This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Random Testing The Right Way To Combat Drug Abuse By Athletes?

772 words - 3 pages

Bill Fralic and Alan L. Sack analyze their thoughts on the issue of random testing drug abuse by athletes. Bill Fralic, an offensive guard for the Atlanta Falcons, believes that random testing is the only way to stop the use of illegal drugs. Alan L. Sack, Honors Program chairman at the University of New Haven, believes that random testing is humiliating, inconvenient and it violates privacy to the athletes that are drug-free.Although both writers disagree on the view of random testing, they do agree that drug abuse is a problem among athletes. For example, Fralic asserts that "there are players who justify drug use." Fralic is saying that athletes believe that it is alright for them to use drugs as long as they have a doctor monitor their use. "There is no responsible use of drugs in sports," states Fralic. Likewise, Sack says that something needs to be done to "address the problem of substance abuse." In other words, both writers agree and state clear points that some type of action must take place to solve the problem of drug abuse.What should be done to resolve this issue? That is where the disagreements between the writers take place. Fralic considers random testing as being the right way to combat drug abuse by athletes. "I believe drug use is rampant," says Fralic. He believes that it is unfair to the other athletes and that "random testing is the only way to stop the drug abuse madness" Fralic's main point is that without random testing, athletes will keep cheating the system. Today, athletes are warned ahead of time for when they will be tested. This lets the athletes adjust their schedule for when they should or should not use drugs to keep from getting caught. However, if drug testing is kept random then the athletes would not be warned ahead of time and would be risking their career if they decided to use drugs. Bill Fralic concluded his argument by saying "If the drug abuse issue is not solved, then sporting events will become something of a freak show."In contrast, Sack feels that random testing is not the right way to combat drug abuse by athletes. Sack states "drug testing shows little or no concern for the dignity and privacy of the vast majority of hard-working young athletes who are drug-free."...

Find Another Essay On Is Random Testing the Right Way to Combat Drug Abuse by Athletes?

Drug Testing Athletes Essay

2337 words - 9 pages way to help avoid this is by frequently drug testing each athlete on the team throughout the entire year. Each type of drug that athletes choose to use all have negative side effects that put the athlete, their teammates, and even opponents in danger. Whether these athletes are taking performance-enhancing drugs, recreational drugs, or even abusing prescription drugs there is a harmful side effect to follow. Michael Atkinson writes that "Drugs

Drug Testing For Athletes Essay

894 words - 4 pages Case Study Paper: Drug Testing for Athletes in Public School Supreme Court Case Vernonia School District vs. Acton I chose to do my case study paper on drug testing in public schools.This is of great interest to me as a teacher and coach because our school district recently decided to random test our student-athletes. My awareness of the solvent facts in this case will enable myself to be recognascent of any problems that may arise in the

Random Drug Testing is a Waste of Time

1601 words - 6 pages always a way to get around a positive test result if one is resolute about it.      A drug test by urine is completely intrusive; the person who is present to ensure that no tampering occurs will undoubtedly cause the student to be very embarrassed (Greenberger 2). What ever happened to an American’s right to privacy? Why is it that these days it is considered OK to watch another person urinate, against their will, to

Drug Testing of Student Athletes

1049 words - 4 pages Drug abuse is a major problem in our society as a whole and increasingly within our youth. In recent years, many school districts have implemented student athlete drug testing programs within their schools. Athletes were targeted because student athletics are voluntary and the "athletes are often held to higher standards than other students, keeping their grades up for example" (Tantillo, Wen & Morgo, 1995, p. A22)."The issue of drug testing

Random Drug Testing in High schools

780 words - 3 pages allowing them to gain influence over the lives of students outside of school. Also giving authorities this power can easily lead to an abuse of fundamental rights, particularly those relating to privacy, dignity, and integrity. A problem that may have been overlooked by those who originally organized the idea is how the drug testing weather random or requiring consent will affect the students mentally. Those who refuse to give consent to be tested

Random Drug Testing vs Employees' Privacy Rights

1741 words - 7 pages the public good? D. Lab Testing 1. Is it accurate and can the employer rely on the outcome? 2. How much do you spend to make sure you get the right answers E. Positive Test 1. How should the information be handled? 2. What should be done with the employee? 3. What about rehabilitation? F. Who's Rights are We Infringing On 1. Employees? 2. Employers? Privacy and drug testing have gone hand in hand since President George Bush

Drug Abuse Among Professional Athletes

943 words - 4 pages Drug abuse among professional basketball players is a problem as old as time. In some circumstances it may not be the athletes fault. For example when they are treating a minor cough or a cold, the medications used will sometimes contain small amounts of alcohol. On the other hand some athletes purposely abuse drugs for a variety of reasons. Some attempt to cover up the presence of other drug abuse but most abuse drugs because they will enhance

Should students who participate in extracurricular activities be subjected to random drug testing?

1499 words - 6 pages Studies have shown that students who participate in extracurricular activities are less likely to consume drugs if they are subject to random drug testing. This way, a student's health can be monitored just as their education is. Conversely, random drug testing has continued to under go criticism from students, parents, and administrators. They argue that random drug testing infringes on their constitutional rights. However, random drug testing

Mandatory Drug Testing for High School Athletes

1538 words - 6 pages forms to allow for random drug testing throughout the particular sports season. One testing is at the beginning of the season and during the season every week the students are placed into a “pool” and 10% of the athletes are chosen for random drug testing. What happened in this case was a student by the name of James Acton wanted to play football for his school but in this school district the student and the parents have to sign a consent form. This

Drug Testing Student Athletes - Influential or Useless?

2346 words - 9 pages Drug Testing Student Athletes - Influential or Useless? As spoken by the International Olympic Committee(IOC), “The administration of or use by a competing athlete of any foreign substance to body or injection of substance is unfair to the competing fields” (Yesalis 1). Basically any athlete who decides to use substances of any kind should be considered a lousy winner in the competition field and should be ashamed of their wrong-doing because

Routine Drug Testing For High School Athletes

1092 words - 4 pages year due to drug abuse, and the death rates just keep on escalating. If a drug testing system is set up for high school athletes, then those athletes who are tempted to use illegal substances will think twice before using them. Furthermore, those athletes that test positive for these substances will get suspended from their respective teams and this will create a healthier environment—at least in high school sports. A routine drug testing

Similar Essays

Random Drug Testing Essay

720 words - 3 pages up for random drug tests. Its becoming very popular in middle schools, high schools, and colleges. Although many parents say that drug testing in high schools and middle school is an invasion of privacy the NFL, NCAA, US government, and I agree that such tests protect students and athletes from the many dangers of drug use. So what is drug testing? How does it work? Students must sign a contract which states that they consent to random drug

Random Drug Testing In Schools Essay

738 words - 3 pages this can help student grades. Also, if random drug testing improved a school’s grades, then by that logic, it will have the same effect on other schools. “...of the 14% of high school districts, 65% tested athletes, and 28% randomly tested all students.” (Random Drug… para.1). according to Random drug testing won’t only help students, it will also help athletes. This can help keep games fair and safe. However, there are those who

Argumentative Essay: Random Drug Testing

835 words - 3 pages Drug abuse is a sensitive subject to deal with as it always relates to health, well-being and even lives of human beings belonging to any country. Many people are against mandatory drug testing because they see it as a violation of the Constitution. Having the right to reject unnecessary checking and searches is the Fourth Amendment in the American constitution, otherwise known as a person's right to privacy. However, company employers have

Drug Testing Student Athletes Essay

1083 words - 5 pages Drug Testing Student Athletes Every athlete has probably at some point has been told to represent their school with class. Athletes are held to high standards, they are expected do the right thing on and off the field, and to lead others by setting a good example. As a role model for younger athletes and other students, should our athletes be required to prove they are being responsible even when no one is watching? Should we drug test all of