This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Plato Right To Think That The Best State Is One From Which All Conflict Is Banished? Political Theory Essay

1181 words - 5 pages

Is Plato right to think that the best state is one from which all conflict is banished?
One of Plato’s largest beliefs is that the city reflects its citizens. Echoing this way of thinking, it appears logical to discuss how we can create an ideal state by manipulating the way we treat others and our place in society. By reducing the level of conflict within ourselves and social structures, Plato states that the city as a whole stands to profit. However, as will be discussed, humans are disagreeing and inharmonious by nature, meaning this utopia is near impossible to implement.
To start with, it should be remembered that Plato was surrounded by conflict since his birth in 427 BC. The Peloponnesian War involving Athens, his birthplace, and Sparta was long and disastrous, not coming to an end until he was in his mid-twenties. It is, therefore, not hard to imagine why he was so occupied with producing an ideal state with little-to-no discord. However there are many different social classes and groups within any one society, each prioritising different values. Hence it is essential that the organisation of the state is the right one, as Plato remarks that civil war and conflict between these groups are the greatest threats to happiness. “The best is neither war nor faction - they are things we should pray to be spared from - but peace and mutual good will” (Plato, 2000, 628c). It should also be observed that whilst this agreement is of the utmost importance, it should not be obtained through hostile means such as the victory of a stronger side over a weaker one. Overall, there is peace in social diversity. All citizens benefit from each other and add to the common good, creating an order of harmony. Thus it is in our own self-interest to find a structure that promotes this, as according to Plato it is the ‘best state’. In his eyes, this system is that of a philosophical aristocracy or monarchy.
Take note that Plato was of the opinion that tension within society is natural, and therefore some conflict is inevitable. “However, he felt that if a proper balance of the parts could be obtained, social conflict would be at a minimum … [and that] each segment of society would work together in harmony” (Schellenberg, 1996, p. 89). In Plato’s ideal state, it is philosopher kings that mediate between the conflicts of the different classes. They are most suitable to regulate political order, resulting in the state achieving an ultimate form of happiness, due to an amiable, cordial, and cooperative union of different social classes. As Sipka (1969) states “strife is a sign of imperfection and unhappiness… Conflict is a threat to the success of the state and should be kept at an absolute minimum, and removed altogether if possible”. In the Platonic vision of the state, all social classes get to perform what they are best fit to do and are unified into a single community by mutual interests, overseen by a just ruler. In this sense, although each are different, they...

Find Another Essay On Is Plato right to think that the best state is one from which all conflict is banished? - Political Theory - Essay

Brave New World:Comparison between the world state and the savage reservation,and which one is more akin to our own

604 words - 2 pages fact that they are born to parents and die on their own, unlike the world state that cremates its citizens when they are too old to be of any use anymore. In the eyes of the world state's citizens, their world is perfect because they are forced to feel that way by hypnotism and by the fact that they don't know any other world. However, in the eyes of the savages, their world is better than the world state because they believe in the right of free will, and because it is human nature (which the world state's citizens are trained not to act upon) to want to be free, even if it may mean there's not enough security protecting them.

Policing Styles: Which do you think this is most effective? - Thomas Edison State University - Intro to Criminal Justice

571 words - 3 pages . The style is mostly found in larger cities with large population and an organized government. They prefer working on serious crimes. Crime fighter style focuses on the victim. They protect the community from murders and rapist. They tend to consider property crimes less important and would be better be handled by other agencies of the government (Marx, 1974). The most efficient of style policing is social agent style. It is concerned with

Descartes claims that his existence of a thinking thing is the one certain truth, which can serve as the foundation for all other knowledge

931 words - 4 pages Descartes claims that his existence of a thinking thing is the one certain truth, which can serve as the foundation for all other knowledge. With nothing more than just the knowledge that he is a thinking thing, Descartes goes on to further meditate on more monumental topics. Not only does this realization of his existence serve as the foundation for all other knowledge, it served as the starting point of a new era of modern western philosophy

This essay is about my personnal theory that all humans live a co-dependant life

736 words - 3 pages . Money is soon to become a priority and necessity, which if I don't have, will become the death of me. It's a never-ending trap. How can I get out of it? I can only think futuristically to when I'll retire. I'll no longer have worries or have to depend on anyone else for money since I'll have earned enough to accommodate myself.Obviously I'm wrong again, I'm now thinking of "the end"and I see that all I've done with my life is dress in diapers

Contrast the essential differences between the best-fit and the best-practices compensation model. Which do you think is more suitable for Egyptian organizations?

1017 words - 4 pages practices at all, but rather a way of thinking about the role of reward systems in a complex organization…it argues against an assumption that certain best practices must be incorporated into a company's approach to pay." Indeed, he contrasts the reward system for a traditional management style with one that fosters employee involvement. The correct fit for the former includes a reward system that is job-based with merit pay while for the

Do we perceive reality directly through our senses? is it possible the reality that we experience is different to the one in which we actually exist?

1113 words - 4 pages The Deception ofPerception.What we experience directly is a virtual- reality rendering, conveniently generated for us by our unconscious minds from sensory data plus complex inborn and acquired theories (i.e. programs) about how to interpret them.Deutsch, 1998, pp120How can we be sure that our perceptions of reality are consistent with the reality in which we exist? Is there a way to validate these perceptions? Could it be possible that we are

Discuss one disagreement or agreement between Plato and Aristotle. Who do you think is more consistent with Greek cultural tradition?

675 words - 3 pages everyday life. Once a prisoner is let outside, he is blinded by the light of the sun and when the eyes adjusted, they are able to see the actual reality. The prisoners were able to view the actual “perfect form” of the object. Unlike those who are not exposed to the shadows first, they are able to view only what the mind is able to grasp and led to believe that, that is the true form of things but it is not. All that one is actually seeing is

Neoliberalism: a social, political and economical concept that is based, among others, on classic liberalism and the neoclassical theory and its purpose is minimizing the influences of the state on...

3904 words - 16 pages Ordoliberalism is the german version of neoliberalism. Ordoliberalism is a school of liberalism that emphasises the need for the state to ensure that the free market produces results close to its theoretical potential. The theory was developed by German economists and legal scholars such as Walter Eucken, Franz B�hm, Hans Grossmann-Doerth and Leonhard Miksch from about 1930-1950. Alexander R�stow and Wilhelm R�pke (who spent the Nazi period in

BRITNEY SPEARS- This essay just explains why she is my idol and I give her the credit that no one else gives her. Us teens can all relate to brit's music and I made that clear in my essay

531 words - 2 pages her to sing about her personal accounts knowing that she has such a large audience. This shows that she cares about the people she affects; the quality of a true role model. Another instance where this aspect of Britney shines through is in her song, "My Only Wish This Year" from the album Platinum Christmas. In one part of the song, Britney says, "Last night I took a walk in the snow/Couples holding hands, places to go/Seems like everyone but me

Do all dualists believe that there is two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism – Cartesian dualism, parallelism, or epiphenomenalism – is the most plausible theory of...

1103 words - 4 pages plausible as a theory of mind due to the nature in which the causal relation from material to immaterial is essentially redundant.A varying view to Cartesian dualism and is very far from the belief of two-way causal interaction between mind and body says that there is basically no connection whatever between any mental phenomena and any physical phenomena. This view is called parallelism. It says that mental and physical worlds exist, in two

Adolph Hitler's death: I got a lower mark because he said I didn't include a thesis statement, but other than that the essay is all right

2447 words - 10 pages Goebbels intentions had been to die right after Hitler. Hitler's will and testament appointed him as chancellor, and insisted that he escape Berlin before the Russians inevitably reached the bunker. Joseph Goebbels added his own appendix to the will, stating:"For the first time in my life I must categorically refuse to comply with an order from the Führer. My wife and children are at one with me in this refusal... we prefer to bring to an end at

Similar Essays

Thoreau's Theory That It Is Best To Hire One Who Loves The Job Opposed To One Who Does Not

552 words - 2 pages that job which would cause problems. Thoreau's theory is selfish and causes harm to the society. One should think of others and his society before he thinks of his own personal needs.You need more than love for a job; you need talent. Thoreau's theory is illogical by saying all one needs is to absolutely love the job. For example, I adore football. I grew up in a neighborhood full of boys. I can tackle, catch, dodge and throw better than any girl

Economic Systems: Which One Is Best?

801 words - 4 pages end it is still mainly individuals who are in charge of the majority of businesses. Out of all of these types, although none are perfect, it appears that capitalism, more specifically, modified capitalism, is the best for the majority of society. It is more balanced than the other systems because it allows people to have control with help from the government that isn’t over-doing it. Communism and socialism may look good in theory, but when it

Applications Of Fertilisers: Which One Is The Best?

1250 words - 5 pages will stick to your hands but when it is dry it won’t. Here are the main minerals that clay contains: kaolinite, andalusite, kyanite and sillimanite, halloysite, gibbsite, diasporas, aluminum oxide, monotermit, montmorillonite, muscovite, nacrite, pyrophyllite.  Peaty- is hard to be mixed with water, but once it is done it would be a nice soil for the plant growth. It also has the acidic water which ‘fights’ with diseases in soil.  Loam- contains

We Are All One People. This Is An Essay About How It Doesn't Matter Who You Are Or What You Think You Are, That When Tragedy Happens We Are All The Same

601 words - 2 pages there had been a plane that had went into the Twin Towers in New York.We walked quietly out into the corridors where the hotel had put up one television hanging from the upper corner. There was such a silence over the room. People had started rushing around and calling their families. They wanted to let them know that they were all right due to the Southern Governor's Convention and the Vice President being at the airport that was very close to our