Is Homosexuality A Result Of Nature Or Nurture?

1708 words - 7 pages

The argument of nature v. nurture in regards to homosexuality is a topic of intense debate. Those for it, in this case the side of nature will be addressed in ‘for the argument’, defend their reasoning fiercely and there seem to be a significantly larger amount of them. Those against it, in this case the side of nurture will addressed in ‘against the argument’, also defend their reasoning with ferocity but there are significantly less of them. This paper will discuss both sides of the argument, citing peer-reviewed journals/articles, and discussing evidence used to support each side. In each case the evidence will be thoroughly discussed and in the conclusion the evidence will be summarized and my opinion will be stated in the conclusion. As stated in many other papers about this subject, the purpose of this paper is not to prove if homosexuality is right or wrong, but to establish a thorough and unbiased understanding about the biological and/or social source of homosexuality.
For the Argument
The first serious attempt to explain sexual orientation by means other than a person’s social interaction or religious influence was be Von Kraft-Ebbing. His argument, in its most basic form, was that it was ‘inborn’ (Ellis & Ames, 1987, 234). As we gained more knowledge on the endocrine system in the 20th century two men, Magnus Hirschfeld and Auguste Florel speculated that hormone imbalances could result in homosexuality. Genetic factors began to be considered in the 1940s. Since then there have been numerous studies attempting to prove the genetic predisposition to homosexuality. The earliest experiment in biological research began in 1938 with the research of Alfred Kinsey. Kinsey was studying human sexuality with the goal of discovering how many males engaged in homosexual behaviors and why they did. He found that 30 percent of college males had engaged on some sort of homosexual behavior. Based on his studies, which lasted 15 years, “homosexual sexual experience, at least from this study, seems to be confined to adolescence and isolated experiences in the latter years” (“Homosexuality: biologically or environmentally constructed”, n.d., Introduction, para. 1). There is a classification system now where a Kinsey 0 means solely heterosexual and a Kinsey 6 is solely homosexual, with everything in between being varying degrees of bisexual (Pickering, Homosexuality the Causes, para. 1). His studies were published and entitled Sexual Behavior in the Human Male and Sexual Behavior in the Human Female. In 1957 Karen Hooker performed the first test to find biological determinism. The Rorschach test, Thematic-Apperception Test, and the Make-A-Picture-Story- Test were used in this study and while it did not find any significant differences in answers she was able to conclude that there was a “zero correlation between social determinism of sexuality” (Johnson, n.d., para. 4). The next noteworthy test was by D.F. Swaab in 1990. He was the first to document the...

Find Another Essay On Is Homosexuality a Result of Nature or Nurture?

Homosexuality: Nature vs. Nurture Essay

885 words - 4 pages Over the years, there has been a debate whether homosexuality is due to nature or nurture. In other words, are you born gay, or do you become gay? Scientists look into its background and origins of homosexuality. Some believe it is developmental or some have even tried to diagnose a disorder back originally. There are many valid points to either side that can be discussed and much information to be researched about this topic. On one hand

Homosexuality: Nature vs. Nurture? Speech

845 words - 3 pages Let me first begin by clearly stating our position: homosexuality is a product of nature. In other words, someone's genetic makeup--their being in the physiological sense--strongly influences whether or not they will end up gay or heterosexual. Any role that the environment, or nurture, plays in the determination of someone's sexual orientation is minimal at best, but the role of nature in this determination is drastic.Take the case of Jamie

is the creature a product of nature or nurture?

1162 words - 5 pages . Not only was he disrespected by the people living around him, he wasn’t cultivated by Victor on how to behave as well as not being cared or loved for, which was the one thing he truly desired. If it’s a question of whether the creature was a product of nature or nurture, the answer is nurture as he was his own enemy throughout the story. Had Victor took the time to nurture and educate the creature, there would have been a much greater chance that all those deaths would have simply not occurred. It is shown how ones actions can cause so much harm to a large group of people and in this case Mary Shelly’s, Frankenstein is the perfect example of it.

Is Nature or Nurture the Cause of Differences Between Male and Female Brains? : A Detailed Outline

1550 words - 7 pages Focus Questions: Are the differences in the behavior and cognition of men and women biological (nature) or due to social conditioning (nurture)? What are these specific differences and are they socially significant? Thesis Statement: The differences between male and female brains with respect to cognition and behavior are due to both biological factors and social conditioning, though the largest discrepancies are caused by nature. What does

The Nature of Aggression (or is it Nurture?)

1439 words - 6 pages The Nature of Aggression (or is it Nurture?) Every night on the news there are reports about murders, wars, and rapes. But the news isn't the only place where people encounter violent or aggressive behavior. Driving home from work, people get cut off and cussed at on a daily basis. At school, children fight over who will be the first in the lunch line. On the street, people get pushed out of the way if they are not walking fast enough. The

Nature, Nurture, or Both

916 words - 4 pages century. So exactly what is nature versus nurture and why is there not a definitive answer to this question? "Some scientists think that people behave as they do according to genetic predispositions or even "animal instincts." This is known as the "nature" theory of human behavior. Other scientists believe that people think and behave in certain ways because they are taught to do so. This is known as the "nurture" theory of human behavior" (Powell

Nature/Nurture or Both!

1860 words - 7 pages Adem 1                                    Nature / Nurture or Both !                  The controversy over what determines who we are, whether it is Nature (heredity, our biological make up) or Nurture (our environment) is taking a new shape. Through the past decades, psychologists have developed different theories to explain the characteristics of human-beings; how we feel, think and behave. Usually, these

Gender: Nature or Nurture?

1726 words - 7 pages There has been much debate between biologists and social scientists about whether gender identity, the strong belief that one belongs to either the male or female sex category, is the result of humans being obedient to their biological genes (nature) or to their environmental upbringing (nurture). Biologists tend to believe that nature and prenatal exposure to natural sex hormones, especially androgens, determines one?s gender. Social scientists

Nature, Nurture, or Both?

690 words - 3 pages One of the oldest arguments in psychology is the nature versus nurture debate. This debate focuses on if the contributions of genetic inheritance or the environment plays a role in human development. As always, there are two sides of every debate. In this case, there are the nativists, who believe human development is determined by genetics, and there are the empiricists, who believe that development is the result of learning and the person’s

Nature or Nurture?

952 words - 4 pages to the article Math Skills: Nature or Nurture? published on Psychology Today website (, performance in math is somewhat defined by our genes, somewhat by the way we were nurtured. I agree with the author. We probably will never get a definitive answer to this question due to individuality of every single case. As I look back at my childhood years, I cannot

Alcoholism - nature or nurture?

2780 words - 11 pages personality', or are we taught addictive behaviour by our family and society? This classic question of nature vs. nurture is answered with a qualified "both."Alcoholism can be considered to derive from genetic causes. Family studies have repeatedly confirmed that the risk of alcoholism is higher among parents, siblings and children. While genetics may play an important role, there are other factors that can influence individual biological

Similar Essays

Homosexuality, Nature Or Nurture? Essay

1652 words - 7 pages Is homosexuality a result of a deviation in someone's biological make-up, or is it due to the factors of environment while they are growing up? In this essay, I argue that homosexuality is indeed a inborn property rather than the way a child is brought up. To back up my argument I will use religious support, scientific proof and insight from someone who has been around a gay her whole life. This is a topic that has gone through much debate, a

Homosexuality: Nature Or Nurture? Essay

1695 words - 7 pages Homosexuality is one of the most hot button issues in America today. Everyone has an opinion, some based on religious views others based on other external factors. People are afraid to talk about it because it’s something we don’t actually fully comprehend. This is because it scares people to admit they don’t know something. We need to find out if being a homosexual is something we are born with, or is it something we learn over time

Homosexuality As Nature Or Nurture Essay

2661 words - 11 pages Homosexuality as Nature or Nurture Human sexuality has been one of society's most interesting, controversial, debated, and misunderstood topics. It has been the topic of numerous books, essays, documentaries, websites, and television magazine segments. More specifically, homosexuality is probably the most misunderstood aspect of human sexuality. This is mainly due to lack of education, exposure, or just a general close mindedness

Homosexuality: Nature Vs. Nurture Essay

1291 words - 5 pages the straight and gay men and their overall health, thus leading to the realisation that maybe homosexuality is not nurture, but rather, nature (“Being Gay Is Just as Healthy as Being Straight” 1). Changing Your Sexual Orientation With homosexuality being thought of as a “choice,” or something that is subject to change by the religious, conservative, and or rural community, it is only likely that the same group would offer things such as