This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Nietzsche's View Of Morality Better For Us Than Kant's?

935 words - 4 pages

In the book "On the Genealogy of Morals," the philosopher, Friedrich Nietzsche presents an argument as to a view of his opinion on morality. Nietzsche states that he enjoys bringing pain and suffering to others. Nietzsche states that the origins of guilt and consciousness come from the "creditors" and "debtors." Nietzsche also debates that the more powerful a community becomes, the less they need to punish criminals. On the other hand, in the book "Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals," by Immanuel Kant, he states that being good should be the purpose of life. Kant says that if one is happy, he is more likely to fulfill his duty, which is to do good deeds. Kant's view of morality is better for us than Nietzsche's argument.Nietzsche remarks "To the extent that to make suffer was in the highest degree pleasurable, to the extent that the injured party exchanged for the loss he had sustained including the displeasure caused by loss, an extraordinary counterbalancing pleasure: that of making suffer - a genuine festival..." (Nietzsche, 65). Nietzsche says that making others suffer was considered a great joy; he calls it a "festival," that would balance out an unpaid debt. We find the origins of conscience, guilt, and duty in the festiveness of cruelty. To Nietzsche, people were punished simply because it was fun to punish people. If you fail to keep your promise to me, at least I get the pleasure of beating you up. This is the original association of "guilt" with "debt," to Nietzsche. Guilt was a debt to be paid: if you make a promise, you are in debt to me. If you fail to keep your promise, you must pay off the debt in some other way. If that "other way" is pouching you, there are no hard feelings afterward, there is simply an agreement that now our debts are settled and we can go our different ways.Nietzsche states that the origins of guilt and consciousness come from the "creditors" and "debtors" which is like the relationship between buyer and seller. This relationship exists also between people and the community they live in. The community provides shelter, peace, security, and much else besides, placing people in its debt. People who break the laws of their community are not only repaying the debt, but they are assaulting their creditor. But, these offenders face the harshest of punishments.Nietzsche also observes that the more powerful the community becomes, the less it needs to punish offenders. If the community is weak, any attack against it is life threatening, and such a threat must be eliminated. A community that is strong enough to resist all sorts of assaults has the luxury...

Find Another Essay On Is Nietzsche's view of morality better for us than Kant's?

My God Is Better Than Yours: The Hypocrisy of Religion

935 words - 4 pages teach us forgiveness and understanding, but for some reason many have taken on Saint Peter’s job themselves, as though their religion endows them with the divine right to pass judgment upon others. Many do not stop to consider another’s situation or perspective until faced with a similar predicament, as in the case of Hannah, who prior to her chroming never could justify taking another life, or any other crime for that matter. It is until one is

Snowboarding Is Better Than Skiing Essay

831 words - 3 pages snowboard is a more natural position than that of a pair of skis. The sport is also a good exercise, it works out the lower part of the body strenuously as well as a majority of the upper body. Playing hard and long helps your body in weight loss. Every year more and more people are trading in their two planks for a nasty snowboard setup. Snowboarding is much easier on the knees then skiing, years of skiing can have its toll on the delicate parts

What are the consequences of Nietzsche's discussion of religion on his understanding of morality?

831 words - 3 pages Christian.Underlying these sections of the book is an idea about "master morality" and "slave morality", where those who were healthy, strong and free were "good" and the weak and poor were seen as "bad". This idea was reversed when those less well off came to see those in higher positions as "evil". Nietzsche believes that religion has taught us to be content in weakness rather than try to become strong. It seems that Nietzsche is also suggesting that those

Smarter than You Think: How Technology Is Changing Our Minds for the Better by Clive Thompson

782 words - 4 pages People all around agree that technology is changing how we think, but is it changing us for the better? Clive Thompson definitely thinks so and this book is his collection of why that is. As an avid fiction reader I wasn’t sure this book would captivate me, but the 352 pages seemingly flew past me. The book is a whirlwind of interesting ideas, captivating people, and fascinating thoughts on how technology is changing how we work and think

“The country is better than the city for bringing up children,”

703 words - 3 pages Stereotypes exist everywhere in our world whether we wish it or not. They show biases that are personally or culturally held. Stereotypes are based on false assumptions. One stereotype, “The country is better than the city for bringing up children,” will be examined in this essay. Catch phrases, which stick in a person’s mind, are often employed. Such phrases as “Hometown USA” or “starting fresh” may be associated with this particular

Why the Flat Tax is Better for America Than the Income Tax

1576 words - 6 pages Did you know that 44 percent of the people in America do not pay any income taxes? This is approximately 66 million out of 151 million that now pay no income taxes. From 1950-1990, the percentage of people that owed no money for federal income taxes and paid no federal income taxes was 22 percent. This has now doubled and is putting our economy and country at its breaking point. Our current tax system penalizes those that work and save money

Why Reading Is Better Than Watching Television

602 words - 2 pages some people might be bored either one of them or both, but what it is true is that reading teach more than being watching television. Therefore, television may be not that good for me. I still consider television as a good media, which is important too for me and for most of the people. Today, television shows us news, reports, so this is the reason why this media is very important and is a good communication system. Reading

study group is better than study alone

740 words - 3 pages view. Study group are the perfect places to find new perspective. When we listen to others and ask question to them, we will start noticing there are wide variety of different viewpoints on the same idea or topic. By practicing this kind of learning, we are able to see something more broaden. Besides that, study in group can make we learn faster than studying alone. This is because our group members will always explain it back to us if something

Healthy Food is Better Than Junk Food

858 words - 3 pages craving and finally preference for eating. However, increasing obesity among teens, heart problems, eating disorders and new researches call for our attention. The paper discusses healthy and junk food choices, their impact on human body and mind in addition to some animal researches and concludes that healthy food is certainly better than junk food. Healthy food provides not only the right source of energy for everyday bodily functions but balanced

Is Private School better than Public School?

721 words - 3 pages on education, it will be easier in University as they prepare us with better work habits for University than public schools. The transition will be easier and it’ll most likely feel as if you’re attending another high school. Also, private schools have around 88% of students who apply for college or university verses private schools that have around 57%.1 Now, some people think private schools have more disadvantages than public schools and

Japan's Educaiton is Better than United States'

774 words - 4 pages Education is like climbing a mountain; the classes are the obstacles you will encounter during the climb and your career is the top of the mountain, in order to do this, you will need the right experience. However, other students might have more an experience in this field and will end up at the top quicker than you. In some countries, students receive a better education than others. Evidence has shown that Japan’s educational system is better

Similar Essays

Breast Milk Is Better Than Formula For Your Baby

568 words - 2 pages fed baby must work harder to get milk out of a breast than a baby out of a bottle. This also promotes good jaw development and strong oral muscles.There is no formula in the world that comes even close to being as perfectly suited for a baby than its mother's milk. Breast milk protects a baby against diseases, is better nutritionally and is convenient and healthier. It not only benefits the baby but benefits the mother and is a much better alternative to formula.

What Is The Connection Between Kant's View On Suicide And His Understanding Of The Moral Law?

871 words - 3 pages In his "Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals", Kant puts forward the view that suicide is inconsistent with the idea of humanity as an end in itself, and that ultimately suicide is morally wrong. According to Kant there is one Categorical Imperative, which should act as the supreme principle of morality. Kant highlights the categorical imperative in three different formulations, but emphasises the fact that these formulations essentially

My God Is Better Than Yours: The Hypocrisy Of Religion

1959 words - 8 pages forget to be good; we forget religion’s real message is simply an active call to be a better person. We may never agree to disagree when it comes to God, so the best anyone can do is attempt to define the kind of person they want to be. All God ever wanted was for us to be kind and good to one another. Simone, Hannah rescuer and brief lover, has a different perspective on God. When Hannah asks how she could possibly pray to God when he considers her

Sparta Is Better Than Athens Essay

777 words - 3 pages people. Democratic Athens did not provide the basic needs for its people. Athens focused on its arts and entertainment. Spartans oligarchy protected its people by centering their society on military. Sparta was better because it was stable and protected its people. To prove that Sparta was better than Athens this essay will discuss the conflicting focuses of each government and how Sparta met the needs of her people in a time period of war.The