Is Shylock A Villian Or Victim

2129 words - 9 pages

Site#1The debate is so old it should have its own place in the Shakespearean canon. Is Shylock, the Jewish moneylender who demands a "pound of flesh" from a debtor, a villain or a victim? Every time The Merchant of Venice is staged, the debate is restaged along with it. Does Shakespeare's play merely depict anti-semitism, or does it reek of it? Is the Bard describing, even condemning, the prevalent anti-Jewish attitudes of his time - or gleefully giving them an outlet? The papers of a million A-level students are marked forever with such questions.Yet now they have a new force. Because the Merchant is playing in a new medium, making its debut as a full-length, big-budget feature film - complete with a top-drawer Hollywood star, Al Pacino, in the de facto lead.The film declares its own intentions early. The pre-credit sequence, complete with Star Wars-style scrolling text, seeks to contextualise. The opening image is of a crucifix, rapidly juxtaposed with the sight of Hebrew texts put to the flame. The words on the screen tell us that "intolerance of the Jews was a fact of 16th-century life". To prove it we see a mini-pogrom, with a Jew hurled from the Rialto Bridge.It's clear that director Michael Radford does not want to make an anti-semitic film. But he has big two problems. The first is the play. The second is the medium.Start with the play. We may want it to be a handy, sixth-form-friendly text exposing the horrors of racism, but Shakespeare refuses to play along. As the great critic Harold Bloom has declared, "One would have to be blind, deaf and dumb not to recognise that Shakespeare's grand, equivocal comedy The Merchant of Venice is nevertheless a profoundly anti-semitic work."There is no getting away from it: Shylock is the villain, bent on disproportionate vengeance. Crucially, his villainy is not shown as a quirk of his own, individual personality, but is rooted overtly in his Jewishness.Thus, he is shown as obsessed by money, a man who dreams of moneybags, whose very opening words are "three thousand ducats". When his daughter betrays him and flees with a Christian lover, it is her theft of his money which is said to trouble him as much as the loss of a child. "As the dog Jew did utter in the streets/'My daughter! O my ducats! O my daughter!' "Since the laws that barred Jews from almost all activity besides finance had led to the stereotype of the avaricious Jew, Shakespeare is dealing here not with a specific trait of Shylock the man but an anti-semitic caricature.So it is with his demand for revenge, playing on the ancient notion of the Jews as a vengeful people ("An eye for an eye ... "). The same is true of the very forfeit Shylock demands from Antonio. A Jew seeking Christian flesh is surely meant to stir memories of the perennial anti-semitic charge, known as the blood libel, that Jews use Christian blood for religious ritual. Above all, it evokes the accusation that fuelled two millennia of European anti-semitism - that the...

Find Another Essay On is shylock a villian or victim

The Merchant of Venice: Is Shylock a Villain or a Victim?

1061 words - 4 pages In this essay I will try to discover is Shylock a villain or a victim, in the William Shakespeare play “The Merchant of Venice” It is difficult to say if Shylock is a complete villain or a victim, as his character is complex and ambiguous. However, it is difficult to view Shylock as anything other than a devious, bloodthirsty and heartless villain in the majority of the play. There are a few points in the story where he can be viewed as

Is Stalin a Hero or a Villian

1102 words - 5 pages punishment of being sent to a labour camp. One could be punished for various of things while working, breaking equipment, leaving early, or not completing their target for the day, etc. The working conditions were terrible, long-houred shifts with large quotas to complete. In Stalin’s desperate plan to modernize Russia, he made workers push out large quantities of products. In Source 1 of Heroes and Villains,the production target for automobiles was 78

Shylock A Ruthless Villain or A Persecuted Victim

1501 words - 7 pages A villain in a play is a “character whose evil actions or motives are important to the plot” and a victim in the terms of this play is “a person who has come to feel helpless and passive in the face of misfortune or ill-treatment”. Shylock in Merchant of Venice is a Jewish moneylender and Jewish people during Shakespearean time were looked down upon, treated unfairly with no respect. Shylock in Merchant of Venice is portrayed as how a

Is Macbeth a hero or villian?

616 words - 2 pages Throughout the play Macbeth, there are many crimes and manipulating. Macbeth plans most murders for superiority. This makes us wonder if Macbeth is a hero or a villain. With that Macbeth is both a hero and villain from different perspectives.In the beginning of the play, Macbeth and Banquo go to war against Macdonwald and his band of rebels. Macbeth was a great warrior which in return defeated Macdonwald. Duncan rewarded Macbeth with the title

William Shakespeare's Shylock: Villain or Victim

3449 words - 14 pages William Shakespeare's Shylock: Villain or Victim In "The Merchant of Venice" Shakespeare confronts a considerable issue of his time, known as Anti Semitism. "Shylock", his stereotypical Jew lends money to a Christian in an agreement that flesh would be cut from the Christian's body, should it not be paid. Looking at the history of Jews in England, it is evident that Jews were persecuted and murdered up until 1290

The mercheant of venice - is shylock the victim or vilian of the play?

2377 words - 10 pages GCSE English coursework.Merchant of Venice: - Is Shylock a victim or villain of the play?The merchant of Venice is a tragic-comedy play written by William Shakespeare in the Elizabethan period. It was set in Venice in the late 15th century. One of the main characters of the play is Shylock, who was a Jew.Throughout his five scenes in the play he is looked down upon, betrayed, deserted, punished and humiliated by Christian society. His faith and

Is Shylock Victim Or Villain in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

1243 words - 5 pages Is Shylock Victim Or Villain in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice William Shakespeare wrote the Merchant of Venice in the Elizabethan period. The play is about Shylock, a Jewish money lender¡: trying to make a living and survive in a community that despises him and marginalia's him. Before the plot even starts, Shylock is condemned for being a Jew, and a moneylender. Jews were forbidden to be successful

Victim or villain? How is Shylock presented in 'The Merchant of Venice'?

1956 words - 8 pages The merchant in 'The Merchant of Venice', by William Shakespeare, there appears Shylock. As the play unfolds Shylock is seen to be the villain. He is portrayed as being cold, unbending, and evil. But is he? Is Shylock really the antagonist in this play or can he also be viewed as a persecuted individual who resorts to revenge only after he has been pushed too far. To fully understand the character of Shylock we must first look at Elizabethan

Shakespeare's Merchant of Venice: Was Shylock a Victim or a Villain?

784 words - 3 pages ," Shylock was a victim of years' struggle against discrimination toward his religion.One of the most persistent charges against Shylock was that he was cruel and bloodthirsty. Antonio says in act 4 scene 1 that it is impossible to soften "his Jewish heart." Bassanio constantly calls him a cur and insults him; how can he call Shylock coldhearted when he and many other characters constantly jeer at Shylock. This also added reason for Shylock's

In your opinion does Shakespeare present Shylock as a victim or a villain

878 words - 4 pages In Your Opinion Does Shakespeare present Shylock as a Victim or a Villain? Shylock’s greed is displayed through his resentment to people against him. The wickedness of Shylock’s character is demonstrated in Act 3 Scene 1 line 43, where Shylock is thrilled with Antonio’s failures, and desires him to be even more troubled by wanting Antonio “look to his bond”. Shylock purposefully reiterates this, so that the people around him will realise how

The Character of Shylock as a Victim or Villain in The Merchant of Venice

2740 words - 11 pages The Character of Shylock as a Victim or Villain in The Merchant of Venice Do you consider the character of shylock to be a victim or villain in the play The Merchant of Venice? Shylock is one of the most interesting, memorable and debated characters in the play “The Merchant of Venice”. In many ways this is because he is both a victim and a villain. Shylock was made a laughing stock of and is ridiculed by the

Similar Essays

Shylock Victim Or Villian Essay

2613 words - 10 pages victim. It happens in two scenes, the loss of his daughter, and in the courtroom. Shylock was treated like a second class citizen, if a citizen at all. There was no regard for his motives, or his personal feelings. Antonio slapped the penalty on as if he was merely sending Shylock to his room. The loss of identity felt by Shylock does not even phase the presumed 'legal eagle' in the room, the Duke of Venice. Shylock is the victim for no other reason

Shylock; A Villain Or A Victim?

1036 words - 5 pages Venice, it is easy to see why one would think of Shylock as the symbol of the devil, but perhaps William Shakespeare intended for Shylock to be portrayed as the misunderstood victim. It is evident throughout the play that Shylock is a victim of a form of racism, namely anti-Semitism. At the start of The Merchant of Venice, it is revealed in Act 1, Scene 3 that Antonio mistreated him in the past. Shylock recalls how Antonio “rated [him] About [his

Shylock Victim Or Villain Essay

1365 words - 5 pages It is questionable as to what the Jew, Shylock, can be regarded as - victim or villain? Many factors need to be contemplated when determining if Shylock is to be considered a victim or villain. Having been subject to racism and prejudice, losing his daughter and having been treated harshly by Christians, it is debatable as to whether or not Shylock is a victim or villain. It can be suggested that the Jew may have come to be a villain, from the

Shylock Villain Or Victim Essay

851 words - 3 pages place they were allowed to commune with Christians was on the Rialto where they could do business. The Rialto is where we first meet Shylock. Throughout the play Shylock is criticized because he is Jewish. "Here comes another of the tribe- a third cannot be matched, unless the devil himself turned Jew" (Act 3, Scene 1). This is one of the many quotes that support that Shylock is the victim of the play because others torment him for being a Jew. They