Is East End Four Corners Supermarket Liable In Negligence For Jean’s Injury?

1862 words - 7 pages


FACTS: Jean was a regular shopper at East End Four Corners Supermarket, which was part of a large nationwide supermarket chain. She was there at least once a week and sometimes more often if the specials were really good. When Jean was there this week, she slipped on some grapes in aisle 3 and broke her ankle. Grapes are normally found in the fruit section of the store and the store was not sure how the grapes got there or how long they had been there. The store manager indicated that there were a number of spillages every week in the aisles in this store.

Is East End Four Corners Supermarket liable in negligence for Jean’s injury?

ESSENTIAL ISSUES: Is East End Four Corners Supermarket liable in negligence for Jean’s injury?


Let’s identify the legislation and cases that are relevant to the stated problem

“Negligence is an omission to do something that a reasonable person would do, or doing something that a prudent and reasonable person would not do. It is the failure to exercise reasonable care and skill” (Gibson & Fraser, 2013)

A Duty of Care:

This is a duty owned by one person who is called “defendant” to another who is called “plaintiff”. Its basis is the relationship between defendant and plaintiff and the foreseeability of damage or loss.

Foreseeability is a test for duty of care, answering question whether a reasonable person (in plaintiff’s position) would have predicted that there was a real danger of the probability of injury.

“The reasonable person is someone of normal intelligence, credited with such perception of the surrounding circumstances and such knowledge of other pertinent matters as a reasonable person would possess” (Gibson & Fraser, 2013)

Vulnerable relationship: consideration of the vulnerability of plaintiff and control of the defendant

Policy considerations: prospect of indeterminate liability, possible commercial or financial consequences, the impact on social or moral values, or even whether it is fair and equitable.

According to Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562, The High Court mentioned the role of the authority and responsibility and shifted away from protecting plaintiffs who did not take care of themselves.

Breach of Duty of Care

References are to the following Acts: Vic: Wrongs Act 1958; NSW: Civil Liability Act 2003; SA: Civil Liability Act 1936; WA: Civil Liability Act 2002; Tas: Civil Liability Act 2002; ACT: Civil Law (Wrongs) Act 2002.
There would be a breach of Duy of Care if all followings satisfied:
- Foreseeable risk (Risk which would be known by a “reasonable person” if they were in defendant’s position); and
- Considerable risk (Risk that have a higher probability of harm. This criterion has no equivalent in common law); and
- A reasonable person in the defendant’s position would have taken precautions

The issue of damage or harm is central to a negligence action. Damage may be:


Find Another Essay On Is East End Four Corners Supermarket liable in negligence for Jean’s injury?

Four ways in which cohesion is achieved in written discourse

605 words - 2 pages Cohesion, according to Shi(2004), is ' the network of lexical, grammatical, and other relations which link various parts of text' (pp.1). These relations link sentences together and require us to understand there meanings by looking at other words or phrases in other sentences. Halliday and Hasan (1976) have identified a number of ways in which cohesion is achieved in written discourse in the

‘Ten Principles to Aid the Quest for Peace in the Middle East’ - Article Analysis

1180 words - 5 pages Introduction The article, ‘Ten Principles to Aid the Quest for Peace in the Middle East’ was given by Jonathan Rietman in which he concentrated on key areas and issue that should be addressed to resolve the conflicts between Israel and Palestine. This article gives some assumptions and ten principles of negotiations that can be led a comprehensive settlement between these countries. By considering the issues of 11th September 2001, the...

Looking for Alibrandi by Melina Marchetta Josie is a different person at the beginning of the novel than she is at the end. How do these changes in her self come about?

702 words - 3 pages In this novel (Looking for Alibrandi) Josephine Alibrandi is seen as an illegitimate 17-year-old girl who is self-centred, ignorant and sensitive about her illegitimacy and her reputation and what...

This is an essay about the Women and child in Middle East, how Taliban treated them

555 words - 2 pages Human Rights in AfghanistanIn Afghan the regime is under the Taliban. The key ministries are the mullahs. Their aim is to make Afghan into the "purity of Islam". They suppress all the activities and limited women and children's activities in the society.Women in Afghan, they have to be covered in the shroud-like Burqa veil. A Burqa is a...

How Cathy is evil in the book "East of Eden" by John Steinbeck

1483 words - 6 pages The prosecution will begin by establishing the character of the defendant, and further prove that the criminal acts committed by Ms. Catherine Ames were not random, but rather a part of a cynical mindset that deliberately caused harm. Catherine Ames was without a doubt, a stunning work of beauty with the power to make all heads turn everywhere she went. She have lovely gold hair,...

A critical analysis of all four cinematic styles found in 'Requiem For Dream'.

2658 words - 11 pages In the following analysis of Darren Aronofsky's Requiem For a Dream I will examine how the four elements of cinematic style affect the film's theme and the audiences responses to both the characters and the overall story. The audience remains immersed in the story throughout the film due to Aronofsky's acute attention to detail and finely tuned editing. The audience's...

How is the character Dora presented in the first four chapters of Iris Murdoch's 'The Bell'?

1802 words - 7 pages In the opening sentence of The Bell, Iris Murdoch presents Dora Greenfield as a weak,...

Is Gun Control the Answer?; referenced, response to current death of four mounties in Alberta

1608 words - 6 pages 'Is Gun Control the answer?'In response to the shootings of the four Mounties killed in Alberta there have been heated debates for and against the federal gun registry programs. These tragic deaths by a single gunman have sparked great controversy. Finger pointing has been aimed at public policy and hypothetical what-ifs. Everything from Canada's marijuana laws to the way our nation's children are being raised is in question. Former...

The U.S. War in the Middle East: A Fight for Honor and Survival - Why America Should Continue Fighting in Iraq

1173 words - 5 pages On September 11, 2001, ruthless terrorists from the Middle East hijacked four commercial jets. They flew two planes into the World Trade Center Twin Towers, one into the Pentagon, and one into the grassy fields of Pennsylvania. President George W....

"Racial profiling is wrong and we will end it in America"

524 words - 2 pages On February 26, 2004 congress introduced bipartisan legislation called the "End Racial Profiling Act", (ERPA). This is intended to end racial bias in law enforcement, because this tactic erodes community trust."No American is to be subject to law enforcement encounters based on crude bias,"...

Is the Huankantou incident the beginning of the end of communist rule in China?

582 words - 2 pages There are dozens of protests every day in the Pearl River Delta factories and almost none of them is reported in the press anywhere. Sometimes they are large and violent. Sometimes they are so small that they could hardly be called protests. Sometimes they are manipulated by outsiders for financial shakedowns. Sometimes they are successful in achieving the...

Similar Essays

This Essay Is About The Duke Vincentio In Measure For Measure. He Is Described As The Old Fantastical Duke Of Dark Corners.

1497 words - 6 pages The character of the Duke is portrayed by Shakespeare as a very complex, hypocritical and contradictory character. To many critics, he is conveyed as a Machiavellian Prince, using others for his own political ends, and to some critics, a God-like figure, testing the pathology of power in Vienna. Despite these two polar opposites the character is nethertheless a character of ambivalence. Contradiction is one of the main themes of the play, as...

Establishment Of Israel This Is A Five Page Research Paper On The Establishment Of Israel In The Middle East, At The End Of This Essay Is Also An Opinion Written By The Author.

1468 words - 6 pages lThe Modern State of Israel did not begin like any other country. The idea of a homeland for Jews dates back to the 13th century when Jews all over Europe were being persecuted because of their religion. The persecution began in England when King Edward I issued an edict expelling all Jews from England and was soon followed by an all Jew expulsion from Austria and...

Ways Of Raising Children In East Is East And The Bluest Eyes

1723 words - 7 pages Most parents say that their children are the best things they could ever have in the world. There is no way they would trade their children for anything; not even for the most expensive thing ever exist. No wonder they are willing to do and give anything just to make their kids happy. However, apparently, not all parents feel the same way. They might still love their children but showing their affections in different ways; through strikes,...

Location         Burundi Is In Central Africa, Just East Of Democratic

1596 words - 6 pages Location Burundi is in Central Africa, just east of Democratic Republic of the Congo, south of Rwanda, and west and south of Tanzania. It is landlocked between those countries with a total border length of 974 kilometers. Its geographic coordinates are 3 30 S, 30 00 E. Brazil, Malaysia, and New Zealand are at about the...