Is High Stakes Testing Effective? Essay

1541 words - 6 pages

The issue of high-stakes testing is a substantial topic in the world of education today. Some find it to be a useful tool in making decisions in education. By using the results from a high stakes test, schools are able to decide where each student should go next. By setting high standards and high expectations, schools are ensuring that their tests have a purpose. (National Research Council, 1999) Others disagree and find high-stakes testing to be a complete waste of time. In Massachusetts, professors are protesting the use of these tests. They’re saying that high-stakes tests are not a good way to assess the schools performance nor the teachers and students in the schools. Which is it? Good or bad? After much research it has been found that having a high-stakes testing environment in schools creates unsuccessful results in education. Valerie Strauss, an education reporter from Washington, D.C . was able to get information from the Massachusetts professors and researchers themselves who stated:
As educators and researchers from across the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, we strongly oppose our state’s continued over reliance on high-stakes standardized testing to assess student achievement, evaluate teacher effectiveness, and determine school quality. Given that standardized tests provide only one indicator of student achievement, and that their high-stakes uses produce ever-increasing incentives to teach to the test, narrow the curriculum, or even to cheat, we call on the BESE to stop using standardized tests in high-stakes decisions affecting students, teachers, and schools. (Strauss, V. 2013)

In a perfect world, high-stakes tests would be the ideal thing. However, that is not the case. Despite what some people may think, punishing schools for bad test scores is not going to improve anything. Teachers can only do just so much. It should be noticed that these tests have not been designed in an effective way. According to the director of the Bay Area Research Group:
Educators do pay attention to what is on the tests—but the consequences are not necessarily the intended ones. Even the most carefully designed standards are only as effective as the tests that assess how well students have achieved them. And standardized tests can only assess a small portion of the curriculum. State accountability tests leave out some subjects altogether, and they only cover a limited sample of the many subtopics covered in others. In addition, for practical reasons, state tests tend to rely on easy-to-score questions that measure basic skills and recall instead of higher-order thinking. Worse yet, when stakes are high, it's more likely that what's missing from the tests will disappear from the curriculum, especially in schools with low-performing students. (David 2011)

In the study of “Negotiating Identity and Science Teaching in a High-Stakes Testing Environment” the focus is on an individual elementary teacher. It demonstrates the amount of stress she...

Find Another Essay On Is High-Stakes Testing Effective?

High-stakes Testing in Schools Essay

633 words - 3 pages High-stakes testing is a very complicated issue. The watered down explanation given to the members of the public is that of holding teachers accountable for the achievement of their students. However, this is not the only use of HST. HST can also be utilized in determining grade level promotion, assigning a performance rating to an entire school, and determining students’ ability to graduate from high school (Kubiszyn & Borich, 2013). One of

Standardized and high stakes testing Essay

1797 words - 7 pages classrooms. "To demand that teachers be instantly accountable for challenging new content standards when we have not invested in the relearning teachers require if they are to meet those standards" (Sirotnik and Kimball 212) is an irresponsible and unfair act on the part of states and the educational testing community. If schools and teachers are to take on these high-stakes responsibilities then the policy makers must ask the public to put their money

High-Stakes Testing in American Schools

1618 words - 6 pages The NCLB Act has obligated the government to find a way to keep track of progress, which, in their minds, is administering high-stakes tests. High-stakes testing is scrutinized all the time, since some believe it is the only indicator of tracking students and teachers. They seemed to have been ridiculed by many and favored by few; nonetheless there are significant disparities in the public’s and government’s opinion. According to Dunne (2000

High-Stakes Testing, the Standardized Classroom, and the Marginalization of Multicultural Education

1864 words - 7 pages “The world’s greatest problems do not result from people being unable to read and write. They result from people in the world-from different cultures, races, religions, and nations-being unable to get along and to work together to solve the world’s problems.” These statements by James A. Banks have made a profound impact on my view towards multicultural education and the nation’s current trend of standardization and high-stakes testing

The Potential Impacts of Upcoming High-Stakes Testing on the Teaching of Science in Elementary Classrooms-Research Article Critique

1165 words - 5 pages This research was both preliminary and exploratory, with intent to explore the effects of standardized tests in the area of teaching and learning science. The purpose of the research was clearly stated under a sub-heading. The goal was to collect data to indicate teachers’ perceptions and concerns about the high-stakes standardized science testing being implemented in the elementary school. Data of a qualitative nature was collected through

Standardized Testing is NOT Effective

2395 words - 10 pages said that the tests are biased. Within the article Holding Kids Responsible for Our Failures, Paul Wellstone discusses the heavy disadvantages of high-stakes testing. He believes that it is “absurd for us to believe that students who attend the poorest of schools have anywhere close to the same preparation and readiness as students who attend the wealthiest of schools” (Wellstone 89). This is absolutely true. Low SES (low socioeconomic status

Is Pre-Alzheimer's Disease Testing Effective?

2061 words - 8 pages striving to find effective pre-Alzheimer’s Disease tests. However, there are people who believe that these pre-screening methods are not reliable. Those that favor the idea of pre-Alzheimer’s Disease testing believe that cognitive abilities screening, neuropsychological exams, brain image testing and spinal fluid are the key to detecting this disease early in life. Through cognitive abilities screening the administering clinician is able to

Do High School Students Believe the ACT is an Effective Indicator of Their Capacities to Learn?

2335 words - 9 pages be for a greater sample of the population and will contain more components in order to deliver a more effective study with informative results. Bibliography Greene J.P., Winters, M.A., Forster, Greg. Testing High Stakes Tests: Can We Believe the Results of Accountability Tests? (2003, February 3). Retrieved: November 9, 2013 from the Manhattan Institute website: http://www.manhattan-institute.org/html/cr_33.htm. Jaschik, Scott. (2007). A

Do High-Stakes Assessments Improve Learning?

553 words - 2 pages students have learned and will use in the future are not covered or too much knowledge is required. A student excelling in Math might not fare as well in English because of his family heritage. A student that is artistically inclined and is a top English student may struggle with Math and be only mediocre in History. The results from high-stakes testing can keep a student from graduating even though they passed all of their classes. The importance

The Pros and Cons of Standardized Testing

2228 words - 9 pages are made thus leaving teachers out of the conversation. Pressure to raise student scores is how teachers feel about standardized testing in the classroom. The idea behind standardized testing are pushing teachers to make the material mirror the content of the state test. This requires large amounts of time to be spent on test preparation. Evidence regarding high-stakes testing can change the structure of schools. Teachers have varying opinions

The Problems With Standardized Testing

1839 words - 7 pages will require students to take tests in order to gather information about their academic achievement. Although educators and administrators claim that the mandatory ability testing programs being initiated in America’s public schools will hold students and teachers accountable for academic achievement, these programs are really causing more problems than they are solving. Mandated standardized testing is also known as “high-stakes testing

Similar Essays

High Stakes Testing Essay

1250 words - 5 pages educational policies. But, even though education is such an important issue government allows high-stakes testing to crush the education of our nations students. A high-stakes test is one that holds consequences for failure. School districts, teachers and students become victims of high-stakes testing consequences. A school district may loose funding or be investigated causing financial ramifications. A teacher may loose their job because their

High Stakes Testing Essay

1272 words - 5 pages evidence that the pressure and anxiety associated with high-stakes testing is unhealthy for children...and may undermine the development of positive social relationships and attitudes towards school and learning”(alliance). High stakes testing is full of pressure. Just the thought of “failing” and the embarrassment that may lead to can lead children and teenagers to an indifferent state towards learning. High stakes testing causes detrimental

High Stakes Testing Essay

3377 words - 14 pages the "telling, showing, and demonstration of facts". However, the cost associated with these new "standards of education" are antithetical to what these new standards were designed to do, which in turn is affecting students and educators alike.This paper will look at the history of performance assessments, and the ways in which high stakes testing has become the dominant pedagogy for teachers in America. This paper will also look at the pros and

High Stakes Testing Essay

1385 words - 6 pages High Stakes Testing In 1997, President Bill Clinton stated that the United States needed, “ a national crusade for education standards - not federal government standards, but national standards, representing what all our students must know to succeed in the knowledge economy of the twenty-first century”(http://books.nap.edu/books/0309062802/html/13.html). The way to succeed in this journey is through standardized testing that results in