Is The Genocide Convention A Meaningless Document

3490 words - 14 pages

This essay will argue that the genocide convention is not a meaningless document, but rather weak in dealing with genocide as evidenced in the case of Darfur 2003, because of limitations in definition which need to be addressed. The convention is characterized as being problematic due to the following grounds, its definition of genocide and its furtherance’s as well as lack of enforceability and its failure to prevent genocide. Even though the statement contains an element of truth, it is too subjective and unfairly undermines the legal significance of the Convention. This paper will consider this claim paying particular attention to the legal definition of genocide, which is described by Martin Shaw as vague and incomplete. First, this essay will examine the origins and define the concept of genocide in accordance with the GC; second, it will address the case of non intervention during genocide using the realist and liberal paradigms, third, It will address the case study and examine whether or not the genocide convention is indeed a meaningless document then conclude by arguing that it is not meaningless but is in need of reform.
The term genocide was first coined by the Polish legal scholar Raphael Lemkin in 1943.Lemkin had sought to give a name to the Nazi programme of systematic violence in their occupied territories, particularly the mass murder of Europe’s Jews.Lemkin was later instrumental in the creation of the United Nations’ Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide, which was approved by the U.N. General Assembly on 9 December 1948 and provided a legal definition of the term. The Genocide Convention is the first United Nations (UN) human rights treaty later strengthened by the Responsibility to protect (R2P) doctrine of 2010 giving parties an obligation prevent and protect from mass atrocities. Genocide is a term that is fast entering common terminology when pointing fingers at any form of state repression, as evidenced in Darfur. One difficulty is the continuing lack of definition commonly agreed upon by law and social science. For legal purposes, genocide is defined by the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide even though many social scientists are unhappy with the legal definition, some claiming that it is too broad, others that it is too narrow. The Genocide Convention legally defined genocide as "any acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such." Arne Johan Vetlesen argues that genocide is a collective action meaning that it is contemplated, thought out, planned, organized, and carried out by a specific organized collective, by a group. The defined target of genocide is another group. The key word from Vetlesen’s perspective is "intent" Which will later be discussed in the last part of this paper.

The GC is however a liberal tool even though this paper shall rely more on a realist paradigm because it...

Find Another Essay On Is the Genocide Convention a Meaningless Document

The Convention of a Thriller Film

2658 words - 11 pages The Convention of a Thriller Film It is difficult to state a clear definition of a thriller as they cross over many genres, however the single most characteristic of a thriller is the obvious one, it "thrills" the audience. The plots are scary, the characters are at great risk and the films are constructed in a manner that makes the watcher really want to know what happens next. There is no formula for a thriller, other

The American Constitution: A Highly Intelligent Document

1095 words - 4 pages When the Founding Fathers came together they wanted to separate from Britain because their home country was imposing its will on them without any colonial representation in British legislatures. Later, with democratic ideals in mind, the Framers of the Constitution drafted the document that governs our society. They vowed to create the foundation for a strong country that would not treat its citizen as England did. Unfortunately, the

A Look at the Rwandan Genocide

1442 words - 6 pages Thousands of people died. The only reason is because they were a different political party. There are terrible economies. People are suffering and have very little hope. Genocide is the only reason. Everything could have been prevented if genocide didn’t exist. The world basically ignored the genocide and pretended like it never happened because they didn’t want to spend the money. Thousands of people could still be alive if the world stepped

Donald Bloxham's The Final Solution: A Genocide

2269 words - 10 pages Bloxham book ‘the final solution: A genocide’ has brought about much criticism and debate. In this book Bloxham “seeks to situate the mass-murder of European Jewry between 1941 and 1945 within the broader history of European genocide from 1875 to 1945” . In this, he challenges the uniqueness of the holocaust, and presents the argument that the full meaning of the holocaust and final solution can only be completely understood, if it is placed in

Is human society a fundamentally amoral, dog-eat-dog? If so, then Macbeth is right, and human life itself is meaningless and tiresome?

661 words - 3 pages The statement above is an unfair and unjust statement asking if just because the society of today is amoral that life itself is not just meaningless but tiresome too; though the statement makes no sense as it contradicts itself. If the society of today has a "dog-eat-dog" mentality then it has to have meaning. In order to behave in this way there must be something to gain and therefore life has purpose, meaning. Due to this life may be tiresome

Women and the Law in Rome (A Document Study)

591 words - 2 pages document one could infer that Augustus was very big on family and reproduction. He says that there isn't anything better than a wife who is chaste, domestic, good at house keeping, and a bearer of children. He stated that "we must console the mortal side of our nature with an endless succession of generations that shall be like torchbearers in race". The statement basically tells me that Augustus was big on procreation. I feel that companionship

Information Management: The Medical Record as a Legal Document

3671 words - 15 pages records a personal complaint or a complaint not related to their patient’s health, they may find themselves in a court of law defending what they wrote (Pozgar 2007) and possibly ruining their creditability. The law is very clear regarding a patient’s medical records and their value. Medical records are the single most important document a lawyer can use to prove a doctor or health care professional’s innocence. If the details are outline

Religion and The Bosnian Genocide?: Did religion play a significant role in the Bosnia Genocide?

3456 words - 14 pages , open fields, and buildings. Victims were blindfolded and bound behind their backs. Bosnian male victims were then executed and thrown into mass graves. Bosnian Serbs forces were responsible ethnic cleansing and the murder of 8,000 muslim males. Srebrenica is the only location within Bosnia that was considered a genocide. The crimes committed fall under the term of “ethnic cleansing,” which in the former Yugoslavia was undertaken via various means

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Rwandan Genocide to the Holocaust

1432 words - 6 pages Beginning on April 6, 1994, Hutus began a mass slaughtering of the Tutsis in the African country of Rwanda. This mass slaughtering is labeled as genocide, the deliberate obliteration of an ethnic, racial, religious, or political group. The Rwandan genocide lasted 100 days while other countries stood idly by and watched the brutal killings continue. The hatred against the Tutsis began after the RPF invasion in October of 1990. Accusations

Lecture notes on plant structure (download document it is in a table.)

821 words - 3 pages are attached)Internodes The portion of the stem between nodesLeaves Main site of photosynthesisProduces food of plantapical bud (terminal bud) gives growth and length(in many plats the terminal bud produces hormones that inhibit growth of the axillary buds)Axillary buds one in each of the angles formed by a leaf and the stemare usually dormantMANY PLANTS HAVE MODIFIED ROOTS AND SHOOTSExample:Strawberry Plant Has horizontal stem (runner)A runner is

Taking a Closer Look at The Cambodian Genocide

1319 words - 6 pages psychological disorders were caused from the mass killings and the horrors that these people witnessed and went through. Some say that the Cambodian Genocide did not have enough deaths to be considered genocide. As John Ciorciari says, “Genocide” is increasingly being used as a generic label for all the world's most serious mass crimes. “As a result, the absence of the term ‘genocide' can be interpreted by survivors as meaning they didn't suffer

Similar Essays

Is The Declaration Of Independence A Viable Document?

584 words - 2 pages What does the Fourth of July mean to you? Oftentimes, we as Americans don't realize the true importance and historical significance of this day, the day the nation's most prestigious and historical document was finally accepted as a universal belief. The Declaration of Independence is regarded as one of America's most treasured symbols because it identifies the moment at which the nation was born and describes the reasons for its birth. It

Discuss How The Human Condition Is Explored By Eliot As A Struggle For Fulfillment In A Meaningless World.

938 words - 4 pages , but lacks self worth and fears rejection. These are all strong elements of the human condition that are explored throughout the poem. Through the use of imagery, Eliot describes a mundane, meaningless world in which Prufrock is isolated and alone in his miseries. This, coupled with his human weaknesses ultimately costs him the chance for happiness.The poem tells the inner feelings of a man who's in love, but realizes that his feeling may well

Assessing The View That Religious Language Is Meaningless

2910 words - 12 pages Assessing the View that Religious Language is Meaningless In recent times one of the most compelling and interesting arguments against God and religion has come from linguistic philosophy. In very basic terms the argument points out the fact that religion must necessarily use language in order to express abstract ideas such as God, love and so on, and in doing so commits a fallacy because as soon as such ideas are put

Convention On The Prevention And Punishment Of The Crime Of Genocide

2194 words - 9 pages independent governing body for the enforcement of its aims, verification of compliance is difficult. 12. Article IX, disputes relating to interpretation, application or fulfilment, including those relating to the responsibility of a State for genocide and any other acts outlined in Article III, will be submitted to the International Court of Justice at the request of any of the parties to the dispute. 13. Article X, the Convention was