This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is There A Duty? Essay

2772 words - 12 pages

The issue of global wealth redistribution has become an increasingly fundamental topic in our globalized world. The vast amount of literature on this topic has left philosophers and economists to seek questions on whether there is a duty to redistribute wealth and in what way it should be distributed globally. The uncertainty over this remains a key impediment to real life progress. Nevertheless, the crucial aspect of this debate is to understand whether individuals have an obligation to redistribute wealth internationally. There are many deep controversial issues that conflict with the justness of responsibility. However in this paper, I will be using a cosmopolitan outlook by opening up the discussion of the current global situation and what duty an individual in the developed states has to redistribute globally. I will also analyze the poverty in the third world, and assess whether distributing wealth is the most effective mechanism compared to other alternatives.

Theories of global distributive justice address the following sorts of questions. Should we feel morally concerned about the large gap between the developing countries and the developed countries? What duty do us citizens have to provide assistance to the global poor? And what scale should we take the duties to?
Many theorists and philosophers have discussed these questions in-depth and much of the literature has been framed between a ‘statist and cosmopolitan’ approach. The cosmopolitan connotes as a belief in cosmopolis or a ‘world state’ and they believe that a single set of fundamental norms of justice applies to all citizens, regardless of nationality. (Heywood, 2012) Cosmopolitans usually determine that we should all be concerned about inequality, fairness and poverty as a matter on a global level not just on a domestic level. On the other hand, the statists believe that the state is the most appropriate means of resolving problems and guaranteeing economic and social development. Statist theorists deny the distributive justice and see it more as a charity or a matter of humanitarian duty. (De Bres, 2012) Both positions have become an ostensible dilemma in global justice and ethics, especially concluding on the notion of redistribution.
The world is facing many changes within international relations and global politics, and has recently been reviewed and discussed in many philosophical, political and economic literatures. Just over two decades ago, since the Berlin War and the burgeoning of the Internet technology, mechanization and politics coupled with the widespread liberalization of cross-border markets. The new arrival of many new actors took place on the global economic stage and announced a new era for the international community. The rapid development of globalization and the increase of interdependence across nations came through a growth of interchange of service, goods, technology and capital. However, not all developments were technology, the crisis on peace...

Find Another Essay On Is there a duty?

Is there a God? Essay

1458 words - 6 pages Is there such thing as a God, or is He or She just a figment of ones imagination? Is God a crutch that people can depend on or is He or She really there? Is there such thing as miracles? Who created God? Why are there so many different religions and denominations with so many different beliefs? What about the Big Bang theory? Did Noah really have Ark? Last but not least, why would God let such evil and horrific things happen to people in our

Is There A God Essay

1479 words - 6 pages Bertrand Russell has arisen one of the most important issue, which attracts the psyche of every human being. The existence of god has been a question that has plagued mankind started to think logically since forever. People believe in God but when they are asked, have you seen god? The answer usually is negative. Like many other authors, Bertrand Russell had written an article on this controversial topic of “is there a God” in 1952. Before

Is there a God?

1868 words - 7 pages Bertrand Russell, a renowned analytic philosopher, argues about the existence of God in his article “Is there a God?” (1952). For most of his life Russell held the opinion that religions are meant to instill distress and helplessness into people’s minds and belief in religion is the major cause for all the deadly conflicts that have occurred in the past. In his article “Is there a God?” Russell discusses how theologians have been presenting

Is There a Solution?

1445 words - 6 pages contrasts Staples argument. Slobogin takes a different approach on the moral side of the argument. She talked with Mikey Denny, a student who believes that "Kids today are looking to adults and society for a moral compass, and when they see the behavior occurring there, they don't understand why they should be held to a higher standard" (Slobogin). So, at least in Kathy Slobogin's opinion, it is not that today's students have no moral compass. It is

Is There A Magic Formula

1754 words - 8 pages through peoples’ minds, is why? What the majority of people do not understand is that sometimes there is no reason why. The human mind is a complex structure, and there is no algorithm that can be used to determine what action a human being will take. Although there is no formula that can be produced to predict the rate of crime in the United States, gun laws should be reformed, as well as strictly enforced, to reduce the chances of violent crimes

Is There Really A God?

1889 words - 8 pages designed, we cannot assume that it was a sole creator that made the universe, it may be the product of multiple designers or an inept designer. He also argues that because there is evil in the world, the designer could not be perfect; therefore God could not be the perfect creator. Since there is only one universe, it is possible that the universe did not require a designer and that chance could be responsible for the way the universe is . Darwin

Why There Is A God

1938 words - 8 pages Is there a God? I BELIEVE THERE IS When my father lost his business three years ago I thought my life was over. What were we going to do? Things had already become noticeably harder and tense around the house. We even talked about moving. I guess working fourteen-hour days for six days out of the week doesn't mean you'll be successful in world. Life has a funny way of presenting itself. When you're up and doing well, things never seem as good as

Duty versus Charity: Why a Distinction is Essential

1552 words - 7 pages helping your neighbor and helping someone unknown in a faraway country are of equal moral significance. It also makes no distinction between cases where a specific person is the only one in a position to help, and cases where there might be millions of others in the same position. He then highlights the difference between duty and charity. A duty is any action which is not only correct in when it is performed, but wrong when flouted. Charity

Discussion on Mr. Barlow's Is There a There in Cyberspace

838 words - 4 pages Do you know what non intententional and intentional communities are? If you are like me, then you have no idea what it is or how it relates to society. That was until I read the selection written by John Perry Barlow “Is There a There in Cyberspace.” Are you informed on what I am talking about or would you like to know more? You may not even be aware of what nonintentional means. The dictionary definition for this word is "not done on purpose

Is there a Solution to Date Rape?

1491 words - 6 pages , to end up not having sex with her due to an uncontrollable sexual desire or need. However, Pineau argues that women are in fact in control of how their sexual behavior is presented; therefore, they have a duty to control it. She shows support of this claim by this quote, “One does not go into the lion’s cage and expect not to be eaten” (Pineau 455). Pineau argues that women should be provocative and not fear rape because there are indeed ways

Juvenile Delinquency: Is there a solution?

926 words - 4 pages or school depending on the judge’s decision. Second, incarceration sentence type is juvenile hall/detention facilities. There are two types of juvenile hall facilities, regular and secured facilities. The regular juvenile hall facility is used for juveniles who are only sentenced to a short-term, a few months. In contrast, the secured juvenile hall facilities are used for the juvenile who are sentenced to long-term for committing crimes and not

Similar Essays

Is There A Meaning? Essay

1229 words - 5 pages influence over philosophy, he believed that to consider the question: “what is the meaning of life?” is a waste of time. The question, he thought, is rather meaningless and has no ultimate answer, asking it is being somewhat like asking what the color of time is (Mason). There are serious arguments that can be advanced in support of this point of view, especially if we agree that meaning is not something inherent to events, things, and other

Is There A God? Essay

810 words - 4 pages The question on whether there is a God is not very easy to answer. There are two many sides to this question. There is the scientific side that shows that man has evolved over time to its current state. Then there is the theological side that says that God created man, the earth, and the heavens. But what is the real answer or is there any answer at all. When looking at the theological side of this question one must have faith and believe that

Is There A God? Essay

855 words - 3 pages God?Is there a god?If there is a god why doesn't he make himself more evident and his existence not only proved by faith? Vailable questions that have plagued mankind since the place we have come to know as our world, came to be. I consider myself a Christian but many times I struggle with the same questions the atheist and agnostics use to disprove the existence of an all powerful, and omniscient God. Can we prove God or did this God make it so

Is There A God? Essay

1408 words - 6 pages cosmological point of view. The cosmological argument states that all things in this universe have a cause, and since these causes cannot go on for ever there must be a first cause, i.e. God. He argues that there are five ways to argue for the existence of God, the first is the argument from motion. This states that everything in this world has certain potentials for motion. It also states that for these potentials to be met another object n motion must