Israel And Palestine: Merely Nations, Or Outposts Of Civilizations?

1661 words - 7 pages

On March 16th, 2003, 23-year old American activist Rachel Corrie was torn down by an Israeli bulldozer while protesting the destruction of Palestinian homes in the Gaza Strip (Jordan). Five years later, in the summer of 2008, two Palestinian men living in East Jerusalem drove similar machines down busy Jerusalem streets, maiming and killing not a few civilians (Witte). Why did the drivers of these bulldozers – Israeli and Palestinian, both – commit these acts? Supporters and critics of Israel each have their own perspective.

The Israeli government would only go so far as to name the death of Rachel Corrie a tragic accident (Jordan) and continue to justify the demolition of houses for security reasons (Omeish and Omeish). When faced by the attacks perpetrated against its own people, however, it was much less aloof in its reaction. Debate arose over the possibility of placing more restrictions on Palestinian occupants of East Jerusalem, and some Israelis called for more forceful dealings with the families of Palestinian terrorists; on the subject of one of the attackers, an Israeli teenager proposed that “if they had ruined his house or deported his family, maybe this man would have thought twice about what he did” (Witte).

The Israeli perspective on these bulldozer attacks assumes the stance that the Palestinian resistance movement – in all its forms, such terrorist attacks included – is based on the values, not the experiences, of the Palestinians. Had the Israeli teenager considered the fact that the driver of the bulldozer could have committed the attack in protestation of the ruination of Palestinian houses and deportation of Palestinian families, would he have come to the same conclusion that such ruination and deportation could discourage these desperate acts? It is unlikely, because supporters of Israel offer up an explanation of terrorism as a doctrinal, rather than reactionary, phenomenon: in their view, these terrorists are radical Islamists who harbor a “universe of hatred” for Israel “as a democracy, as a Jewish homeland, as a country in which liberalism in all its forms, including cultural, prevails” (Stevens), not as members of a group which has been subject to ethnic cleansing and “memoricide” since 1948 (Pappe). The notion that terrorism may be rooted in the injustices suffered by its perpetrators is ignored in favor of assigning them – as Palestinians, Arabs, Muslims, or whatever generalization of the terrorist identity best fits the Israeli spiel – a static and inherent value system that may be conveniently defamed as anti-Semitic, anti-democracy, and anti-liberalism.

Benjamin Netanyahu, Prime Minister of Israel, has put this perspective into writing. He alleges that international terrorism is waged by Arab regimes driven by a fanatic hate of Western values and a concordant desire for Islam to become the dominant world power; the focus of these fanatics on Israel is due to its position as “the Middle East’s only...

Find Another Essay On Israel and Palestine: Merely Nations, or Outposts of Civilizations?

Palestine and Israel Essay

1257 words - 5 pages kill innocent Palestinians on streets and bomb and destroy their buildings as well. In the case of Israel and Palestine, both of them claim that they are right. However, both are equally guilty of terrorism. This is demonstrated when the Palestinians send suicide bombers into Israel and Israel strikes back at the Palestinian army and civilians. They both believe God is on their side, so they think that what they are doing is right. In addition

Palestine and Israel Essay

1472 words - 6 pages Israeli athletes were murdered by Arafat’s forces that were now the heads of the PLO (Palestine Liberation Organization). After the Attack Arafat made a UN appearance and showed evidence towards peace. Finally in 1977 Egypt and Israel make peace with each other. Other Arab nations were infuriated by the Egyptian peace treaty and made separate treaties with Israel. Even after the few years of peace Israel continued to define its borders by

Palestine and Israel

2510 words - 10 pages Palestine and Israel Our views of world conflicts such as war are influenced by the part of the world in which we live. When exploring media coverage of discord, it is important to think about where the author is from and how it has influenced the way he/she has portrayed disharmony. Reports on a world conflict can express extremely different views depending on the social values and understandings of the writers. One must read articles

The Israel and Palestine Conflict

1443 words - 6 pages by side. Demography: During 1947 a plan to form two separate states one Jewish and the other Arab: this came about by the United Nations Partition Plan for Palestine. While the Jews accepted the partition plan with seemingly little upset the Arabs rejected it. With the Arabs rejection came about a civil war later in the year of 1947, and a year later the establishment of the State of Israel came to be. “The Palestinians became dispossessed

Media Manipulation and America's Favoritism of Israel in the Israel-Palestine Conflict

4065 words - 16 pages that America sees in Israel that Europe doesn’t, or vice versa? It is evident that US media slants and manipulate reports of the Israeli-Palestine conflict in favor of the Jewish community. Also supporting the notion of favoritism is the imbalance in the economic support given to the conflict by the U.S. Then why this Israeli support? The two groups identified as sources for the Jewish support are identified as neoconservatives and special-interest

History and Geography of Palestine

913 words - 4 pages lands in the world.Palestine is one of the smallest regions in the Middle East. Most of its territory is under Israeli control. Palestinians control less than 400 sq. miles. However, the total area is 2,400 sq. miles (Kjeilen). Palestine refers to a region of the eastern Mediterranean coast from the sea to the Jordan Valley and from the southern Negev Desert to the Galilee lake region in the north (Honig). Palestine borders Egypt, Israel, Jordan

The People And The Land (Israel and Palestine). by Zaineddin Obeid

3498 words - 14 pages displaced before, during, and after the fighting are still not allowed to return to Palestine. This led to the U.N. General Assembly Resolution 194 that called for the right of the return or compensation of Palestinian refugees from the 1948 war. Israel's admission to the U.N. was partly based upon their willingness to accept and implement this resolution. However, Israel never implemented the resolution and more than 7 million Palestinian refugees

Hamas and Terrorism: A Blockage to Peace between Israel and Palestine

753 words - 3 pages between Israel and Palestine, provokes more attacks from both sides and contradicts the steps towards peace already taken and therefore is not successful in achieving freedom or peace.Hamas remains one of Palestine's most prominent terrorist groups zealously fighting for a free, Islamic Palestine and the destruction of Israel. As more people are caught up in this argument dating back to biblical times, each generation is raised in a state of war

George W. Bush and the U.S. official position on Israel vs. Palestine

920 words - 4 pages Israel-Palestine ConflictThe position of President George W Bush and the USAI: BACKGROUNDIn 1947 Britain handed over the Palestine problem to the newly born United Nations. The UN agreed to partition Palestine into a Jewish state, an Arab state, and a neutral UN zone containing Jerusalem, a city sacred to three religions. The Jews were thrilled, the Arabs adamantly opposed.In late 1947 the UN ratified the plan, and proclaimed the State of Israel

Why are there such divergent views of the history of the Middle East and why has the acceptance of such views been so instrumental in helping perpetuate the conflict, especially that between Israel...

2418 words - 10 pages Matriculation No: 120004127Module: IR2006Tutor: Simon TaylorDate: February 17th, 2014Word Count: 2,061Question: Why are there such divergent views of the history of the Middle East and why has the acceptance of such views been so instrumental in helping perpetuate the conflict, especially that between Israel and Palestine?IR2006Why are there such divergent views of the history of the Middle East and why has the acceptance of such views been so

League of Nations and United Nations.

945 words - 4 pages authorizes an unprovoked war on Iraq, it will have defeated the purpose for which it was created. If the United Nations Organization is truly interested in peace, it would force Israel, US's closest ally, to end its occupation of the land and people it conquered and which the UN has told it to vacate on several occasions, to no avail. If any country is in defiance of UN Security Council resolutions, and should be forced to comply with them and with

Similar Essays

The Question Of Palestine And Israel

1321 words - 5 pages The Question of Palestine and Israel Palestine and Israel seem destined to be enemies forever. There has been conflict for as long as Israel has been a sovereign state, and it does not look to be ceasing anytime soon. Both sides have used questionable tactics, sometimes successful and sometimes not, to become notorious throughout the world. Both sides have created or supported organizations to help fight the other. From even before the

The Peace Process Of Israel And Palestine

2391 words - 10 pages taken by them in the past. Even if Israel agrees to meet ninety -nine percent of their needs, Palestine won't settle unless Jerusalem is included in the deal and vise versa. Another negative element contributing to the difficulty to achieve peace is lack of strong leadership in these nations. The leaders of both sides don't seem to have solid supporting systems from their own political circles. The Palestinian leader Yasir Arafat, often

Israel And Palestine Essay

1757 words - 7 pages Israel and Palestine The Arab-Israel conflict is a story which has taken place over a century. In order to understand the conflict between these two cultures their collective histories must be taken into consideration. It was a long and hard path for the Jewish population to get a piece of land they can call their own. A land free of religious persecution. I think that history has shown that these two states can not and will not be able to

Israel And Palestine Essay

723 words - 3 pages the accords. This was the first step towards peace in a long time between the warring nations, and one that many people believed was going to bring an end to the fighting. These accords were significant because it was the first time that Israel ever recognized the Palestinian Liberation Organization as representatives of Palestine.      The purpose of Oslo was to pull out all of the Israeli troops from the West Bank and