This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Compassion Really A Crime? Analysis Of "A Crime Of Compassion" By Barbara Huttmann

913 words - 4 pages

Is Compassion Really a Crime?Imagine standing in a hospital room watching a man suffer in agonizing pain day after day and not being able to do anything about it. This is the situation that Barbara Huttmann faces in her essay "A Crime of Compassion." Huttmann, a nurse, is forced to watch Mac live in agonizing pain without legally being able to let him die. The message that she displays in her essay is suffering people should be permitted to die if they aspire to do so. Using various rhetorical devices, Huttmann portrays her message by first introducing Mac to the reader, then illustrating his suffering and finally letting him die.Huttmann opens her essay by introducing Mac, a young police officer who is diagnosed with lung cancer. She uses imagery to recall the day that Mac first "walked into the hospital with 32 pounds of attack equipment, looking as if he could singlehandedly protect the whole city, if not the whole state" (420). This image allows the reader to visualize and characterize Mac prior to his cancer. Contrastingly, Huttman later illustrates the Mac's condition six months after he is diagnosed. At this point Mac has lost "his youth, his wit, his macho, his hair, his bowel and bladder control, his sense of taste and smell and his ability to do even the slightest thing for himself" (420). Huttmann creates contrasting images to show the horrific changes Mac has gone through due to his diagnosis. In the first image, Mac is depicted as a super heroic figure who is indestructible. As he enters the hospital, he carries with him a fearless attitude that enables people to look to him as a figure of protection. However, in the second image, his health has disintegrated and he has wasted away to nothingness. He can no longer perform basic tasks let alone protect anyone. While not yet relating to the message, these images begin to show the tragic course of events that Mac has fallen into in comparison to the previous state of his life.Huttmann continues her essay by illustrating Mac's immense suffering. At this point, Mac "had wasted away to a 60-pound skeleton kept alive by liquid food [the nurses] poured down a tube, i.v. solutions [they] dripped into his veins, and oxygen [they] piped into a mask on his face" (420). This hyperbole portrays the inhumane-like treatment Mac is receiving. The doctors and nurses are manually filling Mac's body with the basic necessities of life just to keep him breathing. It is made clear to the reader that the life Mac is living, is not really living. He has essentially been reduced to a corpse that...

Find Another Essay On Is Compassion Really a Crime? Analysis of "A Crime of Compassion" by Barbara Huttmann

Teaching Compassion in a World Were Compassion is Lost

859 words - 4 pages main character in To Kill a Mockingbird that reveals true moral decisions do not come from law or society, but from within. Atticus showed his compassion and empathy toward his neighbors by excusing their ill-mannered and discourteous behavior. He did this by looking at their lives from an understanding perspective and knew it was morally right to excuse them of their rude behavior. Here, we see that “compassion is the basis of all morality” (Arthur Schopenhauer) and as we learned from Atticus, "You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view… until you climb into his skin and walk around in it.” (Lee 37)

An Evolutionary Analysis of Compassion

676 words - 3 pages focus on one’s self, motivate a slow withdrawal of social contact. Finally, compassion is an emotion that Charles Darwin mentioned as the strongest of humans’ evolved ‘instincts’ (Goetz, et al. 2010). The feeling of compassion will benefit us in caregiving for our next generation, attract desirable mate, and motivate us on following the cooperative norms. Works Cited Goetz, Jennifer L., Keltner, Dacher, Simon-Thomas, Emiliana, 2010. Compassion: An evolutionary analysis and empirical review. Psychological Bulletin. Vol 136(3). pp. 351-374.

Importance of Compassion

776 words - 3 pages “If you want others to be happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion.” ― Dalai Lama XIV, The Art of Happiness. This quote said by the Dalai Lama has a great meaning to it. Most just see compassion as another word in this world, when it’s so much more than that. Compassion bring people together, makes the world a better place, and most importantly allows you to connect with others. Compassion is necessary to the

The House of Compassion

1378 words - 6 pages families in need, diapers is a common need that is often forgotten by the public. The soup kitchen provides food for those that our hungry, and recently the House of Compassion as started a Garden of Compassion which they use to grow food to continue to feed and inform those that our in need. The Emergency Shelter is available for those that have no where to go. They have many beds for people to sleep in, and they are encouraged and supported while they

Warning Signs of Compassion Fatigue

1293 words - 5 pages toxins in the body. As for the emotional needs, caregivers should seek help and guidance from a mentor, friend, supervisor, or counselor (Lombardo & Eyre, 2011). Being able to express one’s concerns and feelings can give caregivers emotional support and can help to re-establish a since of hope. Spirituality is another area where caregivers are affected by compassion fatigue. Because of this, it is essential that caregivers take time to reconnect

Is Prostitution a Victimless Crime? Nope Prostitution Is a Crime Full Of Victi

852 words - 4 pages definition to that of Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Scientism and a slew of others. Next, the feminist movement identifies this as a crime by men against women, which makes sense when one sees that 90% of prostitutes have been raped in the last year. 85% have been stolen from. (Bakhyadze) Doesn’t it already seem like this view is playing out and wouldn’t it make sense to legalize so that these crimes can be prosecuted. Another reason is the economic

Case Study Analysis - Our Lady's Home of Compassion

894 words - 4 pages The Home of Compassion Hospital at Island Bay, a surgical and medical hospital with small rest home which provides a broad range of surgery as well as offering respite care, intermittent care, care of terminally ill and convalescent care. It is not for profit and targets people who 'fall between the cracks' with regard to health care. To receive treatment people pay what they can afford. Generally speaking, the hospital's philosophy is that each

Shoplifting is a Crime Committed by Many

1097 words - 5 pages that they simply do not have the money for. This is offer the case with teens who are trying to keep up with trends and their peers. Sometimes people steal to meet their basic needs of food and clothing or to provide gifts for their children. Pressure younger kids and teens can be pressured by friends and peers to steal items in order to gain acceptance by certain groups or people. They tell you if you want to be liked and fit in they must steal


994 words - 4 pages change. In conclusion, it may be agreed that a strong criminal justice system is still (importantly) required. Nevertheless, the numbers of benefits which can be perceived by the practice of social intervention strategy in preventing and reducing crime are apparently greater. In order to attain the best result, social intervention needs to be delivered consistently, targeting more than one ‘risk-factor’, started from an early age, and supported

A Critical Analysis of Crime and Social Harm

863 words - 4 pages Governments ‘Respect’ website 2007 Crime is doing something forbidden by law. That could mean stealing a mobile phone, vandalism, graffiti, mugging, stealing or taking and selling drugs” (Muncie, Talbot and Walters, 2010, p. 3). This definition of crime is very much focused on the ideas of what criminologists would class as ‘street crimes’, crimes that are generally committed by the poorer people within society, young people who come from council

Compassion is the Victory

991 words - 4 pages not lived until a person feels deeply about someone or something. To achieve this state of mind, one must be the active in the present moment and be connected to themselves simultaneously. This is reiterated by Hahn, to quote “When your mind is liberated, your heart floods with compassion” (54). Compassion is the product of the combination of mindfulness and meditation because compassion is the greatest gift a heart can feel. The mind, when

Similar Essays

A Crime Of Compassion Essay

637 words - 3 pages Sometimes there are situations in life that make people think about death. Everyone is going to die one day but what if that person wants to end his life earlier. Should anyone be allowed to decide about his own life in any bad situation? I can't answer that but instead I'll explain a specific situation when death should be acceptable. I never thought about death as a way to solve a problem but when I read "A crime of Compassion" by Huttmann , I

Critique Of Barbara Huttman’s A Crime Of Compassion

1019 words - 4 pages Critique of Barbara Huttman’s “A Crime of Compassion” Barbara Huttman’s “A Crime of Compassion” has many warrants yet the thesis is not qualified. This is a story that explains the struggles of being a nurse and having to make split-second decisions, whether they are right or wrong. Barbara was a nurse who was taking care of a cancer patient named Mac. Mac had wasted away to a 60-pound skeleton (95). When he walked into the hospital, he

My Take On Crime Of Compassion

738 words - 3 pages , get the choice to end our sad lives? Because a life like that, isn't a life; you are not living, you are dying. In the article, “A Crime of Compassion”, Hunttman did exactly that. She ended a life who asked her as a human being to give him peace, not as a nurse programed to save. Could one really pin her a murderer for committing such a brave act? Ending a life is not a light decision, but she did it because Mac, the patient, asked of it from

Compassion In The Workplace In Nickel And Dimed By Barbara Ehrenreich

731 words - 3 pages . They all know how their co-workers feel, and to share a smile, it may help someones day. The novel Nickel and Dimed by Barbara Ehrenreich shows the hard working, fast paced environment of the work place. Even the smallest jobs can take a toll on a person. Along with taking a toll, the novel also references the main point of workers showing compassion on the job. From the story, Barbra talks with one of her co-workers, and tries to help her out