Is It Possible To Define ‘Art’?

2136 words - 9 pages

The expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power.
The above quotation is the Oxford Dictionary’s definition of art. It is one of the many definitions and theories written in answer to the question “what is art?” However, that very question implies an inhibited and essentialist answer such as “Art is…” Throughout the centuries philosophers, critics and authors have attempted to edge us ever nearer to the evasive concept that is ‘art’. It is an incredibly difficult concept and practice to theorise and define, especially in the twentieth century, as it is the very essence of art, as with all creative practices, to constantly challenge what has gone before and its pre-conceived definitions. Leo Tolstoy states that:
In order correctly to define art, it is necessary, first of all, to cease to consider it as a means to pleasure and to consider it as one of the conditions of human life. Viewing it in this way we cannot fail to observe that art is one of the means of intercourse between man and man.
This is taken from his iconoclastic collection of essays and polemics on art called ‘What Is Art?’ In this impassioned and powerful work, Tolstoy criticised the elitist art society in the nineteenth century, and rejected the idea that the sole purpose of art should be the creation of something beautiful. This view alone goes against the vague definition of the Oxford Dictionary, and immediately we see the issues with defining art unfold. There are countless theories written by too many people for us to create one definition that is able to be applicable to all art, from all periods. However, many have tried, and this essay will focus on the main philosophies and theories regarding the definition of art, and their criticisms. By looking at the theories in approximately chronological order, we will hopefully be able to see how the definitions of art have changed and evolved over time and what these different theorists focus on. This essay will look at the writing of Clive Bell, George Dickie, Morris Weitz, Ludvig Wittgenstein, Arthur Danto and Garry L. Hagberg.
Arthur Clive Howard Bell, commonly known as Clive Bell, was born in 1881 and died in 1964. He was an English art critic and theorist, and generally associated with the Bloomsbury Group and the concept of formalism in aesthetics. Formalism is, as a general rule, the belief that it is an object’s formal properties that make it ‘art’, or define what aesthetic experience the viewer will have. However, Bell took this to extremes by proposing that nothing other than the formal elements of an object have any relevance whatsoever in regard to its aesthetic value, or whether it is even a piece of art. Indeed he wrote in 1913: ‘To appreciate a work of art we need bring with us nothing but a sense of form...every other sort of representation is...

Find Another Essay On Is it possible to define ‘art’?

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1310 words - 6 pages determines how important it is, and who should be responsible for the decision in case things got out of control. Being a conflict between different opposing sides, and having serious harmful consequences, citizens shouldn’t start a revolution unless there is a necessary demand for change and reform. According to Thomas Jefferson, the third president of the United States, the author of Declaration of Independence, and the

Is It Possible To Be A Verbal Intelligent?

1004 words - 5 pages , such as word games, drawing pictures and writing a story about it, debate and group discussion, reading books and many other activities. Therefore, verbal intelligence is not inherited as what many people may think, but it is an acquired skill that a person can learn and increase. Inherited traits such as skin color, hair color, facial features and others are what can be called the inherited characteristics. People are born with the ability to

Photography: Is it Art?

2147 words - 9 pages What makes something art? This may be one of the greatest unanswered questions of all time. Of course, many people have tried to answer it in their own way. If it’s beautiful, it must be art. But is it still art if you don’t see any of the beauty it was meant to contain? If it was created from a purely original idea, it must be art. But then what is realism? The concept of art becomes much more vast and complicated once a person starts digging

Life without friendship? Is it Possible?

563 words - 2 pages Life is more rewarding with friendship. Every day is a chance to meet someone new. It does not matter if you're at school, work, or just out running around, people are everywhere. Whether you get along with them or not is your choice. In my experiences, I have found there are three different types of friends that help your life run more smoothly. Many of us meet a good number of friends though work. These would be what we call your “work

Discuss Whether it is Possible to Maintain the Neutrality of Humanitarian Aid

2785 words - 11 pages what an organisation declares publicly is its principled position, does not necessarily follow to be strictly the internal approach adopted in the field. The intention is not to deceive but to facilitate access and presence and define further the best modality of operations. Equally, perceptions could be out of the hands of the ones declaring it, ‘[c]laims of neutrality are one thing, but actually being neutral or being perceived as neutral is

Is It Possible For Human Beings to Detach Themselves from Capital?

778 words - 3 pages Is it possible for human beings to detach themselves from capital? There’s a lot of substance in this paper, not only does Dipesh do a great job of critiquing Marx he uses Marx against himself. Using deconstruction Dipesh is able to whittle down the arguments of Marx and redraw them where the humanity really stands inside capital. This essays intended audience is those interested in Marx, Marxist Thought, Marxist Theory, Economics, and

Sharia: Is it Possible to Transcend the Rules in Today’s Secular Society?

1111 words - 4 pages contrast greatly different than the government found in the Islamic nations. (U.S. Const. art. VI, cl. 3.) Essentially, to the United States government, Sharia law, like any law that’s not established nor in accordance with our Constitution, is a foreign law. Foreign laws are used in U.S. courts when appropriate; for matters such as foreign judgments, contracts and incidents that involve foreign governments or when parties involved request it

In what circumstances is it possible for a court to award exemplary damages in tort?

1421 words - 6 pages police.III. Category TwoCategory II exemplary damages are mainly sought in libel cases in Hong Kong. Since Broome v Cassell & Co Ltd it is well established that exemplary damages can be awarded in libel cases.Nevertheless, Broome specified that the mere fact that a libel is committed for business purpose is not enough. For exemplary damages to be granted, it is necessary to prove that (i) the defendant knew what he did was illegal or that he was

Making It Possible to End Homelessness

1110 words - 4 pages Making It Possible to End Homelessness (MIPH) is a subgrantee’s of the HPRP program, which was created to help families gain housing stability in Middlesex county. The program was awarded $1.4 billion to service clients threatened with evictions. The program’s intent is to reduce homelessness by keeping families stably housed, connecting with mainstream benefits, and working on a stabilization plan to avoid homelessness in the future. However

Is It Possible For God To Be All-good And All-powerful While There Is Evil In The World?

1235 words - 5 pages evil: Moral evils were discussed by Augustine and later adopted by Aquinas.(Stumpf , 1983). Evil, by Aquinas is not a thing, it is the absence of a the good. The same as for the blind the absence of sight. In this context the question is, why does God allows the evil to exist whether it exist per se or by the absence of good? Aquinas replies that the perfection of the universe required the existence of various kinds of beings, including bad as

Abortion: Is it Possible to be both Pro-life and Pro-Choice? Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan

1032 words - 4 pages In this paper, I will investigate the right to life for embryo based on Carl Sagan and Ann Druyan’s article “Abortion: Is it Possible to be both “Pro-life” and “Pro-Choice”?” My conclusion is an embryo is a potential person thus it has the right to life. Sagan and Druyan argue that embryo does not have human characteristics; therefore it is acceptable to abort it. I will show that embryo is at least a potential person, so it has the right to

Similar Essays

Is It Possible To Harmonise International Trade?

2546 words - 10 pages trade law is not possible due to dissimilar perspectives on fraud issues. It is argued that international trade law harmonisation is not possible because of diverse interpretations due to cultural differences. Chuah claims “different countries will apply the “harmonised” rules differently and this thus defeats the intended object” (2013, p. 20). Since each country involved in global trade vary in cultural practices, values, primary language, socio

Is It Possible To Speak Of An English Culture?

2167 words - 9 pages replied "Well, that's the same thing, isn't it?" and the discussion moved on. This leads into one of the more major problems in trying to define Englishness, as to a lot of people British/English has almost the same meaning. It is extremely difficult to pinpoint English nationalism mainly as the English seem rather unsure as to exactly who they are in the first place. Nationalism is perhaps best described as a person's feeling of attachment, loyalty

Is It Possible To Travel At The Speed Of Light?

3982 words - 16 pages Ever since 1966, when the first episode of Star Trek aired, there has been a question lingering in the mind of humans; fans, children, and scientists alike. To some, it is just wishful fantasizing, but to others, it is a goal to pursue and an idea that may not be so far-fetched -- Is it possible for humans to travel at the speed of light? If so, why should humans attempt this and will they? If not, what are some of the limitations of travel at

Testable Question Is It Possible To Observe Diffusion Across A

512 words - 2 pages Testable Question Is it possible to observe diffusion across a semi-permeable membrane? Background Research Diffusion is the movement of molecules from an area of higher concentration to that of a lower concentration. Once the particles have reached equilibrium, there is no longer any net movement because a gradient no longer exists. It is the result of the random movement of molecules or Brownian Movement. •1 Dialysis is a separation