This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Islam And Democracy: Mutually Exclusive? Essay

3548 words - 14 pages

The September 11th terrorist attacks unleashed unimaginable devastation upon the United States and subsequently upon the Arab-Islamic world. While the government of the United States scrambled jets and prepared soldiers for war, there was another battle, arguably more important than the war the United States was preparing to wage. This battle was waged not on battlefields but in classrooms, between scholars who struggled to define and rectify the democratic deficit in the Muslim world. Theories have been offered ranging from Islam and democracy being diametrically opposed, all the way to Islam considering democracy, or democratic principles, as essential. Lurking in the midst of these two extreme theories are the more moderate and demonstrable theories.
Extreme viewpoints fail to accurately assess and address the true situation. A more accurate theory is that which perceives Islam and democracy as being neither innately hostile toward each other, nor inextricably linked. Rather, an accurate theory proposes that Islam and democracy share principles essential to both. This theory is substantiated by evidence that current Muslim hostility can be explained by the history of Western intervention in the region and that within the sacred texts (Qur’an and Sunna) the presence of modern democratic principles provides strong textual confirmation of inherent compatibilities with Islam.
The contemporary Islam-democracy dichotomy can be best understood as the result of historical intervention in the region by Western democratic powers, which triggered serious conflict between the West and the Islamic world. The list of historical intervention by Western powers is long, but some cases are more historically significant than others. In 1917 the British supported the Zionist cause with the Balfour Declaration calling for the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine. After WWI, Great Britain and France dissected the Ottoman Empire and arbitrarily authored new national boundaries. In 1953, the British and the United States, in a concerted effort, overthrew the democratically elected Mohammad Mosaddeq because he sought to nationalize Iranian oil; a direct threat to American and British interests. In March of 2003 the United States contravened the wishes of the international community by invading the sovereign Arab state of Iraq. Thousands of American troops remain there as an occupying force. These actions by Western democratic powers marginalized the communities in which they intervened and engendered those same societies with a false view of democracy which remains prevalent today.
Furthermore, the West in general and the United States in particular, has been accused of, and rightly so, holding the Arab-Islamic world to a double standard. Historically and contemporarily the United States has supported repressive regimes such as those in Saudi Arabia, Iran under the Shah, and Pakistan under Zia ul-Haq, when doing so was in its...

Find Another Essay On Islam and Democracy: Mutually Exclusive?

Hoping for a Peaceful Democracy in the Middle East

1154 words - 5 pages the other” (Kamrava, 2007, p. 194). He then cites a comprehensive study that examine the relationship between Islam and democracy. Unlike what other scholars assumed, he shows that these studies have concluded that “democracy itself and Islam are not mutually exclusive, certainly not if democracy is measured by the more rudimentary political rights index” (Kamrava, 2007, p. 196). Although such assertions seems convening, Springborg does not

Reanalyze the Relationship of the West and Islamic Civilization Future

1502 words - 7 pages stated that Muslims unable to accept democracy because of the nature of Islamic law and this situation potentially lead to the virulent clash between the West and Islamic countries. He argued that Islam is the exclusive religion which is not flexible to adopt another political idea. This situation is occurred due to Islam basic system which integrates religion principle to political system. For Muslims, Islam is not only a religion. Koran has a

Muslim World Cosmopolitanism

1734 words - 7 pages ruling elites preached and provided though not always practiced perfectly. Islam also provided religious egalitarian alternatives to hierarchical Catholicism and Hinduism. The rise or, in the words of Professor Hodgson, the venture of Islam as an empire builder or world order was the result of a historic coincidence when early Muslims seized initiative to rise at the expense of two rival empires that had mutually exhausted themselves to impotence

Social and Political Understanding of the Islamic World: Muslim Brotherhood

1548 words - 6 pages ’ and ‘modernity’ the two need not be mutually exclusive. Certainly, few would call the Muslim Brotherhood progressive, and whether or not they can adapt to the highly charged political landscape of post-revolutionary Egypt remains to be seen. However, their evolution since their beginnings in the 1920s is evidence of the ability of political Islam to adapt to changing circumstances, making it a relevant and appealing mode of governance for many

Political Islam in Indonesia

1998 words - 8 pages was divided between two political versions of Indonesia: PNI's Sukarno's Indonesia based on the Five Principles of Pancasila and Masyumi's Muhammad Natsir's Indonesia with Islam as the state's foundational principle.When the Constitutional Assembly was dissolved by Sukarno in 1959, and Indonesia entered the period of Guided Democracy, Islamic parties were subjected to much control by the state and many were paralysed as a result. After Sukarno's

The Government of Democracy

1635 words - 7 pages democracy. Many analysts argue that nationalism and Islam are the key components to why democracy has not yet been adopted by Middle Eastern countries. Democracy means a “government by the people; a form of government in which the supreme power is vested in the people and exercised directly by them or by their elected agents under a free electoral system.” Democracy is a Western Civilization ideology of Government invented in Ancient Greece, 507 BC

Islam and America

662 words - 3 pages enemy to the Islam faith. Islam condones democracy and rather advocate for application of Sharia Law in governance of the subjects found within the jurisdiction where this is found. There are no checks and balances to such a system. In conclusion, the Islam and America have a long history and there seems to be no way the ideologies from both sides will converge. This is because the two parties are interested on the same thing which cannot be split and that is power and control. America fears that when this power slips of their hand, that is the end whereas the Islam feel that this is their rightful possession that was stolen from them with emergence of new order.

Does the Current Conflict Between the West and Islam Confirm or Contradict Huntington's Clash of Civilization Thesis?

2604 words - 10 pages Samuel Huntington's thesis on "The clash of civilisations" of 1993 provoked a plethora of varied responses. A Professor at Harvard University, Huntington wrote in order to voice his predictions and warn the world of an upcoming clash of cultures, most notably between the West and Islam. The recent reaction in the Middle East to America's self-styled 'war on terrorism' provides a timely case study for this debate. While an affinity will

East Versus West: Challenging the Binary and Stereotypes

1755 words - 8 pages addition, when there is a gray area, the people in the middle ground often ignored or marginalized by the extremes. This binary of east versus west has only increased in the years since the World Trade Center attacks in New York City on September 11, 2001. However, while many look at the East and West as two mutually exclusive stories, both the East and West share an overlap in several major areas, including art, religion, religious and political

French Government: An Oligarchy Rather Than a Polyarchy

1253 words - 5 pages parallel between research on France as a pluralist state and Robert Dahl's New Haven study by showing that France like New Haven appears to be a pluralist democracy. I then plan to show just as G. William Domhoff did with Dahl's original study, that the same inequality in power exists in France as in New Haven. This power inequality leaves a certain elite with a greater control over the states political system. To me true democracy must include all

Given that 88% of Indonesians are Muslim, why is political Islam not dominant?

1157 words - 5 pages the form it should take with regard to the nation's politics. Whilst the Guided Democracy and the New Order had a major impact on Islam in politics during the period from 1959 to 1998, the post-Suharto era sees the rise in importance in the way the Muslim public itself see as the role Islam should take. With the emphasis on the view of Islam as Cultural Islam and the general distaste for Islam to take a dominant role in politics, it would not be possible for Political Islam to become dominant, despite the 88% majority.

Similar Essays

Islam And Democracy Essay

2512 words - 10 pages , some aspect of Islam that makes it inherently hostile and incompatible with Western notions of democratic rule? This is the question which John Esposito and John Voll have tried to examine in their book Islam and Democracy. Published in 1996, this book explores the different ways in which Islam relates to democratic principles and ideas. Arguing against previously held explanations about the nature of Islam and the very definition of democracy

How Gods Intervene In Mortals' Lives, And How Fate And Free Will Are Not Mutually Exclusive And They Both Go On Throughout "The Odyssey"

1481 words - 6 pages hand is not engineered. It speaks to the concept of having full authority over one's aspirations and ultimate direction. The key there is "ultimate." The gods can make up the plan and choose the path, but the people had to walk it. Therefore, fate and free will are not mutually exclusive and they both go on throughout The Odyssey. Odysseus is given the opportunity to become immortal if he would stay with Calypso, but it is his choice to leave

Indonesian Democracy And Islam: Midterm Essay

994 words - 4 pages restrictive nature of political Islam, and lastly, the regression of political Islam leading to moderate Muslims taking power and a democratic model taking form. However, before democracy had become compatible with Islam in Indonesia, it was necessary for democratic consolidation, or the process by which democracy matures, to take place. According to Juan Linz and Alfred Stefan, there are five interlocking arenas that allow for this process – civil

Analyse The Complex Relationship Between Islam And Liberal Democracy

2410 words - 10 pages world 2006) The table on Islam and democracy shows that democracy has not found a home in the region and the authoritarianism continues to be a strong force in Muslim domains. Here states with an Islamic majority comprise one in two of the world's authoritarian regimes.Is the government Countries with an Non-Islamicelected by Islamic majority countriesdemocratic means?Yes 11 110No 36 35Total 47 145(Adapted from Hague and Harrop, 2004: 62)The