Is The Mexican Revolution Justifiably Called A Revolution?

1202 words - 5 pages

The Mexican Revolution threw Mexico into turmoil for about two decades making itself an established time period in Mexican history. It has been written down as a revolution as people had rose together to get their voice heard. In this essay I shall look at the facts of the situation and see if this event in Mexican history is justifiably called a revolution.The Mexican revolution occurred when the Porfiratio, or the 35 year reign of Porfiratio Diaz, had driven people to anger. The need for a change in leadership was the initial cause, indeed the trigger, for the revolution and the change was achieved and so it can be said that the Mexicans had carried out a revolution from a general study.However, if we were to look into it from a historical context by underlining the basis for a revolution and comparing it with the situation of the time then we find a deifferent conclusion.In this struggle for a change in leadership many other leaders to power. However, they came one by one and fell like a pack of dominoes. Even though Diaz was removed this was not the objective desired and so it cannot be said that this was a proper revolution.Revolutions in general are fought with an ideology in mind. While the need for democracy is what sparked this revolution the different leaders that came into power came with their own brand of ideologies making this affair a very sordid one. Madero for example was liberal and wished to help all the differing classes while Huerta who replaced him was an outright dictator assassinating other rebel faction leaders. Amidst such was Zapata who carried out extreme agrarian reform with having the peasant class as his supporting strength who was in contrast to Carranza who had capitalist view backed by the US. Thus, this Mexican conflict did not have any particular ideology being defended or fought for.The Mexican revolution also aimed to improve the country economically and politically. However, inflation rose and foreign investment came to a standstill and opposite results occurred where banditry was on the rise carried out by both, the rebels and the government forces. Therefore, this conflict did not assist the country in any significant way as a revolution aims to do.Furthermore, it was not an entirely internal affair either as the United States (US) was also involved sending assistance and aid to some pro American dictator or the other. While a revolution aims to unite the country in its resolution this conflict only managed to further separate the country. After the revolution, for example, Mexicans chose to ignore politics as they were fed up with the chaos that had occurred in the Mexican Revolution.Moreover, not all of the Mexican people were involved and many didn't even care showing the lack of motivation in this Mexican conflict. This is unlike a revolution where the whole country is involved and everyone has a point of view or fights for a side with passion and zeal.In the book "The Underdogs: A True Story of the...

Find Another Essay On Is the Mexican Revolution justifiably called a revolution?

the mexican revolution Essay

721 words - 3 pages Turner 1Shamar TurnerENGL 150.001Professor Collier25 July 2013The Mexican Revolution: Dictatorship vs. ChangeThe Mexican Revolution was a complex and controversial conflict between the residents of Mexico and the dictatorship of the government, which lasted from a period of 10yrs starting in the early 1900s. The revolution was about the various beliefs of numerous dictators on how the country should be governed from an economically point of view

Women of the Mexican Revolution Essay

1906 words - 8 pages will explore why, for women of all kinds, the revolution against Diaz became a popular cause. It will also explore how various groups of women worked for revolutionary forces, why women of all classes were disappointed by their lack of progress, and how these groups of women were very separate from one another. Lastly, it will explore the post-revolutionary life of women in Mexico. To provide some back-story, the Mexican Revolution is said to

Pancho Villa’s Role in the Mexican Revolution

997 words - 4 pages could not atone for any previous transgressions in his life of crime, but his tactics as a revolutionary war commander made him almost unstoppable when it came to fighting for equality. Pancho Villa was an important factor in the Mexican Revolution and its beginnings. He was one of the first revolutionaries to fight against the Mexican government, and successfully evaded and won fights against the United States government. His greatest achievement

The Mexican Revolution and Portfirio Diaz

1239 words - 5 pages For thirty-four years Mexico existed under the dictatorship of Porfirio Diaz. During this time Mexico’s industries flourished however the Mexican people remained deep in poverty with little to no opportunities for educational growth. The Mexican revolution was the result of Diaz’s fall from leadership, the peons need for independence, and resulted in a new beginning for Mexico. The Mexican Revolution began due to Porfirio Diaz not allowing

"The Called it a Revolution" A description of the benefits that came from America's "Revolution": both the Revolutionary war,a nd the Industrial Revolution of early America

610 words - 2 pages The American Revolution created a great change in the colonies in the mid to late1700's. Gordon S. Wood's, The Radicalism of American Revolution explains not only achange in the government of the colonies, but in society itself. "Such a change marked areal and radical revolution, a change of society, not just of government." (Wood, 169)People no longer saw themselves as subjects of the King, but as citizens who played alarge role in the

Trends Uniting the French, Mexican and American Revolution

856 words - 4 pages left holding high the Treaty of Paris and the French Revolution left with a Declaration of Independence. The Declaration of the Rights of Man was drafted by Marquis de Lafayette, who was beyond influential with both the French and American Revolutions. (American and France 01). It is easy to say though that since he had so much influence on the French and American Revolutions, that he also inspired some of the Mexican revolution. All three

Mexican Revolution: Memorias de Un Mexicano (film)

1532 words - 6 pages extravagant parties and holidays that took place. Another thing that must be noted is that of Diaz's relations with other countries, various times we see him meeting with leaders or representatives of other nations that presumably looked to make business with the Mexican president.Not only do we get to see the ways of the people, this documentary tells us a story, a story of conflict, of envy, a story of the Revolution that has had a hug impact on the

Mexican Revolution: Diaz´s Administration and Beyond

1946 words - 8 pages . Not only that, Diaz had regulation over the banks and railroads which it didn’t had much control over it . This assumption meant that Diaz favor the rich and foreigners rather the majority of the Mexicans. During Mexican Revolution and after, thing got very complicated from the start. Once he found problems like all new presidents have and the groups are going to be disappointed of his intentions. He wants to give political freedom and a modern

The Underdogs by Marizno Azuela. Provides a personal view of the Mexican Revolution of 1910 through the eyes of Francisco Villa's personal physician

566 words - 2 pages The Underdogs provides a personal view of the Mexican Revolution of 1910. The author, Mariano Azuela, served as a doctor with Francisco Villa's famed Division of the North, "Los Dorados." He criticizes the folly and brutality of the Underdogs as well as the cynicism and venality of Los Ricos. With this insight, he incorporates his firsthand knowledge of the revolution into this story. The novel is made up of two main characters, Demetrio Macias

Mexican Revolution - How "revolutionary" was this event in reality? Explores the changes brought about during this time period. - Mexico - Early 1900's

1059 words - 4 pages The Mexican Revolution was revolutionary, but not in the ways that the fomenters of the revolution were planning, rather it Revolution? On November 20th, 1910 Francisco I. Madero put forth a call to arms for the nation's population to rise up and throw off the shackles of the oppressive bourgeois that ruled with the Diaz regime for the previous 35 years. There were several clear goals that Madero had for this revolution; in

How far could the 3rd Reform Act be justifiably called a turning point?

592 words - 2 pages the landed gentry to control the labourers. They could not look for automatic nomination. The 3rd Reform Act was good for the agricultural labourers, small tenant farmers in Ireland, the urban working classes. This was largely because the franchise changes led to a wider urban distribution. Joseph Chamberlain described the Reform Act as 'a revolution which has been silently and peacefully accomplished.' political power was now rapidly passing

Similar Essays

The Mexican Revolution Essay

1144 words - 5 pages revolution had a huge impact on the country of Mexico that is still felt in some places today.      The earliest start to the Mexican Revolution of 1910 happened one hundred years earlier when two priests, Miguel Hidalgo and Jose Morelos, led a stand against the Spanish colonial officials who were controlling Mexico at the time. On September, 16 1810 Hidalgo led Mexico's Indians in a revolution directed against the Spanish plantation owners in

The Mexican Revolution Essay

1174 words - 5 pages Diaz and the Mexican revolution had a huge impact on the country of Mexico that is still felt in some places today.The earliest start to the Mexican Revolution of 1910 happened one hundred years earlier when two priests, Miguel Hidalgo and Jose Morelos, led a stand against the Spanish colonial officials who were controlling Mexico at the time. On September, 16 1810 Hidalgo led Mexico's Indians in a revolution directed against the Spanish

The Mexican Revolution Essay

1166 words - 5 pages huge impact on the country of Mexico that is still felt in some places today.The earliest start to the Mexican Revolution of 1910 happened one hundred years earlier when two priests, Miguel Hidalgo and Jose Morelos, led a stand against the Spanish colonial officials who were controlling Mexico at the time. On September, 16 1810 Hidalgo led Mexico's Indians in a revolution directed against the Spanish plantation owners in northern Mexico. He was

The Mexican Revolution Essay

1583 words - 6 pages The Mexican Revolution began November 20th, 1910. It is disputable that it extended up to two decades and seized more than 900,000 lives. This revolution, however, also ended dictatorship in Mexico and restored the rights of farm workers, or peons, and its citizens. Revolutions are often started because a large group of individuals want to see a change. These beings decided to be the change that they wanted to see and risked many things