Is International Relations A Science? Essay

1430 words - 6 pages

Introduction
There is an alarming difference on how science and political science affect those looking for answers through these disciplines. When a new theory or explanation emerges in the scientific community, most are quick to say, “science has proven...” However, when political scientists arrive at a new conclusion, or when an existing “fact” turns out to be false, and a new paradigm comes along in the political science arena, most people are quick to brush it off, and rarely do they change their minds when the new paradigm contradicts their belief. Whether this raises questions on the validity of the claims made in the political science field, or if it raises questions on the ...view middle of the document...

The political science discipline deals with the theory and exercise of politics, political behavior, and it explains and analyzes political systems. The terms political science and politics are most commonly used interchangeably, but political science is focused on solving puzzles and producing results, which generally requires the scientific methodology of theory, and research. However, it is similar to normal and other social sciences in the way its political scientists uses methods, tools and techniques that relate to the kinds of inquiries required to solve complex puzzles. Nevertheless, unlike politics, political science is not about relationships (between nations), it is about producing results to issues in a variety of fields that exist within its framework.
International Relations (IR), political economy, geopolitics, political theory and law, political philosophy and ideology, and policy analysis, are some of the subfields hosted by the political science discipline. The dominant methodological approach in IR focuses on examining the process of international systems and the dynamics of countries and regions throughout the world by practicing objective and systematic observation to verify its methods and results (Nye and Welsh, 2013).
Political scientists work tirelessly trying to solve puzzles that can, does, and will continue to make an impact on the quality of life of people all over the world. The goal for this paper is to move beyond the on-going debate concerning the validity of political science as a genuine science. Prominent Political scientists such as the late Kenneth Waltz, Hans Morgenthau, Henry A. Kissinger, Samuel P. Huntington, who are considered pioneers in the field, have made their contributions to the great demarcation debates (NYT, 2013). Due to the broad scope of what comprises political science and what it does, the focus of this paper will be on the major sub-division of Political Science, which is International Relations (IR). It will also present the role of political scientists, and how they use scientific methods to study political and social fabric of nations around the world.
What Is International Relations?
International Relations became a subfield of political science when tensions were rising between the United States and the Soviet Union (Martin, 2013). Following WWI and WWII, scholars and philosophers became interested in how nation-states interacted with one another and set out to develop a “conceptual framework on how international relations could be analyzed” (Martin, 2013). However, it wasn’t until the 1970s that International Relations became accepted as a social science “with the discipline becoming explicitly theoretical and empirical and its rewards going to those scholars who embraced a scientific approach” (Frieden and Lake, 2013). Although IR gained significant recognition long ago, these authors are not satisfied with the progress made within the field, and suggest that the discipline...

Find Another Essay On Is International Relations a Science?

What Is Science; Is Medicine A Science?

3273 words - 13 pages What is science; is medicine a science? What is science? Distinctions In addressing this topic, the first question to focus on, is how one defines a science. Some would say that a more distinct line could be drawn between what is a science and what is definitely not a science (a non-science). Science is traditionally personified by objectivity. Ideally, bias has absolutely no place here, and it is through this objectivity one hopes to understand

is psychology a science? Essay

2371 words - 9 pages 1. The Status of Psychology as a ScienceIn module 3, we looked at some arguments for and against the use of the scientific method in research. Here, our emphasis is on science in general, not just the methodology (although some of the content you learned for that exam could likewise be used here).This controversy focuses on the issue of psychology's status as a science. There are two strands to this debateIs psychology as a science?Should

Is Psychology a Science?

1266 words - 5 pages Psychology is commonly defined as 'scientific' study of human behaviour and cognitive processes. Broadly speaking the discussion focuses on the different branches of psychology, and if they are indeed scientific. However, it is integral in this to debate to understand exactly the major features of a science, in order to judge if psychology is in fact one. There must be a definable subject matter - this changed from conscious human thought to

Is Marketing a Science?

3292 words - 13 pages ABSTRACT.The common perception of marketing is that of an interdisciplinary field comprising knowledge from diverse fields of science, like business administration, sociology and mathematics. Despite - or probably because of this diversity - there have been extensive complaints about a deficit concerning the scientific status and the theoretical foundation of marketing. Marketing is still in a state of unresolved coexistence of theories, and in

Is Psychology a Science?

1639 words - 7 pages Is Psychology a science? In order to answer this question it is important to understand the definitions of both psychology and science. The word 'psychology' comes from the Greek 'psyche' (or soul) and 'logos' (or study), which came to be known as the 'study of the soul'. The American Heritage Dictionary defines psychology as:1. the science dealing with the mind and with mental and emotionalprocesses2. the science of human and animal behavior.In

Why Is Power Central to Realist Perspectives of International Relations?

1404 words - 6 pages history (Chiaruzzi, 2012, pp. 37). In contrast, neorealism is based on a scientific method by examining economic theory and philosophy of science rather than historical reflection (Chiaruzzi, 2012, pp. 41). In addition, power is central to realist perspectives of International Relations because it is crucial for the understanding of two principal issues: who can be expected to win a conflict? And, related to this, who governs international politics

Sovereignty is of declining significance in international relations

1921 words - 8 pages Carl Schmitt once stated, “The protego ergo oblige” (n.d); meaning I protect therefore I oblige. This is the basis of a key aspect of International Relations: Sovereignty. Theoretically, it can be defined as the supreme power or authority. Sovereignty as a concept plays a critical role in maintaining international order however has been interpreted in several different ways; its context in theory and in reality. In order to appreciate

The Kurds: a nation without a State - International Relations - Essay

1834 words - 8 pages relations with the US. Opening to neoliberalism, and thus follow the independent Kurdistan?s agenda to seek international cooperation with nations with conflicted interests in the area would mean more conflict to the Middle East. Following a realist approach is the safest pathway for the Iraqi Kurds. Works Cited BBC News. ?Iraqi Kurdistan Profile.? BBC News World: Middle East, BBC, 19 September 2017, http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-28147263

What is the Subaltern? Can the Subaltern speak? - International Relations - Essay

1442 words - 6 pages International Relations Essay Post-Colonialism “What is the Subaltern? Can the Subaltern Speak?” Berili Agnesia Dargawan ES3-2B 15025195 Post-colonialism theory affected and changed the way international relations study sees and questions. It created a more critical way of thinking to the study and brought up subjects such as races, gender and class bases of power which were vaguely acknowledged by the conventional international relations

Is Psychology a Science? - Homework Assignment

864 words - 4 pages the features of my voice changed. When thinking about this I wanted to understand why this happened and if it had something to do with a part of the brain. Task 3: Is psychology a science A reason why psychology is not counted as a science is because of certain variables. In normal sciences such as chemistry and physics, variables are clearly acknowledged. Some of them being current, voltage, amps and grams when carrying out research and

Cloning is a Misunderstood and Underestimated Science

3159 words - 13 pages Cloning is a Misunderstood and Underestimated Science On February 23rd of 1997, an announcement was made that would shake the world and, inevitably, change it forever. Ian Wilmut, an embryologist with a genetic research facility named the Roslin Institute in Scotland, claimed that he and a group of scientists had successfully cloned a sheep. The sheep, named Dolly, was revolutionary in the Bioengineering world because it was the first

Similar Essays

International Relations: An American Social Science?

2746 words - 11 pages The question of whether the discipline of International Relations (IR) was in the past, and is still now, a predominantly American social science, is one that has taken up a great deal of discourse in the field of IR. Indeed this question has been the driving force for the IR theory course for which this paper was written; as evidenced by the title and content of the course textbook at the very least (International Relations -- Still an American

Connection Is Key: International Relations Intertwined

884 words - 4 pages Connection is Key: International Relations Intertwined Ancient Greece is responsible for many contemporary ideologies for philosophy and politics. Combining the two creates a whole intertwined web of thought and circumstance. Philosophy is the study of basic concepts such as existence and freedom, however, philosophy does extend on to other concepts. Politics is the ideology and practice of governing a group. Both the concepts of

Is A Realist Understanding Of International Relations Still Applicable In The Early Twenty First Century?

1541 words - 6 pages PAGE 1 Essay 1Respond to any one title in no more than 1,500 words.Chosen Title:Is a realist understanding of international relations still applicable in the early twenty first century?In Politics we must act "as if all men are wicked and that they will always give rent to the malignity that is in their hands when opportunity offers" (Machiavelli: 1970 Book 1, Chapter 3) purporting that each state will do what it needs to do in order to

Political Economy Is Basically A Debate Between Adam Smith And Karl Marx International Relations Essay

3468 words - 14 pages UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM School of Government and Society Student ID No: 1812749 Programme of study: Political Science and International Relations Module title: Understanding Politics Module banner code: POLS 101 Word Count* 2,352 Module leader: Dr. Peter Burnham Seminar Teacher Mattias Hjort Submission date: 4 December 2017 Assignment title: “Political economy is essentially a debate between Adam Smith and Karl Marx”. Discuss. Extension: no