Islam And Cartoon Controversy Essay

1900 words - 8 pages

A discussion of religion can branch into any number of topics, over any number of denominations and sects, about its effects on law and politics, and its role within society. However, mention religion today, and one subject arises universally: Danish cartoons. Out of context, this sounds ridiculous, but within a sound framework, the subject broaches religion at every possible entry. Perhaps no event in recent history, excluding 9/11, has provoked such a universal and rapid backlash. Retaliation against the publication of these comics stunned and shocked the world and led to the mass proposition of one question: Why? This line of thought sprung many queries. Why are Muslims so offended? Why did the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten publish the comics in the first place? Why is Islam seemingly out of control? Simple minds propose that Islam just can't handle a few jibes, and that the religion produces lunatics. However, sift through the misconceptions and the prejudices, and a more complex answer lies within, one that includes surprisingly little Islam and a far greater amount of oppression and subjugation. The heart of these protests lies not within Islam, but in the molding of the ignorant by power and the makings of history.
The explosion of protest began on September 30, 2005, when the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten published twelve cartoons depicting the Islamic prophet Mohammad in a variety of settings, many deemed offensive by Muslims and others. The most controversial cartoon depicts Mohammad wearing a bomb in his turban, which is a blatant reference to Islamic suicide bombers. The cartoons have since been reprinted in fifty countries, ("Jyllands-Posten Muhammad Cartoons Controversy") ensuring that the majority of the world read the news and took sides. Denmark claims the printing was an exercise in free speech; Muslims claim the cartoons defile and misrepresent Mohammad (Associated Press). Technically, both are right, as the paper, through free speech, defiled Mohammad. This makes a resolution hard to determine, for what should the authorities support in this scenario: free speech or Islamic code? Denmark refused to apologize, and the offending newspaper received death threats and protests. However, the riots the world witness did not occur immediately. Danish Imams lobbied the Middle East, stirring the flames of discontent over the cartoons. Finally, waves of violence spread across the Islamic states, and to a lesser extent, secular Europe. Hundreds of demonstrators stormed the Danish embassy in Syria and set it ablaze, "calling for the execution of those involved" in the cartoon making (Associated Press). Twenty-four died in protests over the cartoons in Nigeria, five died in Pakistan, and protestors torched the Italian embassy in Libya. Young Muslims clashed with Copenhagen authorities in Denmark, and protestors in London gathered at the Danish embassy. Literally, the world took up arms.
If one is to...

Find Another Essay On Islam And Cartoon Controversy

Persuasive Essay- Political Cartoon Offensive on Many Levels

525 words - 2 pages article of the Hattiesburg American, a man asks why this is such a big deal to Muslims and why has a simple cartoon caused such a big mess. Jon Altman does his best to suggest why the Muslim community is so offended, and I believe the way he went about doing so was effective.First, he gave the man some background on Islam, which I think is a very good idea. Most people living in southern Mississippi do not fully understand the ways of the Islam

Satire, the Mirror of Reality Essay

2437 words - 10 pages cartoons as a sign of solidarity (Henry). The sympathy, however, was not entirely on the Jyllands-Posten´s side. For example, the editor of a French newspaper was fired because of his decision to reprint the cartoons (Henry). In Russia and South Africa, courts decided to ban the cartoons (Klausen 9). In the United States, the cartoon controversy was feverishly debated. On the Colbert Report, Stephen Colbert, an American satirist, stated that he

Indonesian Democracy and Islam: Midterm Essay

994 words - 4 pages , traditionalist and modernist Muslims have been tied into the political cleavages that exist, weakening political Islam. The controversy of religious alignment has resulted in the formation of a multi-party system, weakening Islamic political parties and showing high levels of electoral volatility from one election to the next; this level of volatility has been caused by political parties remaining isolated from the electorate. In addition, this lack of

Beowulf, The New Hero

618 words - 2 pages have inappropriate content. Let's take Spongebob for example. There is controversy that this cartoon is teaching kids about people who are gay or lesbian. After reading this in the newspaper, I watched the show and thought of what a child might think when watching Spongebob. After watching Spongebob with my younger sibling, I asked him what he though about the show, and he replied, "I thought it was funny." I came to the realization that kids don't

Media Analysis Assignment: Understanding the meaning of Islam

1680 words - 7 pages Among the most prominent of the world's many religions is Islam, which today is the cause of great controversy within our society. To understand the multiple meanings that Islam conveys one must ask: "What is the meaning of Islam?" The essence of the religion has been sought after by many scholars, and it is widely believed that the religion is based on one's own interpretation of the Quran, the Islamic holy book. The significance of my analysis


630 words - 3 pages Christianity and Islam are the two largest religions in the world, founded upon the principal belief that there is one God who created the world. Nevertheless, both ideologies have their own accounts that have contradicted each other since their beginnings. As time changed these religious sects have undergone an innumerous number of events that question their validity and have led to controversy in recent years. Unequivocally both

How has the media portrayed Islam in societies around the world?

2471 words - 10 pages reactions are unbelievable. It’s clear enough that Islam vastly, in its core values and teachings, is unfortunately misconstrued. Islam is given huge attention as well, and with the media, it’s full of controversy and notoriousness.

A Brief History of Islam

748 words - 3 pages There are three great western religions that through history have globally expanded throughout the world. One of those western religions is Islam. Islam was first introduced and developed on the Arabian Peninsula. Islam, like Judaism and Christianity, is a monotheistic religion. Islam means "submission" to one god. The followers of Islam are known as Muslims. One primary leader of Islam is a man named Muhammad. When an economy began


696 words - 3 pages me ask the question, "Are these the only ways of fighting prejudice about Islam?" The answer is no. I think by burning flags and making threats of violence more people are being pushed away from Islam, rather then getting closer to an understanding of it.The cartoon of the Prophet (S.A.W) was the first attack which enraged Muslims around the world. Some non-Muslims of course did not see a problem is a simple cartoon; after all they believe in an

The Bill of Rights (a story drawn in strips): Political Cartoons

1731 words - 7 pages SYG law in there own defense and get off with a lesser sentence. I also have a reasonable suspicion that this cartoon is referring to the recent Trayvon Martin case in which the defendant George Zimmerman got off on house arrest for using the SYG law in his defense (although admittedly shooting the teenager). The case has since sparked more and more controversy in the realm of the second amendment and continues to be debated. THE THIRD

Conflicts in the novel Segu

1169 words - 5 pages in people and trade. The effect of this change would later be described as the world’s lowest point of society. “On the other hand, Islam was dangerous: it undermined the power of kings, according sovereignty to one supreme god who was completely alien to the Bambara universe” (41). Was Islam the real controversy causing the conflict, or were the Bambara people stuck in their own worlds?      “There is no god but Allah

Similar Essays

Cartoons Depicting Muhammad Essay

950 words - 4 pages inform the reader about Islam but further stereotypes around it. The government of Denmark is bias as it will not allow Flemming Rose to print any cartoons about the holocaust because it would be racist. It's clear that hidden insults and a hate for Islam was the basis for these cartoons as they were camouflaged by freedom of speech.In conclusion, cartoons depicting Muhammad have controversy because it promoted a Muslim stereotype, it degraded

Muslim Women Essay

1706 words - 7 pages continue to be untrustworthy, so men need to be gentle with women, love them, and treat them the right way. People in America and other countries throughout the world are quick to judge members of the Islam religion. They look at the controversy going on about how Muslim women are being oppressed and discriminated against, but who are they to judge other cultures and traditions? In this image, it descripts are cartoon of what looks to be an

The History Of Islamophobia Essay

1091 words - 4 pages saying "Don't be afraid I call it freedom of speech." His words contradict with what is happening in real life. The Europeans have their own religion and beliefs but actually they are not convinced with Islam and they still think that Muslims are terrorists. In the FBI cartoon the FBI stamp all Muslims as terrorists although they belief in freedom of thought and religion ; they still think of Muslims as terrorists because of the ill

Visibly Muslim By Emma Tarlo Essay

1032 words - 5 pages events such as 9/11, the London bombings of 2005 and the Danish cartoon controversy (Tarlo 2010) it can be seen that muslims are portrayed stereotypically in a violent way, creating conflict with being accepted into society. The cartoon controversy reasserted the association of Islam with violence and terrorism (Tarlo 2010) and this can have dramatic effects on the muslim population as a whole as it can create false judgement and feelings of