This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is A Documentary Always More Realistic Than Fiction Film? If So, Why? If Not, Why Not? What Makes A Film More Or Less Realistic?

1000 words - 4 pages

Is a documentary always more realistic than fiction film? If so, why? If not, why not? What makes a film more or less realistic?

In this essay, I will explain why a documentary is always more realistic than a fiction film. I will show my thesis by exploring elements that influence how realistic a film is: film editing and format, genre, and transparency. I will use the documentary of Armadillo (2010), by Janus Pedersen, and the fiction film of The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach (1968), by Danièle Huille as examples.
To begin with, some of the significant differences between documentaries and fiction films are transparency and aesthetics. Documentaries present existing, authentic ...view middle of the document...

Hence, the film’s editing makes it artistic. Another example of fictional film elements comes from when the cameraman perfectly records the Taliban attacking the Danish soldiers. He puts himself in danger: right in the middle of the fight. If the audience did not know any better, this fight could have been perfectly staged. It is as if the purpose of Pedersen were to create an entertainment film using a real life situation, rather than to document a real life event.
Also, The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach is a fiction film that could be considered more realistic than a documentary of Armadillo’s nature. The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach aims to show the life of Johann Sebastian Bach recounted in second person by his wife, Anna Magdalena. Although the movie is fictional, Huille uses stimuli proper of documentaries that support the film’s narrative. An example of this comes from authentic letters and manuscripts from J.S. Bach presented in the film. This provides the audience with a veritable account of J.S. Bach’s life; thus, it increases the film’s realism.
Nonetheless, because of Armadillo’s transparency, it will always be more realistic than The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach. Despite the use of extended shots on musical scores and original J.S. Bach transcripts that make the film resemble a documentary, The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach is just a reproduction of J.S. Bach’s life. No matter how real the film appears to be, it is a “pseudorealism of a deception aimed at fooling the eye,” just because it was an acted film. It relies on deception. Therefore, Armadillo is more realistic than The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach.
In conclusion, based on The Chronicle of Anna Magdalena Bach and Armadillo, transparency is what predominantly makes a film more or less realistic. Thus, this is an example that shows documentaries are more realistic than fiction films. However, Huille’s film may be, in Picasso’s words, “a lie that brings us closer to the truth,” because it is a lot more transparent...

Find Another Essay On Is a documentary always more realistic than fiction film? If so, why? If not, why not? What makes a film more or less realistic?

more is not always better Essay

1013 words - 5 pages Polypharmacy: More is Not Always Better Polypharmacy is defined as the concurrent use of multiple medications, usually taking more than four, in order to manage several different illnesses or decrease chances of serious complications but results in negative outcomes. This includes prescribed drugs, the over-the-counter (OTC) drugs, herbal remedies and dietary supplements. The combined use of these drugs can interrupt desired drug-drug or drug

A Film With More Than One Connection

2572 words - 11 pages many to not pay as much attention to history because they believe that it is only in the perspective of which the government or teacher wants to them to know, and in fact that is often the case. But somehow when you tell the viewer that it is a science fiction movie, they are more intrigued by it and it seems to have a bigger effect on most viewers. Through the historical fiction seen in the film we are able to understand what really went on in

Can Terrorism Ever Be Justified? If So How? If Not, Why Not?

3205 words - 13 pages justifiable.In short, if there are examples of terrorism permitted under just war theory, they will have to meet a number of challenging requirements. Indeed, 'they will have to be acts of political violence that are proportionate and effective, done in support of a just cause, and not immoral in themselves. Additionally, they will have to be more, perhaps very much more, discriminate rather than less discriminate or indiscriminate in who is targeted

Why the Millennium Development Goals are Not Realistic.’

2202 words - 9 pages the only region that encountered a growth in the number of living in extreme poverty, from 290 million in 1990 to 414 million in 2010. Furthermore, the World Bank projects that, by 2015, about 970 million people will still be living on less than $1.25 a day in countries classified as low- or middle-income in 1990. With this, the aforementioned point that it is not possible that the goal will be achieved by 2015 is justified. Furthermore, with

What are the first few civilizations? If so, why is

545 words - 2 pages What are the first few civilizations? If so, why is it that they are considered civilizations, and what about them? The first few river-valley civilizations are considered to be civilizations by our scholars, and each of those civilizations' characteristics, advantages by creating societies, and things that we should remember will prove them to be civilizations---as well as explain a little bit about each of those civilizations

Train Journey - A reflective short story asking if money is more important than family

740 words - 3 pages form of an afterlife that the various religions claim of. Anything proved by science was fact as far as Martin was concerned and anything else was just complete fiction. But if there was no afterlife, thought Martin, then why were there so many people convinced of their near death experiences? Many people had changed their lifestyle completely and made a u-turn on their way of life. Martin was beginning to rather like the idea of an afterlife but

'Dracula is nothing more than a simple gothic horror story' - describes why it IS more than a simple story

655 words - 3 pages "Dracula is nothing more than a simple Gothic horror story"Dracula is far more than just a simple Gothic horror story. There are several aspects of the novel that point towards it being a complex example of the Gothic genre. Not only does it provide its audience with some classic elements of the Gothic genre; for instance medieval settings, supernatural appearances and mysterious happenings; but it also offers insight into a number of themes

What Makes a Great Film?

1070 words - 4 pages should not be obstructive. This is so since if a musical score is too loud or too emotional; it could possibly taint the brilliance of the performances and the film itself. In addition to a musical score in producing a distinctive film, special effects can greatly mould a movie. With special effects, it generally makes the visual effects appear convincing. This means that things that are not in reality possible would be made possible on screen

A Little More Than Human a little less than god

1244 words - 5 pages partially due to the fact that Winston Churchill was Franklin’s distant cousin (Kunhardt 188). Franklin played a major role in not only insuring the U.S. success literally but also mentally, to help maintain the faith of the U.S. Franklin gave his first of his famous “ Fireside Chats” on March 12th 1993. Franklin D. Roosevelt was a little more than human a little less than a god. Through his life Franklin faced many trials like polio and a close call

Why EQ is More Important than IQ

1514 words - 6 pages is more important than IQ nowadays. A person with high EQ shows signs of not afraid to express his feeling and express them with reason, logic and reality, and not the slave to negative emotion such as fear, worry, guilt. We should be brave and do things that we want to do. Besides, we should act out or do something to desire and not of force or duty. We should always express our feelings clearly and directly with three word sentence, so that

Why Prometheus is more courageous than Antigone

685 words - 3 pages for it. "... is willing to die in order to give her brother an honourable burial" (Watling 13). This shows that if Antigone is really determined to do something she will do anything, even if it costs her life. Prometheus is more determined because he suffered for so long and is still refusing to tell the secret where Antigone does not really suffer for a long period of time and quits without fulfilling her wish to be loyal to her brother by

Similar Essays

Is Euthanasia Ever Morally Justified In Your View? If So Why And Under What Conditions? If Not, Why Not?

3158 words - 13 pages Alise Boehme PHIL101 - Bioethics Assessment One Student Number : 220107672 Word Count: 2737 Is euthanasia ever morally justified in your view? If so why and under what conditions? If not, why not? Many people have their own judgment on whether a human should have the ability to end their own life, some believe it would be morally acceptable if they were suffering from terminal illness or were in serious un-­‐relievable pain, but

Do You Think That The Concept Of Organisational Culture Is A Useful One In The Real World? If So, Why? If Not, Why Not?

3912 words - 16 pages initiated (either deliberately or inadvertently) as a reactionary response to problems and this, Bate (1994:8) proposes "may explain why so little is known about the cultural change process in organisations". Bate observes that there is an assumption "that an understanding of the cultural process is not absolutely necessary before an attempt is made to change it".Anthony (1994, in Fulop & Linstead 1999) argues that every cultural change process

Is The Ban On Muslim Headscarves In French Schools Justified? If So, Why? If Not, Why?

1585 words - 7 pages not be such a choice. On another note, if the government strongly believes that Muslim women are vulnerable to their communities, then the banning of headscarves will not end this oppression, especially if it is only restricted to public school, so if this were the case, then more extreme measures would have to be taken. With all of this considered, it is clear that the French ban of headscarves in public schools is not an attempt at neutralizing

Is Descartes' Evil Demon Thought Experiment A Stronger Argument For Global Skepticism Than His Dreaming Argument? If Yes, Explain Why; If No, Explain Why Not

1134 words - 5 pages dreaming argument and evil demon argument justifies global scepticism and which of the two is a stronger and more convincing argument.According to Descartes, we rely on our senses to determine what is most true and many of the decisions we make are based on our senses and feelings. However, our senses can deceive us, so what's not to say that our senses are not deceiving us all of the time. Or if what our senses tell us is supposedly true most of the