Is Legalization A Realistic Alternative To The War On Drugs?

4811 words - 19 pages

For years, the issue of legalization has been an increasingly controversial subject. Millions of dollars are spent annually in the War on Drugs causing many to wonder if this fight is cost-effective or if an alternative such as legalization would be more realistic than current efforts in drug prevention. Opponents' state that with legalization would come an increase not only in availability, but also with everything associated with that availability. This includes suffering of users and their loved ones, death of users and innocent alike, increases in health-care costs, cost to employers, drug-related crimes, and increases in various other social, economic, and emotional costs. On the other hand, advocates argue it is pointless to continue to ignore the presence of drugs in society. They feel society must acknowledge the now-illegal narcotics as it has with alcohol and tobacco. Legalization would result in purity assurance, labeled concentration of the product, obliteration of pushers, obliteration of drug crime, savings in expensive enforcement, and significant tax revenues. Both sides of the controversy are confident with the credibility and effectiveness of their respective arguments, making it necessary for society to ask itself whether legalization of narcotics is a realistic alternative to current prohibition and the war on drugs or if legalization would result in more negative consequences than positive.The United States government's current position on narcotics is prohibition. The cornerstone of drug prohibition in America came with the Harrison Narcotic Act of 1914. The Harrison Act restricted the use of opiates, such as morphine, heroin, and cocaine, to medicinal purposes. Strong evidence suggests that the law was instituted in order to prevent casual or non-medical users, frequently called "dope fiends" from obtaining the drugs outside of medical practice. The American experience with drugs at the end of the 19th century demonstrated the serious problems that can be caused by the general use of a wide range of legally available drugs. These problems were judged unacceptable by Americans of that day. Prohibition was the result of nonpartisan public outcry over the negative effects of unrestricted drug use. (Trebach 41-44)The most important question in regards to legalization is how it would affect use and abuse in this country. Advocates of legalization such as Steven Duke and Albert Gross argue that those who do not use under prohibition will not use under legalization. Duke is a law professor at Yale University, and Gross is a lawyer from San Diego, California. They are greatly respected advocates for legalization, their greatest fame stemming from their co-authored book, America's Longest War. The key argument made by advocates Duke and Gross is that "the major reasons why people desist from smoking and drinking - health, social stigma, morality, aesthetics - are also applicable to the drugs currently labeled 'illegal'" (120)....

Find Another Essay On Is Legalization a Realistic Alternative to the War on Drugs?

The War on Drugs Essay

1524 words - 6 pages . Crime prevention methods may not be immediate, but it is the most efficient and effective long-term. Not only is the war on drugs costly, it is also ineffective at reducing or eliminating trade and usage. The “War on Drugs” campaign has been unsuccessful in preventing the illegal drug trade. As a result, the campaign has managed to marginalize and impoverish the participating societies, causing social and economic harm. By pointing out the

The War on Drugs Essay

1794 words - 7 pages by scholars on the issue.      My preconceived expectations prior to conducting this research was that the “war on drugs” is not effective because looking at my neighborhoods, I have seen a lot of drug dealers and users get arrested but there are still more on the streets. Also the punishments imposed are cruel which lead to me to think about how minority get sentenced when it come to drug arrest. And looking on the nature

The War on Drugs

2969 words - 12 pages only way you can help yourself get better is by wanting to get better. If you are an addict if a drug and say your parents find out about it, the first thing they do it put you in rehab. And the first thing you want to do when you get out of rehab is to do exactly what you were doing when your parents found out, getting high. You yourself have to make an effort, or no good will come.The war on drugs is growing, and something incredible has to be

This is an essay on drugs and the legalization of them. It was turned in and convinced many of those to whom I had presented it to.

1228 words - 5 pages another impediment would be the theory that, the legalization would decrease price and increase availability;... I beg to differ.It is scientifically proven that the thing that makes drugs so enticing is the fact that it is not allowed; human nature is to want to break the rules for the adrenalin rush of having the chance of getting "caught"; there would no longer be a spice to the act of smoking a little bit of marijuana. Sin: committing an act which

Education is the Best Weapon in the War on Drugs

2639 words - 11 pages Education is the Best Weapon in the War on Drugs It seems that in the ongoing debate over whether to legalize drugs in the United States, quite a few people feel that legalization would diminish the crime rate. Their argument points out that the permissible use of marijuana would eliminate the necessity for people to go into hard drug territories to purchase such a drug and maybe

“The Wild Iris is a Poem That is Realistic to All Humans” Discuss

529 words - 2 pages "The Wild iris is a poem that is realistic to all humans" DiscussMany poems explore issues that are relevant to life and our world. "The Wild Iris" by Louis Gluck looks at how life becomes sad when human suffering becomes unbearable. It also examines the significance of expressing one's thoughts, communication and finding confidence to do so.The poem compares human suffering to the growth of the wild iris or any plant or flower. A plant

The Legalization of Drugs and The Consequences on Society

2243 words - 9 pages has been made, which has been highly followed in some cases, that the use and distribution of illegal drug type substances should be legalized. The legalization of drugs, in various forms, is something that a large part of society do not have a problem supporting. The facts are that a large part of society use drugs on a fairly steady bases and that legalizing some forms of drugs could be beneficial to those individuals. The individuals that use

Stop the War on Drugs

1972 words - 8 pages segregated schools. The social movement already exists. There are many websites and groups advocating for the legalization of drugs. We must inform the public of the many negative effects this drug prohibition has caused. You have to be realistic when it comes to the ending of the War on Drugs. There are two ways to resolve conflict: one party can surrender unconditionally or a negotiator can bring a compromise between the two parties (Sidi,Ram). There

War on Drugs: Germany compared to the Netherlands

955 words - 4 pages The War on Drugs One of the key aspects to consider when evaluating domestic political actors preferences towards policies pertaining to illegal drug use in both the Netherlands and Germany is to evaluate their ideological differences. The Netherlands attitude towards drug policy revolves around limiting the negative impacts illegal drug use has on society by implementing laws catered towards decriminalization. On the other hand, Germany

There is No Alternative to War

1018 words - 4 pages There is No Alternative to War There is an average of twenty ongoing wars in the world at any given time. Some are internal civil wars, others are between nations. But the purpose of this thesis is not to report warfare, but the act of it. This includes the evolution of conventional and nuclear warfare, the potential effect of a nuclear war and why it is necessary for nations to fight war. This analysis will be based on a study of Gwyn

The Failed War on Drugs

1342 words - 6 pages the ever increasing costs involved in a war that simply cannot be won in the traditional sense. While it is true that the War on Drugs as a policy is fundamentally broken, there is currently a trend towards new types of policies which could offer more effective solutions. The War on Drugs has created more problems than it has solved. While effectively filling our prisons over capacity, it does nothing to address the source of the problem leaving

Similar Essays

The War On Drugs Is A War On The Poor

1252 words - 5 pages      The “War on Drugs" has been so terribly ineffective that it leads one to question its true motives. Even a dog can eventually learn from an electric fence, so why not the United States government? Is the goal really to curtail drug use, or is it to segregate society and vilify the disadvantaged? A combination of mandatory minimum sentencing and other unjust laws has led to an enormous rise in U.S. prison populations. Thanks to these

America’s War On Drugs Vs. Legalization

3570 words - 14 pages motivation but further studies are necessary to more clearly understand the severity of these consequences. Furthermore, proponents of the legalization of drug argue, current drug law enforcement is costly and ineffective. To begin with, law enforcement officials are spending a lot of tax money on the crusade against drugs. The current drug war costs 9 billion dollars on a federal level and 18 billion dollars on state and local levels

The War On Drugs Essay

3377 words - 14 pages struggled endlessly with this drug, its illegal usage, and decriminalization is Jamaica. Using Jamaica as a model for the more in-depth study of “the war against drugs” proves to be most interesting in that Jamaica has had a long and economically fluctuating history with marijuana. Henceforth, to lead us into the study of Jamaica and its legalization and decimalization of marijuana that can be used on both a large and small scale we turn to a

The War On Drugs Essay

581 words - 2 pages this war be won when the government has to spend so much money combating in opposition to it?? On top of the ridiculous cost of all the factors of the war, the availability of the illegal drugs complicates things even more. It is horrible news to hear or know that an eighth grade student can readily get a hold of drugs just as easy as a dealer. An eighth grader has the ability to obtain heroin or cocaine as effortless as he or she could