This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Is Vere A Hero Essay

707 words - 3 pages

In 1891, the novel, Billy Budd, was published by Herman Melville. Readers claim the novel is a masterpiece, holding controversy about certain characters, especially captain Vere. In 1971, Charles A Reich had written “The Tragedy of Billy Budd” showing that Captain Vere was wrongly accused. In 2002, Robert Martin had written “Is Vere a Hero?” to show that Vere is no hero. Both works support their reasons well using textual evidence, however Reich’s work is more persuasive than Martin’s.
In Robert Martin’s critique, Is Vere a Hero?, he claims that Vere is not a hero. First Vere is a despotic captain. For example, He had manipulated the court of Billy Budd’s trial. Whoever spoke against the captain, Vere, would be killed. Also, when Vere learns about a possible mutiny, he takes the law into his own hands, strictly following the letter of the law and disregarding the spirit of the law. He then weighs both, private conscious and martial law to deal with the given situation. Vere then ...view middle of the document...

When Vere had meet Billy, Vere learns that, from the passion he had given to Billy, there are values beyond the law. At the scene of Billy Budd’s death, questions the law, how society enforces its laws, and the rejection of human values following laws. Laws destroy men, both moral and immoral, not yet distinguishing between the two types. For example, the newspaper article, A Depraved Criminal, symbolizes society’s failure to understand the spirit of the man. Society is a poor and artificial thing, condemning even the most moral of men. The blame should not be placed on Vere, rather to the law and society.
Of the two works, Reich is superior to Martin’s. Reich stresses how we should look past Vere’s view and look at him for what he is. For example, Reich writes “Vere comes to recognize that there are values beyond those which the law embodies”. This quote shows that, after Billy’s death, Vere learns that intentions do matter. Billy’s death was a result from Vere’s decision and Billy’s actions. However, readers shouldn’t blame Vere, due to him not knowing any better. Reich writes, “his [Vere] understanding is limited” and explains how Vere did not know that intentions did matter, before Billy’s death. The image being drawn is Vere understanding intentions did matter when it was too late.
Martin’s work is inferior, compared to Reich’s. Martin does support support his points well, but lacks at points. For example, “Who speaks for ‘civilized society’”, Martin writes and explains, but does not fully elaborates his point. The passage is explained to an extent, but does not answer the question ‘Who speaks for civilized society?‘. Also, Martin writes, “Slavery is at the heart of Billy Budd”. This quote confuses the reader in thinking that, ‘Why is slavery at the heart of Billy Budd?’. Martin leaves some of his points unsupported and confusing the reader. In comparison, Martin stands inferior to Reich.
Reich shows more of an explained reason, while Martin shows more of a general statement. In Reich’s work, the reader is barraged by many supporting reasons, unlike Martin’s. Both works show only a perspective of Captain Vere being a hero or not and a major point of controversy, in Billy Budd. Herman Melville’s novel is heavy in arguments, while also being well respected and known.

Find Another Essay On Is Vere A Hero

What is a Hero? Essay

954 words - 4 pages A hero is characterized as any person who is admired for their courage or achievements, thus serving as a model. Some other characteristics associated with a hero are bravery and daring. It is the manner of facing and dealing with anything that is recognized as dangerous, difficult, or painful that further defines a hero. A primary example of a hero is the courageous men and women, many of whom are employed in a regular non-military job

What is a Hero? Essay

554 words - 2 pages What is a Hero? There are many types of heroes (such as the ones in comic books, myths, movies, or even just everyday life heroes) but all of them have perseverance when they’re going through a conflict. Heroes are role models and they’re people that we look up too. They all have unique and special qualities that make one another different from each other. For example policemen battle crime everyday and when they’re overcoming a conflict they

what is a hero?

471 words - 2 pages Random House 255 West 45th Street New York, NY 10022 To Random House Editorial Review Board: What is a hero? Everyone's vision is somewhat different. To me, a hero is someone whom I can look up to as a role model for something he or she has accomplished. These might include tasks that were performed with bravery and unselfishness. This is why I propose to you to enter into Tom Brokaw's new book titled, The Millenium Generation, a person who had

What Is A Hero?

1330 words - 6 pages What is a Hero? I have grown up admiring all of the heroes that influence our society’s imagination. I first witnessed a hero as a cartoon, which happened to be the strong and magnificent Hercules. He was the courageous character everyone wanted to be as a kid. However, personal and societal conflicts were factors that helped create Hercules, and most heroes in Greek Cultures. I then matured and became more ambitious. Soon I watched the

What is a Hero?

690 words - 3 pages Many people have heroic qualities but being a hero and having heroic qualities are completely different. A hero should know how to decide what is right and wrong. Someone that you see as being higher than you in strength, greatness and confidence and that someday you could be just like them. To me, a hero is unrealistic. I strongly believe that the only hero one has is the one they find in themselves. I've never depended on anyone and never

Is Frankenstein a hero?

759 words - 4 pages Can someone who makes a monster be a hero? (Is Frankenstein a hero?) When most people think of Frankenstein they think of the big scary monster with the deep set eye the big forehead and the screws in his neck. Most would be surprised to find out that Frankenstein in fact, was the scientist who made the horrifying monster. The monster was really never named through his life in the story. When most people think of Frankenstein many thing comes

What Is A Hero?

2418 words - 10 pages The Value of Heroic Nature: Ancient versus ModernWhat is heroism? Is it being able to slaughter an entire army singlehandedly? Is it being a good father to your children? Or is it being able to do what is right, even if the choice is hard to make? The Oxford English Dictionary defines being heroic as "Of or pertaining to a hero or heroes; characteristic of, or suitable to the character of a hero; of a bravery, virtue, or nobleness of character

Odysseus is not a Hero

768 words - 3 pages A hero is "a man noted for his special achievements" according to the dictionary, but if you ask most people what a hero is, you will get the same general response. They will probably say "someone who does something for other people out of the goodness of his heart." Odysseus, who is the main character of the book "The Odyssey" written by Homer, would fit the dictionary¹s definition of a hero; but if you go deeper, looking at what people

Hector is a pure hero

557 words - 2 pages Hector is a Pure HeroCommentary on the hero in the Iliad often involves Achilles and Hector. Who does either of them qualify as a hero? According to Merriam-Webster dictionary, Hero is the one who shows great courage, strength or ability, admired for his brave deed and noble qualities. Although both of them show super-abilities at the battlefield, Hector, with noble responsibility, is much more a hero than Achilles.Achilles, a distorted

agatha christie is a hero

903 words - 4 pages In today's modern times we hear the word hero all of the time. The news media throws the term around as if it is an everyday word. What exactly is a hero? Who, or what, can be classified as heroic. The correct definition of the word hero is: One invested with heroic qualities in the opinions of others. A hero is a person who is admired for accomplishments achieved. That is a fine definition for books and intellectual minds. Agatha Christie is a

How Odysseus is a Hero

1580 words - 6 pages A person will typically think a hero as one who is equipped with great strength or ability. But a hero is more than just being brave or strong. In the epic poem The Odyssey by Homer, Odysseus goes through many challenges and is faced with his biggest weakness: his hubris or excessive pride. Though, Odysseus earns the title of a hero because he exhibits courage, utilizes cunning, and overcomes his hubris. To begin with, Odysseus deserves to be

Similar Essays

What Is A Hero? Essay

667 words - 3 pages What is a Hero? In today's world the news media throw the word around like it is an everyday word. So what exactly is a hero? Who or can be classified as a heroic? The correct definition of a hero is: One invested with heroic qualities in the opinion of others. That definition is for books and intellectual minds, but to an average person like me a hero is much more than just that. First, to understand what a hero is, we must find

What Is A Hero Essay

779 words - 3 pages Outline:Thesis: The fundamental qualities of a true hero are the ancient, heroic qualities: honor, courage, and determination."Real American Heros"A. September 11, 2001B. Public service personneltitle: What Is A Hero?In your opinion, what qualities should a hero always have? The fundamental qualities of a true hero are the ancient, heroic qualities: honor, courage, determination. Nothing has changed since the dawn of storytelling. We still look

Is Grant A Hero? Essay

945 words - 4 pages If you watch modern movies you will find that these times it is quite easier to be a hero than it was fifty years ago. The world gives us multiple opportunities to proves ourselves and give us the self-satisfaction of being able to say you are a hero. But what is a hero? Grant says, “A hero is someone who does something for other people. He does something that other men don’t and can’t do. He is different from other men. He is above other men

Is Odysseus A Hero? Essay

2027 words - 8 pages Throughout the epic, Odysseus is portrayed by his friends and peers as a magnificent man, a godlike figure. But, throughout the journeys of The Odyssey, Odysseus’ true character shows. Heroes are no exception to human nature; all people tend to act differently in public than in private. A commonly accepted definition of a hero is, “a man of distinguished courage or ability, admired for his brave deeds and noble qualities.” Odysseus has not shown