This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Islam And Anti Semitism: A Conflicting Set Of Stories

3370 words - 13 pages


11 Nov 2013

Islam and Anti-Semitism: A Conflicting Set of Histories

History provides us with few disputes as entangled as Jewish-Muslim relations. Though it was not always such a pervasive problem, it has compiled into one of the most divisive, exclusive, and problematic debates of the current era. Countless scholars have attempted to interpret the Muslim outlook towards the Jewish people. Islamic anti-Semitism is one of the greatest oversimplified nuances of the modern Middle East and of Islamic theology. The mere mentioning of Islam in conjunction with anti-Semitism, can act as a prism through which passes widely varying opinions, histories, and myopias. It can be argued that it is a dire imperative that must be understood to fully grasp Islamic culture and history. While it is a common thread that runs through various facets of Islam; its causes, significance, and implications are greatly misunderstood by Western culture. Through the following, a multilateral examination will be conducted to evaluate some of the most prevalent undertones of Islamic anti-Semitism. Historical Arguments Against Islamic Anti-Semitism

Originating in the seventh century, Islam began a dramatic and rapid spread throughout the Arabian Peninsula, soon penetrating parts of Africa, Europe, and Asia. With an almost inexplicably fast expanse, it would be farfetched for Muslims to not emerge as the rulers of any preexisting Jewish populations of the land.

But how far reaching was Islamic anti-Semitism in the early days of Islam? This is a matter of contention amongst scholars who have studied the subject. Notable scholars Claude Cahen and Shelomo Dov Goitein insist that historic anti-Semitism wasn’t very specifically prominent throughout the Muslim world and was discriminative toward all non-Muslims (I.E. not singling out the Jewish community) following that same thread, these scholars contend that Medieval Islamic anti-Semitism was not a pandemic, but had occurred sporadically.

In his work Islam and Islamism Tibi Bassam agrees with Lewis that Judeophobia existed throughout the history of Islam, but was greatly modified in more recent times. He believes that the more genocidal form of anti-Semitism was a German creation and that Islamic form was much more harmless (prior to the twentieth century). Bassam states that the Islamic world did not see a more radical anti-Semitism until the 1930s (by Arab nationalists, not Islamists specifically per se). He does concede however, that the current form of Islamic anti-Semitism is a dangerous phenomenon. It should be noted that Bassam believes Islam is inherently free as a culture and faith of this hatred, but it “is a basic feature of contemporary Islamism.”

Another argument against true nature of Islamic Anti-Semitism comes from Bernard Lewis. Lewis contends that early Islamic Anti-Semitism was mostly harmless. He asserts that while Muslim populations have perpetuated derogatory Jewish...

Find Another Essay On Islam and Anti-Semitism: A Conflicting Set of Stories

A Study of Anti-Semitism in The Merchant of Venice

2363 words - 9 pages A Study of Anti-Semitism in The Merchant of Venice ‘The Merchant of Venice’ was written by Shakespeare in 1596 and appeals to both audiences of comedy and tragedy. The play features anti-Semitism which is a response to 1500’s Britain as well as other literature of the time. Anti-Semitism is the term used to describe discrimination towards Jews and Judaism. ‘The Merchant of Venice’ has received both positive and negative

The history and roots of anti-Semitism is Europe

889 words - 4 pages When people hear of anti-Semitism, they think of the horrific events that happened in Germany when Hitler was in control. But anti-Semitism actually existed in Europe long before those events took place. This essay will discuss why the Jewish people have been discriminated against, what has happened as a result of that discrimination and what action has been taken to prevent it.Anti-Semitism started because of religion. According to the New

Hitler and Anti-Semitism Analysis

1021 words - 5 pages Throughout the centuries, there has been a strong and persistent hatred towards Jews. The origins of this loathing have arose from factors such as religious beliefs, economic factors, nationalism, and beliefs about race and biology. One of the most prominent anti-sematic figures in history was Adolf Hitler, who had numerous reasons to detest the Jews. Hitler had a vision that Germany would one day have the perfect race; the Aryan race and that

Jewish Denial of Anti-Semitism

806 words - 4 pages of the ubiquity of Nazi anti-Semitism at the time. It is clear that the Jews were wrong to deny reality during the Holocaust because it prevented a possible means of escape for them, concealed evil with optimism, and hindered their decision-making processes. As a result of the Jew’s rejection of the truth, they crushed all chances of them planning an escape before Nazis captured them. In Night by Elie Wiesel, Eliezer talks about his community’s

Shakespeare And Anti-Semitism In The Merchant Of Venice

1384 words - 6 pages      Anti-Semitism and the desecration of the Jewish population have been in existence for nearly five thousand years. In the Elizabethan era, a question of anti-Semitism invariably arises. In William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice, we find that one of the characters is the embodiment and expression of anti-Semitic attitude that is pervasive in Elizabethan society. "Anti-Semitism was an intricate part in

Hath Not a Jew Eyes? The Identity of Shylock and Purpose of Anti-Semitism in The Merchant of Venice

2357 words - 10 pages rich use of language may be particularly susceptible to various interpretations, there are numerous examples that clearly demonstrate certain actions of Jewish oppression. Specifically, Shakespeare implicitly explores trends of anti-Semitism and establishes an ambiguous identity for Shylock by providing both a symbolic portrayal of the Jewish culture and a distinct dichotomy between Shylock and Antonio. Shakespeare alienates Shylock by

What are the historical roots of anti-Semitism? Where did it stem from? Define the difference between anti-Semitism and anti-Judaism

553 words - 2 pages It began with hostility toward or discrimination against Jews as a religious or racial group. The definition of anti-Semitism has been the focus of innumerable discussions and studies. While there is no universally accepted definition, there is a generally clear understanding of what the term encompasses. Anti-Semitism is the hatred of the Jewish people. It has existed to some extent wherever Jews have settled outside of Palestine. Religious

Racism, Anti-Semitism, and the Southern Courts

2272 words - 10 pages Section A: This investigation is centered on the question “To what extent did racism and anti-Semitism affect the court case of The People V Leo Frank?” The essay focuses on the effect of racism and anti-Semitism against Leo Frank, a Jew from Brooklyn, during and after the trial where he was found guilty. It discusses these forms of racism and anti-Semitism in context of the time period of the court case, from 1913 to 1915. The paper discusses

Determining Whether there is a Presence of Anti-Semitism in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

1363 words - 5 pages Determining Whether there is a Presence of Anti-Semitism in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice It is quite clear when reading The Merchant of Venice that there is a large focus on Shylock being a Jew. This is very prominent in his "I am a Jew" speech he, the Jewish moneylender, angry and betrayed, rails against the non-Jewish world which torments him. Antonio "hath disgraced me, and hindered me half a million

Prejudice, Racism and Anti-Semitism in William Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice

2768 words - 11 pages Prejudice, Racism and Anti-Semitism in William Shakespeare’s play, "The Merchant of Venice" Throughout William Shakespeare’s play, The Merchant of Venice, there is a strong theme of prejudice. Portia has to deal with prejudice against her sex, the Prince of Morocco has to deal with prejudice against his race but the character that is most discriminated against is Shylock. He is hated for being a Jew and a money-lender, but Shakespeare has

Anti-Semitism and Lack of Concern Among Non-jews During the Holocaust

996 words - 4 pages Thesis Statement: Antisemitism is to blame for the lack of concern among non-Jews during the up rise of the Holocaust.      It is hard to grasp the number of lives lost during the Holocaust. How someone could have so much hatred towards one group of people. Or how so many people could set back and watch something like this take place without protest. To begin to understand how a tragedy like the Holocaust could have

Similar Essays

A New Form Of Anti Semitism Essay

1285 words - 6 pages Sam Bould Mrs. Osokina History 102, section 018 4 April 2014 A New form of Anti-Semitism Adolf Hitlers’ Mein Kampf published July 18, 1925 outlined Hitler’s plan to reform Germany based on one true race. During this time period; shortly after World War One, Germany was on the bridge of economic, political, and social shambles. In 1919 the signing of the Treaty of Versailles threw Germany even closer to self destruction. The Treaty

History Of Anti Semitism Essay

2541 words - 10 pages who were considered to be the scapegoats in the history of Christian Europe. Hitler was able to do through acts such as the Civil service and the creation of the Nuremberg Laws. Through out history Jews were considered to be different from everyone else. Not only did the Nuremberg Laws emphasize this thought, it also took it one step further in a modern society . Stackelberg says in his text that “Nazi anti Semitism exploited popular feelings

Roots Of Anti Semitism Essay

5674 words - 23 pages could last for 25 years. The Jews were sent to isolated area and they were tortured and verbally abused until they renounced their faith and accepted Christianity. (Flannery)      In Germany, the Jews continued to suffer. They were repeatedly used as a scapegoat. Germans were in despair after the Franco-Prussian War and the economic crash of 1873. This created many anti-Semitic political parties. ("Anti-Semitism&quot

Theft Murder: The Inadequacy Of Reparations And Restitutions As A Result Of Anti Semitism

3617 words - 14 pages "Extortion and blackmail" (Levin 202). We can see that the Swiss reluctance reached all the way up to the highest leader of the country, the President.The anti-Semitism did not come just from the leadership but also from the large populace. The leaders of the Jewish side of the negotiations suffered incredible anti-Semitism. Hundreds of anti-Semitic letters were sent to Jewish Institutions in regards to these leaders (Levin 202). A photo of Avraham