This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Economic Central Planning Obsolete? Essay

1179 words - 5 pages

One hundred fifty years ago, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels published their classic masterpiece, The Communist Manifesto, in which they provoked the ideas of "centralization of credit in the hands of the State, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly," and "extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the State; the bringing into cultivation of wastelands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan." In other words, they provoked an economic system that was based on the idea of central planning. Thus, their idea brings up an important issue, is economic central planning necessary? Some people believe that central planning, as an economic system is no longer workable or desirable. Others believe that central planning is a desirable model. Still others believe that some principles of central planning are worthwhile in certain circumstances. It is believed that although in some cases that central planning do indeed make the economic system less workable or desirable, some principles of central planning are necessary in certain circumstances. People usually need incentives to motivate them to do things that will bring them the most profit, and therefore they refuse to cooperate with the central planning system should the system conflicts with their own interests, which makes the central planning system fail in certain cases. Due to most men's selfish, evil nature, men usually don't know what is the best for the whole society; hence some principles of centrally planned economy are needed to help men to make some correct decisions. By balancing men's motivation to be productive with the principles of centrally planned economy, a desirable and workable economy system can be created in the modern world, therefore shows that economic central planning is not obsolete. Central planning system fails by its own because that people usually need motivations to motivate them to do things that will bring them the most profits, and therefore they refuse to cooperate with the central planning system should the system conflicts with their own interests. For example, Lenin initiated a program during 1917 to 1921, which was called war communism; in which that the Bolshevik government controlled everything. The peasants inside Russia used to be able to sell the extra food they had to make up the money for other uses, but under war communism, the state made the peasants to give their surplus food to the city workers and the army in order to win the civil war that was going on in Russia. The problem was that, who would give other people food for free; since giving other people food for free dose not bring profits to the peasants, the peasants naturally rebelled. Peasants protested by growing less, or give the state low quality food. As a consequence, by April 1920, only 29 percent of all food was distributed through the official government system. Serious food shortages...

Find Another Essay On IS ECONOMIC CENTRAL PLANNING OBSOLETE?

The importance of community pl Essay

975 words - 4 pages The Importance of Community Planning Community planning is an essential part of economic development and establishment of a character unique to the community. Lack of planning leaves all development or lack thereof, up to market forces. In many cases market forces will dominate a communities identity, but they are not always perfectly aligned with the desires and values of community members. A town, city or region, left to develop without the

Outsource in the US, PRC and Other Involved Countries

2197 words - 9 pages 作的意见]). Wenzhou city is famous for leather shoes industry, so it is understandable to obsolete some production lines that are tens of times exceed the central standard, but similar exaggerated plans are found in several city government official sites. Because of the lack of primary materials, the author would believe that those local plans are well investigated and researched, but since exaggerating plans is an undercurrent flowing through the

A Comparative Study of Regional Planning in Britain and the Netherlands

1726 words - 7 pages Netherlands through its national policy characteristics and describes the different actors of Dutch administrative system (three-tiers: central government, provinces, municipalities). Herein, he highlights the outcomes and actions of these actors (as they are different from British). He is comparing the Micro-Regional and Metropolitan Planning processes with the UK. While doing the comparison, he is using some maps in order to show the spatial

Changes due to Urban Renewal in Pyrmont-Ultimo

1170 words - 5 pages cottages were the most common type of housing present. In the 1960’s however, Pyrmont-Ultimo was deteriorating at a fast rate and became an unfortunate example of urban decay. The government policy of decentralisation, which is having industries move away from the centre of the city, was having an extreme impact on the suburb’s population. This suburbanisation was caused due to congestion, obsolete plants, an ageing infrastructure, high cost of land

New ESSAY

3396 words - 14 pages crisis is the most frequent condition which energizes change. But must companies approach the precipice before major adaptation to new conditions is possible? Are the human and economic costs of a crisis an inevitable by-product of major change? In my view the answer to these questions is no! Change can be stimulated and managed without crisis. Though one obvious lesson for managers is to make use of external crisis when it presents itself as a

“Village of Evergreen Park Options for Sustainable Development “

2087 words - 9 pages members. Giving land for private use adds to further “land use” segregation. The community is in need of more trees wherever they can be planted. The community is missing the “green” element. By solely developing residential living and the primary focus of “land usage” the development of environmental stabilizers; such as, community gardens, native planting and orchard planting have become obsolete. Evergreen Park sustainable urban planning approach

Oil Industry

649 words - 3 pages petroleum industry), infrastructure (where obsolete equipment in need of replacement or repairs), safety (oil industry have strict rules to deal with prevention of accidents) and environmental concerns (needs to become more proactive to prevent environmental damage). The following is a list of the top 10 risk factors cited by the 100 largest U.S. E&P companies retrieved on website energy digital: 1. Regulatory and legislative changes and increased

Planning for the Future in ChevronTexaco

944 words - 4 pages process. They are consulted regularly in order to make sure contractual obligations are followed and to test the legality of initiatives being proposed. Oftentimes in the planning process ChevronTexaco is discussing the deposition of retail outlets that could be affected if determined to be obsolete or non-strategic. The legal department is there to assist in the compliance in regulatory issues that could damage ChevronTexaco if not followed

Theoretical Background

1883 words - 8 pages knowing, valuing and giving meaning.” Moreover, Healy (ibid) stated that inclusionary argumentation, as the ideal planning process, is “a practice that underpins conceptions of what is being called participatory democracy.” Healy, also, concludes that collaborative planning is a way to achieve consensus in a democratic society which respects differences and, which can live sustainably within its economic and social possibilities and environmental

The Search for Low Carbon Cities in China

2835 words - 11 pages feasibility of such measure in China. More importantly argue that it is indeed possible to achieve low carbon status for existing Chinese cities. It does so by first look at the characterisation low carbon cities, follow by the examine the economic, political and social mechanisms that are in place to facilitate the reduction of carbon in cities, as well as discuss some of the barriers to low carbon urban development and how China can overcome them

The Erp System

699 words - 3 pages more efficient in short time. So they start reducing the time that they were use it in transit, in allocated, and in reserved and in obsolete units. Another reason to use the ERP system is that the information could not be easily shared across functions or organizations, and usually all their works were often inconsistent and irreconcilable. The benefits of the ERP The management of the company knows that there are lots of benefits

Similar Essays

Discuss The Transformation Process Of State Owned Enterprises (So Es) In A Transition Economy. Illustrate By Using A Company You Have Researched In China, Vietnam Or Russia

1085 words - 4 pages betterThe nature and cause of the problems that China and other transition economies attempt to solve are similar. We argue that the system of central economics planning and its related problems are to attempt to pursue a capital-intensive heavy - industry - oriented development strategy, when the economy is constrained by capital scarcity.Lastly, it is always the impact of peer pressure that draws positive employees from abiding the management

The Central Bank Or The Fed

1241 words - 5 pages bank oversees the commercial banks, where the central banks ensures that the financial system provides citizens confidence in their soundness. The objectives of the central banks are to provide low, stable inflation, high economic growth, stable financial markets, interest rate stability and exchange rate stability. Objectives of the Central Banks Inflation in an economy is much more desirable when it is low and stable. When there is a high

Centrally Planned Economies And Free Market Economies Economics Essay

2146 words - 9 pages antithesis of central planning, it is capitalism that is characterized by the private sector to control production, distribution and consumption. Capitalism worked well in satisf ying market demand. Central planning, on the other hand, f unctions through administrative guidelines. While capitalism is of ten seen as an economic asset rather than a polit ical system, economy plan implies a strong polit ical will and strong links with the socialist

Strategic Planning Essay

623 words - 2 pages resources to obtain the goals of the organization. Some believe that in today’s rapidly changing environment, strategic planning is becoming more difficult and therefore more obsolete because changes are occurring so fast that plans-even those set for just months into the future-may soon be obsolete. The fact is that with the fast changing environment it is even more important to have strategic planning in every business today.   &nbsp