This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Jay Gatsby In F. Scott Fitzgerald´S The Great Gatsby, A Good Man?

979 words - 4 pages

To decide whether Jay Gatsby is a good man or not, one must define what a ‘good man’ really is. Although it is an extremely vague and layered term, a ‘good man’ best fits the description of a man whose intentions are never meant to harm anyone. In addition, readers must remember that the Gatsby in the novel is Nick Carraway’s version, and that is a very biased version. Yet, based off of the events depicted in The Great Gatsby, I believe that Jay Gatsby is a good man.
Gatsby is not formally introduced until chapter three, and due to his initial description, readers hold him in much higher regard than other characters in the novel. Nick introduces Gatsby in an extremely intriguing and flattering manner, saying, “He smiled understandingly – much more than understandingly. It was one of those rare smiles with a quality of eternal reassurance in it, that you seemed to come across four or five times in life” (Fitzgerald 48). Gatsby’s introduction is completely opposite of Tom Buchanan’s, in which Nick uses words like “physical” and “powerful” to illustrate Tom as a stereotypical dumb jock and bully (6). Yet, despite the biases created within readers by Nick from the beginning of the novel, Gatsby does not purposefully harm anyone, as far as the reader knows, which leads me to believe that he is a ‘good man’.
One may argue that Jay Gatsby is not a ‘good man’ by discussing his illegal profession of bootlegging. This argument is flawed though, because Gatsby began bootlegging for Meyer Wolfsheim after World War One, and as a poor and starving veteran, was offered a free lunch and a job. Any man who is living the poor conditions that Gatsby was at the time would likely never decline a job offer, especially if it was a morally sound one. Yet, one could also argue that Jay Gatsby is not a ‘good man’ due to his numerous lies in the novel. Unfortunately though, it is part of human nature to lie, and all of Gatsby’s lies, like his own name, mean no harm to anyone as far as readers know. Gatsby is very carefully spoken, and is seen as more of a liar than he really is due to the assumptions made by others resulting from his careful language.
Regardless of how one would go about arguing how Jay Gatsby is not a ‘good man’, he is undeniably an embodiment of the American dream. Born James Gatz to two poor farmers in the Midwest, Gatsby’s “imaginations had never really accepted them as his parents at all. The truth was that Jay Gatsby … sprang from his Platonic conception of himself. He was a son of God … to this conception he was faithful to the end” (98). The notion of the self-made man alone is something that is honored within American society, and therefore, Jay Gatsby is an honorable person. Parallel to Benjamin Franklin,...

Find Another Essay On Is Jay Gatsby in F. Scott Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby, a Good Man?

The Prohibition, a Theme in F. Scott´s Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby

1370 words - 6 pages In the 1920s, prohibition, the ban on alcohol is in full force in order to better society, alcohol was seen as the corrupter of people’s judgement. Ironically prohibition caused society to decay, despite the many boons happening at the time. Beneath the seemingly prosperous country lies corruption, inequality, and despair. The corruption is so obvious, that author F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote a book on this subject called The Great Gatsby. His

Façade and Lies: A Theme in F. Scott Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby

1016 words - 5 pages tiniest bit and we can see it. In deduction, the book shows how putting up a façade can affect the rest of your paths in life. Whether it is fashioning a new person like Gatsby did or not acknowledging who you are like Nick does. Works Cited The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

F. Scott Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby in a Different Light

697 words - 3 pages The Great Gatsby written by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a fictional novel that concerns the young and mysterious wealthy Jay Gatsby and his obsession with Mrs. Daisy Buchanan. Color is used in throughout The Great Gatsby to better illustrate the authors underlying meanings of richness, facade, and hope. Gold symbolizes success and richness and adds a sense of value to anything wearing it. When Gatsby invites Nick to the party at his

The Ambiguous Gatsby in F. Scott Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby

955 words - 4 pages Qualities like absolute moral perfection are even less attainable than world peace, and they have no place in quality literature. No one relates to the main character that never lets his emotions get the better of him once in a while. Truly powerful characters require at least some degree of moral ambiguity. Jay Gatsby in F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby engages in illegal liquor sales and business with the man who rigged the World Series

Mr. Gatz vs. Mr. Gatsby in F. Scott Fitzgerald´s The Great Gatsby

785 words - 4 pages The Great Gatsby is a novel by Scott Fitzgerald about the protagonist, Gatsby, luring daisy back into his life. This is all through the perspective of Nick, who is the cousin of daisy. Jay Gatsby and James Gatz are the same person labeled with different names in different points in time, but was their name the only thing the differentiated the two? James Gatz was raised by his parents who were poor farmers who were all too aware of the harsh

Comparing Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby of The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1449 words - 6 pages “Two sides of the same coin,” is a commonly heard English saying used to describe two items that seem very different from each other but in reality share a number of similarities. Scott Fitzgerald demonstrates this idea in his novel, The Great Gatsby, when he introduces the characters Tom Buchanan and Jay Gatsby. At first glance, both characters may seem like polar opposites. However, with a closer analysis, one can see that they are more alike

The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1240 words - 5 pages the book The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald, the narrator, Nick Carraway, believes Gatsby to be a great person with a “gorgeous” personality. It is Nick’s perceptions of Gatsby that encourage the reader to also find him “great.” Gatsby, through his actions, his dreams, and his heart, distinguishes himself from the “foul dust” and makes himself “worth the whole damn bunch put together.” Gatsby creates an illusion for others, as he manages to

The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1441 words - 6 pages Since the beginning of time, man has written himself into history. Whether it was on cave walls, or in scripts, men have wanted to leave behind a legacy. One of the most well known men is author F. Scott Fitzgerald. Fitzgerald had always wanted to write the greatest American novel- and so he created the Great Gatsby. Although it is not the greatest American novel, it is studied by high schools and has several movie adaptions. However, he had to

The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1156 words - 5 pages age, also called the roaring 20’s was a time of economic prosperity, constant partying and overall optimism and happiness. What F. Scott Fitzgerald does in his novel is express the part of the jazz age that nobody talks about, which is the large focus on wealth, materialistic tendencies, and looming sense of superiority. The Great Gatsby consists of many symbols. The first of these symbols is the Green light at the end of the dock that Gatsby can

The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1603 words - 7 pages , in curiosity, search the party for the mysterious Jay Gatsby. They finally give up searching around midnight and goes outside, where they sit down at a table with a handsome man, who introduces himself as Jay Gatsby. Nick becomes very intrigued with Gatsby. After Gatsby leaves, a butler comes to tell Jordan that Gatsby wants to talk with her. Nick waits for hours, for Jordan’s return, and when she finally reappears, she is excited and says she

"The Great Gatsby" by F. Scott Fitzgerald

1505 words - 6 pages The American Dream can be defined as the freedom to pursue one's goals and desires, the opportunity to overcome socio-economic barriers that previously held one in place. The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald portrays the idea that the American Dream is just an illusion which dances on the waves of opportunity in America but never quite makes it ashore. Fitzgerald salutes the American Dream but warns against the dangers of living to fervently

Similar Essays

Jay Gatsby´S Outlook On Life In F. Scott Fitzgerald´S The Great Gatsby

833 words - 4 pages With regards to human nature during the Jazz Age during which he wrote, F. Scott Fitzgerald, author of The Great Gatsby, would most likely agree with the general philosophy of Jean-Jacques Rousseau on human psychology. In a nutshell, the view of Rousseau was simply that man is naturally pure and free, only to be corrupted by society and the outside world. In connecting Fitzgerald’s use of appropriate color symbolism to the two parts of

Unhealthy Pursuits In F. Scott Fitzgerald´S The Great Gatsby

741 words - 3 pages Literature has been portraying the idea of the American dream in many different stories throughout all of history. This dream can be defined as someone rising from the bottom and finding wealth and love in their everyday life. In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby, the storyline illustrates the life of several characters pursuing the American dream in New York City. The characters are all by intrigued Jay Gatsby, the man who lives across

Mansion Symbolism In F. Scott Fitzgerald´S The Great Gatsby

1526 words - 7 pages In The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, there are many symbols that not only shows the greed and simple mindedness of the time, but also provide great clairvoyance into not only the story, but the character themselves. Jay Gatsby’s mansion is a superb example of this and is relatable to almost every part of the novel; it symbolizes the essence of the American Dream, being that from such a small start, Gatsby is able to have such a

Blindness In F. Scott Fitzgerald´S The Great Gatsby

838 words - 4 pages In a famous poem by Thomas Gray the well known phrase “Ignorance is bliss, ‘tis folly to be wise” was used to describe the happiness the Author found in not knowing real consequences. This is similar to the Characters of The Great Gatsby, the great american novel written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, who have more money than they can spend and feel as if they are exempt to the lawand can buy their way out of any situation. What they are also unaware