Is Ecotourism A Viable Tool Toward Sustainability?

1469 words - 6 pages

The debate over ecotourism's success as a tool for conservation and development in the developing world is aggravated by the dispute over what exactly ecotourism is. The International Ecotourism Society offers a succinct and often cited definition: “responsible travel to natural areas that conserves the environment and improves the well-being of local people” (TIES). Ecotourism is often tied to the concept of sustainable development. “Sustainable tourism development meets the needs of present tourists and host regions while protecting and enhancing opportunities for the future” (WTOa).
As the notion of ecotourism gained popularity, Boo (1990) was one of the first to express reservations over ecotourism's potential. She warned that it should not be viewed as a harmless alternative to mass-tourism and pointed out its possible dangers. The research that followed was mostly critical of ecotourism and not focused on highlighting any success.
Honey (1999) provides a recent, objective and comprehensive look at the realities of ecotourism and its place in a broader development strategy. Measuring ecotourism is difficult because it is often lumped together with nature, wildlife and adventure tourism. “Much of what is marketed as ecotourism is simply mass tourism wrapped in a thin green veneer” (Honey 1999: 51) a concept referred to “ecotourism lite.” Acott and La Trobe (1998) refer to the same phenomenon as “shallow ecotourism.” They provide a conceptual framework for measuring whether an ecotourism venture is a sincere attempt at sustainability and conservation or if it is simply an exploited term. Ecotourists and their impacts are measured on a continuum ranging from shallow ecotourism to deep ecotourism. Shallow ecotourism differs little from conventional tourism except in its marketing, and deep ecotourism is that in which decisions are made from a biocentric, not anthropogenic, nature. Deep ecotourism views nature as having an intrinsic value.
     Ecotourism can be played out on three different stages though they are often not exclusive. Government protected areas, private reserves, and Community Based Ecotourism (CBET) ventures can all host visitors. Government protected areas are typically national parks or reserves which are often established because there is economic justification in doing so. Tourists attracted to the park are worth more than the resources in it. For example, a lion in Kenya is worth far more as a tourist attraction than it is as hunting game (Wood 2002). While these areas enjoy a high level of protection, they often displace local people or mean enforcement of land use that marginalizes historical stewards of the land. However, “it is now recognized in parts of Africa, for example, that local people should be compensated for the loss of access to resources they suffer when wildlife parks are created” (Scheyvens 1999: 246).
Private reserves that tourists pay to visit have been successful in terms of...

Find Another Essay On Is Ecotourism a Viable Tool Toward Sustainability?

Why Social Media Is A Beneficial Tool

1032 words - 5 pages attention deficit disorder. The problem is that people have to be able to distinguish between work and play. If a person really has their mindset on work, then they will not get distracted. If anyone is really committed to learning or getting work done, then social media should not be an excuse for distraction. Facebook was originally designed to be a tool which would allow individuals to keep up with their old friends by posting pictures and

Music Is A Powerful Tool For Globalization

1672 words - 7 pages the lyrics of Wyclef Jean’s If I was President and Nancy Schimmel’s 1492 one learns how music is a powerful tool in building consciousness and solidarity on global issues. The power that music has throughout the world is infinite. Many songs have the capability to help identify a culture, as well as educate countries about other cultures. Music has a way of inducing feelings, awakening old memories, and producing new ones. It can be used for

Is Biodiesel a viable alternative to petroleum for tucks and buses?

679 words - 3 pages Is biodiesel a viable alternative to diesel from fossil fuels for trucks and buses?Current practice of producing diesel from fossil fuels is in question regarding its sustainability. As the demand for diesel oils and petroleum, both of which are made from fossil fuels, increases, the supplies are decreasing. Therefore it is imperative we investigate alternative ways to power vehicles. This could alternative could be biodiesel.I chose this

Is Biodiesel a Viable Alternative To Diesel From Fossil Fuels For Trucks And Buses?

1029 words - 4 pages of sulfur compounds and aromatics (Habmigren, 2003). Until today, it is still the only alternative fuel for motor vehicle. The biodiesel blends have ranged from 2/98% (B2), 20/80% (B20), to 100% (B100) (Hafman, 2003). The reasons biodiesel is a viable alternative to diesel from fossil fuels for trucks and buses are it can reduce the pollution, it can enhance the country's economy, and it is renewable sources and can produce almost same energy as

Prompt: Is Israel’s very survival dependent on the creation of a stable and viable Palestinian state?

851 words - 4 pages Prompt: Is Israel’s very survival dependent on the creation of a stable and viable Palestinian state? Let us have ambitions; ambitions to move beyond the violence and occupation, to the day when two states, Palestine and Israel, can live together side by side in peace and security. ~King Abdullah II. In the country of Israel there are two conflicting ethnic/religious groups, the Israelis and the Palestinians. Israelis have most of the power

Natural Gas is a Viable Alternative Energy Source for Electricity Production

2921 words - 12 pages potentials associated with coal and natural gas. Finally, a discussion of the results confirms that based on available data natural gas is a viable alternative energy source for electricity production. Coal is the most abundant domestically produced conventional fuel source in the United States. In 2012, 2,026,798,000 pounds (1,013,399 thousand short tons) of coal were produced and (890,483 thousand short tons) were consumed in the United States alone

Description: argues that fiscal policy in Australia is shifting away from being used as a tool of macroeconomic management towards being used as a political tool.

1161 words - 5 pages management. This shift in the role of fiscal policy can be attributed to the fact that monetary policy is a more effective macroeconomic tool, the recent reduction in government debt and the increasing use of fiscal policy as a political tool opposed to an economic one.YearBudget Result $ Underlying Balance1996/97Actual $5.3 billion cash deficit1997/98Actual $1.2 billion cash surplus1998/99$4.2 billion cash surplus1999/00$12.7 billion cash surplus2000

Is Muller's Ratchet A Useful Tool In Explaining The Evolution Of Sexual Reproduction?

1155 words - 5 pages Muller's ratchet is a hypothesis that helps explain the advantage of sexual reproduction (Chao, 1997). Muller's ratchet is a very useful tool in explaining the evolution of sexual reproduction, however it has its limits. In order to understand this, an examination of Muller's ratchet, completed experiments, and its limitations must be accomplished. Mutation and drift create problems in an asexual society and the drift theory of sex declares

Downsizing is efficient and effective and thus, a viable strategy for firms competing in a global business environment. Do you agree?

4616 words - 18 pages York Times national survey found that at least a family member in one-third of all U.S. households has been laid off since 1980 (New York Times, 1996, cited in Hickok, n.d.). In fact, according the U.S. Department of Labor Statistics on September 2003, 93 000 jobs were lost in August 2003 (Baumol et al, 2003). By some measures, downsizing has failed as a tool to achieve the main purpose, i.e. reduce costs. According to a Wyatt Company survey

The Arguments For and Against the Idea that There Is a Move Toward a More Equal Division of Labour Within the Home

2190 words - 9 pages The Arguments For and Against the Idea that There Is a Move Toward a More Equal Division of Labour Within the Home In today’s modern society there is a debate on going about whether or not that there is a move towards a more equal division of labour within the home and family. Sociologists are interested in many different aspects of family life. Firstly, are husbands and wives today equal? In the past, men dominated

Veiling the Truth: A Look at How the Hijab is used as a tool of Oppression and Resistance in Iran With Comparisons to Indonesia

3230 words - 13 pages -Hosseini 2007: 1; Mir-Hosseini 2003: 41; Berger 1998: 93; Smith-Hefner 2007: 390-391; Brenner 1996: 674; El Guindi 1999: 6). Veiling is used as a tool for oppression. By having women veil themselves, it enforces the control by the male run and male dominated society (Mir-Hosseini 2007: 7). Also, the punishment for women appearing without a veil transitioned as the concept of veiling was addressed, transitioning from seventy-four lashes, to being

Similar Essays

The Consumption Sustainability Conundrum: Is There An Answer?: A Critical Analysis Of “Toward A New Consciousness

2965 words - 12 pages ties and environmental integrity. I have chosen to focus on solutions pertaining to science and education, because I believe they are fundamental agents of change, which serve to inform ethics, policy, and economics. Science Sustainability, or living within the means of our planet, is a relatively new scientific concept. Until recently, global populations were easily accomodated by the resources endowed to all of us from the earth. There have

Is The Declaration Of Independence A Viable Document?

584 words - 2 pages What does the Fourth of July mean to you? Oftentimes, we as Americans don't realize the true importance and historical significance of this day, the day the nation's most prestigious and historical document was finally accepted as a universal belief. The Declaration of Independence is regarded as one of America's most treasured symbols because it identifies the moment at which the nation was born and describes the reasons for its birth. It

Is Drug Treatment A Viable Alternative To Prison Time?

1265 words - 5 pages against the prisons. With the prisons and county jails facing major overcrowding issues and drug treatment programs being a viable alternative to prison time, more states need to be implementing drug / treatment programs. Treatment / Drug Courts are specialized courts to help stop drug, alcohol, and related criminal activity (U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration,2011). These courts closely monitor the participants in the treatment programs and if

Is Telework/Telecommutes A Viable Option For Newco?

1399 words - 6 pages Introduction Over the past several years the telework or telecommute options have increased in popularity. As technology continues to be enhanced and baby boomers start to leave the work place the new age of workers are trying to have a more balanced life. The balance or flexibility to get you job completed and take care of the family is an increasing dilemma for employers trying to attract the best qualified employees. According to study