Is "The Sapphires' A Reliable History Source? History Essay

958 words - 4 pages

To what extent is the film ‘The Sapphires’ a reliable historical source?

‘The Sapphires’ is a contemporary Australian film, which explores concepts relating to the treatment of indigenous peoples in history. It informs not only Australians but the World on what shocking events the Indigenous people had to experience in the mid 1960s. Although it is a sincere genuine story that focusses on the Aboriginal girl group, the ‘Cummeragunja Songbirds’ battling against prejudice, its historical reliability isn’t entirely valid. Only two out of the four Sapphires visited Vietnam, as their mother was unaware of where it was and what was happening (resulting in an agreement) and it was too dangerous for them to go. Furthermore, the film minimizes the mistreatment of Indigenous Australians during the 1950s and 1960s, as it was much more than a few racial remarks and trauma, instead it was horrifying experience that scarred one another for an entire lifetime, without overcoming it it in the process.

The Sapphires examines the consequences of the Stolen Generation, rather than the actual removal of children. The difficulty of reconciling with Indigenous family members after their removal and cultural assimilation is an emotion that contemporary audiences are inspired to consider, in addition to the historical events of child removal. The powerful message of the continued existence of the Stolen Generation is reiterated through the character Kay. Ten years’ prior, Kay’s light colour skin made her a worthy candidate for removal and subsequent assimilation into white culture. This was because Authorities targeted mainly children of mixed descent, i.e. what they called ‘half-caste’ Aboriginal children. Throughout the film she struggles with her identity, when she reflects on the very different upbringings of her and her cousins. The scenes dealing with the stolen generation are some of the most historically accurate sections of the film, however, beyond the feel-good drama, the film minimizes the mistreatment of Indigenous Australians during the 1950s and 1960s, elides the 20 years’ era of self-determination and plays down the racism of the assimilationist period. Through the character of Kay, the director implies that the policy of taking children away from their families (the Stolen Generations) had positive results. For example, when Gail says, “Psh yeah, we make ya ‘shamed do we? Geez, you haven’t changed one bit have ya? Still talkin like some upper class gubba (white person) like we’re your personal slaves!”, we understand that she is referring to the fact that Kay has been brought up with white people, diminishing her aboriginal culture. In actual fact, despite Kay’s ‘successful’ upbringing, being part of the stolen generation is likely to have left her with intense trauma lasting a life time.

Social discrimination plays a key role in this particular film, however, it is...

Find Another Essay On Is "The Sapphires' a Reliable History Source? - History - Essay

This is a essay about the Code of Hammurabi - History - Essay

1398 words - 6 pages Code of Hammurabi The code of Hammurabi is one of the most historic findings in human history. The creation of the code or law was a historic achievement for not only the Babylonian society but for the entire Mesopotamian region dating back to about 1754 BC. Throughout our human history, our past civilizations have created an economic, political, and social laws for our human society. Many of these laws were created so that there was justice for

My Trail of Tears essay is a breif history review or the Trail of Tears

1083 words - 4 pages mistreatment and the abuse that was wrought upon the Cherokee Indians. It was a trail of blood, a trail of death, but ultimately it was known as the "Trail of Tears". In this history of the Cherokee Nation we are trying, but without success, to be as unbiased as possible. It's the War of 1812. Andrew Jackson is mounting up forces against the Pro-British faction of the Creek Indians. The United States appealed for Cherokee support for aid in war against

The essay title is : a reflection on figurative nudes (usually used for art history class)

992 words - 4 pages an object that is owned. The impressionist artists later on began to paint women, their mistresses with a different understanding of body maybe more as attempting to look at the person. But her I am looking at the body.If one was to un-gender the body and look at the representation of 'body' rather than female body, one could look at Michelangelo's David. The body here becomes an object of miraculous beauty. He has looked at the body after

This essay is a brief history and background on Budhism

3639 words - 15 pages , Confucian, Taoist, and Hindu (Corless 41). Such persons might or might not call themselves or be counted as Buddhists. Nevertheless, the number of Buddhists worldwide is frequently estimated at more than 300 million (Berry 32). Just what the original teaching of the Buddha was is a matter of some debate. Nonetheless, it may be said to have centered on certain basic doctrines. The first of the Four Noble Truths, the Buddha held, is suffering, or duhkha

Is the history nonsense?

639 words - 3 pages In responding to the President Bill Clinton's call for a national dialogue on race, Luis J. Rodriguez, the author of an article "Stop the Lies", suggests that we need to give the people in different colors a proper recognition in our history; and points out that the industrial economy is the foundation of racism. In a question, the American automaker, Henry Ford suggests that "History is more or less bunk" and the only history that we need to

Main Contributions of Bede's Ecclesiastical History as a Source for Early English History

631 words - 3 pages There is not a single work along English History that could have been more determinant and indispensable than Bede's Ecclesiastical History. By describing the story of the English people through their experience of Christianity he became our intermediary with the world of Anglo-Saxon England and their believes. Therefore, in what follows an attempt will be made to describe the main contributions of Bede's Ecclesiastical History as a source for

why is the jungle a primary source?

993 words - 4 pages Primary sources are used by people who have experienced specific events in their lives. They allow a reader to connect to them on a more relatable basis. Primary sources are also very reliable because the author of a book or newspaper article, for example, was actually there. So they have all the evidence they need for what is being documented. The Jungle, by Upton Sinclair, is a primary source because Jurgis actually went through the hard labor

This essay is about the history of concubines in China

593 words - 2 pages Though we may see it as wrong, concubines have been apart of the Chinese culture for centuries. Many people do not understand what the life of a concubine was like, but one can rest assure that it was not very pleasant, but considered quite normal when it first started. The history of concubines in China can be dated back to 221 BC, in which the Ch'in Dynasty shifted the Taoist culture to a Confucianist culture, and -in spite of how some may

Imperialism is the policy of an empire - History - Essay

840 words - 4 pages , Philippines Islands were the immediate territory America had to consider keeping or annexing after defeating Spain. However, people held different views concerning the topic, which resulted in a national debate. William Jennings Bryan was against imperialism, especially keeping the Philippines as American empire (Thriceholy.net, 2015). Bryan begins by explaining the difference between an empire and republic. His main point is that republic cannot

History of Reliable and Clean Water Supply in New York

1726 words - 7 pages Throughout history the need for a reliable and clean water supply has plagued large cities from ancient Rome to the modern day metropolis such as New York City. The need for water has always been a challenge facing any city. With the increase rise of population and the migration from rural living to city dwelling; the search for water is ongoing. New York City specifically has had a grand history of water management from early engineering

This is a report for History on the country 'Colombia'

1480 words - 6 pages Chiles is16,900 ft. high, thePurace is 17,060 ft. high, and the Pan de Azucar is 16,840 ft. high.The eastern region of Colombia is a grassy lowland. 1/6 of Colombia isuninhabited glacierland, and 1/5 is high plateau.Colombia has many rivers. The most important river is the Magdalenawhich is 965miles long and flows north to the Caribbean Sea. Others are the Meta,the Amazon, theGuaviare, and the Putamayo. There aren't many lakes in Colombia. Thelargest

Similar Essays

To What Extent Is Our Sense Perception A Reliable Source Of Knowledge?

578 words - 2 pages To what extent is our sense perception a reliable source of knowledge?Ramelia Merritt 10/27/14To start with, using our senses many possibilities for knowledge are openedto us. Our senses have some limitations that prevent us from our knowledge. But what is knowledge? Generally, knowledge is a term that a lot of people accept when they want to say that they know something. More specifically, knowledge for meis when I can not only know something

To What Extent Is Our Sense Perception A Reliable Source Of Knowledge?

578 words - 2 pages To what extent is our sense perception a reliable source of knowledge?Ramelia Merritt 10/27/14To start with, using our senses many possibilities for knowledge are openedto us. Our senses have some limitations that prevent us from our knowledge. But what is knowledge? Generally, knowledge is a term that a lot of people accept when they want to say that they know something. More specifically, knowledge for meis when I can not only know something

The History And Source Of Christianity

1415 words - 6 pages Religion has existed for countless centuries. Christianity is one of the major religions in this world, which had people be criticized, battle in wars, and killed for, but it still survived to this day. The purpose of this paper is to study the source of the religion, recognize the teachings, observe its spread throughout the world, and to identify how it stands among people today. Approaching this paper by a factual report I

Which Source Provides The More Convincing Interpretation Of Henry Vii's Foreign Policy? History Essay

835 words - 4 pages before the dark period in his life. This is a severe limitation to the usefulness of this source and makes it less reliable if we were looking at Henry’s foreign policy as a whole. As the king had gone into seclusion after his beloved wife died, it meant that he was weak which also meant that threats to the throne arose, but Henry, however, could not simply raise taxes as he used to, since there were many factions within the country ready to start a