Is There Intrinsic Value In Nature?

3119 words - 13 pages

Intrinsic Value PAGE 1
Running head: INTRINSIC VALUE OF NATUREIs There Intrinsic Value in Nature?Debra A FosterUniversity of Maine at FarmingtonPHI101Dr. George MillerAbstractThe definition of intrinsic and extrinsic (instrumental) value will be shown. The author will relate her own view of intrinsic and extrinsic value. The viewpoint of Aldo Leopold on the land ethic will be examined. This author's interpretation of Leopold's views will be presented. The extrinsic value of nature, as seen by William F. Baxter, will be examined. The author's reaction to Baxter's theory will be discussed. The author's own views on the intrinsic and objective value of nature will be put forth.Is There ...view middle of the document...

Who decides if something has value? This is a philosophical discussion, so the philosophers of this world must decide. This is where the big debate comes in. If we add our topic of nature what will happen?Does Nature have Intrinsic Value?According to Holmes Ralston III, "Intrinsic contrasts with instrumental; subjective with objective; and we next map these terms onto each other and the natural world. Intrinsic value may be found in human experiences which are enjoyable in themselves, not needing further instrumental reference-an evening at the symphony, or one listening to loons call. Beyond this, intrinsic natural value recognizes value inherent in some natural occasions, without contributory human reference. The loons ought to continue to call, whether heard by humans or not. But the loon, while nonhu​man, is itself a natural subject. There is something it is like to be a loon; its pains and pleasures are expressed in the call. Those who cannot conceive of nonexperienced value may allow nonhuman but not nonsubjec​tive value. Value exists only where a subject has an object of interest."(Pojman, 1994, p. 1, para.4)Ralston III clearly extends the valuation of nature to include nonsentient beings. These beings are capable of at least motor-affective response. He seems to argue the fact that nature does have intrinsic value.Ralston III further argues, "Centres of experience vanish with simpler animals. In the botanical realm, we find programmes promoted, life courses generated and held to, steering cores which lock onto an individual centeredness. There is a kind of "object with will," even though the feeling is gone. Every genetic set is, in that sense, a normative set; there is some "ought to be" beyond the "is," and so the plant grows, repairs itself, reproduces and defends its kind. If, after enjoying the Trillium in a remote woods, I step around to let it live on, I agree with this defense, and judge that here is intrinsic objective value, valued by me, but for what it is in itself. Value attaches to a nonsub​jective form of life, but is nevertheless owned by a bio​logical individual, a thing in itself. These things count, whether or not there is anybody to do the counting. They take account of themselves. They do what they will, which we enjoy being let in on, and which we care to see continue when we pass on. (Pojman, 1994, p. 2, para.1)On nature in general, Aldo Leopold states: "An ethic to supplement and guide the economic relation to land presupposes the existence of some mental image of land as a biotic mechanism. We can be ethical only in relation to something we can see, feel, understand, love, or otherwise have faith in."(White, 2003, p. 522, para.1) I believe Leopold is speaking of morality ethics.Leopold further explains "the biotic pyramid." He states, "Plants absorb energy from the sun. This energy flows through a circuit called the biota, which may be represented by a pyramid consisting of layers. The...

Find Another Essay On Is There Intrinsic Value In Nature?

In nature is tyranny Essay

841 words - 4 pages ‘’In nature is tyranny’’ Is a man born a tyrant or is a man shaped one by the events during his life? According to Malcolm ‘‘king becoming graces’’ are ‘’justice, verity, temperance, stableness, bounty, perseverance, mercy, lowliness, devotion, patience, courage, fortitude.’’ A person who has none of those, would therefore not be a good king, a tyrant even. When comparing Macbeth to those graces, one must come to the conclusion that

Discussion on Mr. Barlow's Is There a There in Cyberspace

838 words - 4 pages Do you know what non intententional and intentional communities are? If you are like me, then you have no idea what it is or how it relates to society. That was until I read the selection written by John Perry Barlow “Is There a There in Cyberspace.” Are you informed on what I am talking about or would you like to know more? You may not even be aware of what nonintentional means. The dictionary definition for this word is "not done on purpose

Stacy's Story: There is Beauty in Aging

2118 words - 9 pages has become more confident and less worried. In a recent study, it was found that people experience an increase in self-confidence, self-control, and emotional stability as they age (Roberts and Mroczek, 2011). Some researchers believe that these changes are due to intrinsic maturation, which is essentially the idea that the development of personality is “determined by biological maturation, not by life experience” (McCrae and Costa, 2008, p. 167


539 words - 3 pages THERE IS A RULING CLASS IN AUSTRALIA Wealth, power and position. These three factors alone categorise each and every human into a group where they are placed with people of similar status. This is known as a person's class. Today in Australia there is a new class that influences society as a whole and it is known as the ruling class.The Australian society consists of three different classes that are determined by wealth. The first of these

Is there a Narcissistic Epidemic in America?

1319 words - 6 pages a number of reports that indicate there is a disturbing rise in the number of cases of Narcissistic Personality Disorder among the youth of today. Recent studies compared teenagers from past generations to those of recent generations and the findings suggest that there is in fact a rise in narcissism among the adolescence in today society. However, what is behind this rising trend? According to some, they believe it can be attributed to the ever

Is there love in her heart?

1748 words - 7 pages there shows that she can never be happy or content with anything she gets in life. She will always be Walker 2 unhappy or maybe in bored with what she has and will constantly have the need to acquire more. She will never be satisfied with what she has and is given. Emma is selfish and is only thinking about what she wants and she clearly does not see the good she has. Once Emma gets bored and depressed from her small town life and her wish

There Is No I In Team

2168 words - 9 pages , “We’re trying to push the boundaries of the workplace…” (Stewart). There are a multitude of different people who work at the core of Google corporation, all bonded by their job and their work environment. Google’s focus is, “to create the happiest, most productive workplace in the world,” according to Dr. Newman. One instance in how they do this is allow their employees the freedom to create their own desks and work place. This allows people to

?Literary ?value? is not inherent in the text but is

1421 words - 6 pages ?Literary ?value? is not inherent in the text but is produced by the institutions of society, especially the education system. Thus the text is not only ?produced? by its writer, it is ?re-produced? by society?.? Literary value can be determined by the relevance a piece of literature has to an audience. The determination of whether this relevance falls solely within a text, or on the other hand is somewhat universal in its context and thus

In the news today there is an article about a

1297 words - 5 pages In the news today there is an article about a high-school boy who brought guns to school and shot several students. The parents of the victims are suing various computer game companies saying that the violent games present shooting and killing people as pleasurable and fail to portray realistic consequences. A representative of one of the companies released a statement saying that this is another example of individuals seeking to elude

Is There Political Will in Egypt to Promote Gender Equality?

1941 words - 8 pages percieved as a norm. Religion is a very contraditing topic when it comes to gender inequality, and there is honestly more than just Religion to blame. The problem with culture and tradition is that people rarely ever question its morality, since people have been doing it for years, therefore it is viewed as the obvious thing to do, when in fact it's time people start thinking for themselves and not just following this or that tradition because its

For Every Action There is a Reaction in Macbeth

1263 words - 5 pages for he used them as sources to his future. Justice is served; Macduff seeks revenge and honour for his family’s slaughter, nature is balanced the way it should be when Macduff slaughters Macbeth and Malcolm is put back in the honour of the throne and is called King of Scotland. So, therefore, the witches are just as guilty for the events that place, but yet they suffer no punishment for it. The only people in the whole play that have done wrong

Similar Essays

Intrinsic Value In The Non Human Natural World

1238 words - 5 pages Intrinsic Value in the Non-Human Natural World When it comes to the question of non-human rights and the value of nature, there are adamant advocates, those who completely disagree with particular values and rights for the ecosystem, and those could care less. For myself, I believe I have fallen somewhat in between these extremes and have honestly never really considered the idea of intrinsic value and certain rights

Value In Nature Essay

1890 words - 8 pages generated value is neither instrumental nor intrinsic, but systemic (Rolston, pgs. 82, 86, 84). We will examine each in part and see how Rolston’s argument matches up with Leopold’s. Both Leopold and Rolston realize that nature is not isolated; rather organisms are “interlocked in one humming community of cooperations and competitions, one biota” (Callicott, p.138). There is a “rare,” “orchestrated,” music to nature whose “notes [are] the lives and

“In A Prosperous Society, Value Is Predominantly Of An Intangible Nature.”

681 words - 3 pages In this day and age there is increasing competition in the market place, leading to the availability of numerous products which all satisfy similar needs. When making the purchasing decision, consumers take into account the tangible and intangible value of the product. The tangible value of a product can be interpreted as the physical aspects of the product, such as quality of material. The intangible value of a product includes the immaterial

“ In A Prosperous Society, Value Is Predominantly Of An Intangible Nature.”

667 words - 3 pages Skills: Value" In a prosperous society, value is predominantly of an intangible nature." (Marketing Manager)In our modern society, differentiating products and services from competition has become essential for firms. Consumers benefit from a large variety of products in their efforts to satisfy their needs and thus, intangible values, such as quality, customer service and style, have become key determinants of consumption choices. Firms