Is Number Subjective? Essay

620 words - 2 pages

Is Number Subjective? In section twenty-two of The Foundations of Arithmetic, while in a discussion of whether or not number is a property of external things such as a pile of playing cards, Gottlob Frege writes "The Number 1, on the other hand, or 100 or any other Number, cannot be said to belong to the pile of playing cards in its own right, but at most to belong to it in view of the way in which we have chosen to regard it." Reading this passage alone, Frege may seem to be implying that number is something subjective, something that depends on a decision on our part. Yet in section forty-seven Frege writes "That a statement of number should express something factual independent of our way of regarding things can surprise only those who think a concept is something subjective like an idea. But this is a mistaken view." What is Frege's meaning in the first passage, since its apparent implications seem to be contrary to the passage in section forty-seven? With further investigation, it becomes apparent that he is not saying that statements of number are subjective, but that statements of number are really statements of concept, and therefore are objective. The way which we choose to regard it an object is another way of saying the objective concept which we choose to apply to an object, which may be subjective. But number is never subjective.In the first passage cited above, where Frege writes that the number that belongs to the pile of playing cards depends on "the way in which we have chosen to regard it," he is not claiming that the number belonging to the pile of playing cards is a subjective decision on our part. In fact, Frege insists repeatedly throughout the book that number is something objective. Rather, he is saying that the number...

Find Another Essay On Is Number Subjective?

The Scientific Account of Inductivism vs. Falsificationism: Is Science Objective?

1023 words - 4 pages The following essay aims to discuss whether science is objective or subjective in light of two competing theories: inductivism and falsificationism. Addressing the main quote, I will state how Popper would respond to two of Chalmers’ core ideas, before providing my own opinions and justification on the matter. Chalmers account of science is from an inductivist’s perspective. He believes that science is achieved through justifying universal

Managing Public Transport Using Customer Satisfaction Data

1110 words - 5 pages operationally) and Q2: In what way can measures/data on subjective experience contribute to transport policy making?A further discussion will be provided below. The Pros and Cons of Measuring Objective and Subjective Data Commence with the concept of service quality, satisfaction is an substantial idea which known as noted value to comply with customer expectation (Edvardsson 1998). Therefore, it is needed satisfaction measurement in perceiving

Definition of Impartial

832 words - 3 pages of conditional and prioritized values before venturing into this. Whilst one may argue that it is subjective, I think it can be rational. A tentative example might be as follows: a) The highest priority is survival of a species, with the individual’s survival subservient to that in cases where they might conflict. b) In order to ensure this priority, individuals should have access to the resources needed to sustain the greatest number of members

Adlerian theory of counselling

1694 words - 7 pages (Kazdin 2000). This essay will also look at the counselling techniques that can be used to understand and help the client, not only in terms of his or her entire context, but also in terms their subjective perspective of life. The Adlerian technique has application in contemporary counselling and the number of Adlerian training centres continue to grow.This paper will address a therapeutic approach known as the Adlerian technique named after its

Performance Appraisal. "Most Performance Appraisals are subjective"

2030 words - 8 pages The basis of the majority of performance appraisals within the modern workplace is one person (a supervisor or manager) rating another, an inherently subjective process. There are variations such as 360 degree appraisals that include the opinions of others such as customers and peers/colleagues in the process but it is the action of one person passing judgement upon another that is subjective in nature and the root cause of many of the problems

Performance Management Within the Workplace

2488 words - 10 pages another that is subjective in nature and the root cause of many of the problems encountered in the research associated with performance appraisals. Performance appraisals are of importance to the organisation, as they often provide the only measure of an individual's contribution and as such the means for identifying either over or under achievement. This information identifies strengths and weaknesses among employees

Pain: Understanding the Subjective, Objectively

1374 words - 5 pages subjective. What then, makes us resistant to the idea that pain is subjective? Part of the answer to this question lies in the fact that a good deal of pain has a concrete neurophysiological basis. Indeed, there are a number of scientific measures that can serve as clear indicators of the presence of conditions that are known to induce pain. Imaging studies that reveal tissue or nerve damage are an example of such indicators. Indeed, even less

Agent Alienation in Consequentialism

1633 words - 7 pages contribute to his or her happiness; it is concerned with the direct consequences of a certain action. Objective hedonism holds that an agent ought to act in accord with what will bring him or her the most pleasure; it is concerned with the long-term benefits or detriments of a particular action. So a sophisticated hedonist would be an actor who “aims to lead an objectively hedonistic life ... and yet is not committed to subjective hedonism”.7

Social Science

1648 words - 7 pages in their research, as well as personal feeling and subjective situations. From my point of view, the interpretive approach is trying to be “objective” by defining the experiment with more details. Although the research methods attempt to avoid the subjectivity of research, in my opinion, the subjectivity in conflict research cannot be eliminated totally. I have listed four factors which may affect the research’s objectivity. Researcher's own

Planning Methods Brief

1123 words - 4 pages . Finding Appropriate Data Though a high number of data sources are available to us, this does not resolve the obstacle in finding appropriate data to measure certain issues. Firstly, there is a lack of appropriate quantitative data to develop satisfactory and meaningful measures for subjective issues such as community identity, which is especially interesting in such newly formed spatial zones as Local Enterprise Partnerships. When analysing

Artificial Sentience

1067 words - 4 pages of inner, qualitative, subjective states and processes of sentience or awareness. Consciousness, so defined, begins when we wake in the morning from a dreamless sleep - and continues until we fall asleep again, die, go into a coma or otherwise become ”unconscious.” The difficulty with this definition with regards to the Turing computability of consciousness is that it defines the existence of a subjective state as a

Similar Essays

Does Personality Correlate With Subjective Well Being?

1566 words - 7 pages Most people agree that having an easy-going personality will contribute to the overall well-being of the individual. Certain personality traits have an effect on the individual well-being. Individuals showing improvements in those traits, over time, will often show comparable enhancement to their well-being. Subjective well-being refers to how an individual evaluates the quality of their life. In simple words, subjective well-being is how well

To What Extent Is Truth Different In Mathematics, The Arts, And Ethics?

1580 words - 6 pages unique in interpretation to every observer, truth in art is also distinct: it is found in the subjective emotional and critical response it evokes in its observation. For instance, everyone has a different view of a given work of art, as everyone’s emotional responses are distinctive and thus truth in art, the method of the artwork and its meaning, is unique to everyone. We must now turn to the nature of truth in ethics. Ethics is the examination

History And Memory Essay

4411 words - 18 pages completely subjective. It is apparent that each of the children wrote about what was important to them at the time. Adolf Hitler may have been executing thousands of Jews a block away, but Janine Phillips was more intent on writing about her sister’s movement from one concentration camp to another. It is a fact that one recalls experiences differently according to their current state of emotions and feelings. Hollidays’ book gives a number of different

Excuse U Essay

928 words - 4 pages ? This research will thus be guided by several questions: • Is the positive relationship between life satisfaction and volunteerism stronger in elderly women than in elderly men? • Does the positive relationship between life satisfaction and volunteerism in elderly women become stronger with age? • Does the positive relationship between life satisfaction and volunteerism in elderly women increase with the number of hours spent volunteering? If so