Is The Israel Palestinian Issue A Conflict Or Colonialism? Middle East Regional Relations Essay

3551 words - 15 pages

‘Conflict or colonialism?’ Discuss this question in relation to the relationship between Israel and the Palestinians.
Traditionally, the Arab-Israeli conflict has been viewed as just that, a conflict. The mainstream media and Western scholarship emphasise the role of religion, security and Arab rejectionism of Israel’s right to exist as key drivers of the ongoing dispute. Both Israel and Palestine are seen to have equal claims to the land in question, with little attention given to the idea that the establishment and ongoing consolidation of the Jewish state follows a deviant pattern of colonialism. After considering the Zionist narrative, this essay will argue that Israel’s use of physical and symbolic violence to appropriate Palestinian land and culture is in line with common definitions and experiences of settler colonialism. Violent land grabs, settlement expansion and cultural genocide will be considered as indicators of Israel’s overarching ambition to displace the native population and establish control over as much territory as possible, a central goal of settler colonialism. Ultimately, understanding the conflict through this paradigm recognises the vast power imbalance, oppression and systematic discrimination that Palestinians suffer from on a daily basis in a way that the conventional view fails to and could thus provide a novel insight into potential solutions to the issue.
The Zionist claim to the Promised Land is one that is rooted in the Biblical promise to the Jewish people of the land between the River of Egypt and the Euphrates (The Holy Bible, New International Version, Genesis: 15:18). Therefore, Zionists do not see themselves as foreigners, conquerors or colonisers, but as an exiled people who are returning to their rightful home after centuries of persecution in the Diaspora. This view of Zionism as a national liberation movement emphasises the economic, social and cultural processes that spurred the Jews in Eastern Europe to flee to Palestine and while these are certainly important factors in explaining the need for a Jewish state, the resultant narrative downplays the fact that the land that they fled to had already been populated by Palestinians for thousands of years. In fact, Masalha (2014: 3) notes that modern Palestinians are more likely to be the direct descendants of the ancient Israelites, Canaanites and Philistines, to whom the land was promised, than the European Ashkenazi founding fathers of the Zionist state. By highlighting their historical, cultural and spiritual connection to the land while ignoring the existing Palestinian presence, Israel presents a one-sided narrative to the international community. The result is that the mainstream Western discourse also sees Palestine as a “land without a people for a people without a land” and directs little international criticism towards the legitimacy of the methods used to establish the Jewish state.
Additionally, Zionist scholars argue that there was no...

Find Another Essay On Is the Israel Palestinian issue a conflict or colonialism? - Middle East Regional Relations - Essay

International Relations of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict

2343 words - 9 pages state in the sense that it does not have its own territory and it is not sovereign. However, in a diplomatic sense it could be seen as a state because of treaties like the Oslo agreements, which have led to a Palestinian Authority that governs and represents the Palestinian people living in Gaza and the West Bank when negotiating with Israel. Therefore, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict may be viewed as either an inter-state conflict or even an

Establishment of Israel This is a five page research paper on the establishment of Israel in the middle east, at the end of this essay is also an opinion written by the author

1468 words - 6 pages . Israel also has been known to go into Palestinian territories and kill Palestinian families, another example of genocide just as the Nazis did to the Jews during WWII.Critics would argue that Israel does belong in the Middle East because the Jews need a safe haven to go to because they were being persecuted throughout Europe and were being exterminated by the Nazis. I agree that the Jews need a place to live in peacefully but the way they did it

Nationalist Conflict in the Middle East - Cedar House - Essay

1663 words - 7 pages Chaska Concar-Tavares Cathy Marshall Nationalist Conflict in the Middle East Introduction The Middle East has been an area of conflict for over a hundred years, this is due to many different reasons but one of the large reasons for this is the conflict over an area called Palestine and who has claim over that land. This conflict is between two Nationalistic groups in the late 19th and early 20th century, the Arab and Jewish people. The war was

Middle East Conflict

974 words - 4 pages The Middle east Conflict is a conflict between Israel and arab neighboring countries including Egypt, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Iraq and the state of Palestine. It’s history goes back all the way before WW1 to the collapse of the Ottoman Empire with wars continuing on and off steadily since 1930’s. It is a complicated conflict as there is Political, territorial and religious factored into the conflict. Some of the documentaries I watched were

Middle East Conflict

877 words - 4 pages known section in the history of the Middle East; the Arab-Israeli War, in which there were a series of attacks on the outnumbered new state of Israel which were uncoordinated since, as said before, the Middle East is not a cohesive unit at this point in time, and were actually beaten back a bit by Israel which gained more land than they were allotted by the UN partition until an armistice was signed on January 7, 1949. However, this was not the end of conflict, which is almost synonymous with history, in the area, and it has remained divided and cannot truly be lumped together as one unit, the Middle East, but we do it anyways.

The Middle East: Conflict in Journalism

1830 words - 7 pages The Middle East: Conflict in Journalism Before beginning my essay, “The Middle East, Conflict in Journalism”, I would like the reader to read a few terms. These are merely food for thought, do whatever with them you wish. Conflict: A state of disharmony between incompatible or antithetical persons, ideas, or interests; a clash. (The American Heritage) War: A state of open, armed, often prolonged conflict carried on

The Middle East: Land of Conflict

1879 words - 8 pages , and have long been a concern for the nations outside of it. They are a major and vital supplier of theworlds oil supply and are therefore very important to the economy. As theconflicts continue, so do the outside opinions as to the cause of them.Sami Hadawi, a Palestinian scholar, lays the blame squarely at the feet ofIsrael. He claims the unjust occupation of Zionists in Palestine is solelyresponsible for the Middle east conflict. The United

Peace in the Middle East: Jumpstarting the Process This was written in Feb 2003 for a International Relations course. What the US should do to make progress in the Israeli/Palestinian problem

1321 words - 5 pages the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was increasing, not until the September 11 attacks did the administration's focus dramatically shift to the Middle East. Both sides had high expectation of U.S. movement, as the War on Terrorism was declared. Israelis relied on the America's sympathy, because now they too were a victim of Islamic terrorism. The Palestinians noted that in order to solidify support of Arab nations in the fight against terrorism, the

The United States Relations with the Middle East

2962 words - 12 pages and created a power vacuum in the Middle East, in 1953, through Operation Ajax. The U.S. then informally colonized Iran, under Shah Pahlavi’s rule, in order to possess economic and political hegemony over the volatile Persian Gulf. The U.S. effectively transformed the Shah into an autocratic ruler who controlled the Iranian government and people. As a result of Pahlavi’s despotic rule, the Iranian public felt a growing enmity towards the Shah

The Arab-Israeli Conflict: Protecting Democracy in the Middle East

3986 words - 16 pages harmony in the Middle East. It is a task of mammoth proportions, rife with possibilities for failure, but one which is the responsibility of any government that is to be taken seriously by the international community to undertake. The peace that Israel seeks is often hampered by those who claim that the violence and unrest in the region is solely their fault. However, what people will not tell you is what blame the Arab nations hold for destroying any

Water In the Middle East: Prospects for Conflict and Cooperation

1580 words - 7 pages disputes mainly using forces, even the smallest ones, seemingly minor disagreement can lead to large-scale war. Practically saying, Hasbani river in South Lebanon has enough chances to become a detonator of new Arab-Israeli conflict. Lack of unleavened water - is an issue for entire region f the Middle East, which accounts for about 5 % of the overall Earth population. At the same time, the region's water resources are less than 0.9 % of the world’s

Similar Essays

The Palestinian Israeli Conflict In The Middle East

3597 words - 14 pages The Palestinian-Israeli Conflict in the Middle East The Arab world is not in a compromising mood… Nations never concede; they fight. You won’t get anything by peaceful means or compromise. You can, perhaps get something, but only by the force of your arms…But it’s too late to talk of peaceful solutions” (Bard 1). The Arab League Secretary Azzam Pasha said this statement on September 16, 1947, eight months before the state of Israel was

This Paper Is About The Palestinian Israeli Conflict And Favors The Side Of Israel. Basically A Persuasive Essay And Argues For Israel

2668 words - 11 pages conflict (Harris 4).Ever since Israel was established in 1948, it has been a nation on high alert. Although, the Arabs failed in their first try to destroy the Israeli state, they never stopped talking about another attempt. Arabs in the Middle East have taken pride in murdering innocent Israeli civilians and military officials. The Palestinian government often pays people or their families to carry out suicide bombings in Israel. The glorification

Israel Palestinian Conflict Essay

1100 words - 5 pages believe that the same area, Palestine, was to be used for the creation of a sovereign Jewish state. This occurred in 1917 when a letter written by the British Foreign Secretary, Arthur James Balfour, reached one of the most influential Jewish families, the Rothschilds. Balfour’s letter showed sympathy on the matter stating that Britain would support the creation of a Jewish homeland on Palestinian soil (Trueman). Afterward, many Jewish people

Israeli Palestinian Conflict Brief History Of The Conflict In The Middle East

929 words - 4 pages states in Palestine, with Jerusalem and its surroundings to be placed under international supervision. The second called for the creation of a single federal state containing both Jewish and Arab constituent states. Seven out of ten UNSCOP delegates voted in favor of the first proposal.The Israeli-Palestinian conflict, a part of the greater Arab-Israeli conflict, is an ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestinians. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict