Is Psychotherapy More Effective When Therapist Disclose Information

1017 words - 4 pages

“ Is Psychotherapy More Effective When Therapist Disclose Information About Themselves? ”

In the world of psychology therapist raise a question whether or not they should “disclose personal information during psychotherapy. Several therapists “have suggested that therapist self-discloser can have a positive impact on treatment. From this view, self-discloser by the therapists may elicit greater discloser by the client enhancing the possibilities for client self-exploration”(e.g., Bugental, 1965, chap. 7; Jourad, 1971, chap. 17; Strassberg, Roback, D’Antonio & Gable, 1977). In addition, “self-discloser is thought to encourage an atmosphere of honesty and understanding between client and therapist, fostering a stronger and more effective therapeutic relationship”). However many other therapist disagrees with that statement. They reply “ psychodynamic theorist since Freud have generally regarded therapist self-disclosure as detrimental to treatment because it might interfere with the therapeutic process, shifting the focus of therapy away from the client”(e.g., see cutis, 1982b; Freud, 1912/1958; Greenson, 1967, chap. 3). In addition, it is argued that therapist self-discloser may adversely affect treatment outcome by exposing therapist weakness or vulnerabilities, thereby undermining client trust in the therapist”(e.g., see cutis, 1982b, 1981)

According to the journal “These differences in identifying therapist self-disclosures may be of importance in the evaluation of their impact on treatment. For example, theoretical concerns about therapist self-discloser have emphasized the risk of shifting the focus of therapy away from the client. However when therapist self-disclose, are in direct response to comparable client disclosers the presumed risk of alerting the focus of treatment is likely to reduced”.

The study: clients
There are a total of 36 clients that participated in the study, 15 being men and 21 being women. All of the clients requested therapy and also the clients are over the age of 18. “Exclude from the study were clients exhibiting sings of psychotic behavior, disoriented thinking, or neurological impairment”. The mean age of the clients is 27, the range 18-42. The client “presenting problem included issues such as depression, social or performance anxiety, relationship conflicts or lack of impulse control. None of the client where aware of the study.

The study: therapists
There were a total of 18 therapists that participated in the study 7 being men and 11 being women. The mean age of the therapist is 28.5, the range is 22 –42. All were doctoral students who had completed at least 2 years of clinical training (m= 3.6 years

,range 2-5 years). Before beginning the study, the therapist had conducted a mea of 1,319 hr of therapy (Mdn = 950 hr, range =400-5,000 hr).

The study is scheduled one therapist for every two client. The therapists are separated in three parts of self-discloser 1-none, 2-mild, and 3-extreme....

Find Another Essay On Is Psychotherapy More Effective When Therapist Disclose Information

Treatment is More Effective Than Jail for Drug Offenders

2418 words - 10 pages jail stints when he heard about the Salvation Army?s inpatient treatment program. He got accepted and has been clean about five months...Felder faces a three-year prison stint if he fails Drug Court. (Seven 2) Through these treatments the one addicted must realize that it is up to themselves and only themselves if they ever wish to move on with their lives. From here they can start to create a more promising life (a life where they have actual

Corrections: Rehabilitation Is More Effective Than Retribution vs

1550 words - 6 pages Today our criminal justice system has a multitude of options when dealing with those who are convicted of offenses; fines, probation, community service, short term sentences in jail or longer sentences in a variety of different level prisons and the ultimate punishment is still death. Our goals are clear and direct, stop the behavior, make restitution, teach new skills and for many rehabilitate through therapy, drug and/or alcohol

Position Paper: Niccolo Machiavelli - Is it more effective for a ruler to be feared or loved?

790 words - 3 pages . People will be much more willing to follow a leader who exemplifies modesty. If people criticize your approach often the best thing to do is not get involved in arguments. A good leader should intake the criticism and finds way to improve his ideals base on them. An effective leader should direct whilst maintaining a positive attitude, opposed to creating a climate of fear or competition. These traits epitomize a leader.This is why in today's

Bretton Woods vs. Protest – Which is More Effective in the Fight Against Global Injustice?

2563 words - 10 pages Bretton Woods vs. Protest – Which is More Effective in the Fight Against Global Injustice? The highlight of the anti-globalization movements came in 1999, when protesters lined the streets of Seattle, the location of a meeting of the World Trade Organization (WTO). A theme had been building, and it seemed to come to a head at Seattle: wherever the WTO, International Monetary Fund (IMF), or World Bank met, protesters would follow

Physical Attractiveness is More Important Than Any Other Factors When Looking for a Potential Date

5774 words - 23 pages Physical Attractiveness is More Important Than Any Other Factors When Looking for a Potential Date This experiment was conducted to test the experimental hypothesis; ‘Physical attractiveness is more important then any other factors when looking for a potential date’. The experiment investigated whether physical attractiveness really is the key factor, which determines a relationship or not i.e. if the individual is good

Who benefits and who loses when a common market for labour is extended to more countries

1948 words - 8 pages Who benefits and who loses when a common market for labour is extended to more countries? Explain your answer with reference to economic theory and to EU experience. Comment also on the future implications of the 2004 enlargement. Many people talk about the 'common market', by which they meant the European Economic Community in its early decades. Ths is a group of geographically close European nations among

When it is all said and done, the current criminal justice system is about as fair and effective as we can resonably expect

2326 words - 9 pages ability to the fullest tostop these offenders from re-offending within our community.The first argument in the weaknesses of the criminal justice system addresses the time an offenderspends in remand, in the wait of their trial date. The length remandees are spending in custody is far tooextensive, and more action needs to be done to trounce this problem within our system. When a personis placed in remand it is believed the main factors are; so

Education will be truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student

545 words - 2 pages will be really effective when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each students, because the aim of higher education lies in developing the personalities of students and encouraging them to innovate in various ways more than teaching them to simply hold similar and general knowledge frameworks. Only when the education respects the individualities and emphasizes the distinguishing ways to teach, would it become

Education will be truly effective only when it is specifically designed to meet the individual needs and interests of each student.

527 words - 2 pages learning. It is truly effective when the teaching method can attract every student's interests and feed each person's needs. How can a student learn more things more effectively via the way he don't like? For instance, a child will more quickly get to know the toy which attracts him most and find joy from it.However, in the real life, it is impossible to design a magic education to cover everyone's needs. Since each individual in the world is unique

Communication in Management: In The Workplace.What is communication? How can it be more effective? What types of communication exist? How can it be understood or misunderstood?

2376 words - 10 pages communication skills with his or her employees."Every time we open our mouths to speak, we are taking a leap of faith--faith that what we say will be understood by our listeners more or less as we mean it" (Tannen). When verbally communicating with an employee, a manager should always be clear and precise in relaying tasks and assignments, in giving guidelines, and in giving feedback on an employee's performance.To be effective in verbal

To what extent is integrated positron emission tomography/computer tomography (PET/CT) more effective than PET and CT alone in preoperative assess...

2024 words - 9 pages , some interpretive errors might occur. Finally, PET/CT scanner also has some limitations. This integrated machine is more complex than solid PET or CT and requires considerably higher dose of F-flourodeoxyglucose (FDG) in contrast to the quantity needed for CT imaging. Occasionally, when the CT-part of PET/CT scan analyzes the condition of patient’s lung cells, scanner interprets the FDG uptake as an abnormal and may give false-positive results

Similar Essays

Services Are More Effective When Tailored To Individuals Client's Needs

1760 words - 7 pages 1. Statement of the Problem The problem addressed in this study is that despite broad recognition that services are more effective when tailored to individual clients’ needs, there is limited evidence of the impact that services matched to client needs have on treatment outcomes. 2. Purpose of the Study The purpose of this study was to examine the fundamental social work practice principle that treatment is more effective when tailored to

A Personalized Hell Is More Effective

920 words - 4 pages A Personalized Hell is More Effective Hell has been described in many different texts, all explaining how Hell may be organized. There have been many examples in the Bible, myths, folktales, and music through out time. One example in particular is in Dante's, The Inferno, where hell is described as having many layers, which are categorized by individual sins, such as thievery, and are punished for an eternity. In Dante's model, more sin

Solar Energy Is A More Effective Source Than Wind Energy

810 words - 4 pages Judging by this title, most people would probably skip reading this paper and go on to something more exciting. Don’t worry, I’m not going to try and sell something. The point of this paper is try and show the reader why solar energy is more effective. Is it possible for anybody to really prove that, or it just an opinion? Both energy sources have their advantages and disadvantages. But which one is the right one? Read on to find out more

Craft Unions Compared To Industrial Unions: Which Is More Effective?

1888 words - 8 pages for the labour movement. In fact, with the rise of unions from the late nineteenth century to the mid twentieth century, two very distinct forms of unionism emerged, craft unionism and industrial unionism. However, the most effective form of workers organization from 1860 to the 1950s was industrial unionism, and this is evident when comparing the different goals/values and organizational practices of both types of unions.With rising