This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is It Wholly Fair To Brand Durkheim As An Advocate Of An Elitist System? Sutd Essay

1409 words - 6 pages

Theorising Society, the Self, and Culture
Question 4: “It not only supposes that individuals are not consigned forcibly to performing certain determined functions, but also that no obstacle whatsoever prevents them from occupying within the ranks of society a position commensurate to their abilities. In short, labour only divides up spontaneously if society is constituted in such a way that social inequalities express precisely natural inequalities.” (1893/1997, p. 313) Is it wholly fair to brand Durkheim as an advocate of an elitist system?
The entire objective of Durkheim’s pursuit, is solidarity. The unification of society, be it through a collective consciousness or interdependence. He insists though, on moving towards the latter, but it is hard to come by one whose size does not exceed its responsibilities, in today’s context that is. Through the division of the available roles required for the society to function, the individuals would be forced to rely on one another to go in with life. It may sound forced, but this encourages bonding and it helps the society grow. In the days of Durkheim however, there existed these societies whose people were contended with doing the same as one another. To solve this problem of unequal roles and people in the modern world, there came about specialization, the creation of new roles to fulfill. With specialization though, a new problem of hierarchy arose and elitism was brought to light.
What is elitism? Elitism simply refers to the belief that there exists a superior and an inferior and the power is concentrated within the former. The individuals in the former group are filtered out from the masses through their traits and capabilities, that is meritocracy. This process of division of labour “allows the potentially qualified and deserving individuals and equal and fair chance of achieving success on their own merit” (Tan, 2008, pg. 8). Due to the numerous amount of roles, this system of categorization cannot arise naturally and the duty of preserving social order between the different classes of merit is taken upon by as Durkheim mentions, “That organ is the state or government” (1893, pg. 280). However, there is this negative connotation that lingers around the word elitism. Considering that people are given the chance to prove their merit, and hence move up the social ladder, it seems like it is a fair concept of distribution.
He believes that as long as there is no constraint, that is, as long as the individual is given a chance to fight for a place in society, the system is fair to all. What meritocracy fails to see is that there might be inherent advantages or disadvantages that are scattered unequally among the society. This means that the “natural inequalities” (Durkheim, 1893, pg. 313) are not considered when allocating the various roles available. Whether it is because of natural gift or special training that that individual could attain through means unavailable to others, some people are...

Find Another Essay On Is it wholly fair to brand Durkheim as an advocate of an elitist system? - SUTD - Essay

Is It Possible To Have An Inclusive Society? - Essay

1518 words - 7 pages created to equalise the opportunities in education and health for Aboriginals and Torrens Strait Islanders, but Australia isn?t finished. It will take time for Australia to fix the harm caused by our ancestors, but we are making progress to become an inclusive society. As everyone knows, education is significantly important in ensuring people are able to have a happy and successful future. Unfortunately, European education has failed our

Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country

1751 words - 7 pages Global Economic Freedom is an issue that we as conscious business people should be aware of. It is not enough just to know the rules and laws that govern the economic system in one's own country. With the continued expansion in global business it is almost certain that a business dealing with foreign countries will need to have a general idea about the foreign countries economic system and the general rules and laws that govern that economic

This essay is an analysis of the genre of british social problem films, it uses the text 'Sapphirre' as an example

1838 words - 7 pages service. Suddenly there was something that separated father and son and gave birth to a new class divide of sorts. Literally thousands of adolescents were now out working for real money and earning lots of it. No longer required to conform to the infrastructure of society as their parents and elder siblings had known it. They enjoyed an affluence previously unheard of among their peers. "The Sunday graphic in 1960 found a boy who could hang &pound

Is it possible to speak of an English Culture?

2167 words - 9 pages female. An image such as this is chosen for a reason rather than originating from any factual basis. It is a particular point of view, the dominant ideology of the ruling class. So in light of this the question to be asked is why do people who are not part of the dominant class take on these notions and feel proud to be English, especially when it is unlikely that they will ever become the person represented by the dominant ideology? The answer

An Investigation on the Importance of Brand Names to Consumers

2274 words - 9 pages brand names are important to consumers? Aims & Objectives. The main objective of the proposal is to examine why brand names are important to consumers which could also consist of what branding is and how important it is to consumers in everyday life. Hypothesis My hypotheses are as follows: The higher the satisfaction with one brand name, the more the customer will trust the brand name. The brand name

Challenges of Being an Advocate and Neutral Facilitator (Mediation)

809 words - 3 pages include the possibility of providing ancillary support to the veteran; however, it is a fine line to cross. As the advocate for homeless veterans the first priority is to ensuring the veteran is clean and sober and provide support if not.As the advocate of veterans in this situation, I would focus my efforts toward working amicably with the VA system to make the situation as tolerable for the veterans as possible and to help the veterans keep a

Macbeth - it is unusual to find a character in drama who is wholly evil

981 words - 4 pages a dreadful crime, and Lady Macbeth was driven to the point of suicide because of her immoral sins. Conscience is what gave them moral sense; it is because of this that we can say that they are not 'wholly evil'.A destitute, starving man may steal food out of sheer desperation, even if aware that the penalty for stealing is death. If the man is caught, this desperation could lead him to murder the person who caught him, so that he won't be

Is Our Justice System Fair to All?

1688 words - 7 pages Zimmerman's version of the story. Yet, the jury managed to set him free with 0 consequences. Was justice really served in the State of Florida vs. George Zimmerman case and is our justice system fair to all races? It was the first of August, 2010, when an African-American woman from Jacksonville, Florida, Marissa Alexander, was sentenced to 20 years for firing a warning shot in an effort to scare off her abusive husband. Alexander also tried to use

This is an essay about "12 Angry Men", by Reginald Rose. It describes juror 6 and the cons of the Jury System

942 words - 4 pages Juror 6:In the story "12 angry Men", by Reginald Rose, juror six is described as an honest but slow man, one who finds it difficult to create a positive opinion, and is often listening and slowly trying to understand the opinions of others, rather then forming his own. In the text of the play, we can find examples of many of these characteristics of juror six and even more that were not given to us by the author.The first, and most obvious

This is an essay on drugs and the legalization of them. It was turned in and convinced many of those to whom I had presented it to

1228 words - 5 pages another impediment would be the theory that, the legalization would decrease price and increase availability;... I beg to differ.It is scientifically proven that the thing that makes drugs so enticing is the fact that it is not allowed; human nature is to want to break the rules for the adrenalin rush of having the chance of getting "caught"; there would no longer be a spice to the act of smoking a little bit of marijuana. Sin: committing an act which

Shooting an Imperialistic Elephant This is an article critique of George Orwell's Shooting an Elephant. It was submitted as an assignment for a course in English Writing

1113 words - 4 pages narrator says. He loads the cartridges into the gun and pulls the trigger. The narrator shoots again and again. But eventually departs in agony as the elephant continues to gasp painfully. Going back to symbolism, it takes great might to kill one's conscience and even after accomplishing so, it becomes painful to live without its guidance. "Shooting an Elephant" is so much more than an account of mundane activities. It is Orwell's honest outlook on power, society and his shrewd conclusion that imperialism is a double edged sword that slays both the conqueror and the conquered. Written in UK English 1

Similar Essays

"What Is Democracy" This Is An Essay Written About Democracy. It A Reaction Of An Average Person As To What Democracy Means To Them. This Is Not A Step By Step Definition Of The Political System

1354 words - 5 pages The claims of superiority, often evident in the attitudes and actions of the west, is based on their acceptance of democracy and the ideals which it suggests. Democracy is the fundamental basis that western countries use to claim themselves superior to other countries in the world. Western countries believe that democracy is the only fair form of government and are often critical of countries that have different forms of government. One of the

It Can Be Argued That Australia Is Not An Egalitarian Society Because Of The Fact That It Does Not Provide A Fair Go To Everyone. This Essay Talks About Inequality In Australia

578 words - 2 pages It can be argued that Australia is not an egalitarian society because of the fact that it does not provide a fair go to everyone. The famous fair go idea is nothing but your average democracies responsibilities and this does not even apply to all. Examples of inequality and injustice are shown in Australia's past to non Anglo Saxon citizens, towards asylum seekers and homosexuals.The White Australian policy is a reflection of how the Australian

Challenges Of Being An Advocate And Mediator

840 words - 3 pages , nourishment, and support. This aid might include the possibility of providing ancillary aid to the families as well, but it is a fine line to cross.As the advocate of a homeless child the first priority is getting the support for that child, and it may include stretching the arm of responsibility to be the person to figure out how the parents, siblings, or other extended family members will eat or where they will sleep in any given night. "These

Campaign Finance Reform An Overview And Critique Of Campaign Finiance As It Stands And Suggestions To Improve The System

894 words - 4 pages As it stands, campaign finance is moderately regulated, yet these regulations are rife with loopholes that allow anyone with sufficient know how and resources to unfairly influence an election. I use the word influence because, quite simply, money talks. I believe that current regulations are inadequate; in the 2004 election alone, over a billion dollars was squandered by the combined efforts of John Kerry and George Bush despite the existence