This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Restorative Justice More Appropriate In Dealing With Young Offenders Than Conventional Criminal Justice?

2674 words - 11 pages

This essay aims to make clear the system of restorative justice and its aims towards youth offending, whilst arguing points for and against the current system and whether or not it is more appropriate in terms of dealing with youth offending. It will also define restorative justice as well as defining what is meant by conventional justice. Making clear how and why these two systems came to be a part of youth justice whilst concluding as to which if either is more appropriate in dealing with youth offending behaviour.
“Restorative justice is a process whereby parties with a stake in a specific offence collectively resolve how to deal with the aftermath of the offence and its implications for the future” (Munchie, 2004).

Restorative Justice is a new way of thinking about and responding to crime, especially in relation to youth offending. For the past decade, especially, there has been an increasing interest in new approaches towards criminal justice in general but more so in terms of juvenile delinquency and finding an appropriate form of punishment to escape the labelling of youth delinquency, which involve the community and focus much more on the victim.
Zehr (1990) who is thought to be one of the pioneers leading the argument for restorative justice highlighted three questions presented when taking a restorative approach; what is the nature of the harm resulting from the crime? What needs to be done to make things right or repair the harm? Who is responsible for this repair? He ascertained that ‘crime is fundamentally a violation of people and interpersonal relationships’. He also noted that violations create obligations and liabilities and that restorative justice seeks to heal and put right the wrongs. Restorative justice has become mainstream following the establishment of youth offender panels under the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999. There are already existing restorative practices that are place within the conventional criminal justice system at present namely probation, restitution and community service (Zehr, 1990). Admittedly they are not readily termed restorative justice programs however they are grounded in its theory.
The current conventional criminal justice process takes a more punitive, ‘retributive’ view of criminal justice. The retributive approach has become grounded into our current system of justice whereby it intends to establish blame on offenders and make them repay their debt to society by inflicting a form of punishment (Ball, 2000). The general stance in relation to the ‘retributive system’ is that its more offender-oriented and its focus is the past rather than the future (Griffiths, 1999). In addition to establishing blame, it tends to give less attention to future-oriented concerns such as how to repair the damages caused by the crime and how future recurrences can be prevented (Young, M, 1999). It has been argued that the existing ‘retributive system’ places excessive emphasis on the past...

Find Another Essay On Is Restorative Justice More Appropriate in Dealing With Young Offenders Than Conventional Criminal Justice?

Restorative Justice Essay

982 words - 4 pages Restorative justice is an innovative approach to the criminal justice system that focuses on repairing the harm caused by crimes committed. The methods used in the conventional justice system may deter the offender from committing further crimes, but it does neither repair the harm caused, nor help them acknowledge their responsibility, instead it stigmatises them, worsening the situation instead of improving it (Johnstone 2003). “Stigmatisation

Restorative Justice Essay

1692 words - 7 pages sentences. With regards to other sentences, such as those directly aligned with retributive punishment theories, the accused will incur a type of suffering, which is seen as “payment” for his wrong doing. With restorative justice the accused attempts to repair broken bonds, as far as possible, with the victim and those affected by the criminal conduct of the accused. The exact way in which these relationships will be repaired is dealt with in such a way

Restorative Justice

1957 words - 8 pages community.Restorative justice is perceived by many as an innovative approach to criminal justice that focuses on repairing the harm caused by crime and involves members of the community. Unlike retributive justice that focuses on punishing the crime, and the community is represented by the state.Community recognition that the current retributive response to dealing with offenders, especially our youth, is not always suitable in either cost or effectiveness as

Restorative Justice - 2844 words

2844 words - 11 pages involvement in the reintegration of young offenders into the "communit[ies] of concern" affords the community a level of conflict control which, like that of the NSW scheme, returns the conflict to the community.Communities cannot control youth crime unless they confront these crimes with shame . It is this reintegrative shaming, present in the practice of NSW Youth Justice Conferencing and QLD Community Conferencing which lay at the core of

Social Justice Is More Than A Definition

1449 words - 6 pages citizenship also demand opportunities and life chances. Finally, to recognize unjust inequalities should be reduced and where possible eliminated.” Since Social Justice is more than just two words and one simple definition, it has the capability to cover many issues that concern the people in general; not only Americans, but people everywhere in the world. Issues concerning social justice are to protect those who are more vulnerable in various aspects

Is Restorative Justice Gaing Support in South Africa?

1752 words - 7 pages Introduction Punishment, central to any legal proceeding where the accused is found guilty, directly falls under criminal law and is determined by punishment theories. Whether South Africa is moving towards restorative justice approaches influences many aspects: it allows the protection of society, results in more of a crime-free life for the offender and it gives offenders the chance to learn from their experience, and gain insight into their

Restorative and Community Justice

1103 words - 4 pages , rather than incarcerating them. This way it gives the offender the opportunity to show their remorse and they learn how they have personally harmed the victim(s) and can then work on making amends to the victim and the community. Restorative justice programs send an intense message to the offenders that criminal behaviour is not acceptable and provides them with the opportunity to make amends with their victims, gain skills, and come back into the

Balanced and Restorative Justice

1102 words - 4 pages juvenile’s chance of becoming an offender. Juvenile offenders, victims, and the community are the primary members involved in the BARJ treatment, but Juvenile justice professionals play a vital role as well. The juvenile justice professionals ensure offenders complete the restorative requirements as outlined by BARJ treatment. The main and most influential restorative requirement of the offender is to build a rapport with the victim. Juvenile

Restorative Justice: Forgiveness is the Best Punishment

1300 words - 6 pages Restorative justice is concerned with healing victims' wounds, restoring offenders to law-abiding lives, and repairing harm done to interpersonal relationships and the community. It seeks to involve all stakeholders and provide opportunities for those most affected by the crime to be directly involved in the process of responding to the harm caused”. The Rwanda government has suffered a tremendous violent act in the loss of their two major

Restorative Justice Handbook

1537 words - 7 pages affected be involved in repairing the harm?(Jessica Kingsley Publishers). Summary This resource book is separated into three parts: explains restorative justice, explores restorative justice and how to use them, and how to implement a whole school approach. Restorative justice is just as relevant to criminal justice workers as schools. The restorative process aims to make things right as possible after a behavior and a relationship is harmed

Purpose of Restorative Justice

570 words - 2 pages use of capital punishment in the United States. The laws providing for mitigation and aggravation in sentencing are explained and the concept of mitigation in capital cases is dealt with specifically" (Palmer, 1999). The only time death is an option is when serious crimes are committed. Retributive justice is also seen as a deterrent for the offenders and others who are thinking of committing a crime.Bibliography:Bloom, S. L. (1999) Restorative

Similar Essays

Evaluate The Effectiveness Of The Criminal Justice System In Dealing With Young Offenders

1391 words - 6 pages charges are still ineffective in dealing with Young Offenders within the Criminal Justice System the majority of them are in place for the greater good and are assisting young offenders when it relates to the Criminal Justice System. Doli Incapax is just one of the ways in which children are now treated more equally under the law. According to the theory ‘it is presumption that children are incapable of having criminal intent’ which in terms

Restorative Justice Empowers Victims And Challenges Offenders

1415 words - 6 pages , the disease is more than an organic condition as it is highly influencing the experience of the individual in the world (Marcum 2004:316 ) . Any damage to our body involves a distortion of how we perceive the world. On the other hand, the human body experiences are par excellence socialized experience, bodily sensations and impulses are profoundly shaped in the social, economic and political patterns which determine the construction of certain

Restorative Justice Essay 1722 Words

1722 words - 7 pages transform crime and justice because of how different it is to the current criminal justice system that prioritizes punishing the offender and neglects the other justice concerns associated with the victim and community (Bobocel, 2009). Furthermore, as Zernova (2007) argues, restorative justice is concerned not with punishing offenders but with repairing harm caused by the crime. This is a complete opposite approach than what is used by the current

Restorative Justice Essay

1853 words - 8 pages legislation with no resolution to the more serious cases. Seeing that an imperative aim of retributive and restorative justice is deterrence, it can be concluded that the state needs to take precautions- like taken in 2010- before the crime has been committed. Tshegofatso Maswabi, Restorative Justice Initiative project manager, said"Restorative justice grew out of dissatisfaction with the criminal justice system and its limitations in dealing with