Is Conceptual Critiques Relevant For Psychology?

1822 words - 7 pages

We shall consider Skinner’s Operant Conditioning theory as another type of example on Conceptual Critiques (Skinner, 1963). His theory states that the best way to understand a behavior is to look at the association made between the behavior and the consequence of that behavior. Although Skinner’s primary interest was in human behavior, most of his research was done on animals using laboratory apparatus well known as the Skinner box.
Hence, in his experiment, Skinner placed rats in the Skinner box and observed its’ behaviors. Initially, these rats would be randomly moving around exploring, and would usually press the bar accidently. At this point, a food pellet would drop into the tray. He observed that if a hungry rat receives a pellet of food when it presses a lever after, maybe 2 minutes have elapsed since the last pellet, then its response rate increases with the passage of time. In other words, after the first incident of the food pellet dropping into the tray, the rate of the rats pressing the bar rises dramatically and remains high until the rats hunger were satisfied. Thus, this study showed a clear association made between the behavior and the consequence of that behavior. In this case, the consequence of a behavior encouraged the repetition of that behavior also known as positive reinforcement.
On the other hand, Anderson, Bothell, Byrne, Douglass, and Lebiere (2004), commented that Skinner did not show interest on why the organism behaved in this way and instead he was satisfied with knowing what kind of behavior could be expected from various organisms including humans when given a fixed-interval schedule. This comment is a misleading distortion as it overlooks Skinner’s efforts to explain the gradual increase in response rate. Moreover, Ferster and Skinner (1957), improved on some explanations such as the cuing function of the pellet itself, the discriminative properties of the number of responses produced during the interval, and the conditioning of changes in response rate instead of single responses. Although they seem to be cruel today, these attempts definitely qualify as an interest in understanding of a behavior.
Skinner’s theory is again another example of the ignorance of Conceptual Critiques. Even though, his theory addresses a particular issue, the other party might tend to misinterpret that, it does not. This is due to unstated chains of inferences, which were vital assumptions in the theory. If Skinner did not disregard the Conceptual Critiques, and clearly stated his inferences, his theory wouldn’t have been questionable by future Psychologist and instead would have been a solid foundation for the understanding a behavior. Hence, I would like to emphasize that Psychologist should not overlook Conceptual Critiques in their theoretical works as it in fact, helps their theory to be stronger and reliable.
Thirdly, we shall consider the Piaget’s Child Development theory as another type of example on Conceptual...

Find Another Essay On Is Conceptual Critiques Relevant for Psychology?

Area of study (change). Essay on why area of study is still relevant for todays students. Reference to both (Novel)Maestro (Short storey) Sky High

1160 words - 5 pages for attention and companionship and just someone to fill the loneliness."As I glance at my watch 7:55, I wanted to know more but at what price, Rosie would be waiting for me...." Moments also show us Paul's confusion towards feelings "My contempt fuelled by feelings far more complicated and contradictory than I had thought". This is a perfect example of the way that people are unpredictable and although you think you may know what is happening

This essay is about a case study for Industrial Orgnizational Psychology.

1314 words - 5 pages active part in the Orientation Days in cooperation with management. Management could make employees satisfy with their job by showing appreciation, recognition and encouragement.FactsThe UHB Student Housing Resident Assistant Program is a peer support project for the purpose of improving the physical and psychosocial conditions in all the student halls. The RAs are basically expected to create a buffer zone between the administration and the

This is an APA style report for an experiment conducted in an Experimental Psychology class.

1192 words - 5 pages important role in the attitudes and impressions humans have about one another. Like wine, wisdom is better with age and for some reason, we associate baldness with wisdom. Although male faces with less cranial hair appeared older, they also appeared more intelligent (Cash, 1990).Research repeatedly shows that facial hair is a positive factor in an individual's appearance. Pellegrini (1973) performed an experiment in social perception in which

Community Psychology essay discussing the idea of change and whether or not it is good for people as a whole.

1002 words - 4 pages Community PsychologyCHANGE: THE HARDEST THING FOR ANY OF US TO DOThink about how hard it is for us to change a habit, one that we have had for a really long time, so long that we cannot distinguish or remember a time when we didn't have the habit. If it is so hard to change a habit on an individual level, how are we supposed to change a habit on a Microsystems level all the way up to a Macro system level?What worked in the past may not work for

This is a critical analysis paper that I wrote for an Abnormal Psychology class. It discusses the ineffectiveness and over-prescription of SSRIs such as Prozac.

798 words - 3 pages The Ineffectiveness of ProzacWe live in an age of growing research and technology, and new medicines are coming out for every sort of problem and symptom. Each day scientists discover more about the body and its functions and among these discoveries and understandings is the expertise of serotonin and its functions within the human brain. The grasp of serotonin has brought about the development of SSRI’s, or selective serotonin reuptake

This essay is a biography of Charles Manson. In Freudian terms, it explains the way his mind worked. This essay was made for psychology 41 (Life Span).

1943 words - 8 pages . Block, a psychiatrist examined him, noting "the marked degree of rejection, instability and psychic trauma." His illegitimacy, small physical size (due to malnutrition) and lack of parental love caused him to constantly strive for status with the other boys. "This could add up to a fairly slick institutionalized youth," Dr. Block concluded, "but one is left with the feeling that behind all this lies an extremely sensitive boy who has not yet given

Critical Response

1081 words - 5 pages “What is Black/African American Psychology,” was one the first question asked to us students on the first day of class. A lot of us gave out answers, such as it is a study of the behavior of African Americans. Some said that this course would explain why “we act the way [that] we do.” I really had no specific or scholarly answer myself, but I knew I would be in for a treat. However, after reading the articles, Theoretical and Conceptual

Psychology & Religion: The Spirtual Side to Counseling

1102 words - 4 pages go away soon.      The psychological study of religion is a meaningful area of psychology in America. It is relevant to our understanding of people because it addresses an important facet of life in America, with more than 90% of Americans professing belief in God, and the vast majority of citing specific religious preferences (Baston, 1996). It offers a rich source of material for the study of attitudes, coping, and

Forensic Psychology Literature Review

1779 words - 7 pages respected within their fields of study. Also included within the studies was legitimate evidence from court cases that utilized theories from both Law and Psychology. The court cases discussed are the 1843 case of Daniel McNaughten and the establishment of the McNaughton Rule, along with the 1954 court case for the “Social Science Briefs” (276). Other information included was the fact that in 1971 the first program for Psychology and Law is founded

Positve Psychology and Aristotle's Virtue Ethics Converge

1627 words - 7 pages health associated with volunteer work also challenge equity theory, suggesting giving social support is more rewarding than receiving it (Peterson, 2006). Upon analysis of Aristotle’s (350 B.C.E) Nicomachean Ethics, in which he describes a theory of the virtues, several aspects were similar to ideas practiced in positive psychology. Aristotle begins with the assumption that all human actions are intended for good; asserting that happiness is the


781 words - 3 pages Experimental Strategies and Conceptual Change The article The Development of Scientific Reasoning in Knowledge-Rich Contexts written by Leona Schauble relates a series of experiments which give some insight as to how conceptual change and experimental strategies effect subjects of varying ages, ten fifth and sixth graders and ten noncollege adults. The conclusions drawn from the article are relevant in determining the cognitive strengths and

Similar Essays

Conceptual Framework For Therapeutic Occupations: "There Is Nothing So Useful As A Good Theory"

1812 words - 7 pages CFTO PAGE 3 Conceptual Framework for Therapeutic Occupations:"There is nothing so useful as a good theory"Michele FreitasOT 3012Janis DavisNovember 17, 2008Conceptual Framework for Therapeutic Occupations:"There is nothing so useful as a good theory"Occupation is the central idea of the profession of Occupational Therapy. The reason that the profession was founded was to use occupations to enhance every day life (Slagle, 1922). To explain the

Song Analysis For "My Kind Of Scene" By Artist "Powder Finger" Topic: Discuss The Relevant Lyrics And Explain What Message The Song Is Giving That You Think Is Important For The Future.

607 words - 2 pages Australian StudiesMusic AnalysisThe song "My Kind of Scene" is about the way that life is today in our society. It covers the pressures of life, life in general, not giving up and also that life only gets better. I think the message in this song is very relevant for the future of our society and my reason for this happens to be the name of the song and also the main chorus which is "It's not my kind of scene." I think that if all Australians

Social Aspects Of Paranoid Schizophrenic Recovery The Assignment Is A Research Paper For Abnormal Psychology.

2809 words - 11 pages environments are most conducive to a full recovery.My primary resource is my friend Auntie. I have spent a great deal of time with him for the last five years and have been around to witness his highs and lows. He also graciously allowed me to interview him for this paper. Because I am merely a psychology student and not a professional, I re-enforce my observations with those made in the 'Bonnie Tapes,' for validity. For direct evidence I will refer

Expert Witness Describe What An Expert Witness Is. What Do They Add To The Court Room? Why Are They Important? This Is A Very Good Essay For Psychology And Law Classes. It Is Detailed And Well...

1461 words - 6 pages Untitled Mental health experts have been working side by side with the justice system for years. These professionals are also known as expert witnesses in the courtroom. Through training and experience, an expert witness is known to have intelligence beyond that of an average person and is relied on to present facts to the judge and jury. The difference between a regular witness and an expert is that the more educated witness is