Is Antigone A Tragic Play Essay

583 words - 2 pages


Is Antigone a tragic play as defined by Aristotle?
     
     Antigone is not a tragic play. Rather it is a theological debate spawned by Sophocles, a debate that is still raging today, the debate of who holds the higher law, the Gods or the State. While this debate has slowly twisted into Church versus State, which is a very different argument, the highest questions still remain the same: Which one is held higher in men’s (and women’s) hearts? Antigone answers this question with shocking clarity in her admission of guilt to Creon, “ I should have praise and honor for what I have
done. All these men here would praise me, were their lips not frozen shut with fear of you. Ah, the good fortune of kings, licensed to say and do whatever they please! C: you alone are in that opinion. A: No, they are with me, But they keep their tongues in leash.” By saying thus, Antigone is proclaiming all everyone holds the laws of the Gods higher than the laws of the State, unless the State is the more immediate threat.
     But this all raises another question, does the law of the Gods really matter? Will the Gods truly beseech you and seek to bring you harm for not following in their ways? One who is not so religious would say no, it is not the Gods who hold the sword at your throat but a man, who at that moment cares nothing for the Gods. But in the case of Antigone, the Gods do act out their revenge. Tireseas spake: “I tell you Creon, you yourself have brought this new calamity upon us. Our hearths and altars are stained with the corruption...

Find Another Essay On Is Antigone A Tragic Play

Antigone: A Tragic Heroine's Characteristics Essay

723 words - 3 pages In Antigone, The likelihood off it being two Tragic hero characters is unlikely in Greek tragedy, and there is only one in the play Antigone. The king Creon has several of the qualities that constitute a tragic character, but does not have all of the necessary necessities. Antigone, although she is a woman, contains all of the aspects that are required for her to be the main character and a feminine heroine which is seldom seen

Antigone, A Tragic Hero In Literature.

846 words - 3 pages Antigone A Tragic Hero In LiteratureIn the short ancient Greek play entitled, Antigone by Sophocles the reader is introduced to many basic themes and most significantly the prime example of a "tragic hero" in literature, which is exceptionally well incorporated into Sophocles' Antigone. Upon reading this play I personally perceived Antigone to produce all of the characteristics of a tragic hero.First off, it is very obvious that Antigone is a

A Tragic Hero: "Antigone" by Sophocles

1284 words - 5 pages Everyone needs a hero, someone to look up to and to admire. Most literary heroes are recognized by great courage, strength, and nobility. However, heroes in tragedy are identified through qualities that tend to differ from the idea of a typical hero. Having a reversal in fortune, taking responsibility for one's actions, and having a catharsis are all qualities that tragic heroes are thought to possess. In Sophocles' "Antigone", Creon is the

"Julius Caesar is a Shakespearean tragedy but, despite its title, the tragic character of the play is Brutus."

962 words - 4 pages portray. Although he does not say so, Brutus's suicide is caused by many factors: his remorse, the death of Portia, and the battle lost to Antony. His last words admit to Caesar that he has been avenged: "... Caesar, be still, I kill'd not thee with half so good a will." (Line 50-51 Act V Scene V)In conclusion, Julius Caesar, the Shakespearean play, certainly shows the tragedy of Brutus rather than the tragedy of Julius Caesar, despite its title

Is Dantès a Tragic Hero?

815 words - 4 pages of the “love that blinds him”. Therefore, Dantès is a tragic hero because it is his fault that he wasn’t aware that the people all around him were plotting against him. Dantès knew there was a possibility that the people around him would be plotting against him, however, being so trusting he completely ignored this warning. While Dantes is at sea Alexandre Dumas mentions that Dantes and Danglars were in a quarrel. Danglars is jealous that

Antigone, Sophocles Drama King Creon This is about King Creon in the story Antigone and his tragic flaws.

517 words - 2 pages places too much stock in being a righteous ruler. Creon's lack of judgement towards the situations and his unwillingness to change his mind-set creates a great deal of turmoil by the cessation of the play.Creon's inability to show compassion for those whose morals are valued moreto them than their lives, like Antigone, sets the scene for a tragedy to beproduced. Only after it is too late he realizes that he had made a fatal mistake in notlistening to

Macbeth as a Tragic Hero in William Shakespeare's Play

2107 words - 8 pages Macbeth as a Tragic Hero in William Shakespeare's Play Macbeth is a Shakespearian play involving an ambitious brave warrior, (Macbeth) who is cousin to the King of Scotland. The play focuses on Macbeths ambitions. Macbeth meets three weird sisters, who predict that one day he would be king. But Macbeth's ambition over took his life as he ended up doing anything to become king, even kill the ones closest to him. There

Macbeth as a Tragic Hero in William Shakespeare's Play

2152 words - 9 pages Macbeth as a Tragic Hero in William Shakespeare's Play The play ‘Macbeth’ gives us many opportunities to consider the reasons for Macbeth’s actions. In this essay I will be considering the factors that have made Macbeth behave in such a way that he goes as far as killing his King, his companions, his companions’ families and drove his wife Lady MacBeth to commit suicide. I will also be talking about the techniques that

A tragic hero comparison between Rex Warner's "Prometheus" and Sophocles' "Antigone"

874 words - 3 pages Aristotle was a Greek philosopher, a student of Plato and teacher of Alexander the Great. He wrote about diverse topics including drama and physics. He defined tragedy as we have known it for many years-- a drama that imitates life. Based on his insight, it is apparent that in Greek tragedy there are characters which are more heartbreaking than others. In Rex Warner’s “Prometheus” and Sophocles’ “Antigone”, Creon is

Is othello a racist play?

884 words - 4 pages Othello - A Racist Play?Although there are lots of things to suggest this is a racistplay I don't think that racism actually dominates the play, eventhough it has a racist theme. There is a romantic union between blackand white which gets destroyed because most people think therelationship is wrong. At the time the play was written, 1604, eventhe Queen of England was racist so there must have been a stronghatred of blacks around that time.Most

Shakespeare's Macbeth is a Tragic Hero

1848 words - 7 pages Macbeth is a Tragic Hero In many respects Macbeth, of Shakespeare’s play Macbeth is the least admirable tragic hero of literature. Typical tragic heroes have at least a few admirable character traits. One may, or may not like the hero, but there is something in their characters or their situation on which one can hang some sympathy, even if there is not enough for us to rationalize away their actions. But Macbeth is a mass

Similar Essays

Is Jean Anouilh's Antigone A Tragedy Or A Triumph? This Is An Assessment Of The Tragic And Trimphant Elements Within The Play 'antigone'

4517 words - 18 pages Is Antigone a tragedy or a triumphJean Anouilh's Antigone was first produced in Paris in 1942, it is based on Sophocles' version of the novel, which was written in 442 B.C.E and performed in Ancient Greece. It is a modernist play, which has the effect of highlighting the importance of the themes of the play and lets the audience focus more fully on the tragic and triumphant elements of the play. Antigone was performed under Nazi-occupied France

Antigone: A Tragic Hero Essay

955 words - 4 pages a fool is judge' (180). If anything this clearly states that she has excessive pride for what she has done and will make sure that Creon knows this and her unfeigned gratitude for her dead brothers.As one can tell the role of a tragic hero is one that Antigone plays well. Although she dies at the end of this play, Antigone feels no regret in what she has done. She also shows that she is proud of the fact that she never denied burying her brother. One would infer that although of her death, Antigone died for what she believed. This is the utmost characteristic in the portrait of a tragic hero.

Antigone Tragic Hero Essay About "Antigone," By Sophocles. Discusses Why Antigone Is Not A Tragic Hero And Compares Her To Oedipus, Who Is A Tragic Hero.

899 words - 4 pages character from the beginning to the end of the book. Because this example is one of a lack of change, it would be most helpful to examine how an actual tragic hero does change. In the beginning of the play, Creon, markedly confident and intent on proving his sovereignty, said to Antigone "You wait and see! The toughest will is first to break" (p. 211). By the last choral dialogue, Creon had realized his mistake. He said to the chorus "Then lead

Antigone As A Tragic Hero Essay

509 words - 2 pages Antigone as a tragic hero The debate over who is the tragic hero in Antigone is unanswered. The belief that Antigone is the hero is a tough one. Antigone is widely thought of as the tragic hero of the play bearing her name. She would seem to fit the part in light of the fact that she dies for doing what she believes is right. She buries her brother without worrying what might happen to her. Unlike Antigone, Ismene says “And break the law, our