Is Health Care A Right Or A Moral Responsibility?

3163 words - 13 pages

With landmark reforms and scrutiny at the highest levels of government over the past few years, one thing is certain. America and her people are taking a good hard look at health care. It would be hard to argue that few people are unaffected by the use and access to this precious, lifesaving resource. But one thing has become apparent in the debates over the use of this resource; it seems that the national opinion about this resource is fractured into the competing ideas of many different groups. It seems that America has long been trying to answer the question about how to address this topic for quite some time, perhaps unto its very founding. So, to understand how we view this resource, we must first ask ourselves, is health care a right, a privilege or a responsibility?
The first step in answering this question must by necessity be to define the parameters. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines a rite as something that a person is or should be morally or legally allowed to have, get, or do(“Merriam-Webster”). This same source defines a privilege as a right or benefit that is given to some people and not to others. (“Merriam-Webster”) A responsibility is defined as a duty or task that you are required or expected to do or as something that you should do because it is morally right, legally required, etc. (“Merriam-Webster”). Now that it has been made clear what each of these points entail, we must now ask, how shall health care be labeled in respect to these dichotomous ideals?
Health care as a Right
Although we have a rudimentary understanding of what constitutes a right from the definition we established from the dictionary, a deeper understanding necessitates a deeper conversation. In America, we hold to two separate ideas as to what constitutes a right. We have rights that flow to us from the mere fact that we are alive, and we hold to the fact that these rights flow to us from some sense of the Devine. We call these our “inalienable rights” and amongst these are the rights to “life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” (“The Declaration of Independence: A Transcription”).
The next type of right that we receive is established by our legal system of government, and these rights are predicated upon many separate sources, many of which are built upon each other. These sources include the Christian Bible, the English Common Law system, and the Constitution of the United States, as well as all of the laws, statutes and legal precedents that flow from that most hallowed of documents. To develop our understanding of why health care should be viewed as a Right, our examination of this principle will begin with the Eighth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution.
The Eight Amendment states that “Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted”(“Bill of Rights” ). It may seem like this simple sentence has nothing to do with Health care, but given that it was adopted in 1791...

Find Another Essay On Is Health Care a Right or a Moral Responsibility?

The Affordable Right to Health Care

2431 words - 10 pages , the smokers and the reckless. Is it the personal responsibility of each of the citizens of the United States to practice a healthier lifestyle, or should that responsibility belong to the federal government, and be enforced through taxation? Health care as a right through taxation would be considered a “common good," which in terms of public finance is a good or service, provided by the government to be used by all equally if needed (Hyman, 2011

Health Care or a Billion Dollar Industry

1215 words - 5 pages Health care in the United States is a booming topic that everyone seems to have their own opinion on, but are the health care companies really interested in making the world a healthier place or are they more interested in making money? This is a growing social problem in not only the United States but the world. The social problems that are arising from health care are the growing pharmaceutical problems, the issue on overmedication, and the

Is Education a Right or Privilege?

933 words - 4 pages them in the pursuit of the goals that they may have set for themselves in life. I strongly believe that a good, heck, or even a regular education is a right that cannot be taken away. Education is a right and not a privilege. John Dewey once stated in “Thinking in Education” that the “method of instruction needs improvement, which exact, promote, and test thinking.” A student willing to learn will most likely think incongruously than

This is a opinionated paper on Health care and if the government should gain profit in health care or help society for no profit gain.

1329 words - 5 pages insured. Take an AIDS patient for example, as of right now, there is no cure and he/she is going to die. But how can he or she pay for the drugs and treatment to prolong his life without sufficient health care that will cover him/her when he's/she's healthy, and also when he's dying. There are millions of cases, the boy who needs a new heart, the elderly man with a broken hip, or how about a girl playing hopscotch that was a victim of a drive by

Citizenship, A Right And A Responsibility?.

1545 words - 6 pages       When I think of America I think of freedom and citizenship. The right to vote or the right of free speech are aspects that, as citizens, we posses. Being born in America automatically gives you these rights and many more, and most importantly, you become a citizen. Now, with citizenship comes responsibility such as obeying the law and paying taxes. So if you follow these simple rules does this make you an

Primary Health Care: A New Approach to Health Care

2171 words - 9 pages Primary health care is the care nurses adopt to emphasis the health care to the people themselves and their needs to shape their lives of the people. Primary health care includes all areas that play a role in health, such as access to health services, environment and lifestyle. Hospitals and the health care centers are the only aspects providing the health care to the people in towns or communities. According to (Anne McMurray, 2012

Is privacy a right?

2303 words - 9 pages , further information is collected about him in th e database. His credit file, work history, health reports, bank balances, family statistics, and personal lifestyles may now be available. Soon, this bank of information expands the capability of checking up on a consumer's background which becomes publ ic information to anyone, reputable or not, on the Internet. Thus, for the convenience of shopping on-line, the consumer is threatened by the loss

Is Abortion a Right?

1850 words - 7 pages that a fetus is not human. If we exterminate a fetus because of his or her intrinsic nature, we are acknowledging that that fetus has the qualities of a unique human being" ("Abortion as Gay Bashing?"). Finally, the left would have to rationalize denying an abortion to a woman who wants one, which liberals acknowledge is her right, just because they don't agree with her reason for doing so. Another possible scenario would be an attempt by

Gay Marriage: A privilege or a right?

2003 words - 8 pages The question of whether gays should be allowed to marry in society is one that has been on the United States' agenda recently. There are those who say that marriage is a right that should be given to all, and that denying gays this right is a form of oppression. To decide whether or not gays are in fact being oppressed, and if they should be allowed to marry, I will analyze the works of Edmund Burke, Jeremy Bentham, and Karl Marx. In his

Need for a New Health Care System

1411 words - 6 pages cost of health care will come. With the baby boomer generation coming to eligibility age for Medicare, it is inevitable that Medicare will run dry. This can not be solved by lowering prescription drug costs or attacking any problem individually. The entire system must be changed.      With the implementation of a national health care system, uninsured Americans will be eliminated, prescription drug costs will be lower, and Medicare will be

A National Form of Health Care

3052 words - 12 pages does the American public have to say about a universal health insurance program? Well, in a January, 2006 New York Times/CBS News poll and a November, 2006 Gallup poll 62% and 69% respectively, said it’s the federal government’s responsibility to “guarantee health care for all” even if it meant paying more in taxes to do so (Teixeira, n.d.). Lastly, the “ERISA Law “or the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 is another reason why

Similar Essays

Health Care As A Right Essay

815 words - 4 pages either uninsured, or they are insured and the cost may still be too high. This is the root of major epidemics among the health care crisis to the public. The more untreated, average citizens there are, the more likely it is for viruses to spread throughout a community or city. Yet, if healthcare was supplied to everyone, there would be substantially less worry for outbreaks of deadly, yet preventable, epidemics. Health care spending in the U.S

All Americans Have A Right To Health Care

1534 words - 6 pages .      Considering that the United States ranks low in health status, the percentage of its population covered by health insurance is also low. Health care should be a right that all Americans has, not a privilege. (McGovern) With this in mind, everyone should work to extend that right to every American. “To succeed at it, we must find common principles that unite us and move beyond what divides us.” (Sweeney) We must work together to make coverage

Health And Nutrition. This Essay Is A Paper Mainly Used For A Health Class. It Talks About How To Take Care Of Yourself By Excercising And Eating Right.

1410 words - 6 pages What does health and nutrition do in your life? Well if your thinking that it doesn't make a difference in your life then your wrong. It is probably one of the most important things in someone's life. And it isn't really very hard to stay in shape and eat right. There are many ways and reasons to stay in shape also!The first reason to eat right and stay in shape is very simple. It is so that you can go out and do things and be able to keep up

Explore An Issue: Responsibility For Heart Disease Should Cigarette Smokers Have To Pay For Their Own Health Care In A Place Where Free Health Care Is Offered? For Example In Canada.

1078 words - 4 pages well as the many other people who partake in other unhealthy or dangerous activities. Additionally, it cannot be proven that a specific individual’s disease was a result of smoking more than it was a result of other factors such as genetics or a faulty diet. It is also impossible to say what would have happened if an individual had not taken up the habit of smoking, they may have cost the government more money in health care if they lived a