Is It Morally Permissible To Abort A Living Fetus

975 words - 4 pages

Is It Morally Permissible to Abort a Living Fetus?
Melinda becomes part of a Space Exploration team. She and twenty others embark on a journey to explore Planet Xenia. Upon arrival at the foreign planet, the space exploration team is attacked by violent aliens with large teeth and tentacles. Melinda and only three of her companions make it back to the escape pod safely. Shortly after their escape from the untamed planet, it is discovered that Melinda has been impregnated by one of the aliens. The team must decide whether it is morally permissible to abort the fetus. Both a utilitarian (act and rule) viewpoint and a Kantian Deontological standpoint must be analyzed to determine the outcome of this unborn fetus.
From a utilitarian point of view, the amount of pain and happiness decides whether the act is morally permissible. In reference to the pain and happiness of the fetus, an act utilitarian would act in favor of the abortion in order to avoid the pain and scrutiny that would accompany the life of a fetus that is half human and half alien. In accordance with the act utilitarian, a rule utilitarian, when acting on behalf of the fetus, would also vote for doing the abortion. This is because under this particular circumstance, the happiness of the group would be maximized by avoiding the unpredictable and risky outcome of birthing a half human, half alien child. The viewpoints stay consistent when considering the happiness of the mother and group. In this case, both the act and rule utilitarians would be in favor of the abortion for mostly the same reasons above; the amount of pain experienced by the mother would be decreased by having to give up her life to care for a baby that will inevitably be scrutinized and made fun of and the happiness of the group would be increased by avoiding the unpredictable actions and outcomes of giving birth to a creature such as a half human, half alien. Problems arise however, because a Utilitarian point of view completely avoids the abortion argument in general; it is wrong to kill humans, an unborn baby is a human, so abortion is wrong. A Utilitarian only looks at the total happiness that can be achieved by the action of abortion and ignores the ethical issue of taking the life of a human. Nevertheless, in both situations under these circumstances, aborting the baby would decrease pain and increase happiness for the baby, the mother and the space exploration group.
The opposing view on the subject is that from a Kantian deontological standpoint, one which puts emphasis on the duty of the individual in determining the moral worth of an action. In its most basic form when applied to this argument, the moral duty of a...

Find Another Essay On Is it Morally Permissible to Abort a Living Fetus

Is it Wrong for Women to Abort Fetuses with Down Syndrome?

791 words - 4 pages . Especially to those who are pro-life (people who are against abortion.) Some people feel so strongly against abortion that one state has banned abortion of fetuses with genetic disorders. In fact, the governor of North Dakota recently signed a bill stating that it is prohibited to abort any fetus with a genetic abnormality. This means that if any physician performs an abortion on a patient who is aware of the fetus having a birth defect, then this is an act of a class A misdemeanor.

"Living On A Fixed Income" is about what it is like to live on a fixed income

1018 words - 4 pages , I've mentioned the gas to get there and the insurance to be able to keep your car on the road legally.So as you can see the effects of living on a fixed low-income are numerous. It affects all areas of your life, anything that involves money, which are most things in today's society. You must be a smart planner and think ahead carefully. When you have a family, it has its own effects in their lives as well as your own. When you live on a fixed low-income there is much to plan for and careful planning is the key to living a happier life.

Do you think that it is morally acceptable to have preferential treatment programs for disabled veterans?

951 words - 4 pages Yes, it is morally acceptable to have preferential treatment programs for disabled veterans. Nothing contained in this title shall be interpreted to require any employer . . . to grant preferential treatment to any individual or to any group because of the race, color, religion, sex or national origin of such individual or group on account of an imbalance which may exist with respect to the total number or percentage of persons of any race

Revenge, is it morally justified? Refers to The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas

1023 words - 4 pages on smaller issues. But is it morally justified? The answer to this question is largely depends on whom you ask, and it may vary according to the concepts and values that he/her was raised on - it differs among different peoples, cultures and traditions. In this essay I will try to answer this question from the point of the story The Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas. In order to discuss the revenge issue of this book let us begin by a

"What Does It Mean To Be A Morally Responsible Teacher In A Social And Political Society"

555 words - 2 pages through high school I noticed that many student's worst subject was history. I have made it my goal to become a history teacher, and to inform the students of our society about the importance of history in our life. Being a morally responsible teacher in a social and political democracy means being aware of what is going on in the world at the time. It also means being able to see when a student is having trouble outside of class that is

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. Was it morally right to create a monster?

776 words - 3 pages Morality. It has been questioned by people, honored by people and revered since the beginning of time. Yet even today not one person can say what is morally right. It is a matter of opinion. It was Dr.Victor Frankenstein's opinion that it was alright to create a 'monster'. Frankenstein's creation needed a companion. Knowing that his first creation was evil should the doctor make a second? With the knowledge at hand, to Dr.Frankenstein, it is not

The title is the Bridge to Enlightenment. It talks about how To Kill a Mockingbird shows us how a typical six year old child and go from being egotisical to more morally aware and world centric

2452 words - 10 pages to reach this conclusion because of the empathy he has; he is probably one of the few people in To Kill a Mockingbird who actually understands Tom for who he is. Atticus serves as the link from egocentrism to moral awareness because he is also the man who emphasizes the idea of "understand a person…climb into his skin and walk around in it" (30). Atticus is morally aware because he is able see things from a different point of view; he is

Social Changes in Farming-tells about how it is becoming easier to farm, but harder to make a living off of it

901 words - 4 pages using more mechanization. By doing so, it increases efficiency with the hope of increased net income.Another negative aspect of the changes is the fact that small farms are disappearing. The small farms are disappearing because of the increased cost of living. Farms need to become incorporated just to support a family. Small farms can't produce enough grain or milk to make ends meet. Because the farms are becoming larger and not as family

Business Ethics: Do you think it is morally acceptable an employer to read his or her employee's e-mail?

790 words - 3 pages also it should be morally acceptable, as long as the employer informs the staff of the monitoring system in place. Employers have to step cautiously through the legal minefield of surveillance, however, the dangers associated with doing nothing are even worse. The most understandable effect of email and Internet abuse are the hours of misplaced productivity. Writing personal emails to friends on company time, even where the subject is

Do you think it is morally acceptable for an employer to make rules against dating in the workplace?

1238 words - 5 pages possibly asking her out it was explained to me that that type of relationship was inappropriate. In fact it was most frowned upon when a dating relationship takes place between a commissioned officer and an enlisted member. The main reason for this type of relationship is because it can cause a conflict of interest. A person that holds a position of authority as a commissioned officer has a relationship with an enlisted person it can cause

Torture is Morally Justifiable in Some Extreme Cases (write a letter to the editor in respose to Mirko Bagaric's article)

1020 words - 4 pages stating that it should be permissible to kill an innocent person who "almost certainly" has information that the authority would like. "In those circumstances you would start with a minimum degree of harm; if that didn't work, you would escalate it, and if that unfortunately resulted in an innocent person being killed, in those circumstances that would be justified. I think as a society we would accept that one person being killed to save thousands is

Similar Essays

Is Pornography Morally Permissible? Essay

1549 words - 7 pages is viewing a photograph of a naked child in an attempt to establish the identities of the participants.” In this case the pornography is used for evidence. This is plausible but in most cases this is not what child pornography is used for. In essence my belief is that child pornography is not morally permissible because it can effect the person involved in negative ways and is wrong to expose kids to such things as this at a young age. There

When Is It Ever Morally Permissible To Kill And Eat Animals?

1196 words - 5 pages Is it ever morally permissible for human beings to kill and eat animals? When is it ever morally permissible for human beings to kill and eat animals? This is a question in which its answers have been argued since the early period of stoic philosophy up to now with the “rights view.” Known philosophers, Tom Regan and Epictetus use two different moral theories to defend what is morally permissible. Tom Regan uses the “rights view” moral theory

'what Are The Possible Environmental Risks Of Growing Gm Crops? Is It Morally Permissible To Proceed With A Harmful Course Of Action If You Are Unsure Of The Consequences?

1280 words - 5 pages permissible to proceed with a harmful cause of action if we are unsure of the consequences? Genetic engineering is still in its relative infancy, and from the risks it is evident insufficient research has been carried out. The situation feels eerily like deja-vu, bringing back memories of the disastrous consequences chemicals such as DDT and thalidomide brought. For both, inadequate analysis was carried out to investigate the possible long-term

Is A Fetus A Person? Essay

1240 words - 5 pages no outside judgment. When deciding if abortion is morally permissible the strongest argument is that fetuses are innocent beings and killing an innocent being is morally impermissible. Any being descending from a human makes it a human, and therefore a fetus is human. As a society we see murder to be immoral especially of an innocent person. Pro-life supporters argue that abortion is equivalent murder because life starts at conception, making