’ groups. Prejudice towards the Irish manifested in a variety of differing sentiments, ‘…from seeing the “native Irish” as “wayward children…” that “…needed strong leadership”’. Through to the more

Discuss The View That The Period 1800 1850 Was One Of Both Progress And Disillusion For Irish Catholics

1609 words - 6 pages rent collectors during the famine.The general election of 1841 marked a turn in the tides for Irish nationalists. The liberals were defeated in Parliament and the conservatives returned to power, meaning that O'Connell and the Irish could no longer count on the support or sympathy of Parliament. Another defeat came in 1843 and is generally seen as a turning point for Irish Catholics. A monster meeting was to be held in Clontarf on October 8th

Discuss And Evaluate The Use Of Statistics In Current And Historical Cases Of Forensic Significance

916 words - 4 pages Introduction: The science of statistics refers to two distinct areas of knowledge. One area refers to the analysis of uncertainty and the other area refers to the listing of events, counts of entities for various economic, social, and scientific purposes. It is for these reasons that statistics can be of great value within the area of forensic science. Evidence that is used within a legal setting, contains doubt, which means that this evidence

Luck Of The Irish Essay

1812 words - 8 pages A is for Arranmore or Aran Island Árainn Mhór, Árainn Uí Dhomhnaill, meaning the 'Aran of the O'Donnells' to distinguish it from the Aran Islands off Galway Bay or the Scottish Isle of Arran , largest inhabited island of the County Donegal and with 7 square miles of land is 2nd of all inhabited Irish islands. It has a permanent population of around 650, summer pop of 1000. Settled in pre-Celtic times, an old fort and several middens-ancient