Is File Sharing Via Internet Illegal? Essay

1649 words - 7 pages

Is File-Sharing Illegal?

    Abstract:  file-sharing violates existing copyright law by facilitating the widespread and illegal distribution of copyrighted material.  This paper examines the case against file-sharing, by looking at how the players bear responsibility for the illegal acts currently made possible by this new technology.  Finally, it suggests some remedies for file-sharing companies to reform themselves and become a potentially powerful and revolutionary company while still acting in compliance with the law.


Ancient lore told the story of the sirens, beautiful nymphs who would sing to passing sailors, distracting them from their duties and causing the errant ship to crash into the rocks below.  Moving to the present time, we see a nascent technology that allows its users to violate the law, perhaps even unknowingly.  Nearly everyone who uses the Internet today has heard of Napster, the program invented by wunderkind Shawn Fanning that allows for the millions of net users to share music each other.  This technology has come under heavy fire recently, especially from the recording industry, which claims that Napster knowingly allows and even encourages the violation of copyright law, depriving both the artist and the industry of the fruits of their labor.  Supporters counter that the technology supports nascent artists, and revolutionizes the music industry.  This case is currently in the United States court system, and the question before the government, and indeed the entire web community is simple: Is Napster illegal?


            The answer to this question is neither simple nor final, and debate on the subject will definitely continue as the technology and the industry evolves over time.  At present Napster does violate the law, although the reason is circumstantial, and not inherent to the technology itself.  Napster can exist within the law, but does not at present time.  To prove this assertion, we must look at four points.  First, we must distinguish all of the parties involved in the use of Napster.  We will then examine the technology behind digital music in general, and specifically Napster.  Then we will be able to detail the case against Napster, as well as the applicable law involved.  After looking at Napster's defense, we will attempt an answer at the ultimate question, as well as for what damages Napster might be liable, and possible remedies that would hopefully satisfy all of the parties involved in this murky, and potentially landmark, case.


            By far and away, the largest problem in dealing with a case like Napster is determining all of who is involved, and what actions and interactions they contribute to the core issues at hand.  Since Napster's primary focus is the distribution of digital music, we must look at the producers, the distributors, and the consumers of the music.  First, we have the artists, who create the music, and who also are split on the issue of...

Find Another Essay On Is File-Sharing via Internet Illegal?

File Sharing and Online Piracy: How Does it Effect Copyrights? Is it Ethical?

1914 words - 8 pages prison then you could have ever imagined. “What have I done wrong? Am I really hurting anyone?” you ask yourself. Peer-to-peer file sharing is nearly a 15 year old action that creates a connection between computers across the world to share any types of files and information. The creation of Napster in 1999, drastically lower music sales, laws against theft in the United States, and a growing understanding of the file sharing world all contribute

Napster:Explained. In this report i explain exactly what napster is and how it has changed the file sharing industry.

3454 words - 14 pages say that their users are guilty of trading copyrighted music, not them. Napster states that they have clearly stated on their website that trading copyrighted music is illegal. Napster says that they cannot stop their user's actions. CEO of Napster, Eileen RIchardson says, "All we're doing is being an index for a certain kind of file format." The Copyright law clearly states: "Someone who materially contributes to infringing activity, is liable

Workplace Surveillance: Is it Ethical for employer to monitor their employee's communication via Internet?

2598 words - 10 pages attempted including compiling comments from other authors.ResearchBased on the research conducted by the Privacy Foundation, it was found out that what is driving the growth of e-mail and Internet surveillance in the workplaces is mainly the low cost of the technology itself. Employee monitoring, as measured by the sales of surveillance software, has increased at least twice as fast as the number of U.S. employees with Internet access in the past

Illegal Music Swapping

950 words - 4 pages in vain. Illegal Music Swapping Illegal digital music swapping is something that millions of people do every day, even children in the elementary school age range know how to “torrent” music from the internet. The definition of illegal music swapping is a very loose statement, since the DMCA (Digital Millineum Copyright Act) has guidelines that vary for different types of file. For instance a digital music file encrypted using the Apple DRM


1015 words - 4 pages companies who lose the money and the music store workers who lose their jobs. These consequences don't become a problem for just one person but rather to a chain of people that eventually affect everyone.File-sharing and music downloading should be stopped because if the person gets caught, downloading music, there will be consequences that may include lawsuits because it is illegal. File-sharing is illegal because users are able to gain access to

File Sharing

1394 words - 6 pages File Sharing Napster was just another step into the huge world we know as the internet or the World Wide Web. It was a step I believe in the right direction, but some people have differing views. Napster is a program in which people could chat, share files such as mpeg or mpeg3 layered files or other formatted files across the internet. This program was very controversial because it was a very well made program. Its design and user

Illegal Music Downloads

1200 words - 5 pages acceptable?No, downloading music files from the Internet without permission of the copyright is illegal and is consider a theft.Legality to the Companies who provide free downloading service:a. Are companies like LimeWire conducting illegal practices?According to LimeWire and other companies conducting this type of activities, their actions are completely legal. Their position is base on the "file sharing" premise. They claim that they are not

Web Audio: Downloading Audio On The Internet

1807 words - 7 pages file sharing is illegal but it still occurs everyday nonstop. Programs like Napster and Kazaa are to be expected because the internet provides a worldwide link between people and the files that they want to share. There have been many cases through the years to try to stop the peer-2peer phenomenon but the sites continue to survive. Even with all the legal action that has been taken in the past, many of the P2P users feel that they are not at risk

Impact of Technology on Music

1418 words - 6 pages Impact of Technology on Music The introduction to the internet in the early nineties and the creation of broadband, MP3, and the file sharing network known as “peer to peer” has completely revolutionised the music industry. A large percentage of music is today downloaded over the internet, and not bought over the counter in a record store. This essay will address the impact of new technology on music, and how music is distributed. To do

Cost of Free Music Downloading

1206 words - 5 pages , viruses, spyware, spam, and popups are often added to files that are traded on P2P networks or they are disguised as applications. All it takes is one download for your computer to become infected. "In 2004, MyDoom was originally let loose via Kazaa. And though the virus is propagating predominantly via e-mail messages, it continued to worm its way through the most popular of the peer-to-peer file-sharing services" (Metz). Recently, rogue

Internet Piracy: Theft of Intellectual Property

1757 words - 7 pages work that was shared online. "We've been telling people for a long time that file sharing copyrighted music is illegal, that you are not anonymous when you do it, and that engaging in it can have real consequences," said RIAA president Cary Sherman. She added, "Nobody likes playing the heavy and having to resort to litigation, but when your product is being regularly stolen, there comes a time when you have to take appropriate action." The RIAA

Similar Essays

Internet File Sharing Essay

1367 words - 5 pages sharing of copyrighted material, as well as provide alternative means to illegal file sharing. Another similar incident in the United States involves university students being sued for copyright infringement by the Recording Industry’s Trade Association (RIAA). This association is accusing the students of illegally downloading or sharing music files over the Internet. RIAA sent a nationwide wave of 396 pre-litigation settlement letters to

File Sharing On The Internet Essay

849 words - 3 pages File Sharing on the Internet Want to see the latest box office movies? How about checking out the latest records by your favorite rock band? What if you feel like playing a game or reading a document or doing some research? Today, with the progress the Internet is making, this is all possible in your own home in your own PC. For people who know where to go, the Internet offers endless possibilities for finding entertainment. Perhaps the most

File Sharing On The Internet Essay

1488 words - 6 pages File Sharing on the Internet When we think of pirates, we see scruffy men with unshaven chins, a bandana, a gold earing, a black patch on one eye, and a wooden leg, men with guns in hand, riding the seas in their wooden ship proudly flying the terrifying skull and crossbones. Well, pirates these days look much different. In fact, you may be sitting by one right now. They are ordinary people who have come to enjoy the technologies the

The Impact And Persistence Of Rising Internet Piracy And Illegal File Sharing. This Report Shows How Internet Piracy Put Effect On Music Industry.

2178 words - 9 pages , consumers may think that it will be difficult for one to discover their internet piracy. This means they are likely to perform this action of piracy. In some country, illegal download and sharing file can be easily done. The reason behind this may come from lack of behavioural control.3.2 Theory of Social CognitiveAccording to LaRose and Eastin (2004), Social cognitive theory is used to predict human behaviour. The behaviour performance will be