Is The Essential Clash In The Novel Between A Scientific Or Spiritual Approach To Life?

2029 words - 8 pages

One critic may believe that the essential clash in the novel is between the scientific and religious approach to life. This is easily said considering the lifestyles of the main two characters, the way in which they conflict with each other, and this being what the story seems to revolve around. Jed's life is perhaps more extreme than a typical approach to life, his life revolves on his take on religion and what he believed God would want, but it is not based around any kind of organised religion, as might be typical. He is very extreme in what he believes, as he will even resort to violence for his spiritual belief. Perhaps Jed's believes are not at all typical, and are more brought on by his unhealthy mental state? Joe's approach to life is a scientific one, and he is not really extreme. He is an atheist, and he writes about what he believes for a living, but we get the impression he would not let his believes lead to violence. His believes are not the centre of his life, unlike Jed's, and he comes across as fairly level headed, and certainly mentally stable.

However there is far more going in the novel, on than just this clash between a scientific and spiritual approach to life. Tragedy, trust and morality are all key themes that Ian Mc Ewan presents to us. We witness the breakdown of Joe and Clarissa's relationship and the near suicide of Parry. We see Joe lose all of the confidence and trust in himself he once had. The clash between a scientific and spiritual approach to life is a consistent theme throughout the novel, but along with it are other issues, which the author wishes us to address.

It could be said that the first chapter of the book is very important when considering the rest of the book. It is in this chapter that the drama begins, as we see a picnic on a sunny day turn into a life or death struggle with the elements. Mc Ewan's dramatic switch, the transformation of the scene, is extremely effective in creating tension and encouraging us to read further. This is the place where death and random tragedy take a firm place in the novel, and is of course the pivot on which the story turns. The story begins almost like a romance novel, but turns into a thriller. The theme of tragedy has been said to play a big part in the novel, with the ballooning incident being a completely random event that has a destructive effect on the people involved. This relates to the character's behaviour after the event, depending on how scientific or spiritual Jed or Joe are, affects how destructive the event is. This is especially true when we think of Clarissa, for her the event can be seen as a situation which nobody is to blame for, quite different from Joe's opinion.

As the story begins to move on and we see Parry behaving in his unreasonable classic `stalker' fashion, we side with Joe, and the issue of trust becomes important. Our trust in Joe, which we are led to by Mc Ewan's style of writing,...

Find Another Essay On Is the Essential Clash in the Novel between a Scientific or Spiritual Approach to Life?

Is the Jewish Seder meal just a tradition that Jews practice or is there a spiritual experience and depth when it comes to eating and taking part in t

1100 words - 4 pages done out of tradition or is there a spiritual depth when it comes to eating and taking part in it. Section B: Plan for Study After deciding why I wanted to find out more about the Jewish Seder meal, I was able to do extensive research to try to answer the question I had. I was able to find a good amount of information on why the Seder meal is celebrated, what takes place at the meal, and the spiritual aspects to the steps of the Seder meal. I

The clash between past and present in "A Rose for Emily" by William Faulkner

880 words - 4 pages In “A Rose for Emily”, written by William Faulkner, a character (Miss Emily) chooses to live in the past, and “den[ies] changing the customs and the passage of time” . Faulkner succeeds in showing the great contrast between the past and the present era, not only in Miss Emily herself, but also in many other ways. Therefore, the aim of this current essay is to explore the ways in which he presents this recurrent clash between

CAPM vs. APT: Do you think APT or the CAPM is the best approach for a financial professional to use?

1036 words - 4 pages -taking, to make profits.An arbitrage opportunity occurs where the same security sells for two different prices, usually, but not necessarily, in two different stock markets. Arbitrageurs will buy the security where it is underpriced and sell it where it is priced higher. As a result of arbitrage activity the price will quickly equalise.Arbitrageurs (or 'arbs') are market traders who make their money from identifying and exploiting market pricing

The Bible: A Spiritual Guide or a Deadly Weapon?

1643 words - 7 pages inconclusive, questionable and greatly exaggerated, but still credible in their court system. If there is shared knowledge between communities, there can be more growth and building from what others have already done. If there is no sharing of knowledge, or if only certain groups of people are educated, humans are doomed to repeat simple mistakes, or even risk the complete destruction of their communities. A human that does not learn from

Hinderances to Spiritual Growth in the Church

1201 words - 5 pages dangerous truth. The question is not only how to get them more involved, but also the church needs to find out why it has lost 'taste'. Spiritual growth has nothing to do with the number of years one has been a Christian, our position in Christ, that is whether one has accepted Christ or not ,our knowledge of the Bible, or God's love because God cannot love one person more than he loves another.( MacArthur, 2014). According to MacArthur

Rationale for Commerce in the school curriculum - explaining to a mother and son why commerce studies is essential

969 words - 4 pages essential life skills such as problem solving, decision-making, critical thinking, reflective learning and the opportunity to participate in the community.These skills are not only valuable in the outside world but can be beneficial in improving students' comprehension of other key learning areas, for example mathematics. The concepts taught and the perceptive nature of Commerce allows students to apply their knowledge gained from mathematics in a

This esssay is about living life to the fulles or a life philosophy

654 words - 3 pages ? Do I have a sole purpose in the universe? Then you ask yourself the biggest question of all. What is the meaning of life? The concept of the word "meaning" is to have a purpose or to have a certain importance. The word life, in brief, is when planets are formed by an ultimately powerful being that we all call God. For centuries people have imagined an ultimate powerful being that formed all life and creation. This all relates to living your

water is essential to human life

618 words - 2 pages Everyone knows that water is essential to human life, but one third of the world's population lacks sufficient access to safe drinking water and sanitation to meet their basic needs. [www.gwp.org]Every year 3 million people die prematurely from water-related diseases in developing countries. [www.gwp.org] 884 million people in the world still do not get their drinking-water from improved sources, almost all of them in developing regions

The Life-Span Developmental Approach to Counseling

982 words - 4 pages development is a multi-faceted approach to counseling. Using these and other theories gives a licensed professional counselor a variety of tools for counseling. I expect these theories to help me determine a specialty in my future practice, relying on the overlap and complexity of working in terms of an entire human life. References?Boeree, C. George. (1997). Erik Erikson: 1902 to 1994. Shippensburg, PA: Shippensburg University. Retrieved 21 June 2005

A Good Man is Hard to Find: The Cross of Two Spiritual Paths

2816 words - 11 pages would of known" (Piedmont-Martin 7). Piedmont-Martin also explains that the Misfit's parting words to Bobby Lee, "It's no real pleasure in life," indicate that he appears lost in his spiritual path (8). The Misfit cannot resolve the religious and moral paradox of his own bleak situation; he finds it unfair that he has suffered more than he has deserved to in life, and he sees no rational explanation for his predicament. Thus, he is trapped in a

Dialogue and the Art of Thinking Together: A Pioneering Approach to Communicating in Business and in Life

1041 words - 5 pages . This leads to fake assumption life form made-which in the majority luggage leads to a number of kind of disagreement. Ought to be obligatory interpretation for anybody desiring to be a true head! According to the slogan, Isaacs provides "a pioneering approach to communicating in business and in life." This he does by means of imminent and expressiveness. There is an immense necessitate for what this volume provides; particularly now as

Similar Essays

In Jack London's Novel, "The Call Of The Wild", Adaptation Is Essential To Survival.

1043 words - 4 pages Crucial ChangesIn Jack London's novel, The Call Of The Wild, adaptation is essential to survival. First, Buck, a St. Bernard and Scotch shepherd mix, adapts to all of his surroundings to survive. Next, Spitz, a brutal dog who possesses a relentless personality, uses his force to thrive in the cutthroat world. Lastly, Hal, Charles, and Mercedes, later owners of Buck, do not acclimatize, which results in a disorderly, fatal existence. In

Scientific Management Is Sadly Underestimated As An Approach In Modern Organisational Life. Provide A Detailed Justification Of Your Agreement Or Disagreement Of This Statement. (I Disagree With It)

1899 words - 8 pages To question whether scientific management is underestimated in the organisation of modern businesses is to misjudge the complexity of modern-day work practices. As scientific management is simply defined as 'an approach ...emphasising the scientific study of work methods to improve worker efficiency' (Management: A Pacific Rim Focus, 2001, p.36), it can be concluded that such a simplistic, inhumane approach does not belong in the 21st century.A

Discuss The Advantages And Disadvantages Of A Scientific Approach To The Study Of Society.

1625 words - 7 pages Scientific approach can be defined as the involvement of standards and procedures for demonstrating the empirical warrant of its findings, showing the match or fit between its statements and what is happening or has happened in the world. Scientific approaches to understanding the world can be distinguished from other approaches in two fundamental and irrelevant ways, firstly, an approach that claim to be scientific irrespective of whether or

The Wayang Kulit Is Essential To Understanding The Relationships Between The Characters. Discuss

980 words - 4 pages Srikandi, or Jill.The Wayang Kulit is essential in understanding character relationships because it is upon the intricacies of the Wayang that the author has molded his characters and their actions and thoughts.In the final section, Patet Manjura, we see the finding of enlightenment by Billy and Guy, as they find the right path. The Wayang again plays an important role, as while the Wayang is brought to a successful conclusion, the characters also